Different way of Prostrating and Bowing using the Neck
-
So I had heard before during my days of traditional Islam that one way you can do Ruku (bowing) and Sujud (Prostration) rather than the traditional full bend of your body or kneeling and then flattening yourself was using your neck. In this case you would half bend your head downward for Ruku and fully bring your head downwards for Sujud. Cases I would do this would be when there isn't proper space or area for praying when somewhere.
So I wanna know if this still is applicable to Quran-alone?
As well what is the view on Qada prayer (making up prayers)? Are those still possible too?
Thanks
-
YES!!!
neck gymnasitcs are good! and OK as a prayer! )
QADA prayers are NOT!
http//www.youtube.com/user/WhereIsTruth
-
YES!!!
neck gymnasitcs are good! and OK as a prayer!
QADA prayers are NOT!
http//www.youtube.com/user/WhereIsTruth
sounds good but with Qada, what if I was unable to pray cause of sleep?
-
Peace peace!
Here are some points to consider
*The sole purpose of the salat is remembering God.
*God allows us to pray while riding or walking IF we're in fear/dangerous situation.
*God tells us to do our salat with reverence.
*There is really no reason to miss doing your "salat", (can do it virtually anywhere) except if you oversleep.
*There is no mention of "neck" bowing as a prescription in the Quran to symbolising the full prostration/bowing. Thus it is left to the individual, keeping in mind that we should be reverent-like during our SalatMay the Lord God endow us with wisdom & understanding & Guide us to his path pr
~Peace~ peace -
Missed "Salat" prayers answer from the Quran
http//www.masjidtucson.org/submission/practices/salat/missedsalat.html
and youssef4342, which clergy do you belong to?... whatever
-
Where in quran does it say you have to make up "missed salat"?
Does this rule apply only to Muslims? What about someone who has truly converted at the age of 95 and has say, 3 days left to live?
-
Missed "Salat" prayers answer from the Quran
http//www.masjidtucson.org/submission/practices/salat/missedsalat.html
and youssef4342, which clergy do you belong to?... whateverKeeping in mind that God tells us to Retaliate evil with Good, i will tell you,
Peace God sumbiter!
God gives us an example of Solomon as he missed his prayer. It does not say that he made it up! This is logical because salat is like a train that leaves right on spot, you cannot be a minute late or early (keeping in mind that now with our technological advances, we can calculate sun rise/sunset/noon by the minute)Godsumbitter, please do not be discouraged because i did not agree with your ideology. Seek the approval of God instead of me. Take this advice from me by criticising me you only hurt yourself. No soul bears the wrong of others. Please keep cool, and open-minded. I've been through many situations. I was a unbeliever of God, i was gone far astray. But I think God overlooked my negativeness and saw my positivness. Ask God for his forgivennes, and guidence. For God is ever merciful!
Please now, "Those who show goodness, goodness will be shown to them" (1630 & 3910 & 4223 & 5331)
please see The importance of being Nice http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9602900.0
~Peace peace handshake -
hahahaha OPF, with remarks like this, you really remind me how humans always try to outreason and outdo God and His System, and how cleaver people can be sometimes!...
So strange that God did not have all those exceptions and anomalies in mind... rotfl
this neck topic is quite fun, and a real mirror of the absurdity of bodily worship to whatever...
should I remind all that Allah is not a deity, but a Reality Principle of Harmonious Truth?PS
by the way, do you all know that any regular religious practice is in fact a psychological obessesive-complusory dis-order?
It is a variant of neurotcally behavioral compensation for important emotional lack... -
Thank you youssef4342, you are really nice!
I agree with you that it is good to be nice...
I just wonder how is it possible that with so many nice people around, the mankind brought itself where it is?
Whatever the humans could have destroyed, they destroyed earth, climate, bodies, culture, religion, art, politics...et al.
All and whatever humans ever touched, they so nicely disfigured and destroyed, (save a few examples of course...)
Jesus came, look what they did with Christianity, Moses came, look at Judaism and sects, Quran came, just look the quantity of Muslims in billions what they did with it and what kind of Islam they created? I suppose they were also trying to be nice? no?So, I am quite distrusful of nice people, specially clergy, which is ALWAYS so NICE...
http//www.youtube.com/watch?v=MsS6HUqYU1w
-
Peace,
Nowhere have I seen it say "you need to make up missed prayer".
Nor is it God I am trying to outreason nor his system, both of which totally encompass me before anything else. So who am I trying to outdo, that is the question. To rephrase that question, who is your God? What is your highest reality?
Please be careful with matters like salat especially if/when you have no certain knowledge. It might be that you miss out on the truth while you are unaware, that's very dangerous for your soul. Don't discount any possibility
{8310}
Woe, that Day, to those that deny-
{11}
Those that deny the Day of Judgment.
{12}
And none can deny it but the Transgressor beyond bounds the Sinner!
{13}
When Our Signs are rehearsed to him, he says, "Tales of the ancients!"
{14}
By no means! but on their hearts is the stain of the (ill) which they do!You understand? If the stain on your heart can drop you to hellfire, who is to say it cannot stop you seeing salat for what it truly is? We must let go of all preconceptions to find the masjid al-haram. Even those preconceptions we have made after realising the old ones were folly. And the preconceptions that arise from that repeated too, ad infinitum. Refer to my signature
-
Thank you OPF
Now you are talking!!!
