Looking to interview code 19 deniers
-
Evidence proves Rashad Khalifa was not a Messenger. He made numerous mistakes in his teachings.
"If any book contains a few lies (and we have more than just "a few", then, the endorsement of that book is not reliable." 'Quran - A Reformist Translation' Appendix 6 "Why Trash All the Hadiths as Secondary Authority Beside the Quran?", pg. 627
From the quotation and juxtaposition above I predict that you will most likely be confusing the LIES with ERRORS. Let's see...
Allah does not make mistakes, nor forgets. Surah 482, 2052
Considering the context you are quoting this verse, I predict that you will most likely be confusing a fallible HUMAN with GOD and you have most likely IDOLIZED a human messenger. Let's see...
Reason upholds if a man says he is a Messenger of Allah and makes mistakes in his teachings, fabricating falsehood, he is not a Messenger.
As I predicted above you are confusing the human errors and deficiencies with lying. The human messenger in your mind cannot make any error in understanding. According to you a human messenger is omniscient, that is, has the same knowledge as God. According to you Muhammad knew everyhting mentioned in the Quran, which is clearly rejected by the Quran itself.
Reason upholds following hadith is forbidden by Allah, yet it is still upheld as proven by your removal of two ayats from your Quran translation, among other teachings by Rashad Khalifa upheld in your commentary and Appendices.
I am not following any commentary or appendices of Rashad, and I never quoted Rashad for saying this or saying that. You are making up your own story about me. As for the 9128-129 in your manuscript, I do not see your point here.... Since you mentioned here is a simple question what is your evidence that those two statements are indeed part of the Quran, not later addition to the manuscript? Do you have any evidence besides a NUMBEr, the number of the people who believe so?
He professed to represent a returning Messiah and Mahdi, teachings not found in the Quran. This is found in his newsletter and reported on submission.org
http//www.quranalone.com/SP/57_1989_09.pdf
http//www.submission.org/millennium/mahdi.htmlI disagree with you framing the issue, since Rashad rejected the Sunni and Shiite beliefs in returning Messiah and Mahdi. But, like everything you tend to understand the way you wish. I will not indulge in wasting time discussing Rashad's hadith.
Unfortunately, I do not have time to respond all of your arguments and indicate your errors and distortions. For instance, I see that you distort the translation of verse about the finality of prophethood.
Peace,
Edip -
From the quotation and juxtaposition above I predict that you will most likely be confusing the LIES with ERRORS. Let's see...
Calling oneself 'the Messiah and Mahdi' is an error and not a falsehood? When the Quran does not teach this, but the additions of man teach this, and the man STATES it was revealed to him by Gabriel, you say that is an error?
Allah is very clear about those who say something is revealed to them when it is not"And who does greater evil than he who forges against God a lie, or says, 'To me it has been revealed', when naught has been revealed to him, or he who says, 'I will send down the like of what God has sent down'? If thou couldst only see when the evildoers are in the agonies of death, and the angels are stretching out their hands 'Give up your souls! Today you shall be recompensed with the chastisement of humiliation for what you said untruly about God, waxing proud against His signs.'" Surah 693
A man who says he was revealed to by Allah teachings not found anywhere in the Quran is lying; fabricating falsehood.
"Whoso forges falsehood against God after that, those are the evildoers." Surah 394
You should have checked the links, Edip.
Considering the context you are quoting this verse, I predict that you will most likely be confusing a fallible HUMAN with GOD and you have most likely IDOLIZED a human messenger. Let's see...
Who is the one upholding a fallible human's teachings and human hadith to remove ayats from the Quran, as well as uphold teachings the Quran does not teach?
Rashad Khalifa stated hadith are false teachings of man, yet he pulls from hadith to remove two ayats from the Quran to support his Code 19. His Code 19 does not work if the Quran is unchanged. And as shown earlier, Allah promised to protect the Quran and states that falsehood would not enter it in the past or in the future. Surah 4142But by removing the two ayats, you bear witness Allah did not uphold His Word.
