Hot/"ramadan" Answer
-
Peace Meteora,
I don't know. Do I look like the god?
I gave an opinion which I am entitled to. Wanna fight? jediSo your opinion is that you don't know what the word "ramadan" means. I would suggest that if you want to add value you should try to find out what something means before discussing it. )
Peace,
Ayman
-
Peace Meteora,
I said I thought ramadan could be a name without meaning, not that it doesn't have one, and certainly my opinion wasn't that I don't know it's meaning i.e. "my opinion is that I don't know the meaning of ramadan", So...what the hell? laugh
So your opinion is that "ramadan" is a name without meaning and you know its non-existent meaning.
Peace,
Ayman
-
Peace and Blessings be upon you all,
God does not want you to suffer and couldn't care less how many days you fast. We can't even confirm that shahar means month! Fasting is a universal practise ordained upon all the scriptures. God sent messengers to all Nations (as the Quran says).
If you can fast easily then do so, otherwise just give to the poor (as the quran says) and do not worry about anything. God Loves you.
Peace and Blessings xox
Rida Almansour (Acceptance of the One who will triumph)
-
Peace Rami,
Then what have you got to back up your accusation?I can also say that you are an imposter but I would have to produce my evidence for it so its no good repeating Aymans rhetoric, come up with some thing new or shut up.Keep your wondering to yourself I dont need lesson from you at least .Ha ha ha there we go again and at last we know the real identity of this one who would love to see our month of fasting disintegrate. You really thinks I pay any attention to what you have got to say.
peaceYour language is repulsive.
I have no comment.
Peace.
-
...are you high?
Don't be rude or I will elektro
-
Your language is repulsive.
Peace.
Peace Rami
It was only in response to your abhorrent accusation.
I have no comment.
In that case stay out of this discussion.
However let me give you an example of what I consider truly repulsive Quote from siki on August 25, 2009, 070605 AM
Yes! because the country is plagued with 180 million (minus a few) sunni sectarians, siki
Does this ring a bell? This language is no different from the one used by Hitler, referring to Jews, and I believe no one should harbour such feelings for anyone and that?s why I gave him the Roman Salute in reply.
peace -
Peace,
Quote from Ayman "Hence, the vast majority of people never sees the new-moon crescent and only sees the 1-2 day old crescent"
Ayman says that an error of 1-2 days is possible with new moon based timing system. Since his so called system is better than the new moon timing system, his system must produce an error less than a day.
Quote from Ayman "...This is the simplest and most straightforward method that would generate the least discrepancies no matter how primitive or advanced a society is ......."
In one of his post he cited the full moon date of July 6, 2009 which is in fact an error of more than a day thereby disproving his own system. But that's not the end of it, I am going to show if this system is used by the primitive people they would make an error of 30 days or more.
If you look at the sun rise/set time in the table below, you will find sun rise and sun set times are the same for days 20-22 under June column (0443 & 1937 hrs). What does this means. It means Ayman system cannot pinpoint the longest day accurately. Therefore, it is not a clear marker as he claimed to be. Determination of longest day is critical because the full moon sighting is dependent on it per Ayman theory. We need atomic and quartz timing standard to find the longest day. With the aid of modern technology we know this day to be 21 June of each year. How would the primitive people know when the longest day is? How would have they resolve the minute variation in the length of days around June 21? If they were forced to use Ayman theory, some community would have used June 20, another community would have used June 21, and other communities would have used June 22. The one who used June 20 summer solstice (full moon is also on 20 June) will make an error of 30 days. This is because Ayman's theory does not allow the use of full moon prior to summer solstice i.e. June 20 full moon. Please note that such problem does not exist with the new moon timing system
As a side note, we want Ayman to talk/write as much as possible. Because every time he write he contradicts a fact or his previous writing. Even a child will detect his shortcomings. And we find people (mature?) following him. How sad is that? Ayman, please don't stop writing, we look forward to your contradictory statements. It makes my day. Thank you.
The timing for May and July is provided for comparative purpose only i.e. one can determine the maximum deviation in minutes from one month to other and determine for themselves if primitive people were able to resolve such time deviation.
o , o ,
Location W077 02, N38 53 Rise and Set for the Sun for 2009
Eastern Standard Time U. S. Naval ObservatoryMay June July
Day Rise Set Rise Set Rise Set
h m h m h m h m h m h m
01 0510 1901 0445 1928 0447 1937
02 0509 1902 0444 1928 0447 1937
03 0508 1903 0444 1929 0448 1937
04 0507 1904 0444 1930 0448 1937
05 0505 1905 0443 1930 0449 1937
06 0504 1906 0443 1931 0449 1936
07 0503 1907 0443 1931 0450 1936
08 0502 1908 0443 1932 0451 1936
09 0501 1908 0443 1933 0451 1935
10 0500 1909 0442 1933 0452 1935
11 0459 1910 0442 1934 0452 1935
12 0458 1911 0442 1934 0453 1934
13 0457 1912 0442 1934 0454 1934
14 0456 1913 0442 1935 0455 1933
15 0455 1914 0442 1935 0455 1933
16 0455 1915 0442 1936 0456 1932
17 0454 1916 0442 1936 0457 1931
18 0453 1917 0443 1936 0458 1931
19 0452 1918 0443 1936 0458 1930
20 0451 1918 0443 1937 0459 1929
21 0451 1919 0443 1937 0500 1929
22 0450 1920 0443 1937 0501 1928
23 0449 1921 0444 1937 0502 1927
24 0449 1922 0444 1937 0502 1926
25 0448 1923 0444 1937 0503 1926
26 0448 1923 0445 1937 0504 1925
27 0447 1924 0445 1938 0505 1924
28 0446 1925 0445 1938 0506 1923
29 0446 1926 0446 1937 0507 1922
30 0445 1926 0446 1937 0508 1921
31 0445 1927 0508 1920Add one hour for daylight time, if and when in use.
