Jilbab [Quran 33:59]

Wakas

peace bro hk, all,

2196, 2238, 4101/102, 3356, 3359 and some other verses are time bound and circumstantial revelation. All these verses have no influence on the believers as of today because the verses were revealed to the people of the prophet who were present with the the Prophet. The verses revealed were a solution to crisis which the believers faced. Today there exist no hostile situation, no fear of the enemy, therefore all those verses which are related to fear and hostility cease to be effective today.

"time bound" is different to "circumstantial revelation".

Also, specific addressee is different to general addressee.

A careful study will allow us to determine the relevance.

diamantinehoneybunch

Dear Ms Purdah,

What can you say about some places where women are PUNISHED for NOT covering their faces or head huh?

Hide from men?
What kind of stupidity is this?

Women are humans. Men are humans. Both MUST honor themselves, have self-respect and respect each other.

To be soft is to be covered in sacks? See how brainswashed you are.

First of all, women are humans. Men are humans. I never say women can be exactly like men such as exposing chest. But covering the whole body is like equating women to indescent and shameful objects that must be covered to be honorable.

It is of course ridiculous to say to be 'soft' is to cover everything.

Some idiots say women who don't want to cover and want justice and equality just want to be men. What the ****? Those women never say they want to marry women, have male sexual organs, have beards, cut off their bosoms, wear male clothing. They just want justice, equality and same respects. Those people who say these wise women 'want to be men' are idiots.

I am sorry for calling you Ms Purdah coz it is difficult to spell your name.

Why must women hide themselves from men? Women are humans, madam! There are also shy men out there. Do you mean being soft as being polite? How should a man be polite? They do not have to cover themselves to be polite but when it comes to women, women must imprison themselves in black blanket to look polite and show their softness?

4913 O people, We created you from a male and female, and We made you into nations and tribes, that you may know one another. Surely, the most honorable among you in the sight of God is the most righteous. God is Knowledgeable, Expert.

971 And the believing males and the believing females, they are allies to one another............

If you look at these verses, there are no such things as women must hide themselves from men or women must imprison themselves in prison-like clothes to 'honor' themselves or to show their 'softness'.

According to devoutly religious Sunni scholars, women are (awrat). Awrat means indescent, nakedness, shames, genitalia so women must cover themselves like the ghostman in movie Scream to 'honor' themselves. Sunnism is terrible.

If you are saying that women must cover and hide themselves but men can go out freely and expose their normally to appear body parts? hands, feet, elbows, necks, faces, heads, hair, ears,? these mean that you are saying that women are lower and less honorable than men in nature. Ughhh.

I remember reading a Bible verse, according to that verse, it says something like this "I thought she was a prostitute because she covers her face". I didn't remember which verse and chapter it is in.

So far, I have never seen any verses in Qur'an commanding women to hide themselves in prison-like cloaks

Verse 2431 simply says women to lower their gaze, cover their private parts, put coverings over bosoms (paraphrased cover bosoms with coverings) and cover their beauty except that are NORMALLY TO APPEAR; that they may not show their beauty except to some group of people, the people that are listed as exceptions include both some group of WOMEN and MEN, and children that DO NOT UNDERSTOOD THE AWRAT (which means shames, nakedness, indecency) of women. The phrase "their women" also means that even some group of women are excluded from the exception list. The verse never says women who are in the exception lists are Muslim women. It just says "their women" so this verse has nothing to do with niqab / burqa / purdah and veils.

Why I capitalize the "do not understand awrat of women" is, women should not wear clothes that make people think of their nakedness when in public. When women wear tight and revealing (such as mini skirts, shorts, spaghetti string) clothes in public, it will caught naughty eyes. So the phrase "children who have not understood yet the awrat of women" shows that the beauty that must not be revealed is some body parts that some people will think of nakedness of women when they see. Children are in the exception list because children do not understand awrat of women even if women wear shorts and tight t-shirts in front of them.
Showing hair and face do not make some people think of nakedness of some people.

