Makka an/or Madinah?
-
Salam brothers and sisters in God,
I?m new in this forum.
Like any early "ingenious" sunni, I had a lot of questions.
Thanks God, now, after I read some articles in free-minds.org a new Islam reavealed for me.
Alhanduli L?! sun
Anyway, I have a question about the acuracy of the exat local where the Quran?s suras was revealed.
Please, anyone here can show (or indicat any link) if the suras really was revealed in Madinah and/or Makka?
I?m wait some Dalil, proof, about this question for more information, insha Allah!
Stay in peace and sorry my poor english,Lucman Martins, from Brazil peace
-
Salam brothers and sisters in God,
I?m new in this forum.
Like any early "ingenious" sunni, I had a lot of questions.
Thanks God, now, after I read some articles in free-minds.org a new Islam reavealed for me.
Alhanduli L?! sun
Anyway, I have a question about the acuracy of the exat local where the Quran?s suras was revealed.
Please, anyone here can show (or indicat any link) if the suras really was revealed in Madinah and/or Makka?
I?m wait some Dalil, proof, about this question for more information, insha Allah!
Stay in peace and sorry my poor english,
Lucman Martins, from Brazil peaceSalam.
Listen, just read the verses very, very carefully and you'll see what happens.
Just by reading the verses, very carefully, you'll see, InshaAllah, that you can tell where some verses have been revealed.I also can't remember where each verse is but i do remember that Muhammad was waiting for God to show him a new focal point to turn to pray, because earlier they prayed toward Jerusalem, correct, and then they changed and prayed toward Mecca, they turned, right, so that means that they were in Madinah, i think, The God knows best, of course. I mean, if they turned, it means they were outside Mecca. The God knows best.
Remember chapter At-Tur, ayyat 4?
I think, God knows best, that this chapter was revealed in Makkah, because of the 4th verse, of course, The God knows best.Also, check 396, 97.
But whatever you read, verify, my brother, verify everything.
Peace.
-
Salam Brother Alen,
Thanks for your attention.
So, one more question about this topic
"I also can't remember where each verse is but i do remember that Muhammad was waiting for God to show him a new focal point to turn to pray, because earlier they prayed toward Jerusalem, correct, and then they changed and prayed toward Mecca, they turned, right, so that means that they were in Madinah, i think, The God knows best, of course. I mean, if they turned, it means they were outside Mecca. The God knows best."
The mention about the quibla change came to you from hadith?
And the polemic "Bekka"? Bekka is Jerusalem or the ancient name of Mecca or will be that explication founded in submission.org (19 number)?
If brother Layth was correct in his article from the free-minds, the quibla was and still in Jerusalem (Bekka) and now the problem about the original place of each sura grow up!
I?m wainting for more insights, insha Allah! -
All praises and thanks be to Allah!
Salam brother, good to see you broke free from Sunni sect. Alhamdullellah!You can do as brother Alen has said, or you can check out some Qurans which at the begining say where they were revealed. Some were at Makka some at Madina al-tun Nabi, in other words, Madina.
http//www.pmo.gov.my/WebNotesApp/RqrMainE.nsf/pg_About?OpenPage&BaseTarget=q3
The link above is a good place to see where they were revealed. Though Im not so sure about the order of revelations, use your own judgement and see refuge in Allah, from Satan, the rejected.Verify for yourself my brother. InshaAllah, Allah will show you the truth, if He desires to do so.
Allahu Akbar! welcome