Right Hand Vs Left Hand
-
You spell it wrong because we say " " if you want to write it using latin letters, you'll write it like that "Al-Hamdo Lilah" not "alhamdolilah" as you did.
I see your point, but imho you can spell it both ways.
"Alhamdullilah" seems to be the most common and widely used spelling though.
http//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alhamdulillah
-
I see your point, but imho you can spell it both ways.
"Alhamdullilah" seems to be the most common and widely used spelling though.
http//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alhamdulillah
it is wrong, I don't care if it is widely used spelling or not, the important is that it is wrong spelling. Because we didn't write the word in arabic like that (it is composed from two separated parts "Al-Hamdo" and "Allah" ).
so take it or leave it , it's your choice.
-
thereformer1,
there is no indication in the quran that one must attain a hand preference in writing/eating/etc. if you believe quran says so then yes i'm unaware and lack quranic knowledge.I think God should show everything even how you'll walk, he gave you mind to interpret and choose (when God said in a verse that the left position is for the infidels and the non-believers , so be clever and interpret that the left position is not a good thing because it's a position of non-believers ). and know also that hell is in the left position too.
so being not mentioned in Qur'an doesn't mean that we can't banned it, and that's why Sunnah came to banned using the left hand for the same reason and even worst the sunnah told us that the deamons eat by their left hand, so being like them will not make you different from them.
-
I think God should show everything even how you'll walk, he gave you mind to interpret and choose (when God said in a verse that the left position is for the infidels and the non-believers , so be clever and interpret that the left position is not a good thing because it's a position of non-believers ). and know also that hell is in the left position too.
so being not mentioned in Qur'an doesn't mean that we can't banned it, and that's why Sunnah came to banned using the left hand for the same reason and even worst the sunnah told us that the deamons eat by their left hand, so being like them will not make you different from them.
But what about people who are born left-handed? It's like telling a right-handed person to use their left hand to write, use a scissors, etc.
??? -
nope
That's not very nice. It seems quite rude to say that....why it is not very nice ? do you want from me to flatter her ? .
it seems quite rude to say that because it's your own opinion.
-
But what about people who are born left-handed? It's like telling a right-handed person to use their left hand to write, use a scissors, etc.
???As I said before, there is no one born left-handed. it's a habit .
-
As I said before, there is no one born left-handed. it's a habit .
Sorry, but this is a baseless claim.
Left-handedness/right-handedness is determined in fetuses.
http//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Left-handedness
- Hand orientation is developed in fetuses, most commonly determined by observing which hand is predominantly held close to the mouth.
- In 2007, researchers discovered LRRTM1, the first gene linked to increased odds of being left-handed.
- Long-term impairment of the right hand People with long-term impairment of the right hand are more likely to become left-handed, even after their right hand heals. Such long-term impairment is defined as eight months or more.
- Testosterone Exposure to higher rates of testosterone before birth can lead to a left-handed child. This is the Geschwind theory, named after the neurologist who proposed it, Norman Geschwind. It suggests that variations in levels of testosterone during pregnancy shape the development of the fetal brain. Testosterone suppresses the growth of the left cerebral hemisphere and so more neurons migrate to the right hemisphere. The highly developed right hemisphere is now better suited to function as the center of language and handedness. The fetus is more likely to become left-handed, since the right hemisphere controls the left half of the body. The theory goes on to tie the exposure to higher levels of testosterone and the resultant right-hemisphere dominance to auto-immune disorders, learning disorders, dyslexia, and stuttering, as well as increased spatial ability.
The article has references from scientific research, so it can be safely assumed that right/left-handedness is determined from birth, and your opinion "there is no one born left-handed" lacks evidence.
-
Salaam,
This statement of yours compels me to wrote a response
When God said in a verse that the left position is for the infidels and the non-believers , so be clever and interpret that the left position is not a good thing because it's a position of non-believers
Do you take the verse literally? I'll use your approach to this verse and your defense on left-handedness being unnatural in this case
God says in the Qur'an the He condemns the blind and the deaf. Does that mean people who are born blind and/or deaf are unnatural and hence violating God's laws? I mean, being blind and deaf can NOT be natural, it's got to be a habit like you said about being left-handed. That, if I use your argument of course .
Anyway, I take the verses about blind and deaf metaphorically of course .
Salaam.
-
Salam Aleikum everyone
Does anyone know why Muslims believe that everything has to be done using the right hand? Is there any basis for it in the Quran?
No, But in hadhith there is.
-
But what about people who are born left-handed? It's like telling a right-handed person to use their left hand to write, use a scissors, etc.
???They dine with the devil !
-
Sorry, but this is a baseless claim.
Left-handedness/right-handedness is determined in fetuses.
http//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Left-handedness
The article has references from scientific research, so it can be safely assumed that right/left-handedness is determined from birth, and your opinion "there is no one born left-handed" lacks evidence.they said the same things about gays people, and I've learnt that no one born gay or left-handed, because both of them are an abnormal activity from someone has taken from his environment or absence of care .
-
Salaam,
This statement of yours compels me to wrote a response
Do you take the verse literally? I'll use your approach to this verse and your defense on left-handedness being unnatural in this case
God says in the Qur'an the He condemns the blind and the deaf. Does that mean people who are born blind and/or deaf are unnatural and hence violating God's laws? I mean, being blind and deaf can NOT be natural, it's got to be a habit like you said about being left-handed. That, if I use your argument of course .
Anyway, I take the verses about blind and deaf metaphorically of course ).
Salaam.what you stated is totaly different from the problem here, absolutely different . here God gave a metaphore situation where the deaf and the blind have a typical lack of organs who they are necessary for someone normal, so he meant by the deaf who they cover their eyes and by the blind who they don't want to see the truth and cover their eyes from seeing it .. the case here about the left-handed people is abnormal and it's under the lack of attention from parents . so here Good didn't mention any metaphore about the left-handed people but he described that this position basically is for the infidels . so your choice of approaching is weak
-
;D I like you -* keep denying the truth
well, you like me in which way ? and by the way nothing is true even you .
-
I believe that if you were "Born Left Handed" you can change, and vise versa.
I think if you practice enough you can write,eat,lift,etc will BOTH hands. it takes time and effort.if it was as you said a "born left-handed" he or she can't change it.
-
if it was as you said a "born left-handed" he or she can't change it.
I put Born left handed in """" Quotations """ meaning Supposedly. Because I dont know if I really believe you are Born that way, rather I think that is only a theory.
I am more leaning towards the belief that you are probabily born Neutral, and over time you develope a prefference.
This may be wrong too as it is only a theory.If it is true that you are really Born that way, i think either way it is possible to control both hands.
For instance, There are people who can right perfectly with BOTH hands, Eat with BOTH hands, Play baseball with BOTH hands while most people can only do Left or RIGHT. so I was just saying that I think with Much Practice, Humans can learn to Utilize BOTH hands to great ability.
-
I put Born left handed in """" Quotations """ meaning Supposedly. Because I dont know if I really believe you are Born that way, rather I think that is only a theory.
I am more leaning towards the belief that you are probabily born Neutral, and over time you develope a prefference.
This may be wrong too as it is only a theory.
If it is true that you are really Born that way, i think either way it is possible to control both hands.
For instance, There are people who can right perfectly with BOTH hands, Eat with BOTH hands, Play baseball with BOTH hands while most people can only do Left or RIGHT. so I was just saying that I think with Much Practice, Humans can learn to Utilize BOTH hands to great ability.Look we're talking about could someone born left-handed ? we know that something we born with, absolutely we can't change it. so being practice the things is different from things we born with.