Yes, women must cover more than men because women have more attractions that are indecent to reveal even to women. It is clear when women are commanded to cover their breasts but men are not. And women must cover a little more than men must, because women have curvey body, right? It is not decent for women to show their tighs, belly, cleavages and wear tight clothes that reveal the body shapes of women. However, it doesn't mean women must wrap their whole bodies with blankets.
But women are allowed to rest their dress code in front of some group of people.

Verse 2460 simply means women who have passed child-bearing are allowed to put off their garments. Old women no longer have attractions so they are allowed to wear shorts and singlets. People would not fantasize their nakedness while they are looking at old women who wear overly simple clothes.

Jilbab doesn't only have one meaning which means women's garment that covers the whole body. It can also mean wide garment for a woman. In verse 3359, the verb that comes from the root -- or -- which means put lower, lengthen is used and the full word of the root in the verse is / yudneena, which is 3rd person imperfect plural verb. If the jilbab that is used in 3359 means burqa, purdah etc, then how can it will be lowered or lengthened since the type of cloth is already loose, long and baggy? This verse also has nothing to do with burqa because of the word yudneena, and the other meaning of jilbab.

Some put the obligation for women only because their excuses are men will stare at women, men will rape women, women are so attractive that men will be aroused when stare at non-burqa-wearing women and non-hijabi women. Oh what the hell? In verse 2430, men must lower their gaze too! If verse 2431 is commanding women to imprison themselves in prison-like clothes, then there would be little to no use for men to lower their gaze.
Men should not also harm or harass women.

I am sorry if I seem to fail to convey what I want to say.

Regards,
Yuliana

diamantinehoneybunch

I am sick of burqa lovers keep saying that those who are not fond of burqa or veils are just supporting women selling their bodies. Why is this stereotype?

Imagine Women Employees / Workers.

http//www.asianews.it/files/img/AFGHANISTAN_(it)0416-_Burqa_in_crisi.jpg
Women who dress like this as workers in workplaces are and look so unprofessional.

http//www.5pillarz.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/burka-500x373.jpg
They look a tiny bit better than the above picture because they at least show their eyes. But it is still unprofessional for workers to wear it in workplaces.

http//scanfree.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/tumblr_m40f2diJ6W1r0cc7uo1_1280.jpg
This woman dresses modestly. Even if she does not cover her head, she'd still look modest. Head and hair have nothing to do with immodesty. She looks professional

http//www.thelifeofluxury.com/images/woman_suit.jpg
This woman looks professional and respected. Hijab has nothing to do with modesty. Look as professional as the above picture. Anyways I am not sure whether the skirt that she wears reaches almost her ankles or not but let say or just assume that it reaches.

http//www.dwgriffithforever.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/womens-work-clothes.jpg
The woman at the left is not so modest but still looks much more professional than the burqa / purdah wearers. The middle and the right look professional.

http//allfinds.org/pict/women/2/173.jpg
This is not modest. This seems like the woman wants to make a exhibition of her ***. Respected women, don't wear this!

http//www.eurweb.com/2011/03/ask-tamara-too-sexy-for-the-workplace/
Well I don't want to show the image on this site. If employers out there who have female workers wearing like this, FIRE HER!

unknownuser

FIRST, IT"S DAMN MY POST WAS ERASED, SO I MUST REPEAT AGAIN brickwall brickwall

I want to repeat again for my long post , NO WAYY brickwall brickwall..

Sorry I'm little bit emotion

huruf

Why such an obsession with the modesty of women. The morals of societies are not bankrupt because of them, but because of the free way that unmodest males have obtained for themselves.

It is men who pay prostitutes or force women, not women who force males or pay prostitutes to have fun. It is men to twist everything so as to make it possible for them to gain sex any time without entailments. They have shown under any conditions that they do not need any enticement to be licencious, rather they pester women and think up any trick to have them against their will or by seduction with empty words. They are the ones who make sex a past time, which should only be allowed free to them. How many times has been discussed in these forums the poligamy and concubinage issue and how many times we have seen that it is considered by many as something that men should be able to avail themselves of.