You give ammunition to the disbelievers who come forth and say Allah did not protect the Quran by allowing falsehood to enter it over 1400 years ago.As I predicted above you are confusing the human errors and deficiencies with lying. The human messenger in your mind cannot make any error in understanding. According to you a human messenger is omniscient, that is, has the same knowledge as God. According to you Muhammad knew everyhting mentioned in the Quran, which is clearly rejected by the Quran itself.
Wrong.
Muhammad (pbuh) taught ONLY what Allah told him to say."Had he invented against Us any sayings, We would have seized him by the right hand, then We would surely have cut his life-vein and not one of you could have defended him." Surah 6944-47
Muhammad bore witness that he followed only what Allah revealed. He repeats this numerous times in the Quran. Surah 650, 7203-204, 1015, 469
No where have I stated Muhammad (pbuh) was omniscient or possessed attributes of Allah. Please avoid creating strawman rhetoric, as it only proves your foundation is made from sand, and you seek to beat up a false argument.
The statement is concerning what the man taught, and who he said he was giving him his teachings.
Rashad Khalifa changed his Quran translation to insert his name into it. He removed ayats based on teachings found in hadith, to support his false 'Code 19' doctrine. He said he was given revelation, even going to far as to meet all the Prophets (pbut) when ascended to 'heaven' during Pilgrimage.
How can a person meet all the Prophets when everyone is sleeping in the grave, and won't be returned until the Day of Judgment?
Answer He cannot.Do you deny Rashad Khalifa did any of the above?
If he did one of these actions, he is a false Messenger, as he teaches what Allah did not reveal nor upholds in the Quran.Rashad Khalifa stated he was receiving revelation and was sent as a 'Messenger of the Covenant', teachings lifted from the Bible and not from the Quran. As a person who says he receives revelation, but then makes mistakes, Allah is crystal clear
""Will they not then meditate on the Quran? And if it were from any other than Allah, they would have found in it many a discrepancy." Surah 482
You cannot hide from the teachings Rashad himself professed.
I am not following any commentary or appendices of Rashad, and I never quoted Rashad for saying this or saying that. You are making up your own story about me. As for the 9128-129 in your manuscript, I do not see your point here.... Since you mentioned here is a simple question what is your evidence that those two statements are indeed part of the Quran, not later addition to the manuscript? Do you have any evidence besides a NUMBEr, the number of the people who believe so?
You don't follow any commentary of Rashad's, nor his Appendices? Allow me to bring my proof from your own Quran translation.
In your Quran translation above Surah 381 you have 'The Messenger after All Prophets', which is a teaching of Rashad Khalifa, who would 'verify' previous Books.
The Quran was sent to verify (musaddiqun) previous Books Surah 381, 4252, 548, 241, 289, 291, 2101, 303, 692
"And when (Wa-ith) God took (akhatha Allahu) Compact of the Prophets (meethaqa alnnabiyyeena) 'That I have given you of Book and Wisdom; then there shall come to you a Messenger verifying (musaddiqun) what is with you -- you shall believe in him and you shall help him; do you agree?' He said. 'And do you take My load on you on that condition?' They said, 'We do agree.' God said, 'Bear witness so, and I shall be with you among the witnesses.'" Surah 381
"Wa-ith akhatha Allahu meethaqa alnnabiyyeena lama ataytukum min kitabin wahikmatin thumma jaakum rasoolun musaddiqun lima maAAakum latu/minunna bihi walatansurunnahu qala aaqrartum waakhathtum AAala thalikum isree qaloo aqrarna qala faishhadoo waana maAAakum mina alshshahideena" Surah 381
This Compact - promise, agreement - is with those who inherited the Book, for the Messengers of Allah verified the Book that was with them.
"And when God took compact (meethaqa) with those who had been given the Book 'You shall make it clear unto the people, and not conceal it.' But they rejected it behind their backs and sold it for a small price -- how evil was that their selling!" Surah 3187
The Quran verifies previous Books.
