Defenition of marriage suggests sex before marriage permitted?!

Fahad1

Peace bro.

Fahad

Brother Peace

you know I like to discuss a lot of things with you , but it becomes difficult for me when ,

You pop up after such a long time with a reply, that one loses track of the discussion, specially if the thread contains multiple discussion points/posts.

I understand that bro and I am very sorry about it. I wish I could be more regular, but my current schedule is such that I can't help it. So please bear with me.

Your argumentation is broken in a way that it becomes a point to point refutation (by you) only, and one does not have a clear idea as to what you want to say or what is your understanding on the issue.

So, I would request you to come up with a short summary of your understandings, complete with the references, as to why you understand so , regarding zina and mohsinnats, and inshallah we would be able to take this discussion somewhere objectively. No offence please.

A point by point "refutation" or address becomes necessary where people like to make so many points without backing them. But whenever I have summarized my understanding, the main arguments usually go unaddressed(in this discussion and many, if not most, previous ones as well). For example, my understanding of 4/25 still hasn't been addressed even though that's my only argument about al-muhsanaat being married women!

I will try to summarize my understanding again in a better way. No offence taken.

Fahad1

Fahad

60-10 that you refered , the term being used is Mominaat, Not " mohsinnat" because,
In these mominnats , there is a reasonable possibility that a few may not qualify as mohsinnats for you. As some could be belonging to the Haram category, and some , in your opinion do not deserve the title "Mohsinna"

I didn't say 60/10 is referring to al-muhsanaat, but to the "MMA". They can include both al-muhsanaat and fatayaat.

God is recommending that if some married believing women flee to you , because they dont want to be with those people due to religious difficulties, then , you keep them, and pay back a compensation to their non believing husbands.

And now, if i was the one , who was looking to marry some one out of these mominnat, The recommendation is that i should try my best to pick out a Mohsinna.

I will address this in the summary.

Fahad1

Translating Mohsinnate as married women , is wrongest possible meaning that one can deduce,

Because translating 4-24 as married contradicts 4-25 , and also in 4-25 , the recommendation of marrying a believing mohsinnat from mma cat , who is to be a maiden , completely shatters your undestanding,

But where does it say the 'al-muhsana' is to be maiden/unmarried? Or did you just assume that?

siki

But where does it say the 'al-muhsana' is to be maiden/unmarried? Or did you just assume that?

Fatayat is being translated as girls, young maiden, young women, by different translators, However, the correct meaning of fatayat is , Young females,
The stress , being on a Fatayat,from MMA, Not just any woman,

Translators translating them to be as girls or maidens are imagining too far. Although there are bright chances for these young females to be unmarried/maiden, however we can not preclude that some young female could be a widow or divorcee, you are right in pointing it out.

siki

siki

I didn't say 60/10 is referring to al-muhsanaat, but to the "MMA". They can include both al-muhsanaat and fatayaat.

Off course , we do find muhsinnats in MMA cateogry and Fatayats as well, A mohsinna can be a fatayat, and a fatayat may not be a MOHsinna, But there is no MMA in this aya.
60-10 is discussing an issue regarding MOMINNAT ILL MOHJIRRATE.
siki

siki

I will try to summarize my understanding again in a better way. No offence taken.

waiting.

siki

siki

In 425, MOHSANAAT are contrasted with FATAYAAT. The only logical deduction would be that these two categories DO NOT overlap. If men are unable to marry the mohsanaat (of the MMA category as per logical deduction from 424) then they are asked to marry the fatayaat (of the MMA category).

NO brother, there is no contrasting here, just a specific alternate being recommended, what is being said is ,

If you are not able to marry a believing chaste/eligible/halal woman, Try and find the same among MMA category, and when you look in this category (MMA), make sure that you pick up some one believing, and young.