Things being so, why on earth, why, but why the only talk bout modesty is about women, not about the real killers of modesty and self respect which are licentious males? And i will not go into the leering of some of those beasts at the sight of any woman if they feel no stranger is watching.

What a joke is this hypocritical talk of some muslims about modesty! Modesty my foot! It is all about constricting women. If it was about modesty they would be too busy calling males to attention of the many sins they have on them. I am sick to death of all the talk about virtue equating it with women dress. From wherever that may come, it is surely not from Qur'an.

What is the complain about women. Earth's population everybody agrees that it is enormous and even threaten that the earth cannot hold more people, but women keep being blamed for not furfilling their duties with the family. Men continue to be the rapers and the payers of vice everywhere, but it is women who get the perennial sermon on modesty, thausands of pages after thousands of pages without end and then starting all over?

Are we nuts or what? If a sex is failing it is not certainly women. They have more than fulfilled their duties under any circumstances, in most cases, unbearable circumstances. Please, some respect and some rahma. All will ask for rahme when they are in front of the only judge. Go then and blame women and talk about modesty, God is no fool.

Salaam

JavaLatte

Salaam sister mamnoeoea. Thank you for your feedback.

A bomb can hide under a wide coat also it don't need a a face veil for it..many suicide attackers didn't were burqa or face-veil..a large coat is enough to hide something.

But the case is, by using burqa or niqab (it usually known as clothe for women), other people may think that they are ordinary women who are not dangerous.

However, irrespective from that, of course many other crimes committed without burqa or niqab.

Although I don't support burqa or niqab/purdah - I can't, sister ( - I know that I can't forbid woman who really want to wear it.

I hope women will think and ponder themselves to find out whether such clothes instructed by God to be worn by us. I hope by their own consciousness, women will stop to wear this excessive religious clothing.

Sister I am a woman who likes to wear the faceveil but don't want that I will trown in prison for to wear one..

I don't think you will be in jail because of wearing face veil, sis.

I like long skirts and got used to wear headscarf when I go to crowded streets (headscarf is already like casual wear in Indonesia).

However, I don't agree the assumption that women who wear scarf/veil are better (in their faith) than women who don't wear scarf/veil.

With a soft hart,a real soft hart it is not possible for any woman to be not shy in front of men but in this time shyness is called weakness and weakness as a child as prudish..prudish is in the west a blame,a weakness,for to laugh at and something that have to be overcome..but in islam and with my veil I feel that this natural shyness being respected because it is part of me as a woman..
Many woman see braveness as the solution,as a worthy quality and see their shyness in front of woman as no selfconfidence,weakness etcetera.

I think both men and women should have soft heart.

The matter is how and where to apply it right. For example, I believe we should be use the soft heart towards believers.

And both men and women should have braveness, the courage, we should have the courage to defend the right path.

The One who grant good qualities is Allah, our Lord. If person has good qualities, it is because of what Allah has taught. It is not because they wear scarf/burqas/niqab, it is not because they keep and take care of their beards.

But from the purdah I believe now that only in purdah we can have a realy soft hart..purdah and the other rules from God allows the woman to be free,to not have to sale their looks for a minimum price..the abuse of their natural human female qualities like shyness,softness,lovelyness,cuteness..

???

Where did you learn this kind of things?

Sister, I hope you decide your path by yourself without influences of scholars/imams/clerics/religious teachers/sheiks/madhhabs. Leave them, and get focus on God's verses.

Beware of hadiths and you should remove the influences of your religious leaders/religious preachers, many lectures they say are actually poisons to your mind. The Qur'an actually dismantle their frauds.

Allow your brain to think freely and ask for guidance only to your Creator.

Many of brothers and sisters here share their knowledge with us, without aims to find devotees, without asking for payment like what usually done by those Islamic clerics.

Sister mamnoeoea, if you carefully read the posts from brothers and sisters on this forum, you're probably going to find gold pieces of knowledge scattered among many other posts, these golden knowledge are valuable to read.