"And We have sent down to thee the Book with the truth, verifying (musaddiqan) the Book that was before it, and assuring it. So judge between them according to what God has sent down, and do not follow their caprices, to forsake the truth that has come to thee. To every one of you We have appointed a right way and an open road. If God had willed, He would have made you one nation; but that He may try you in what has come to you. So be you forward in good works; unto God shall you return, all together; and He will tell you of that whereon you were at variance." Surah 548
"This is a Book We have sent down, blessed and verifying (musaddiqu) that which was before it, and for thee to warn the Mother of Cities and those about her; and those who believe in the world to come believe in it, and watch over their prayers." Surah 692
"He has sent down upon thee the Book with the truth, verifying (musaddiqan) what was before it, and He sent down the Torah and the Gospel." Surah 33
"When there has come to them a Messenger (rasoolun) from God verifying (musaddiqun) what was with them, a party of them that were given the Book reject the Book of God behind their backs, as though they knew not," Surah 2101
"And believe in that I have sent down, verifying (musaddiqan) that which is with you, and be not the first to disbelieve in it. And sell not My signs for a little price; and fear you Me." Surah 241
Surah 337-8 speaks of the Covenant and Compacts taken by those sent the Messengers; an agreement Allah takes with all who submit their will to Him
"And remember God's blessing upon you, and His compact (wameethaqahu) which He made with you when you said, 'We have heard and we obey. And fear you God; surely God knows the thoughts in the breasts." Surah 57
"And when We took Compact (meethaqahum) of the Prophets, and from thee, and from Noah, and Abraham, Moses, and Isa, Mary's son; We took from them a solemn compact (meethaqan) that He might question the truthful concerning their truthfulness; and He has prepared for the unbelievers a painful chastisement." Surah 337-8
Covenant and Compact of the Book and Prophets Surah 227, 263, 283-84, 377, 381, 3187, 57, 512-14, 570, 6152, 7169, 1320, 1325, 1691, 1695, 1734, 1978, 3315, 3323, 4810, 578
Compact/agreement (meethaqan) 421, 490, 492, 856, 872, 1266, 1280"And We took compact (meethaqa)with the Children of Israel, and We sent Messengers (rusulan) to them. Whensoever there came to them a Messenger (rasoolun) with that their souls had not desire for, some they cried lies to, and some they slew." Surah 570
"And there succeeded after them a succession who inherited the Book, taking the chance goods of this lower world, and saying, 'It will be forgiven us'; and if chance goods the like of them come to them, they will take them. Has not the compact of the Book (meethaqu alkitabi) been taken touching them, that they should say concerning God nothing but the truth? And they have studied what is in it; and the Last Abode is better for those who are godfearing. Do you not understand?" Surah 7169
"such as break the covenant of God after its solemn binding (meethaqihi), and such as cut what God has commanded should be joined, and such as do corruption in the land -- they shall be the losers." Surah 287
"And those who break the covenant of God after His compact (meethaqihi), and who snap what God has commanded to be joined, and who work corruption in the earth -- theirs shall be the curse, and theirs the Evil Abode." Surah 1325
"How is it with you, that you believe not in God seeing that the Messenger is calling you to believe in your Lord, and He has taken compact (meethaqakum) with you, if you are believers?" Surah 578
"God took compact (meethaqa)with the Children of Israel; and We raised up from among them twelve chieftains. And God said, 'I am with you. Surely, if you perform the prayer, and pay the alms, and believe in My Messengers and succour them, and lend to God a good loan, I will acquit you of your evil deeds, and I will admit you to gardens underneath which rivers flow. So whosoever of you thereafter disbelieves, surely he has gone astray from the right way. "
So for their breaking their compact (meethaqahum) We cursed them and made their hearts hard, they perverting words from their meanings; and they have forgotten a portion of that they were reminded of; and thou wilt never cease to light upon some act of treachery on their part, except a few of them. Yet pardon them, and forgive; surely God loves the good-doers.
