How Authentic is the Quran?
-
SaLaM Joe
shock What answer were you expecting? Apart from it being common knowledge that the Torah was given to Moses, i gave you a direct answer to your question. There wouldnt be any mention in the Quran about who are why the Torah was revealed. There is no reason to. But if you want to make sure that it IS Moses/Musa, study judaism. It wont bite.
Now, if you yourself dont know the answer, then that is another thing. But that is as clear of answer you will get .
-
Salaam Jaxal,
Just to be clear, the quran never mentions that the Torah was given to Moses, but it just happens to mention that the Gospel was given to Jesus? Pray tell! If it is COMMON KNOWLEDGE. So indeed, why should Allah mention it. To tell you the truth, I would not follow your methodology to determining such a thing. Clearly there are soe kinks that need to be worked out.
Joe
-
mquran, why would i to continue discussing with you when you admit you cant refute the evidence? Give me 5 good reaons to do that.
lol, i thought so. ok , thanks a lot for proving my point, homer. for the record, your so called evidence is easily refutable. why do you think 2pac doesnt pursue the question i asked
Ok, lets say they can 'prove' the approximation of the date. Does that prove Mohamed approved of it? The jump from date approximation to Mohamed's authentication is rather far. Can I ask you, can someone else not have written it? Can you know for sure?
Because anyone with a half a brain will realise that there is no way anyone can say anything was authenticated by Muhammad unless the Quran itself verifies it. However Homer, you seem lacking even that half.
The only reason you believe in manuscripts is because you got yourself into it and now your inability to understand, let alone refute is showing. I have to say, I havent met anyone like you before, but it takes all sorts, doesnt it..lol.
im done talking to you, but i'll continue to watch your 'torah conversation' with joe. hehe , its so funny watching him toy with you. Reminds me of my cat when she catchs a mouse....
-
Does Quran mentions not to marry 9 year olds even tho they reach their menstration cycle? Anyways, if we want to learn abou the Torah, then we have to pick up the Torah for that and learn basic of judaism
Wow, now Homer's accusing God of approving of PAEDOPHILA. Amazing, this moron is simply amazing.
What answer were you expecting? Apart from it being common knowledge that the Torah was given to Moses, i gave you a direct answer to your question. There wouldnt be any mention in the Quran about who are why the Torah was revealed. There is no reason to. But if you want to make sure that it IS Moses/Musa, study judaism. It wont bite.
Common knowledge? no wonder he wants to go stone-kissing in mecca! its common knowldge. Is there a book called 'common knowledge by jaxal'? It will contains factoids like 'quran teaches democracy', 'quran says to do hajj in mecca', 'prophet muhammad married a nine year old because the quran says its ok' and other misdeeds. Broadmoor will have a good time studying this one...
LOL...'if you want to know moses , study JUDAISM?'. Oh boy..what a fellow ! Here's what Judaism thinks of Moses17Now therefore kill every male among the little ones and kill every woman that hath known man by lying with him.
18But all the women children, that have not known a man by lying with him, keep alive for yourselves.
According to Jaxal's 'torah' belief, MOSES said the above. No wonder Jaxal thinks the Quran approves of paedophilia. He's already got paedophilia on the brain thanks to 'moses' of the torah...lol
For Muslims reading this, please note that according to al-quraan, musa never said any such thing. This perverted book called the Torah is part of the Old Testament, a collection of stories about so-called 'Hebrew Prophets'. Sadly, the Sunnis have bought this 'previous scripture' theory and along with them are ppl who claim to be quranic but also think the quran approves of paedophila. Such people fail to actually open the quran and quote a single verse and so instead of speaking with thier mouths, thier rear-ends end up doing the talking...
-
Ok, lets say they can 'prove' the approximation of the date. Does that prove Mohamed approved of it? The jump from date approximation to Mohamed's authentication is rather far. Can I ask you, can someone else not have written it? Can you know for sure? <---- this one
-
Ok, lets say they can 'prove' the approximation of the date. Does that prove Mohamed approved of it? The jump from date approximation to Mohamed's authentication is rather far. Can I ask you, can someone else not have written it? Can you know for sure? <---- this one
Of course you cannot know for sure but my point is which one is authentic?? If there's different Quran's as in minor differences how do you know that YOU have the authenticated one by Muhammed when it was revealed??Can you know for sure too??We cannot escape that there are different Quran's out there and we cannot know for sure which is the definite one revealed to Muhammed.