Please be patient with us, sister. We still have a lot shortcomings, but inshaAllah we are willing to learn. Hopefully you also get the benefit of our discussions. group

A woman become harsh when she looses her natural feeling to purdah,to hide from men..

Firstly, I thought purdah is face veil, but then I found other meaning that 'purdah' is when women are shut away from the outside world, just seeing their direct relatives. Do you refer to this kind of purdah?

Salaam.

JavaLatte

Peace brother hafeez kazi. Thank you.

Btw, I like your understanding of mosque.

I am a Muslim who visited mosques till the age of 45 but when I started reading and understanding Quran, I felt that the mosque of Quran is an institution where there is an spiritual uplift of the believers, a place where the visitors get purified from SHIRK and SINS. a place where the problem of the society's are solved, a place where the believers receive guidance,It is a place where the community members are inspired to do good deeds and execute good manners, to forbid the community members from committing evil deeds, a place where the believers discuss about Quran and the system of Allah, a place where where the conditions of some unfortunate people of the society who are in need are brought to the notice of the society and urge them to help those needy.

Sorry to quote it here - it's off topic - but that is lovely description of the mosque. peace

No one knows why they wear Burqa / veil

Don't forget, brother. Allah certainly knows.

they are told by their Mullahs and their ignorant scholars to do such things.

Yes, I suppose the answer is something like that.

I also had years when I was influenced by Sunni things (Sunni preachers & Sunni books are everywhere in my country).

They made me believe that it is an obligation to cover women's hair.

I ever thought that sahih hadiths are true, ever thought the scholars are good people who can be trusted.

I didn't think that there will be turning point in my life, now I considered an apostate by them.

Thank you very much Allah, for saving many of us here from the hadith.

I think the Qur'an contains lessons which direct women to dress modestly, to cover body parts that might invite a lot of attention. And what I believe now is that the head is not part that must covered.

I suppose decent outer garment is already sufficient for women - and men should also dress modestly. ;D

But the burqa is... -X

The religious authorities should not force women to wear burqa if they don't want it.

This burqa outfit is excessive and it is like 'walking prison' for women, they cannot breathe freely, they cannot see freely.

The wearing of the burqa / veil is a manifestation of following the likes of Bukhari, the idiot Mullahs and the nonsensical scholars who are themselves misguided and are also misguiding others.

Blue Agreed. That's why they are dangerous. >(

But the scholars also think that those who don't follow the sunna are misguided and are misguiding. Perhaps we are also dangerous for them. D

Peace.

mamnoeoea_qatief_alazhaar

As salaamu aleykum

There are so many answers and so many opinions.

Truth seeking is not an easy way.

I am finding all your answers quit interesting.

But I don't like that the niqab/burqa is under shot because many woman likes to wear them.
It means is not woman unfriendly for those who like to wear them..
I can imagine that it is hard to understand that a woman like to wear a dress like this but trust me there are many of those woman.

That woman like to cover themselves without obligation

In some opinions I read that we have to dress modesty without to cover face and hands etcetera..it would mean that men are only attracted by seeing a but or bossoms (like some people think that surah an nour explains) or for some people who cover the hair to hair..I think that the attraction lays in a pretty face,lovely eyes and yes even pretty hands..but in a hedonistic time like this we can't believe such things..we did see so much nakedness and perversities that we don't feel anymore the attraction of beautiful hands of a woman or a pretty neckline..
I can't believe that God command us against of attraction (modesty) only to cover our brests (that would be more sexistic for men..it mean that men only are attracted to breasts etc..

I think that full the woman is attractive like told by our prophet sallalahu aleyhi wa salaam (Al ma'a tu awrah) and that is a compliment in stead of the other explenations that people give on the ayah..

Thus not only breasts have to be covered,this is also a lie

Woman are beautiful and attractive and men could never resist on their beauty..a men who only can be attarcted when a woman shows her brest is a pervert..

