My islamic calendar
-
Salaam All
You will find here my own and quite complete conclusions about islamic calendar.
Before All, i want to thanks especially brother Ayman for the great work he has done. Many of what I think about Islamic calendar is coming from his writings. Many but not all.
I will not reproduce all the arguments/hojajs of brother ayman here
http//www.scribd.com/doc/19742651/Blind-Dating-Versus-Perfect-Timing-Real-Islamic-CalendarSo I ask readers to read that article before.
Why an Islamic Calendar ? For What ?
Here we have to ?zakkify? our minds about the belief that God wants to manager our ?all days? calendar for outlook tasks.
No need for Allah to give names of months, of days and so on.
The only thing needed is to fix ?Islamic? appointments with his followers. And for this task, Allah uses only what is visible by all his followers, that is moon and sun (10-5;17-12).Laylatou el qadr as ?focal point?
What is called Laylatou el qadr is the greatest appointment is the Islamic deen.
971 We have sent it down in the Night of Qadr.
972 And do you know what is the Night of Qadr?
973 The Night of Decree is better than one thousand Shahr.
974 The angels and the Spirit come down in it with the permission of their Lord to carry out every matter.
975 It is salam until the coming of dawn.Leylatou el qadr is the night where Allah choose to send Quran.
Thanks to brother ayman, we know that shahr mean full moon.
In 975, word salam is generally traduced by ?peaceful? but can be also traduced by delivery or even by ?healthy?The night in wich Quran was revealed was also Shahr Ramadhan
2185 Shahr Ramadhan, in which the Qur?an was revealed; as a guide to the people and clarities from the guidance and the Criterion. Therefore, whoever of you witnesses the Shahr, then let him fast therein. And whoever is ill or traveling, then the same number from different days. God wants to bring you ease and not to bring you hardship; and so that you may complete the count, and magnify God for what He has guided you, that you may be thankful.Qadr means equilibrated measure. It leads for me to equinox day where length of day is equal to length of night, at the same time, throughout the world.
Equinox day is an easy day to determine astronomically from very old times. It is the day where sun rise exactly at the east, in the exact middle (qadr) of two east?s.Ramadhan, in arabic etymology, refers to a hot summer period but also Ramadhyou points to first rains after the hot season.
Meaning of Word Ramadhan is sufficient to throw away the stupid Hijri calendar in which Ramadan can fall even in winter.
Word Ramadhan, alone, points also to the fact that ramadhan is linked to seasons, and then that the Islamic year is a solar year.So we can deduce that quran was revealed in a night of Both equinox day and full moon.
What about the year ?
302 The Romans was defeated.
303 At the ?lowest or nearest? part on the earth. But after their defeat, they will won.Then, Quran was then revealed after an appearent defeat of Romans and just before they bean to won.
History tell us that the curse of war between the two super powers at the era of Muhammad, that is Romans and Persians, who lasted from 602 to 628, occurred in 617.Astronomy tell us that 20 september 617 was both an equinox day and a full moon day.
Astronomy tell us also that full moon of that day was also a supermoon. That is that the moon was at his nearest point to earth so it was at his maximal size from earth.
(please verify by typing year 617 here http//www.fourmilab.ch/earthview/pacalc.html)
Next full Moon after (20 October 617) was a night of inchiqaq of moon, that is a lunar eclipse during full moon http//eclipse.gsfc.nasa.gov/5MCLEmap/0601-0700/LE0617-10-20P.gif).From theses proofs, we can deduce that laylatu el qadr means autumn equinox and from word ramadhan we can deduce that Ramadan points to a full moon that can coincides with autumnal equinox.
Please note that with a ramadan near equinox, we have no more the problem of length of day for muslims doing ramadhan in the noth pole. Neither in South pole. Since at equinox day, lentght of day is equal throyght the world.
Shahr ?counting?
936 The count of the months with God is twelve months in the book of God the day He created the heavens and the earth; four of them are ?haram?s. This is the correct system; so do not wrong yourselves in them; and fight the polytheists collectively as they fight you collectively. And know that God is with the righteous.