Please be careful with matters like salat especially if/when you have no certain knowledge. It might be that you miss out on the truth while you are unaware, that's very dangerous for your soul. Don't discount any possibility
It is exactly what I am worried about, and what I am afraid about!!!
Believe me, I am quite in an agony since I read that book by Safar about Salat and Rhamadan, and I really do not know what to think..., and I do not want to miss something...
I was VERY diligent and completely serious doing Salat and Fasting and Wudu and all of it on time and well!Now I am really afraid to miss something, and I implore someone taches me and explains to me, so that I should know for sure.
I accepted Rashad Khalifa because he brought mathematical miracle of the Quran to mankind. And I accepted his teachings in appendices and in his lectures, and for me it was good version of Islam.
But then came the book by Safar, and now I am totally confused. Quran says nothing, (I mean I do not trust translations and I don't know Arabic, and I don't want to follow any person, guru or anyone).
Is it so difficult for God to communicate such an important matter to us???And please OPF, do not say or give impression that you know some important thing or secret if you do not! Thank you.
-
I like your signature ORF very much! hail
-
well with there being no mention of making it up, I tend to miss the morning ones cause I can't wake up. I always make them up as soon as I'm up, but now I wonder if it is worth it at all by this logic? Should I stop making them up then? what should I do and I can't wake up by alarm, nothing wakes me up except my mothers call and she won't wake me up either.
-
Peace,
I know the following
I came from nothing
I was free of all knowledge
I entered this world as a human and began to process knowledge
In doing so I slipped from the state of innocence/purity as desires arose
All of this is contained in something - ME, I am that I am, and this, this ALONE is all I have ever known, all I can concievably trust, this is my ultimate security, my ultimate love, my sure realityThis used to be my solipsist nightmare. But then I realised what I call "Me" is actually God himself (the Seer, the Hearer), not actually me that I am, bound to a human body (that which rises to the throat upon death). He is seeing and hearing "OPF" who is a part of his vast creation rather than OPF seeing and hearing his own creation (solipsism/atheism).
Therefore as far as it goes I am "the master of my fate, captain of my soul". That is the "important thing or secret" that you may think I am alluding to. So the only thing that remains to investigate is, what is the Sure Reality that no preconceptions can explain? Who am I, truly?
"(I mean I do not trust translations and I don't know Arabic, and I don't want to follow any person, guru or anyone)"
You have one more thing to let go of yourself (your body, your past, your evil, your desires, your good)
"Is it so difficult for God to communicate such an important matter to us???"
Exactly as difficult as it is for you to open your eyes - no more and no less. Let's put it this way People have been performing the "salat" and fasting in "Ramadan" since the revelation of the quran. Do you really think that when all these crappy innovations came out that ALL the people on the planet threw away God's message and suddenly there were no actual muslims but just people who claimed to be? Rather Muhammad the postman delivered, and he delivered splat bang on time. Special delivery (5417), who then will sign on the dotted line and declare that they truly have received this package?
-
Look Aryan Warrior, I used to ask God/Allah to help me and to wake me up for my dawn pryer. And I used not to miss a single one! Even being on the seaside or holidays, always heard the alarm... with His help.
Just ask and implore God to help you! -
Okay but otherwise if we do miss it still, should I make it up? or should I rather repent each time?
-
Peace,
When you skip a meal, do you make it up?
(Not a rhetorical question, answer it!)
-
Thank you OPF!
I love your words!
Specially the first part!
It sounds so sufi and I like that!And I agree with your point.
But the majority of people doing something is no proof for me of anything. They can all be wrong, as I am probably as well.
It is just the question whether we should do the Salat the usual way as Khalifa explained it or not? Phisically I mean, and on time?BTW, what is "splat bang" ? Excuse my poor command of English
-
Yes Aryan Warrior , just repent, you can not make it up.
-
Thank you youssef4342, you are really nice!
I agree with you that it is good to be nice...
I just wonder how is it possible that with so many nice people around, the mankind brought itself where it is?
Whatever the humans could have destroyed, they destroyed earth, climate, bodies, culture, religion, art, politics...et al.
All and whatever humans ever touched, they so nicely disfigured and destroyed, (save a few examples of course...)
Jesus came, look what they did with Christianity, Moses came, look at Judaism and sects, Quran came, just look the quantity of Muslims in billions what they did with it and what kind of Islam they created? I suppose they were also trying to be nice? no?
So, I am quite distrusful of nice people, specially clergy, which is ALWAYS so NICE...
http//www.youtube.com/watch?v=MsS6HUqYU1wPeace be upon you & thank you for your positive remark.
Being/acting nice is a commandment of God (Quran 2195) and retaliate evil with good (1322). Also to say in retaliation what is better/nicer (1753 & 2396) so much so that your enemy might become your own friend! (4134).
Your frustration is now evident to me.
I myself went from being agnostic, to 5-prayers a day traditional Islam, to 5 a day Submitters way, to the 3 prayers a day. All these times i myself had to re-change my ways of thinking. I would advise you to sincerely ask God for his guidance and mercy and compassion. You must choose your path. God guides those who seek his approval (Quran 516). Ask God, and i mean ask him now! Only God guides! we cannot!
Also try to strive in the sake of God, because God guides those who strive/persevere in his cause (Quran 2969)May the Lord God guide those who seek him pr
~Peace peace
them to our