And with those who say 'We are Christians' We took compact (meethaqahum); and they have forgotten a portion of that they were reminded of. So We have stirred up among them enmity and hatred, till the Day of Resurrection; and God will assuredly tell them of the things they wrought." Surah 513-14"So, for their breaking the compact (meethaqahum), and disbelieving in the signs of God, and slaying the Prophets without right, and for their saying, 'Our hearts are uncircumcised' -- nay, but God sealed them for their unbelief, so they believe not, except a few --" Surah 4155
In your Appendix 3, you even quote Rashad's Quran translation "Simple To Understand, Impossible To Imitate". You use the same teachings as found in his Appendices to 'prove' Code 19, even giving detailed description of Rashad Khalifa and his life. Do you want me to go through your entire Quran and post the numerous recycled teachings therein?
There are more than 9, Edip.
And you continue to uphold numerous other teachings found in hadith, copied into Rashad's Appendices, and continued in your translation/Appendices. Granted, you add new teachings like allowing abortion, but the focus of this dialogue is on what you are recycling, not the new fabrications in your translation Appendices.I disagree with you framing the issue, since Rashad rejected the Sunni and Shiite beliefs in returning Messiah and Mahdi. But, like everything you tend to understand the way you wish. I will not indulge in wasting time discussing Rashad's hadith.
Let's quote his words as shown on his newsletter and on the website, shall we?
"Through Gabriel; I was commanded to make this announcement AFTER I DIE MILLIONS OF BELIEVERS WILL KNOW That I represent the Messiah the Jews have been waiting for, the Christ Christians have been expecting, the Mehdi the Muslims have been praying for? I am God's Messenger of the Covenant."
Does not sound like he rejected the beliefs in a returning Messiah and Mahdi if he is proclaiming himself to be those individuals. Proof is from his own words.
Unfortunately, I do not have time to respond all of your arguments and indicate your errors and distortions. For instance, I see that you distort the translation of verse about the finality of prophethood.
Then insha'Allah, if you ever find the time Respond. I will bring proof from the Quran to support why I believe what I believe.
Until you respond, they are unanswered."Then if they do not answer thee, know that they are only following their caprices; and who is further astray than he who follows his caprice without guidance from God? Surely God guides not the people of the evildoers." Surah 2850
My obligation is only to remind and warn, Edip. I have done so and will continue to respond to you using proof from the Quran, insha'Allah.
To me are my deeds and to you are your own. I won't be asked what you did, and on the Day of Judgment we will see who is rightly guided and who was led astray by teachings of satans.
But you cannot say you were not warned.May Allah guide us closer to the Truth.
Peace.
-
Yesterday, Dave Silverman, president of Amer Atheists Org, did better job than the other leading atheist, Michael Shermer in cross-examination. Yet, towards the end of the two-hour debate, he asked help from a magician, the so-called Amazing Randi against 19. That is very interesting, since just a few minutes before, I read to him som...e verses from Chapter 74, including, "it is only an impressive magic." Interestingly, after hearing some examples of 19 in the Quran, he could not say anything except, "Have you met Randi? You should see him for this..."
The shooting for two documentary films is going very well, beyond our expecations. The famous imam of New York's biggest mosque, Shamsi Ali, could not sustain his calm and smiling face against my Socratic grilling for 15 minutes. He got mad and started yelling at me in the middle of his mosque and perfectly fulfilled 7450-51. He left his mosque to me and the film crew.
I will, inshallah, soon write a report on this issue. The docu-films will inshallah be ready by the new year.
-
Today, one of the most famous American atheists was exposed and literally check-mated in a Socratic debate between me and him on the Quran, its scientific aspect and code 19.
I will write an article on this issue. The docufilm, will inshallah be ready by the end of this year.
Peace,
EdipHonest question for you. Do you care more about finding the truth, or more about 'winning' and 'checkmating' and monopolozing and taking credit for ideas? I've followed your often-deluded work for years now, and it definitely seems like the latter. You are an incredibly arrogant person who sometimes has good intentions. Often, however, you care more about Edip than you do the truth. Very obvious. It is a very very big problem for you.
Here's some advice take a break from ramming Code 19 down peoples' throats and instead focus on bettering yourself. You have a massive problem with egotism and arrogance. Growth isn't just about numerology and quranic minutiae. You have serious personality flaws that you need to work on.