God never commands such things

Man_of_Faith

Salaam,

The less used to seeing the beauty of a woman the more you react when you see one without more clothes. I found that true when I lived a few years in Iran and then moved back to Sweden and my views have changed dramatically when it comes to how people dress and what is vulgar. I do not advocate the dress code of orthodox Muslims, but I think one should dress relatively modest. But when you get more used to seeing half-naked women the less you react and I think it is a situation difficult to handle for some people born in the Middle-East who were never used to seeing so much naked skin.

Seeing much of the cleavage of women is a bit distasteful in my opinion, but quite natural in Western countries, and it used to be something that provoked me less in the past when I was younger, and probably more indoctrinated in the culture. I agree with some people here that the Qur'an talks about hiding private parts and prevent the body from moving sexually to cause immodest attaction.

God bless you

huruf

As salaamu aleykum

There are so many answers and so many opinions.

Truth seeking is not an easy way.

I am finding all your answers quit interesting.

But I don't like that the niqab/burqa is under shot because many woman likes to wear them.
It means is not woman unfriendly for those who like to wear them..
I can imagine that it is hard to understand that a woman like to wear a dress like this but trust me there are many of those woman.

That woman like to cover themselves without obligation

In some opinions I read that we have to dress modesty without to cover face and hands etcetera..it would mean that men are only attracted by seeing a but or bossoms (like some people think that surah an nour explains) or for some people who cover the hair to hair..I think that the attraction lays in a pretty face,lovely eyes and yes even pretty hands..but in a hedonistic time like this we can't believe such things..we did see so much nakedness and perversities that we don't feel anymore the attraction of beautiful hands of a woman or a pretty neckline..
I can't believe that God command us against of attraction (modesty) only to cover our brests (that would be more sexistic for men..it mean that men only are attracted to breasts etc..

I think that full the woman is attractive like told by our prophet sallalahu aleyhi wa salaam (Al ma'a tu awrah) and that is a compliment in stead of the other explenations that people give on the ayah..

Thus not only breasts have to be covered,this is also a lie

Woman are beautiful and attractive and men could never resist on their beauty..a men who only can be attarcted when a woman shows her brest is a pervert..

God never commands such things

So beauty is attractive

?What a discovery! And since it is attractive we should ruan away from it, or rather, if the beauty happens to be that of a woman, she must hide, but it is the beauty of a man then there is no need to hide. ?What an awful nonsense!

I like beautiful women, I like beautiful me, I like beautiful landscapes, I like beautiful buildings, I like beatuful gardens, beautiful words, beautiful sounds, beautiful smells, that does not mean that I have to offend anybody because of that or leer salaciously to anybody because they are beautiful.

Have you read the Qur'an? I can't appreciate you have, because if you had, you should remember that there is no instance in the Qur'an where any male is tempted by a woman , covered or not, to the point of making him loose his self-command, but, on the contrary there is the narration of Yusuf where not just one woman, several of them loose their self command because of the beauty of a beautiful man who did nGiod would hide his beauty. Had God commanded somebody to cover beauty because it was tempting, certainly God would have commanded Yusuf to do it, but he did not nor did He command such a thing to anybody man or woman. So beauty is not something that anybody must hide. It is up to those who see it to keep their selfr control and respect themselves.

That beauty should be covered is the opinion of some people who fear it, but it is not something God has commanded or even hinted at.

It is really alarming that a great gift of God to his creatures such as beauty be maligned and transformed in s fearful thing.

Woman are beautiful and attractive and men could never resist on their beauty..a men who only can be attarcted when a woman shows her brest is a pervert..

This is one of the funiest things I have read. Men can and do resist anything and certainly any woman if it is in their interest. You would be surprised how callous they can get with a woman, enven the most beautuiful and the most sexy if they risk loosing something because of that purported attraction. And contrariwise they cannot resist any woman if it is in their interest not to resist her, like if they stand nothing to fear for profiting from her. You must be very young, I think to believe such fairy tales.