Because, in MMA ,

There could be mohsinnat ul ootul kitab, who are also halal as per 5-5.
There could be believing middle aged mohsinnats.

siki

siki

Secondly, "and permitted for you is what is beyond this" LOGICALLY CAN ONLY MEAN THAT MOHSANAAT ARE THE FORBIDDEN CATEGORY WITH MMA FROM THE MOHSANAAT BEING EXCEPTION TO THAT.

kindly explain this,

Alyawma ohilla lakumu alttayyibatuwataAAamu allatheena ootoo alkitaba hillunlakum wataAAamukum hillun lahum waalmuhsanatumina almu/minati waalmuhsanatu minaallatheena ootoo alkitaba min qablikum itha ataytumoohunnaojoorahunna muhsineena ghayra musafiheenawala muttakhithee akhdanin waman yakfur bial-eemanifaqad habita AAamaluhu wahuwa fee al-akhiratimina alkhasireena

This day (all) the good things are allowed to you; and the food of those who have been given the Book is lawful for you and your food is lawful for them; and the chaste from among the believing women and the chaste from among those who have been given the Book before you (are lawful for you); when you have given them their dowries, taking (them) in marriage, not fornicating nor taking them for paramours in secret; and whoever denies faith, his work indeed is of no account, and in the hereafter he shall be one of the losers

Do you find MOHsinnte Mominnate and mohsintel ootul kitab, HAllal or Haram?

Do you find MMA any where?

siki

siki

THE ONLY LOGICAL CONCLUSION WOULD BE THAT IF MEN WANT TO MARRY MOHSANAAT, THEY HAVE TO FIRST MAKE THE MOHSANAAT MMA. Thus converting the "regular mohsanaat" into "MMA mohsanaat" would become COMPULSORY in order to marry them.

Daraba lakum mathalan min anfusikum hal lakum mi mma malakat aymanukum min shurakaa fee ma razaqnakum faantum feehi sawaon takhafoonahum kakheefatikum anfusakum kathalika nufassilu alayati liqawmin yaAAqiloona

3028 HE sets forth for you a parable concerning yourselves. Have you, among those whom your right hands possess, partners in what WE have provided for you so that you become equal sharers therein, and you fear them as you fear each other ? Thus do WE explain the Signs to a people who understand.

Brother TS.

Can you explain about this example given by God , in the light of your above understanding?

siki

Q_student

Dear TruthSeeker
You are saying again and again that "Mohsanaat" has been used in contrast to "Fatayaat".

( 2 / 177)
. { } .

Fatayaat has two meanings
1young ladies
2Slave ladies (figuratively)
If you take the first meaning then "Monsanaat " according to your theory will mean "Old ladies " and if you take second meaning then these will mean "free ladies".
Which meanings are you adopting or you are having something else in your mind?
Regards

siki

MOHSANAAT = PROTECTED WOMEN, and because we don't need permission from their guardians they are not guardian dependent, hence they are "GUARDIAN INDEPENDENT PROTECTED WOMEN" according to the context.

Can you kindly explain the above category " protected women" "Guardian independent protected women?

Protected from what?
How are they protected?
who protects them?

And if you dont have a logical explanation which makes sense, Ask me, I will explain it to you.

siki

siki

MMA = WHAT POSSESSED BY YOUR OATH, and because the context is marriage, this oath can only be an oath to get married to them, hence they are "THOSE WOMEN POSSESSED BY YOUR OATH TO GET MARRIED" according to the context.

That means that you kinda get engaged with these women before you actually marry them, and then according to 70-29,30 your explanation was, ( "one may inspect each others private parts , exactly like husband and wife, so that one may check , "weather these are good enough". Were you hinting at ensuring that these are compatible fitments?

70-29,30 And they protect their sexual organs (from all) except azwaj, and Ma Malakat emnakum.

siki

Samia

I have put it in three colors
1Red it is the Protasis of the conditional sentence
2Green color is the apodosis of the conditional sentence

Blue color does not seem to be a part this conditional sentence because there is suddenly a change of address from 3rd person singular male to 2nd person plural males
Regards

Salaam Student

There's no address to the third person. Address is usuaully to the second person, male or female, singular, plural or dual.

siki

Hence the only mohsanaat eligible to become your MMA would be the protected independent single women.
If a man cannot find such a protected independent single woman who can be possessed by his oath, then he is asked to marry a guardian dependent young woman with her guardian's permission, but first he has to possess her by his oath to get married.
How does a woman become , "protected independent single woman"?
So the priority goes to finding an above category, and if somehow you are unable to, only then, one can ask parents of a young maiden for an engagement and marriage. ( (I guess 95% marriages are not happening this way and hence defying the order in 4-25.
4-25 is also warning about this fatayat nikah , by saying, " This is for those who fear falling in sin ( last resort only) , and preferably you should abstain from doing this , because God knows what is better for you( so according to God, this is not the best course of action for us)

Most of the first timers are going in , only and only for these so called "parents protected young females" , isn't it? ;D

hmm and marrying her direct is not possible , an engagement oath is a must , so that both of you can explore each others sexual organs. caution, caution, NO fornication please , that is strictly prohibited and is punishable with 100 lashes.
D personally I would luv this arrangement. Posses a young female with a promise, explore her sexual organs thoroughly, declare her parts undesirable, reverse your oath, move on to the next young female, and of course no fear, as all this is happening with the parents permission. yuck I guess this is the Norm in the western societies these days.

siki

Samia

Peace siki, truthseeker et al,

That's all cool, I'm open to find the non contradicting meaning which is always the best.