I'm guessing you won't be responding to this post -- you'll be too busy posting about how you beat yet another opponent into submission -- so I'm going to PM you about this too.
-
You are an incredibly arrogant person who......
besides he is ignorant of mathematics..unfortunately
you care more about Edip than you do the truth
he cares more about Edip's beliefs (about 19) than he does the truth.
It is a very very big problem for you
it is rather a very very big problem for 19 miracle, since people trust and listen to him about 19 issues..
on the other hand 19 phenomena are a fact and it is really amazing that even sunnis respect these phenomena more than only-quraners do
peace
-
Those who are the real arrogant are those who are blind and deaf to divine signs. See 7146.
Those who have lost the arguments against my position were more articulate than me. So, the credit does not go to me, but to the truth that I am conveying.However, arrogant people project their arrogancy. When they cannot deal with the subject matter and when they lose the argument, they indulge in personal attacks on the winnig party's character.
These who are attacking my person are demonstrating their pathetic contradiction. They hurl arrogant and false accusations, yet they pretend to be humble and righteous!
The issue is not me, it is the message I am delivering. Primarily, it is not me, it is the truth that you are hating. I hope that you take heed and explore the subject with objectivity and humility.
What I posted here are true and people will inshallah see it witness it with their eyes and ears when the docu-film is published. Then, you will be exposed as a liar by accusing me of being arrogant for merely telling the truth!
Peace
Edip -
Those who are the real arrogant are those who are blind and deaf to divine signs. See 7146.
Those who have lost the arguments against my position were more articulate than me. So, the credit does not go to me, but to the truth that I am conveying.However, arrogant people project their arrogancy. When they cannot deal with the subject matter and when they lose the argument, they indulge in personal attacks on the winnig party's character.
These who are attacking my person are demonstrating their pathetic contradiction. They hurl arrogant and false accusations, yet they pretend to be humble and righteous!
The issue is not me, it is the message I am delivering. Primarily, it is not me, it is the truth that you are hating. I hope that you take heed and explore the subject with objectivity and humility.
What I posted here are true and people will inshallah see it witness it with their eyes and ears when the docu-film is published. Then, you will be exposed as a liar by accusing me of being arrogant for merely telling the truth!
Peace
EdipThis post proves my point exactly. You have no idea where I stand on Code 19. You just assume I am against it since I am against you. Again, ego.
The code aside, you are arrogant. Me exposed as a liar? A liar about what? I said nothing about the validity of the code, only about your demonstrable character.
At any rate, thanks for proving my point.
-
This post proves my point exactly. You have no idea where I stand on Code 19. You just assume I am against it since I am against you. Again, ego.
You might have another problem, Caveman. Do you have any human idol whom you deem infallible? Or do you claim that you are in agreement with me on major theological issues and the only problem you have is my ego? Are you going to hide from people the real reason why you attack my character?
Peace,
Edip -
You might have another problem, Caveman. Do you have any human idol whom you deem infallible? Or do you claim that you are in agreement with me on major theological issues and the only problem you have is my ego? Are you going to hide from people the real reason why you attack my character?
Peace,
EdipStop with the red herrings. My post was about your massive ego and arrogance. That is all. No ulterior motives. Nothing about theology.
It was just about you. Can you accept that someone can be discussing you without also discussing the code, or the quran, or God? Contrary to what you may think, you are not the code, you are not the quran, you are not God. You are Edip, an egotistical arrogant man. And that's all I commented on. Deal with it.
-
You are Edip, an egotistical arrogant man.
repent caveman repent !!! how do you dare to speak so about the assistant messenger of the covenant ?
Anyone who disagrees with Edip on God Quran and code issues is ignorant arrogant and even kafir ;D
repent boy !!!!
-
Salam,
So Edip is the "Sahaba", the righteously guided one rotfl lol, who cares about what Edip believes or I believe. I just want to see the video, I am dying to see it. Will it be in English ? Come on somebody please release a trailer or some clips please (
Peace
----------- Student of Allah -
Interestingly, after hearing some examples of 19 in the Quran, he could not say anything except, "Have you met Randi? You should see him for this..."
