Why reject all Hadeeth?
General Issues / Questions
1
Posts
1
Posters
30
Views
-
Why reject all Hadeeth out of hand? Isn't that just as foolish as accepting any and all hadeeth without question? I understand that hadeeth are for the most part hearsay, but although they may not have value as spiritual writings is it possible they could have historical value? After all, being hearsay doesn't automatically discredit them. It isn't impossible that what was said and what was heard was accurately and faithfully transmitted and recorded.
And please - I am not trolling. This is of dead serious concern to me so I would appreciate rational and thoughtful responses. I can go to a christian board if I want to get flamed, ridiculed, held in derision, etc.