Is Jahannam eternal for muslims or not eternal?
-
Quran repeatedly says people who believe AND do good deeds will see paradise. So sects lik Ibadiyya say muslims who sinned a lot go to hell forever just as the quran usually says.
Sunnis say even bad muslims get out of jahannam eventually based on a hadith and one ayat that says even an atom of faith will be rewarded somehow. So this means all muslims go to paradise eventually.
Who's right?
-
Salam lies exposed. Allah will decide on yowm e qiyamat/day of judgment.
Allah has said in some verses that some people will got jahannam/hell and be aazab/destroyed.
Allah has the power to make any decision he chooses, No man can alter Allah's power by hadith or any other method.
Allah hu akbar.
-
Salam,
280
They say 'The Fire will never touch us except for a number of days.' Say 'Did Allah make you such a promise - for Allah never breaks His promise - or do you say about Allah what you do not know?'But those who believe and do good works We shall admit them to Gardens underneath which rivers flow, and there they shall live for ever, the promise of Allah is true. And who is truer in speech than Allah!
1638
They solemnly swear by Allah that Allah will never raise the dead to life. No, surely the promise of Allah is binding upon Him, though most people do not know.Allah's promise is binding on HIM....
I smiled when I first read this verse (163!
Somehow it made me think that there is something above God P > His promise on Himself, that He ______ not break.
(Intersting, what goes in the blank? is it 'will' as in > will not break
or 'can' as in > can not break)I say both )
Regards
Ramzi