From old times, moon based calendar had the big problem to manage seasons linked to solar year. We will focus on Jews who resolved the problem by not taking account of some days in their lunar year and by adding a 13th month some years to ?recalibrate ? the moon counting to the solar year. That is the embolismic year.
937 ?The forgetting/nassiya? causes an increase in rejection, for it is used by those who have rejected that they may misguide with it by making it lawful one year, and forbidden one year, so as to circumvent the count of what God has made restricted; thus they make lawful what God has made forbidden. Their evil works have been adorned for them, and God does not guide the rejecting people.
Here, it is clear, that some years, Jews has the right ?calendar?. Muslims quite never since they generalized Nasiyya by hijri calendar.
9-36 ask to count ashor from 1 to 12 and not to take at all account of the 13 th eventual full moon in the solar year.The first shahr, that is shar Ramadan, will then be the first full moon after autimn equinox.
The 4 Ashor Haram
9-36 indicates clearly that there is 4 Ashor Haram between the 12 we should count in a year.To know what are these ashor , we have these verse using Hajj as time unit
2827 He said ?I wish you to marry one of my two daughters, on condition that you work for me through eight Hojaj; if you complete them to ten, it will be voluntary on your part. I do not wish to make this matter too difficult for you. You will find me, God willing, of the righteous.?
To be used as unit of time, Hojaj should indicate periods of equals length. Hojja is then also a trimester.
So Moses worked for his stepfather for 2 years and half.Ashor haram are then full moons 1, 4,7,11 after autumn equinox.
Please note that generally, moon seems full for 3 days each lunar month and begin insilakh at the fourth day. This is an another subject about how much saoum and Hajj lasts.What is the quranic name of a lunar month ?
A lunar month in quran is called sanaton, traduced by year.
296 And you will find them the most obsessive people regarding longevity; even more than the polytheists; each one of them wishes that he could live a thousand sanaton. It will not change for him the retribution even if he lived so long, God is watchful over what you do.
Thousand sanaton is about 80 years.
2914 And We had sent Noah to his people, so he stayed with them one thousand sanaton less fifty years. Then the flood took them while they were wicked.
So Noah stayed about 30 years between his people (1000 sanaton=81 years-50 years)
Noah never lived 950 years.1825 And they remained in their cave for three hundred sanaton, and increased by nine.
300 sanaton=exactly 25 years with decimals
No more need for "high longevity".
Sunnato Allah never Changes
Despicte reluctancy of muslims to follow what ?jews and Christians? do, it seems that the are nearer to the true ashor haram.
2197 The Hajj ashor are made known. So whoever decides to perform the Hajj therein, then there shall be no sexual approach, nor wickedness, nor baseless argument in the Hajj. And any good that you do, God is aware of it; and bring provisions for yourselves, though the best provision is righteousness; and be aware of Me O you who possess intelligence.
What mean Hajj Ashor are made known ?
That mean that it is not lost and that we can probably find then in jew version of sunnato allah.Jewish Feast of Succot is the 15 th day of 7 th month of jewish calendar who begin in march. It is called Hag ha (hajja?) Soukkot and occurs in the full moon of september/October. It is our ramadhan.
It is funny to note that ?the feast of the new year? is in the seven month of jewish calendar.
Pessah pilgrimnage Feast also occurs in a full moon (15 th day of the month) during first month of jewish calendar, that is 7 th month if we begin counting from September.
So we have already the two full moons near the two equinoxese in the jewish calendar.
They are accurately fixed by torah.The third pilgrimage Jewish feast is the Shavou'ot feast and don?t ?fit? with the summer solistice actually. It is now around May. However This Feast is not accurately fixed by torah who refers to ?agricultural timings?.
There is no 4th pilgrimnage. The lacking one should have occurred around December, the winter solistice, who correspond funningly to ?Birth of Jesus? and ?birth of Persian Mithra?. The facts that jewish would have rejected a pilgrimnage associated to the messiah they rejected is not amazing.
