What Constitutes a Muslim?
-
Peace Anwar,
It can be a little hard to follow, so to summarise are you saying that for example, islam means compliance, period...not compliance to God as a whole? And muslim means submitter, not a submitter to God as a whole?
But maybe everyone here is just here to save Islam, and they will do it any cost. Maybe truth is not the real issue here, and I've' got it all twisted.
Thus, by using the above... if someone claims to be saving islam then all he is really doing is saving compliance?
I hope i got that right? Or please clarify...
-
Peace,
Peace Anwar,
It can be a little hard to follow, so to summarise are you saying that for example, islam means compliance, period...not compliance to God as a whole? And muslim means submitter, not a submitter to God as a whole?
Yes, Islam means compliance, period, not compliance to God as whole. You've got it. And muslim only means 'submissive' and not submissive to God as a whole. That is atleast in Classical Arabic.
Now what it means to the modern world and what it has meant to Muslims for over 1000 years now (after the Koran) is another issue. But it is an issue that has nothing to do with Classical Arabic despite the lies and interpretations of the scholars.
Quote
But maybe everyone here is just here to save Islam, and they will do it any cost. Maybe truth is not the real issue here, and I've' got it all twisted.Thus, by using the above... if someone claims to be saving islam then all he is really doing is saving compliance?
In its classical Arabic sense yes. But when I said it in that sentence above I meant it in the sense that Muslims have been understanding the word for over a thousand years now, which is basically Mohammadenism in all its "accepted" forms, from moderate to extreme.
I hope i got that right? Or please clarify...
Yeah, you got it right. I'm glad you did. It is very hard for Muslims to free themselves of the brainwashing that they have been raised with and see Islam, both the word and the religion, as it really is.
Godbless,
ProGod -
Peace,
Now what it means to the modern world and what it has meant to Muslims for over 1000 years now (after the Koran) is another issue. But it is an issue that has nothing to do with Classical Arabic despite the lies and interpretations of the scholars.
I see, that makes sense...if the definitions are still there for us to reach this conclusion then the lies and interpretations don't matter...they are just that...
In its classical Arabic sense yes. But when I said it in that sentence above I meant it in the sense that Muslims have been understanding the word for over a thousand years now, which is basically Mohammadenism in all its "accepted" forms, from moderate to extreme.
I see your point...
It is very hard for Muslims to free themselves of the brainwashing that they have been raised with and see Islam, both the word and the religion, as it really is.
I agree, it's difficult... thank you for clarifying!
-
PEACE, PRO GOD,
Yes, Islam means compliance, period, not compliance to God as whole. You've got it. And muslim only means 'submissive' and not submissive to God as a whole. That is atleast in Classical Arabic. Now what it means to the modern world and what it has meant to Muslims for over 1000 years now (after the Koran) is another issue. But it is an issue that has nothing to do with Classical Arabic despite the lies and interpretations of the scholars.
My question to you is, how is Allah using/defining muslim in Al-Quran/Al-Islam? Does muslim simply mean "submissive" or does it mean, specifically, being submissive to Allah? Was Ibrahim simply being submissive to "whatever", and, if so, what was he being sumissive to? or was he being submissive to Allah?
-
Hi,
Well, from what I can conclude, is that those calling themselves ?muslim? actually should call themselves ?muhammedan??
And that to call yourself ?muslim? means that you are doing your very best to follow God?s words. Whether you succeed is a whole other story?
So now, how on earth can we understand who is a ?muslim? and who is a ?muhammedan?, or something else, calling him/herself ?muslim??
Seems to me the word has a very heavy load already?
Do we have to further clarify what we put in the word when we use it?How am I doing so far?
Regds
Ali Omar
-
Priest Bokmei
My question to you is, how is Allah using/defining muslim in Al-Quran/Al-Islam?
God doesn't define the word in the Koran. Islam already had a definition before the Koran every came about. The word Islam in its meaning of 'submission' will naturally only be used in context. You can see well in the Arabic that where the word 'Islam(submission/compliance)' is used the object of that compliance is stated in the context. Most times in the Koran it is to God. But in one context it is to Solomon, where Sheba complied/showed submissiveness to Solomon.
Does muslim simply mean "submissive" or does it mean, specifically, being submissive to Allah?
It simply means 'submissive.'
Was Ibrahim simply being submissive to "whatever", and, if so, what was he being sumissive to?
The context in the Koran is clear that he was being submissive to God. But just like I'm saying 'submissive' + to + God it also says this in the Arabic like 'God we count on you God may we be submissive' or 'God, make us submissive to you.'
or was he being submissive to Allah?
He was being submissvie to God, but the Koran mentions the word 'submissive' or 'muslim' in context adding 'to God' or having the person praying to God and praying to be submissive.
Godbless,
ProGod -
SaLaM Ali Omar
The funny thing is , even a christian is a muslim when he is being submissive to his/her God. Well, its the wrong God, but still he is being muslim / submissive to it. Allah literally means the God. So when christians are being submissive to Jesus, even tho they are misguided, they are still being muslim.
-
Jaxal,
I know you might not even be agreeing with me but my point is that 'muslim' doesn't even mean 'submissive to God' it just means submissive. So subjects of the king are submissvie(muslim) to their king, children are supposed to be submissive(muslim) to their parents and people in general are supposed to be submissve(muslim) to God.
Godbless,
ProGod -
SaLaM progod
No brother i AM agreeing with you. When a christian is completely devoted to his/her God ( i.e Jesus or Mary or the trinity etc... ) then you CAN call that christian a muslim. Even Jews are muslim. Lollllllll hahahhhhh this is funny loooooooooooooooooollllllll
-
Salaam,
You cannot pray to a human and especially not a human who isn't here on earth.
God is the only ONE we can and shall pray to.
He is our creator and we are his creations.
Peace
Sis MajidahPs. prayings to Jesus,Mary,Muhammad etc are uselessD.s
-
Salaam Elena,
I'm aware of that sister!
And it makes me more thankful to Allah that I have opened my yes for the truth and not follow old hearsays.
The Bible have been so manipulated so I'm afraid that all is hearsays or the most of it is.
Peace
Sis Majidah -
-
You can see well in the Arabic that where the word 'Islam(submission/compliance)' is used the object of that compliance is stated in the context. Most times in the Koran it is to God. But in one context it is to Solomon, where Sheba complied/showed submissiveness to Solomon.
D
-
SaLaM Elena
I liked ur 2 green lemon pic more. Yea sunnis pray to Prophet Muhammad all the time. Not like praying to God. But like, they pray to him to intercede for them. Do u understand? So if i was a sunni, i would pray to Prophet Muhammad to ask God to forgive me. That kind of pray. http//www.geocities.com/bigjaxal/s1.gif
-
Salaam Elena,
It's true what Br Jaxal is saying, there are muslims who pray to Muhammad but they don't admit it.
I can take some examples, in their daily 5 times salat they always greet the prophet even if it is GOD they alone should greet.
And some muslims are celebrating the birthday of the prophet and there they use to sing hymns to the prophet and it goes like this I guess.
Sallalahu alaihi wa salaam sallalahu wa alaihi Muhammad
Peace
Sis Majidah
