Why do you recite Fatha during salat ?
-
It is not written in the Quran to recite it during salat ?
If your proof is this verse , then you're mistaken
" He is the Living One. There is no Allah save Him. So pray unto Him, making religion pure for Him (only). Praise be to Allah, the Lord of the Worlds! "
( 40-56)This verse is not talking about salat , it is about duaa ( supplication )
-
Peace,
Where did GOD tell you to recite "Fatiha" during your "ritual prayers" ?
It is not written in the Quran to recite it during salat ?
If your proof is this verse , then you're mistaken
" He is the Living One. There is no Allah save Him. So pray unto Him, making religion pure for Him (only). Praise be to Allah, the Lord of the Worlds! "
( 40-56)This verse is not talking about salat , it is about duaa ( supplication )
As for me...
No, I don't do "ritual prayers", so I don't recite "Fatiha" rituals too. I do follow God's laws to be a good man, and yes following God's laws prevents from evil... but rituals don't....
http//mypercept.co.uk/articles/slw.htm
http//mypercept.co.uk/articles/disproved_traditional_salat.htmBrother Wakas knows well...
Peace,
Zidane. -
Who are you asking this question to?
You seem to be confusing an open public forum made up of people with different views for a sect with one view only.
Wakas
I thought this forum discusses " Quran alone " , isn't it ?!
Or do you mean " Quran alone " have different views also in the same sect ?!! -
Peace,
Where did GOD tell you to recite "Fatiha" during your "ritual prayers" ?
As for me...
No, I don't do "ritual prayers", so I don't recite "Fatiha" rituals too. I do follow God's laws to be a good man, and yes following God's laws prevents from evil... but rituals don't....
http//mypercept.co.uk/articles/slw.htm
http//mypercept.co.uk/articles/disproved_traditional_salat.htmBrother Wakas knows well...
Peace,
Zidane.So what kind of salat you're performing ?!
-
The title of the forum is free-minds.org / progressivemuslims.org
And the introduction says "Welcome to the discussion of God Alone"
So it doesn't say "Quran alone" anywhere.
What I am trying to point out to you is that this forum is an open public forum which anyone can join and as long as they abide by the etiquette/respectful rules of the forum they can discuss any Quran/Islam/God/religion issues etc.
This forum is NOT for specific people. free-minds is NOT a group of people who only have one view etc. So asking your question to the forum is pretty pointless.
If you wanted it to be better worded, I would say something like "For those who recite Fatha during their traditional daily prayer AND have "Quran alone" views, what do you base this practice on?"
I believe there are articles on it, on the submission.org and 19.org websites I think.
-
The title of the forum is free-minds.org / progressivemuslims.org
And the introduction says "Welcome to the discussion of God Alone"
So it doesn't say "Quran alone" anywhere.
What I am trying to point out to you is that this forum is an open public forum which anyone can join and as long as they abide by the etiquette/respectful rules of the forum they can discuss any Quran/Islam/God/religion issues etc.
This forum is NOT for specific people. free-minds is NOT a group of people who only have one view etc. So asking your question to the forum is pretty pointless.
If you wanted it to be better worded, I would say something like "For those who recite Fatha during their traditional daily prayer AND have "Quran alone" views, what do you base this practice on?"
I believe there are articles on it, on the submission.org and 19.org websites I think.
You beat me to it. I was going to right a similar post. Many "traditional muslims" see this site as a sect when it isn't which does get annoying at times.
PEACE
-
Sorry I thought it is the same God alone = Quran alone
Well it certainly seems to be the case given some of the alternatives so I understand why you would think monotheism is restricted like that )
-
So what kind of salat you're performing ?!
Peace Fajr,
(Maybe you already understand this by now...) I do "salat" as described in those links which I already posted.
Let me suggest another ariticle, this one tries clarifying the term "God alone" (by a founder of this site) >> http//www.free-minds.org/articles/gods_system/god.htm
Peace,
Zidane.