Zoroasters, considered as "people of the book" and religion of fathers of Bukhari, Tabari, Muslim, abu daoud, thirmidhi and so on, have also the problem of embolismic month and nassiya in the old calendar.
Nowadays, Zoroastrian calendar is based on solar system.Zoroaster year begin in the spring equinox (21 march) .
However, Zoroaster have 6 Festivals
Maidyozarem Gahambar ('mid-spring' feast), Apr 30 - May 4
Maidyoshahem Gahambar ('mid-summer' feast), Jun 29 - Jul 3
Paitishahem Gahambar (feast of 'bringing in the harvest', Sep 12 - Sep 16
Ayathrem Gahambar ('bringing home the herds', Oct 12 - Oct 16
Maidyarem Gahambar ('mid-year'/winter feast), Dec 31 - Jan 4
Hamaspathmaidyem Gahambar (feast of 'all souls', literally 'coming of the whole group', Mar 16 - Mar 20It is interesting to find that we find dates around the 2 equinoxes and 2 solstices and use of equinox as begin counting of a year.
It is also interesting to note that Maidyarem Gahamber is associated to winter solistice and to ?The occasion was celebrated in the ancient Persian Deygan Festival dedicated to Ahura Mazda, and Mithra on the first day of the month Dey????
(http//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winter_solstice#Deyg.C4.81n.2C_Maidyarem_.28Zoroastrian.2C_Greater_Iran.29).
Mithra, as you know, have many ?common points? with ?Jesus? (http//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mithras_in_comparison_with_other_belief_systems).Thanks, Peace and sorry for my english.
-
Thank you
-
Thanks to brother ayman, we know that shahr mean full moon.
Peace noshirk -- are you sure, how does one fast it or fight in it i.e. during single full-moon?
2185.... so from/who affirm/witness from among you al-shr/the lunar cycle (singular) so to fast/abstain it...
2217 they asking you about al-shr/the lunar cycle (singular) the haraam/prohibited fight in it say fight in it immense...What about the year ?
Which word is year exactly, solar/lunar?
These verses can only mean lunar year.
105 he the one made the sun illuminate and the moon a light and calculated it (masculine i.e. the moon) phases to know yeh number al-snyn/the years (lunar) and the account not create the god such except in the truth expounds the signs for folk knowing
1712 and made we the night and the daylight two signs so eliminate/erase we sign the night and made we sign the daylight visible that may seek yeh bounty from lord yours and know yeh number al-snyn/the years (lunar) and the account and every thing explained we it detailed
so erase we sign the night...
https//encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbnANd9GcSRm80JsiOIK1n0XPSeHz3K2OApCDgI0mgOgBum3MB-xTphKogY
What is the quranic name of a lunar month ?
A lunar month in quran is called sanaton, traduced by year.
296 And you will find them the most obsessive people regarding longevity; even more than the polytheists; each one of them wishes that he could live a thousand sanaton. It will not change for him the retribution even if he lived so long, God is watchful over what you do.
Thousand sanaton is about 80 years.
2914 And We had sent Noah to his people, so he stayed with them one thousand sanaton less fifty years. Then the flood took them while they were wicked.
So Noah stayed about 30 years between his people (1000 sanaton=81 years-50 years)
Noah never lived 950 years.1825 And they remained in their cave for three hundred sanaton, and increased by nine.
300 sanaton=exactly 25 years with decimals
40 x lunar months = 3.23 years (does a 3 year old reach maturity?)
4615 and enjoined we the human with parents his kindness carried him mother his unwillingly and gave birth him unwillingly and carried him and separation his thirty shra/lunar cycle of until when reached peak his and reached forty snh/age said lord grant me that I thank grace yours the one blessed thou to me and on parents mine and that do work righteous of which please you and correct for me in offspring mine that I perish to you and that I from the muslimuna/peacemakers
-
Peace all and thank you brother noshirk for some interesting new points.