Concerning covering the face a find it rahter awkward to other people. There are people who do not have a good hearing and who need to watch the lips of the talker. When somebody covers his or her face, it may be difficult for them to communicate with others. They will be communicating only with those with a perfect hearing, and even then it may be uncomfortable. I do feel uncomfortable not being able to watch the the face of the person I am talking to. Also, the kind of atire of those who cover the ears may create difficulty in hearing. Myself if I can talk to somebody I can look on the face, I certainly prefer it. I find the whole thing of covering the face not a great idea in general. But it is up to the person to dress the way she or he prefers, but one should not be surprised if dressing in a certain way makes communication more difficult.

Again, the virtue of males is not a responsability of any female, it is wholly the responsibilite of the males, an vice versa. So this beauty covering business is bullshit, so that females can be encumbered with enormous responsibilities that God has not put on them, and that is perfectly shown in the narration about Yusulf in the honourable Qur'an. Hiyab, nikab, burqa or whatever as an instrument of virtue or as holier than other dress is bullshit and not Quranic. If anybody wants to wear it, it is his or her own good choice but it is no command or hint or advice given by God.

Remember Yusuf, he was so attractive, why didn't he cover and caused such havoc that all the poor females cut their hands? How thoughtless of him. That men get turned so much on by women that they cannot resist God has not said, but that a man's beauty can be so tempting He has narrated in detail. So fantasizing about the power of the females' beauty is fantasizing, but hte beauty of a male can wreak havoc, the word of God.

Salaam

unknownuser

Salaam

The one of the reason I do not interested to get discussion with qatif is .

Indeed sister mamnuua qatif is a Sunni.
If she a follower of Quran Alone then why she still follow Sunni's mufaseer like Ibnu Taimiyah.

This will be called a circular reasoning.
The example is if we Muslim, the source of our guidance is Quran not Veda, Tripitaka because if yes then our fiqh, theology will be dissaray.

So if she keep do circular reasoning then discussion with her about tafseer is nothing, because intepretation between non-hadith and based-hadith has some distinct gap.

diamantinehoneybunch

Dear Qatief,

Again, you INSULTED women as humans.

You said that women are attractive so men who see attractions will.........

Hey men are also attractive!
I am attracted to Syrian singer Mohamad Bash's face because his face is so cute, handsome and hot.

There are many other hot men that attract the female crowd and make the women scream and shout and some of the crazy women chase, hug and even kiss the hot men's cheeks.

But of course it is stupid to say those hot men must cover in the prison-like clothes.

Are you blind to see the words "except what is ordinary to appear". If you say cover everything than what the **** is the part that is normal to appear?

Some Japanese and Korean girls are interested in Caucasian guys with tall bodies, blue eyes, blonde hair, prominent noses, broad shoulders, muscular bodies, 6 packs etc and other physical characteristics that attract those girls. Both men and women have attractions and beauties.
Yes, both women and men must not reveal their awrat. I have already explained what awrat is.

You are equating the whole women's bodies to awrat? Oh my God!
Awrat means genitalia, nakedness, indecency. You are saying women = genitalia = private parts = nakedness = shames = indecency? Seriously you are so brainwashed. You are insulting your own gender! Merciful God doesn't create women as genitalia so please stop acting like people with 3rd class brain / minds.

mamnoeoea_qatief_alazhaar

As salaamu aleykum

You are not on the pad and sure you can use some softness as a woman..you are insulting other human because of you are talking rude,boorisch,onruspectful..

If this is your interpretation to be a good human and a muslim how you are acting..then astafar..

Also you are intolerant for other meanings..you are insulting me with a 3rd brain level but cna't give a wise and nice answer without to laugh with others,to insult them,to be cynical..

Bravo honeybuch..you are the example of a free woman with "guts" if you wanted to proove this someone have to give you an applaus

For me I like more softness than rudeness as a woman and alhamdullilah..to visit this site have a good side-effect..it makes me more solid in my deen and my beliefs..I feel that rude people can't have the truth and God only leads the nice-ones ,the ones who loves other people with their hart...people who are nice,cute and loving Allah ,they are the ones we have to follow,not the rude-ones who think they have the truth..

Thanks that God put you on my way so that I canlearn from your acts what a muslim not have to be..and thanks to guide me again on the path..