PEACE
-
SaLaM Joe
Again, who was the Torah given to according your methodology?
In your opinion , what does 11.17 says?
im done talking to you
After such a humiliation i put your through, why would talk to me D
its so funny watching him toy with you
Just like it was fun for me to toy with you with ur ridiculous claim of Quran being anti - democratic. Just like it was fun for me toy with ur reidiculour claim that the messenger needs to have good presentation skills. AND just like it was fun for me to toy with your ridiculour claim that Quran is not altered LOOOOOOOOOOOOOL rotfl rotfl
-
Salaam Jaxal,
Again, who was the Torah given to according your methodology?
In your opinion , what does 11.17 says?
I will be blunt. Show me where the quran says the Allah has given tauraat to moosa. 1117 does not mention moosa being given tauraat. So please I am STILL awaiting your prompt response.
Joe
-
Salaam Jaxal,
If the quran has no reason to mention it, why mention it is isa's case?
You believe in order to know about tauraat and musa we must study the Bible. Here you are renouncing alquran.
Jaxal, still, even still, you have not shown me were Allah has stated that He has given musa tauraat.
Joe
-
SaLaM Joe
You believe in order to know about tauraat and musa we must study the Bible
What is wrong with that? You think Quran tells us about these characters in detial? Why does it mean that im renouning the Quran?
And you still, even still, you have not shown me who the Torah was given to. Not even attempted to answer. I answered your question. Now answer mine.
-
Salaamun alaikum 2pac,
Of course you cannot know for sure but my point is which one is authentic??
Right, THAT was my point. We can't possibly tell if the manuscripts are authentic. Thank you. Now I will address your query.
If there's different Quran's as in minor differences how do you know that YOU have the authenticated one by Muhammed when it was revealed??Can you know for sure too??We cannot escape that there are different Quran's out there and we cannot know for sure which is the definite one revealed to Muhammed.
I answered above and will repaste here Al-quraan starts with the assertion of the protection of az-zikr. Az-zikr, if you check 68/4 , means 'the one in eminence'. This is your starting point. Go anywhere in the world and check for the one in eminence. Al-quraan anywhere is one and the same. Secondly, its in 'lisaanun arabiyun mubiin' (16/103). Check your manuscripts and you will see that its ambiguities are very telling. I mentioned before that Ayman tried to manipulate the meaning of 30/1 , saying instead of the romans being defeated, the romans defeated. He could only do that to an ambigious text, but never to the one in eminence. Third and fourthly, please see wakas and joe's post.
hope that helps.
-
Salaam Jaxal,
What is wrong with that?
Only that it makes you a doubter.
You think Quran tells us about these characters in detial?
Definately.
Why does it mean that im renouning the Quran?
Jaxal you believe that in order to know musa and tauraat one must turn to the Bible. This is why.
And you still, even still, you have not shown me who the Torah was given to. Not even attempted to answer.
I told you why already. Pay attention will you?
I answered your question. Now answer mine.
Could you be more clear in it? Are you saying that Allah never mentions giving tauraat to musa?
Joe
-
Again, who was the Torah given to according your methodology?
In your opinion , what does 11.17 says?
Pathetic loser doesn't even know what how 'taurat' is spelled. Its a pity Jaxal's similarly gigantic ego cannot come to terms with the fact that 'tauraat' is never associated with Musa. He need to adopt the Torah, a racist evil book with paedophilic tendencies..I wonder why?
Here's 11/17 for believers in al-quraan
Can they be (like) those who accept a Clear (Sign) from their Lord, and whom a witness from Himself doth teach, as did the Book of Moses before it,- a guide and a mercy? They believe therein; but those of the Sects that reject it,- the Fire will be their promised meeting-place. Be not then in doubt thereon for it is the truth from thy Lord yet many among men do not believe! -
SaLaM Joe
OMG YES! tht is what im saying!
mquran, dont be a mental retard. Atleast out of the whole book, you learnt the spelling of Torah. The rest, is like when a blind kid tries to read. And u aint even blind man. Or is it simply that you are too traumatized from a broken marriage or something? do you always have a big mouth on forums? Are u trying to make up for somethng you lack in real life?