Peace noshirk -- are you sure, how does one fast it or fight in it i.e. during single full-moon?
Please note that generally, moon seems full for 3 days each lunar month and begin insilakh at the fourth day. This is an another subject about how much saoum and Hajj lasts.
-
Peace all and thank you brother noshirk for some interesting new points.
Quote from Noon waalqalami on Today at 035613 pm
Peace noshirk -- are you sure, how does one fast it or fight in it i.e. during single full-moon?Quote from noshirk on Today at 093300 am
Please note that generally, moon seems full for 3 days each lunar month and begin insilakh at the fourth day. This is an another subject about how much saoum and Hajj lasts.Peace Timur -- please clarify if 3 days fast and no fighting; need to be consistent each verse.
2234 and the ones are dying from among you and leaving spouses of should wait by themselves four ashr/lunar cycles and ten of...
How long should they wait; 4 x 3 days full-moon = 12 days and 10 what exactly?
973 night the deliberation better from thousand shr/lunar cycle
Which is it?
1000 x 3 days full-moon = 8.21 years
OR 1000 lunar cycles = 80.85 years -
Peace Noon waalqalami.
2234 and the ones are dying from among you and leaving spouses of should wait by themselves four ashr/lunar cycles and ten of...
How long should they wait; 4 x 3 days full-moon = 12 days and 10 what exactly?
No, You should wait until you have seen 4 different full-moons plus 10 days. These 10 days are frequently mentioned in the qur'an.
973 night the deliberation better from thousand shr/lunar cycle
Which is it?
1000 x 3 days full-moon = 8.21 years
OR 1000 lunar cycles = 80.85 yearsLaylat ul-qadr (The ramadan fullmoon night) is better than a thousand different fullmoon nights, not any 8.21 years.
I admit 80.85 years - hinting to a lifetime - seems to be a possibilty, too.
Maybe shahr can mean both "fullmoon" and "lunar cycle around one fullmoon"="lunar month". Maybe this explains why there are two different plurals of shahr in the qur'an ashhur and shuhuur, shuhuur meaning full moons and ashhur meaning lunar cycles around full moons. I think there must be a logical explanation for these two forms. What is yours?
The above is no definitive truth, only some thoughts of mine.
Peace.
-
Peace Timur,
No, You should wait until you have seen 4 different full-moons plus 10 days. These 10 days are frequently mentioned in the qur'an.
No, days are not mentioned in the verse.
2234 ... four ashr/lunar cycles and ten of/for...
If ashr (leading alif denotes plural) means full-moons, they should wait/not remarry 4 full-moons + 10 = 14 full-moons.
If ashr means lunar cycles or 4 time-lengths moon phase to the same phase + 10 phases = 4 lunar months + 10 days.Example choose any date of her husband's passing e.g. tonight.
Lunar phase on 27 October 2013 http//www.farmersalmanac.com/calendar/moon-phases/http//www.farmersalmanac.com/wp-content/plugins/moon-phase-widget/moon-img/29.jpg
Thus she waits until 4 the same moon phase + 10 nightly phase changes is my current understanding.
https//encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbnANd9GcSRm80JsiOIK1n0XPSeHz3K2OApCDgI0mgOgBum3MB-xTphKogY
Laylat ul-qadr (The ramadan fullmoon night) is better than a thousand different fullmoon nights, not any 8.21 years.
I admit 80.85 years - hinting to a lifetime - seems to be a possibilty, too.
Again, it needs to be consistent; single full-moon night makes 1 or 3 day fast and no fight in it?
2185 ... so from/who affirm/witness from among you al-shr/the lunar cycle (singular) so to fast it (i.e. the lunar cycle) and from/who is illness of or on journey so count from days other...
2217 they asking you about al-shr/the lunar cycle (singular) the prohibited fight in it say fight in it immense...
