Do Quranists Say 'Ameen' After Prayers?
-
Salaam.
Amen/Ameen was originated from Egyptian God Amen-Ra. When the Jews became the slaves of Egypt, this Amen was adopted to their teaching.
Later, this Amen was also adopted to Christianity and later Islam '(http//free-minds.org/history-amen
-
Salaam.
Amen/Ameen was originated from Egyptian God Amen-Ra. When the Jews became the slaves of Egypt, this Amen was adopted to their teaching.
Later, this Amen was also adopted to Christianity and later Islam '(http//free-minds.org/history-amen
There is no verse in the Quran which told us to say "ameen" after salat.So say "ameen" is not obligatory.
-
There is no verse in the Quran which told us to say "ameen" after salat.So say "ameen" is not obligatory.
I never said that it was obligatory but just like stoning, stoning is nowhere in the Qur'an but the Muslims say that it is part of Islam.
-
I never said that it was obligatory but just like stoning, stoning is nowhere in the Qur'an but the Muslims say that it is part of Islam.
Stoning is haram, while say "ameen" is sunnah, this means we say it or not, it's up to us.
There is no verse in the Quran which order us to say ameen, and there is also no verse in the Quran which prohibit us to say "ameen".Ameen is just tradition in Abraham monotheistic.
-
Stoning is haram, while say "ameen" is sunnah, this means we say it or not, it's up to us.
There is no verse in the Quran which order us to say ameen, and there is also no verse in the Quran which prohibit us to say "ameen".Ameen is just tradition in Abraham monotheistic.
Salaam,
What's your proof that Abraham said Ameen?
Despite the origin of amen.Kind regards,
Yuliana -
Peace,
In the sunni masjid they dropped the bismallah (deleted "in the name of God" from the
beginning of salat and add ameen at the end of the Fatihah. Whether it means amen-ra or
not is immaterial, why add a word not from Quran when the Quran if full of praises for God?
Shaytayn is just too fast and too smart and always sees us coming. Now we argue about
a word not even in Quran and serves no purpose! Out of all of the words in Quran, many
choose a word that is non-existent in the Quranic text. hmmAll have a blessed Ramadan
peace
-
Yes, the shaytanic forces are very clever in that they will infiltrate and pretend to be on your side, thus leading you astray, covertly, from within the gates. The shaytanic forces are great impostors. One must remain constantly vigilant and aware. Whenever we switch to auto-pilot, we are led astray. Most people are on auto pilot, leaving all decisions to the past and forefathers, the salaf. But just like tomorrow never dies, yesterday never was. There was never anything but 'now'. The forefathers had forefathers who had forefathers... so who are we following actually? Well, we are following an imaginary way of the forefathers (who never was, because at any instant and time there is only 'now', a way which at every step has been infiltrated and injected with lies and falsehood by the shaytanic forces that are constantly at work. Either take charge of your own life, using your God given reason, or remain on auto pilot and accept to be fed lies and illusions by the shaytanic forces... straight to ruin.
-
Peace All,
To continue in this current vein I would like to add, We can never ever forget shaytayn
and were he is hiding, what influence he would like over us humans, tricks, deceptions,
no matter how petty. One of the attributes of shaytayn is that he is petty. One may
think that adding a word like amen or removing the bismallah from salat as an insignificant
thing, but for shaytayn, he considers it a victory!"I will come to them from before them, and from behind them, and from their
right, and from their left, and You will find that most of them are unappreciative."Shaytayn has promised to attacked the deen from every angle.
Do the people think that they will be left to say, "We believe," without being
put to the test?O you who believe, you shall embrace total submission; do not follow the steps
of Satan, for he is your most ardent enemy.All have a blessed Ramadan
O0
-
... Without saying 'Ameen' don't Quranists feel they are far from Allah and their prayers are missing a very special thing?
Frankly, I think your flawed logic is dull, and you look at things at face value ...
Guided or astray, God is near to ALL human beings ( - 5016).PS
I never use the traditional term "Allahumma aameen" ( ن i.e. "Dear God Amen"! Rather, I often say "Allahumma Stajib" ( ب, i.e. "Dear God respond (to my call/supplication)"SLM