The subtle transition from 423 (Forbidden to marry) ?to 424 And almuhsana needs closer scrutiny and will take a look time permitting -- still busy pondering inheritance verses and few other things.

Salaam Eid

You just put your finger on the most important point. Any interpretation of muhsanaat as chaste/free/ dependent/independent...etc will make these categories forbidden; that's why some interpreters came up with "married", but quickly fell in contradiction with the exception ?lla except" that follows it, which makes "some" married women lawful.

To find the correct meaning of muhaanaat, we have to reconsider the address. In my opinion, the address in this verse has changed from the address in the previous verse. The addressee are a special category of people, and this verse and the verses that follow concern this category.

Samia

Exactly!

Salaam Eid

I do not understand this Eactly! Do you mean that these " chaste hallal/permissible ladies"are forbidden as per 424?!

Ha-Sad-Nun = To be guarded, be inaccessible/unapproachable, be chaste, be strongly fortified, difficult to access, be preserved, be protected (against attack), abstain from what is not lawful nor decorous, preserve or guard a thing in places inaccessible/unapproachable, make or render a thing inaccessible or unapproachable or difficult to access, make/render a thing unattainable by reason of its height, to fortify oneself.
husun n.m. (pl. of husn) 592
hassana vb. (2) pcple. pass. 5914
ahsana vb. (4)
perf. act. 2191, 6612
impf. act. 1248, 2180
impf. pass. 425
pcple. act. 424, 55
pcple. pass. f. 424, 425, 425, 425, 55, 55, 244, 2423
tahassana vb. (5) n.vb. 2433
Lane's Lexicon, Volume 2, page 222, 223

How about "immune" as a meaning for muhsan? In fact it's more correct than "protected/fortified" since this second meaning is a derivative of the form II
of the verb and means fortified "muhaSSan"

5914 They will not fight you (even) together, except in fortified townships, or from behind walls. Strong is their fighting (spirit) amongst themselves thou wouldst think they were united, but their hearts are divided that is because they are a people devoid of wisdom.

siki

Salaam Eid

You just put your finger on the most important point. Any interpretation of muhsanaat as chaste/free/ dependent/independent...etc will make these categories forbidden; that's why some interpreters came up with "married", but quickly fell in contradiction with the exception ?lla except" that follows it, which makes "some" married women lawful.

For God sake, "There is NO forbidden in this verse any where"

Forbiden word is there in 4-22, and again forbidden word is there in 4-23, seeing this precedence it had to be in the 4-24 , for mohsinnats?

But it is not .

This is precisely what everybody is taking for granted NOT realizing that it is causing 100% contradiction right in the next verse, 4-25

siki

Samia

For God sake, "There is NO forbidden in this verse any where"

Forbiden word is there in 4-22, and again forbidden word is there in 4-23, seeing this precedence it had to be in the 4-24 , for mohsinnats?

But it is not .

siki

What's the function of the conjugating article "wau" in the beginning of the verse? What about these "muhsanaat" in this context?
Moreover, verse numbering is not part of the revelation.

Bigmo

Ermmm thanks for the advice! LOL
I wasn't questioning God's words but rather the practical implications ie why would they need to see each other naked.
It is best to keep the translation as 'right hands possess' as people have different views on what it means. I'm still new to all this so I haven't yet studied the Quran, but I respect your opinion.
Salam

I still believe MMA is the Katb al Kitab. That is where you make on oath of marriage and everything but the ceremony did not take place. Its an oath(vows) and its considered a legal marraige although usually a house is need for the marraige to be made official.

Samia

I still believe MMA is the Katb al Kitab. That is where you make on oath of marriage and everything but the ceremony did not take place. Its an oath(vows) and its considered a legal marraige although usually a house is need for the marraige to be made official.

Do you mean that th only difference between MMA and a zawj is a house?