Maybe shahr can mean both "fullmoon" and "lunar cycle around one fullmoon"="lunar month". Maybe this explains why there are two different plurals of shahr in the qur'an ashhur and shuhuur, shuhuur meaning full moons and ashhur meaning lunar cycles around full moons. I think there must be a logical explanation for these two forms. What is yours?
They are same; verse 936 ties count al-shwr (pl.) to 12 shra (singular) from it (i.e. count) 4 prohibited.
936 surely count al-shwr/the lunar cycles (pl.) near the god two ten (twelve) shra/lunar cycle of (noun) in book the god day creation the heavens and the earth from it four prohibited such the practice the value so not wrong yeh in them souls yours and fight yeh the idolaters all as what they fight you all and know yeh that the god with the righteous
Issue is which 4 exactly since they can vary be any of 12 with numerous combinations?
http//www.mathsisfun.com/combinatorics/combinations-permutations-calculator.html
-
40 x lunar months = 3.23 years (does a 3 year old reach maturity?)
4615 and enjoined we the human with parents his kindness carried him mother his unwillingly and gave birth him unwillingly and carried him and separation his thirty shra/lunar cycle of until when reached peak his and reached forty snh/age said lord grant me that I thank grace yours the one blessed thou to me and on parents mine and that do work righteous of which please you and correct for me in offspring mine that I perish to you and that I from the muslimuna/peacemakers
Salaam Noon
Rochd is a relative notion and depends on what we are asked to do.
Rochd is linked to age of marriage in 4-6 and to age were orphans can take their inheritage. 40 years seems too late.3 years and half old is sufficient for rochd to thanks parent and have a beginning knowledge of god.
I know many childs that can do what it is said in 46-15.
please see here http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9605273.msg32575at forty, many are unbelievers while at 3 and half, we were quite all believers, with quite no bullshits in mind.
Peace
-
Peace Timur,
Again, it needs to be consistent; single full-moon night makes 1 or 3 day fast and no fight in it?
Salaam again
in fact there is two kind of periods linked to hajj and saoum
there is absolutely no reason to consider that period of saoum is equal to periode of Hajj.
it is another subject but i tend actually to think that saoum=3 days and hajj=10 days.
Howeve, for that, we have to study accurately meaning of saoum and hajj and what is the aim of each duty.
Please note that never quran said that we have to do hajj at least once in a life.Peace
-
Salaam Noon
Rochd is a relative notion and depends on what we are asked to do.
Rochd is linked to age of marriage in 4-6 and to age were orphans can take their inheritage. 40 years seems too late.3 years and half old is sufficient for rochd to thanks parent and have a beginning knowledge of god.
I know many childs that can do what it is said in 46-15.
please see here http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9605273.msg32575at forty, many are unbelievers while at 3 and half, we were quite all believers, with quite no bullshits in mind.
Peace
Salam ,
The verse 46-15 is pointing to
al-Ashud , al-shidah / mean body strength , forcenot
al-rushd , al-rashad / mean heart maturity , reason , wiser ,
the rushed / maturity is required to be noticed in orphans to to have their money back to get married as per 4-6 , it's evident from the quran that the age of marriage so that orphans get their money is linked to both signs
al-rushd , al-rashad / mean heart maturity , reason , wiser ( and that as 4-6 )
and
al-Ashud , al-shidah / mean body strength , force ( and that as per 6-152 and 17-34 )
Why both al-rushd / maturity and al-shidah/ strength are required ?
Because a boy can reach body strength ( ashudah ) without being mature intelectualy ( rushdah ) so he should not yet get the money because no maturity and intellectual stability , good reasoning noticed and that judgement is as per 4-5 , this boy or men is called safih mean off one's nut or Ribald or impertinent .
So as per member noshirk statement regarding the word sanah ( a year ) , the 40 sanah ( years ) in 46-15 is equal to 3.3 years as member Noon noticed .
Lets assume a 3.3 years old boy reach maturity as member noshirk stated ( 40 sanah in al*quran equal to 3.3 solar years ) so the little boy can get married and have children and look after them and look after his wife , go to work and so on and on ....which is extremely non sens and laughing at readers inelegance .