Not everyone is familiar with how you comb through Qur'an looking multiples and manipulate data.
Perhaps tell him
57 in chapter 42 that starts with
97 in chapter 68 which now you manipulated to start with and created a new initial Wa
How you flip columns showing arrangements that are multiple, hiding everything that?s not.
Total word ltrs gv
102 1 3 2 60 40
66 2 4 1 30 30 5
329 3 6 1 30 200 8 40 50
289 4 6 1 30 200 8 10 40786 not multiple!
Let's try it with ?In name SEid the merciful the inventor?
GV = 26040 6070104 13020081040 1302120010Total word ltrs gv
102 1 3 2 60 40
144 2 4 60 70 10 4
289 3 6 1 30 200 8 10 40
244 4 6 1 30 2 1 200 10779 Multiple!
-
19 letters = 19 x 1
-
GV Total 779 = 19 x 41
-
Letters GV 3 26040 4 6070104 6 13020081040 6 1302120010 = 19 x ?
-
Sequence number Word Size 1 3 2 4 3 6 4 6 = 19 x 19 x...
-
Sequence number Cumulative number of letters 1 3 2 7 3 13 4 19 = 19 x...
-
Conjoined letter numbers added 150426287722 = 19 x...
-
Letter number Sequence number 1231 45672 89101112133 1415161718194 = 19 x...
-
1 sentence 19 letters lengths of words 1193466 = 19 x 19 x 19 x...
-
Sequence number Word Size Word GV 1 3 102 2 4 144 3 6 289 4 6 244 = 19 x...
-
Sequence number Word GV Cumulative GV 1 102 102 2 144 246 3 289 535 4 244 779 = 19 x...
-
Sequence number Word GV Cumulative number letters
1 102 3 2 144 7 3 289 13 4 244 19 = 19 x... -
Sequence number Cumulative GV First&Last GV Values
1 102 42 2 246 64 3 535 41 4 779 11 = 19 x... -
Sequence number Word GV Series Word Size
1 26040 3 2 6070104 4 3 13020081040 6 4 1302120010 6 = 19 x... -
Sequence number Individual GV Value Word Size
1 2 60 40 32 60 70 10 4 43 1 30 200 8 10 40 64 1 30 2 1 200 10 6 = 19 x... -
Sequence number Word GV Series Letter number
1 26040 123 2 6070104 4567 3 13020081040 8910111213 4 1302120010 141516171819 = 19 x... -
Local letter number Individual GV Value Sequence number
1 2 2 60 3 40 1 1 60 2 70 3 10 4 4 2 1 1 2 30 3 200 4 8 5 10 6 40 3 1 1 2 30 3 2 4 1 5 200 6 10 4 = 19 x... -
Sequence number Local letter number Individual GV Value
1 1 2 2 60 3 40 2 1 60 2 70 3 10 4 4 3 1 1 2 30 3 200 4 8 5 10 6 40 4 1 1 2 30 3 2 4 1 5 200 6 10 = 19 x... -
?In name SEid the merciful the inventor? appended front and end with 666
666 26040 6070104 13020081040 1302120010 666 = 19 x ...
- appended front and end by gv of Allah
130305
102 1 3 2 60 40
144 2 4 60 70 10 4
289 3 6 1 30 200 8 10 40
244 4 6 1 30 2 1 200 10
130305= 19 x ...
This nineteen stuff is truly for the most ignorant people on this planet!
-
-
The sopposed fact that the book Moby Dick is structured and can be altered to fit the 19 code shows its baseless numerology. Unless of course God revealed moby dick lol. Which would be silly. Regardless as an earlier poster noted whether it be true or not it has no essential base for a believer. I dont need numbers to believe in the Quran, and applying reason and logic, you can understand and see the valifity and truth to the Quran. whether it is structured mathematically or not Allah knows, as I am horrible in math and would never want to rely on another to explain that to me. So w.e the case Quran is perfect, and if someone needs a number to believe its message. They are deluded. Peace be unto you all