I wish that Allah will guide you to the truth and let have respect for other opinions because rudeness is a sin

JavaLatte

Peace sister mamnoeoea.

Please forgive us if we've offended you, and please keep be patient. Thank you. handshake

We don't want to harm you. I suppose we just hope that more people can be aware and free of brainwashing using hadiths.

Perhaps you can spend time to trace the introduction pages http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?board=26.0

There are many forum members who shared their experiences. Hopefully their stories (of real experiences) make you understand why people like us are here.

Sister, from what you describe about 'woman and men', it seems that your mindset influenced by some kind of bizarre doctrines.

Did you learn from books that include many Sunni hadiths as references?

Be careful when you read that kind of books, because Sunni (and the other Islamic sects) blend Qur'an verses with hadiths.

One of the awful things done by the extreme hadiths followers is insisting to 'protect' women by restricting their movement, keeping them in houses, making them not free to do outside activities.

How about women/girls who have to work hard, for example female farmers.

They are helping their husbands/fathers in order to fulfill their family needs. How they can work in the fields and gardens if the whole body is covered?

How they can get enough food for the family if they are only care about beauties and attractiveness issues?

If those women stop working because of applying purdah and hide at home or behind burqa to feel soft and lovely, then who will finance their daily needs?

Whether the imams/scholars/clerics would support those women's needs? I guess not.

The imams/scholars/clerics fond to issue fatwas - act like 'the Lord', telling this is haram, that is haram.

Many famous Sunni clerics living prosperous from the money given by their worshipers, they don't even care that through the Qur'an, God teaches us to ask of no fee/reward when inviting people to God's path. That is mean not even a penny we can receive from da'wah, because da'wah is not for sale! Many clerics seem so blind to see this simple rule.

If men want to be leader for women, they should maintain community security and protect stability, so the women can safely indulge/active in their own community environment.

Protecting women doesn't mean treating women like pets. Women also have capability to advance community. To achieve healthy community progress, men must be willing to work together with women as solid partners.

If the men curb the women, their community will be gloomy and defective, difficult to develop.

Peace.

Bender

Salaam

The one of the reason I do not interested to get discussion with qatif is .

Indeed sister mamnuua qatif is a Sunni.
If she a follower of Quran Alone then why she still follow Sunni's mufaseer like Ibnu Taimiyah.

This will be called a circular reasoning.
The example is if we Muslim, the source of our guidance is Quran not Veda, Tripitaka because if yes then our fiqh, theology will be dissaray.

So if she keep do circular reasoning then discussion with her about tafseer is nothing, because intepretation between non-hadith and based-hadith has some distinct gap.

Salaamun alayka,

Why do you have for her other standards then you have for yourself?

salaam,
Bender

muslims

Salam

It is quite okay to be Sunni, Hadithers, Buddhist, Hinduist, Satanist, Luciferianist or etc. since no "religion" has a monopoly on truth and believe it or not, we are all those things, at one time or another.

Peace

unknownuser

Salaamun alayka,

Why do you have for her other standards then you have for yourself?

salaam,
Bender

Peace to you too.

Maybe I should wrote like this "If we want study Math, then we must use Math book not history book.

mamnoeoea_qatief_alazhaar

As salaamu aleykum

I can't believe my eyes what I read from some members here.

Please..pray for the sake of your soul.

In the holy quran is written somewhere..do they believe that we will treat the misguided like the moetaqoen.;what's wrong with them..yes what is wrong with them?

If for some members everything is allowed,why there would be need for any guidance..and the people finds themselfs selfsufficient (they think they don't need anyone and know everything with their own brains and own hands..but BE CAREFULL..only God is the provider and only by his rules and his commands a soul will be saved by the punishement of hell or maybe they even don't believe in hell..and yes..what's wrong with them shalla we treat the misguided like the moetaqoen..

muslims

God is the provider and only by his rules and his commands a soul will be saved by the punishement of hell

Salam

What are His rules and commands?

Peace peace

mamnoeoea_qatief_alazhaar