Does the 3.3 "solar year" boy reach strengths too ? as per the word al-Ashud , al-shidah / mean strength and body force mentioned in 46-15 / 28-14 / 6-152 / 12/22 , if so we should expect 2 and 3 years old boy look like this
http//imageshack.us/a/img837/8563/m84i.jpg
Even with mega mass product you can't reach strength at the age of 3.3 old , and even if you did by all sort of genetic modification , you still didn't reach the age of maturity . -
salaam el kitab
4615 And We enjoined man to do good to his parents. His mother bore him with hardship, gave birth to him in hardship, and his bearing and weaning lasts thirty months. So that, when he has reached his "body strength", and he has reached forty sanaton, he says My Lord, direct me to appreciate the blessings You have bestowed upon me and upon my parents, and to do good work that pleases You. And let my progeny be righteous. I have repented to You; I am of those who have submitted.
Well, it is interesting to note that context of verse is placed around pregnancy and childhood.
9 months
30 months
40 months or jump directly to 40 years ?the fact is that what a "40 sanaton" old is asked to do in 46-15 can be done by a 3,3 years old child.
40 years olds is definitively too old for what is asked in 46-15.
Einstein wrote his relativity book at 26 years old.
Einstein isn't know to take "mega mass products"It is interesting to note also that 99,99% of all "high competition athletes" are "retired" at 40 years old.
The "maximum age of strenght" at 40 years is quite comical.
Peace -
salaam el kitab
4615 And We enjoined man to do good to his parents. His mother bore him with hardship, gave birth to him in hardship, and his bearing and weaning lasts thirty months. So that, when he has reached his "body strength", and he has reached forty sanaton, he says My Lord, direct me to appreciate the blessings You have bestowed upon me and upon my parents, and to do good work that pleases You. And let my progeny be righteous. I have repented to You; I am of those who have submitted.
Well, it is interesting to note that context of verse is placed around pregnancy and childhood.
9 months
30 months
40 months or jump directly to 40 years ?the fact is that what a "40 sanaton" old is asked to do in 46-15 can be done by a 3,3 years old child.
salam ,
So according to your claim the verse 4615 is understood according to you as so
Pregnancy + weaning = 30 months ( the months of pregnancy are included in the 30 months in the verse as per "hamloho / carrying him" not as you stated by 9 months of pregnancy separated )
According to you the 30 months child should reach only 3.3 years (40 lunar month ) so he reach body strength and maturity , get married ask allah to preserve his progeny !!!!!!!!!!!!?
If you take off 30 months of bearing ( pregnancy ) , breasting , weaning , from the 40 months (3.3 years) your child have 10 months left so to reach strength , maturity and get married and have children too , a 3.3 years old boy with children ? are you serious man ? If you argue that he is asking that for the future as he is not married yet when he said what he said in 4615 , how come a wiser boy of 3.3 years old saying all that wisdom in 4615 is waiting to not get married ? what he is waiting for ? you are automatically thinking because he is not matured yet and have strength for marriage , then your 3.3 years old theory collapse with the theory of Sanah/year equal to lunar month , because according to you maturity and strength are reached at the age of 3.3 .
-
Your understanding of that subject is conditioned by your perception of growth/age/ physical condections as per modern age analysis where a 40 years old man is already old sick and retired with white hear due to way of life , genetically modified food , stress and so on and on ...
-
Your understanding of the subject of maturity/al-rushd is also conditioned by your perception of inelegance as per your statement above regarding Einstein , someone can be very clever , analytically mind but still not mature / rashed , maturity is linked to conducts and behaviors , good works through correct thinking .
If you still persist about sanah/ year equal to lunar month , Can you kindly answer this questions
1- Is your 3.3 old man/boy theory for 4615 married or not ? does he has a progeny yet ?
