what scientific evidence from the Quran was not known to the peers of its time?
-
Peace enquirer,
Is there any wisdom in the quran that is not present in other books/elsewhere?
I really could not answer that question since
• I would not be so bold as to claim I've grasped all the wisdom that the Qur'an offers (and if I ever do, please smack me)
• I would not be so bold to claim that I've grasped all the wisdom in all other books/elsewhere
Is there any objective proof of the qurans validity?
I don't know. I've always followed my inner compass in my search for al-haqq. I think truly objective proof of just about anything is impossible, since the entire universe itself is subjective, or "omni-jective".
Peace,
Tay -
Peace tay and all. I respect your answers,methods,and humbleness...
If i re-word my questions a little,...can our inner compass guide us without the need for the quran specifically? Ie can other scriptures/our experiences lead us to lead a peaceful,decent,moral,responsible life?...?
Is any knowledge that we have even 'relatively' objective...? Ie the fact we need food to survive,is pretty objective... -
Peace all.I would appreciate if anyone else could also shed some light on the two questions i posed to tay,the re-worded questions i asked tay as well...Thank you...
-
peace enquirer,
enquirer- Is there any wisdom in the quran that is not present in other books/elsewhere?
- Naught is said to you but what was said indeed to the messengers before you; surely your Lord is the Lord of forgiveness and the Lord of painful retribution.
by this verse I also understand that if any scientific facts were revealed to the prophet, then surely those scientific facts would have also been revealed to all the messengers before him.
please check this link.
http//integralscience.org/einsteinbuddha/peace.
-
Peace agentxxx. Thanks for that link...Very interesting....I always thought that buddha,of all the religious founders,was the most clever...The guy was a genius...
I would like others to comment on what agentxxxs' excellent findings mean,in relation to this current debate.... -
Peace enquirer,
I respect your answers,methods,and humbleness
Likewise
can our inner compass guide us without the need for the quran specifically Ie can other scriptures/our experiences lead us to lead a peaceful,decent,moral,responsible life?...?
Yes.
Is any knowledge that we have even 'relatively' objective...? Ie the fact we need food to survive,is pretty objective...
Yes. For the "hands-on" experience of this life, there are certainly objective truths, ie, cells require nourishment for survival, apples fall down instead of up, etc. Regarding spirituality, however, it is strictly subjective, and this has larger implications than what this thread encompasses. To sum it up, we are "one".
Peace,
Tay -
Peace Tay. Beautifully expressed...Agree with you fully... bravo yay
-
Peace Tay. Why dont you start a new thread relating to the implications of your last post.(if you wish. ))....I think it would be very interesting and hopefully beneficial... bravo yay
-
EnquirerIs there any wisdom in the quran that is not present in other books/elsewhere?
I believe fragments of wisdom are present from many sources in human thought. However, one single source of absolute wisdom - which is what i believe al-quraan is - is nowhere present except for al-quraan.
Is there any objective proof of the qurans validity?
There is, but it'll be too late for those who rejected it after al-haqq comes to them (note im not saying al-haqq or ultimate truth/Allah Himself came to anyone, that's not for me to say.)
-
Peace enquirer,
Beautifully expressed...Agree with you fully...
sun
Why dont you start a new thread relating to the implications of your last post.(if you wish. )....I think it would be very interesting and hopefully beneficial...
Interesting, yes. But it would only be beneficial if the structure is coherent. As of now, in my mind, it's bits and pieces that all make sense, but require further study to formulate a cogent argument. In the meantime, perhaps you can add your feedback to the following thread and we can examine these bits and pieces...
http//www.free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=3500.msg44047#msg44047
Peace,
Tay -
the tagline says it all. People keep saying that there is scientific facts to be found in the Quran, not known to its time. Lets take a look at this, because i disagree entirely. ALL science found in Quran was known to man, and societys a long time before.
Peace
While I'm not a fan of the quranic scientific miracles, i would like to see how you can prove what you said above
The Quran told us more than 1400 ago about the internal waves and the darkness of the deep sea, here is my evidence
Or are like the darkness of a fathomless sea which is covered by waves above which are waves above which are clouds, layers of darkness, one upon the other. If he puts out his hand, he can scarcely see it. Those Allah gives no light to, they have no light.
Now the onus is on you to prove to us beyond doubt that these two pieces of scientific information mentioned in the Quran were known prior to more than 1400 years ago "clearly the two facts are understood literally from the verse, no twisting no games"
back to you, btw the argument by that Dr that a sailor told Mohammad about it can't be admissable until you prove it
cheers
-
Peace,
Ok, Magi, then go refute this article
http//www.free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=5580.0
-
Peace all. Im not directing this comment to anyone in particular,but if a person is already convinced/has faith in the quran as allahs infallible book,then if any new and proven science comes along that 'contradicts' the quran,would they then admit a mistake in the quran........?,Or would they say science is 'fallible' anyway.....?
-
Peace all
Ahmed chose to direct his comment to enquirer
Hello enquirer
Yeh if you can prove it beyond doubt I will concede that the Quran is fake
deal?
but only if there will be judges and rules and I have to make the rules with you
-
Peace arnoldayasin. You asked magi to refute the link you gave...
Is there any science that contradicts the quran...? If there is,do you mind refuting this science with reality...?
Peace all. ps; AB; good question to magi....I will post a reply when i get time...Take it easy...PPS; ok,we will talk about a debate later....i assume you have a lot of travelling and such like at the moment,so when you come back...Is that ok? -
Salm enq
yeh after I come back for sure thanks for the understanding, i will be back on the 7th inshaallah
salam
-
peace Ab. I hope all goes well in your journey,take it easy.
-
peace Ab. I hope all goes well in your journey,take it easy.
cheers
-
Peace,
Enquirer, the last 400 years things have been discovered that all one by one were metnioned in the Quran, till now there is not one thing inside the Quran that doesn't coincide science. That is the thing, 400 years of science and not one difference......I accepted the Quran because of the science in it and the wisdom used. I would really doubt there is gonna be any scientifical theory accepted by most scientists that will contradict any law of the Quran. The last 400 years of experience has already proven that.......
And no enquirer, there is not one scientifical theory that contradicts the Quran, i have studied Biochemistry for years and studied all scientifical fields. Till now all theories coincide a 100% with the Quran, so if there is gonna be one theory that contradicts the Quran, it is a wrong theory. Let's say there is gonna be one theory accepted by most scientists.
So that would be mean that 99,9% of all theories coincide with the Quran except 0,1%. I would say with my scientifical view that it is the 0,1% that will be proven wrong over the years. You have to look at statistics enquirer. The 99,9% already is to strong evidence there is nothing that will contradict with the Quran. You have to understand that even the cutting-edge Quantum physics completly coincides with the Quran.
Peace
-
Peace 'enquirer'
Peace all. Im not directing this comment to anyone in particular,but if a person is already convinced/has faith in the quran as allahs infallible book,then if any new and proven science comes along that 'contradicts' the quran,would they then admit a mistake in the quran........?,Or would they say science is 'fallible' anyway.....?
Not only that, but some fools think that in those days there were no premature births, miscarriages, abortions, dead babies, etc. for their own observations, that only recent scientific studies have proven that it was not possible for Muhammad to have ever known about such things when it comes to verses 225, 4067, 7538, etc.