2- You didn't find it logic to jump from 30 month to 40 years old , do you find it logic to jump from 3.3 years old to elders ?as per verses below ?- 40 - 67
4067 (It is He who created you from dust, then from a sperm-drop, then from a clinging clot; then He brings you out as a child; then that you reach your strength , then that you become elders. And among you is he who is taken in death before , so that you reach a specified term; and perhaps you will use reason.)
- 22 - 5
225 (O People, if you should be in doubt about the Resurrection, then indeed, We created you from dust, then from a sperm-drop, then from a clinging clot, and then from a lump of flesh, formed and unformed - that We may show you. And We settle in the wombs whom We will for a specified term, then We bring you out as a child, and then that you may reach your strength . And among you is he who is taken in death, and among you is he who is returned to the most decrepit age so that he knows, after knowledge, nothing. And you see the earth barren, but when We send down upon it rain, it quivers and swells and grows of every beautiful kind.)
-
-
salaam al kitab
( ة
*( ة
.According to this, Tifl should be traduced by newborn and not child.
Please note, in the verses you quoted, the "yokhrijakoum Tifl" wich clearly points that tifl is the "beginning", when we "get out".Now, a child of 3,3 years old can imagine himself as a parent.
Please see vendors of dolls.Peace
-
Peace all,
wasn't there a theory that sanat means half a solar year (period between solstices or eqinoxes)? Anyone remembers a link? According to that theory the age of body strength would be 20 years, which sounds very reasonable to me. 3.3 years are by far to less, 40 years by far to much.
-
Now, a child of 3,3 years old can imagine himself as a parent.
Salam noshirk ,
Can you kindly answer my 2 previous questions re-quoted below, and explain your logic accordingly .
If you still persist about sanah/ year equal to lunar month , Can you kindly answer this questions
1- Is your 3.3 old man/boy theory for 4615 married or not ? does he has a progeny yet ?
2- You didn't find it logic to jump from 30 month to 40 years old , do you find it logic to jump from 3.3 years old to elders ?as per verses below ? -
salam al kitab
All my life, i have understood sanaton as year and have read 46-15 as you read it now.
if we read 46-15 alone, then 40 yars explanations seems plausible.
but if we take into account the 950 years age of Noah and the 300 years of ahl el kahf, we have a problem.so, we have to choose between
1- 950 years, 300 years and 40 years
or
2- 31 years, 25 years and 3,3 years.please note, given the equation of god about noah (1000 sanaton- 50years= duration of staying of Noah between his people), then
sanaton=3 months leads to noah about 130 years
sanaton =6 months leads to noah about 370 yearsfrom a mathematical point of view, the problem for me resume to
can 3,3 fit to 46-15 ?
and not to
which between 40 years and 40 months explanations is better for 45-16 taken alone ?Now, lets go back to what you wrote in red.
46-15 is not saying that the 40 sanaton is married.
4615 And We enjoined man to do good to his parents. His mother bore him with hardship, gave birth to him in hardship, and his bearing and weaning lasts thirty months. So that, when he has reached his "body strength", and he has reached forty sanaton, he says
1 - My Lord, direct me to appreciate the blessings You have bestowed upon me and upon my parents,
2 -and to do good work that pleases You.
3- And let my progeny be righteous.
4- I have repented to You; I am of those who have submitted.it is obvious that it is kind of prayer (doua and not salat) for what will happen in future.
so your question becomes is a 3,3 years old can project himself as parent and ask God to direct him and direct his future childs ?My answer is yes.
see this video of a 3 years old reciter of quran http//www.youtube.com/watch?v=cyVoOcZZ3cE
what do you think he is thinking doing ?
there is many like him.at three years old, childs like to play with dolls. Many Vendors of dolls recommand from 3 years and older.
What a doll if not a kind of projection of child to be a parent.i gave you this link http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9605273.msg32575
there, we find thisIn his new book ?Born Believers The Science of Children's Religious Belief ? author, developmental psychologist and anthropologist Justin L. Barrett lists not only psychological experiments and studies, but information obtained by observing children. He provides evidence that even 12 months-old babies believe in God
12 month old believer ???
i prefer a 3,3 years old believer hypothesis to 950 years old man hypothesis.
Peace
-
please note, given the equation of god about noah (1000 sanaton- 50years= duration of staying of Noah between his people), then
sanaton=3 months leads to noah about 130 years
sanaton =6 months leads to noah about 370 yearsoups!
Equation 1000 sanaton- 50 years= duration of staying of Noah between his people
sanaton=1 months => Noah lived about 30 years in his people
sanaton=3 months => Noah lived about 190 years in his people
sanaton=6 months => Noah lived about 430 years in his people
sanaton=12months => Noah lived about 950 years in his peoplePeace
-
it is obvious that it is kind of prayer (doua and not salat) for what will happen in future.
so your question becomes is a 3,3 years old can project himself as parent and ask God to direct him and direct his future childs ?My answer is yes.
Salam Noshirk ,
What you formulate above in red wasn't my question at all , sorry to say that but You twist and deform my question to become look as what you have wrote above ,
There is difference between projecting someone self to something in the future and doing it or living among it .
my 1st question was
If you still persist about sanah/ year equal to lunar month , Can you kindly answer this questions
1- Is your 3.3 old man/boy theory for 4615 married or not ? does he has a progeny yet ?
see this video of a 3 years old reciter of quran http//www.youtube.com/watch?v=cyVoOcZZ3cE
what do you think he is thinking doing ?
there is many like him.at three years old, child's like to play with dolls. Many Vendors of dolls recommand from 3 years and older.
What a doll if not a kind of projection of child to be a parent.My 3th question
Can you kindly answer the following Do you think/ consider the boy in the link you provided married yet or no ? if so does he have children ( progeny ) ? how old you think his children are ?
No need to answer If you reject the concept of Sanah equal to one lunar month , and can you kindly review your calendar ? perhaps you bring something more accurate insha allah , and may allah guide us all to the accurate understanding and measurement regarding this topic .
-
salam al kitab
Is your 3.3 old man/boy theory for 4615 married or not ? does he has a progeny yet ?
No and no. Hope it is clear.
and 46-15 don't say that the 40 sanaton is married yet or having yet progeny
as you know, not all 40 years have parents still alive, are married and have progenyNow, sanaton is a singular form
I don't know what is singular in your understanding. 12 lunars months ?
can i have your understanding ?
How can you proove that sanaton is what you think. Why not half a year ? it would fit better with the maximum "body strenght"Please note that balagha Achaddahou is used also here
6-152 and 17-34 Age in wich inhertance is given to orphans
10-22 age in which Youssef get "knowledge"
18-82 age in which the two orphans will find the treasure of their father
28-14 age in wich Moses "istawa" and get knowledge (verse before is speaking about baby Moses)so, if balagha achaddahou points to an age, you will have whatsoever to abandon 12 months theory.
Peace
-
salam al kitab
Is your 3.3 old man/boy theory for 4615 married or not ? does he has a progeny yet ?
No and no. Hope it is clear.
and 46-15 don't say that the 40 sanaton is married yet or having yet progeny
as you know, not all 40 years have parents still alive, are married and have progenyNow, sanaton is a singular form
I don't know what is singular in your understanding. 12 lunars months ?
can i have your understanding ?
How can you proove that sanaton is what you think. Why not half a year ? it would fit better with the maximum "body strenght"Please note that balagha Achaddahou is used also here
6-152 and 17-34 Age in wich inhertance is given to orphans
10-22 age in which Youssef get "knowledge"
18-82 age in which the two orphans will find the treasure of their father
28-14 age in wich Moses "istawa" and get knowledge (verse before is speaking about baby Moses)so, if balagha achaddahou points to an age, you will have whatsoever to abandon 12 months theory.
Peace
Salam Noshirk ,
No need to repeat it as you only said it once .
I only want to show that the calendar you provided based in 3.3 years old in 4615 / a year equal to one lunar month is wrong and built upon a wrong basis , thank you for your sincere answer .
I Will inshallah share my views about the above .