-
Peace Rami
It was only in response to your abhorrent accusation.In that case stay out of this discussion.
However let me give you an example of what I consider truly repulsive Quote from siki on August 25, 2009, 070605 AM
Yes! because the country is plagued with 180 million (minus a few) sunni sectarians, siki
Does this ring a bell? This language is no different from the one used by Hitler, referring to Jews, and I believe no one should harbour such feelings for anyone and thats why I gave him the Roman Salute in reply.
peaceBut seriously what is your astronomical point of reference for Ramadan?
And what is your proof from the Quran?
-
But seriously what is your astronomical point of reference for Ramadan?
And what is your proof from the Quran?
Peace Rami,
Read this thread very carefully with open mind and you will get all the answers.
And then bring your evidence for your accusation.
peace -
Ayman, I'm still waiting for a response..
There is no more escaping with your childish comments above.
I said
Quote from progressive1993 on Yesterday at 050409 PM
Also, another question for ayman
How can the Quran have been sent down IN a moon?
Just to recap, it actually says "in".. too bad, eh?
2185 The month of Ramadan, is the month in which the Quran was sent down as a guide to the people and a clarification of the guidance and the criterion...
2185 Shahru ramadana allatheeonzila feehi alqur-anu hudan lilnnasiwabayyinatin mina alhuda waalfurqanThen you said
It is the same as when someone tells you I am sitting in the scorching full moon or in a bright sun or in a cloudy afternoon. This is perfectly normal in regular speech. It doesn't mean that they traveled to the sun and are sitting on its surface!
There you go..you directly answered my question "how can it be reveled IN the MOON of Ramadan." Stop making excuses and baseless accusations like you always do.
Anyways, ayman, just a question
what sounds more logical to you
- The Quran was revelaed IN THE MONTH OF RAMDAN
or - The Quran was revealed IN THE MOON OF SCORCHING HEAT?
Put the whole Ramadan issue aside - which one sounds more logical to you language-wise?
From submission.org/fasting-bible.html
Jeremiah 366. "Therefore go thou, and read in the roll, which thou hast written from my mouth, the words of the Lord in the ears of the people in the Lord's house upon the fasting day and also thou shalt read them in the ears of all Judah that come out of their cities." Here we find a definite practice of fasting. The following verses will show that this is not just a day of fasting, but precisely a month. More detail on this day of fasting is given in verse nine "And it came to pass in the fifth year of Jehoiakim the son of Josiah king of Judah, in the ninth month, that they proclaimed a fast before the Lord to all the people in Jerusalem, and to all the people that came from the cities of Judah unto Jerusalem." This is not a special fast proclaimed by a religious ruler, because this particular king was wicked. Nevertheless, he did follow the formality of what was practiced the month of fasting. The time given for this fasting is stated to be the ninth month.
The season of the fast in this particular year, thought by many scholars to be 604 B.C., is stated to be in the winter. Jeremiah 3622, "Now the king sat in the winter house in the ninth month and there was a fire on the hearth burning before him." Now the present Jewish calendar adds a thirteenth month from time to time to match the solar year, so that the ninth month of the civil year (used in the dates of kings' reigns) falls in May or June, summer in Palestine. If we project the lunar calendar presently used in the Middle East back in history, we find that the ninth month falls in November of the year 604 B.C. It appears that during Bible times a purely lunar calendar was used, and the ninth month was a month of fasting.
Indeed, God did not lie when he said
2183 O you who acknowledge, fasting is decreed for you as it was decreed for those before you that perhaps you may be righteous/aware.
Ayman, do you have any evidence of monotheists having fasted after witnessing the "moon of scorching heat"?? Do you have ANY evidence? I showed you my evidence for the real Ramadan - not the fabricated, one-third "Ramadan" of yours. Are you still going to reject the real Ramadan, and not fast for a full month - not just your lousy 10 days?
Peace
- The Quran was revelaed IN THE MONTH OF RAMDAN
-
Peace Ayman, and everyone,
I know the game A-team are playing as I am a lawyer in the west so I know how the system of exhaustion works. But to help other let me explain; when you make a complaint you need to go through the grievance procedure from first stage to last and the replies you get are long but of no substance. Still you have to exhaust the departments and often, when someone at the top of the ladder is involved, the complaint fails to get sorted pr
Then you must take the complaint to the regulatory body and if the regulatory body sides with the culprit they first of all work on delay tactics being slow to reply. Often you will have to send them a reminder and after that they ask you the same old questions all over and reply to your very valid argument with long letters never answering or addressing your grievance. (
Again you have to draw their attention to the relevant points and then they ignore points and you are back to the same old arguments, at times each letter referring to each point on each line raised. And the process goes on and on until it goes to the top and the top executive may look with sympathy at your file and ask special investigators to look into it who again ask you the same old questions designed only to delay and exhaust. brickwall (I hope now everyone understands why > lawyers charge hefty fees)Ayman you are guilty of that same old tricks and long lecturing and none of us needs that. You did bring lots of valid arguments last year and we proved you wrong. Last year I genuinely thought you were sincere in your search for truth but, after giving all the evidence from the Quran and Language I was surprised to see no change in the views of you or your cronies. This confirmed to me that you are not in search of the truth but on a mission to deconstruct our Ramadan,
Everyone can see for themselves that last Ramadan, from page 8 to 28 of this thread how genuine I was hoping to learn and exchange knowledge but sadly it seems you people have a hidden agenda. You know very well that most in this forum are disgusted with hadith based teaching and I don?t blame them for hating the mullah culture, but to take advantage of this situation to promote your own warped version is even worse.
Now I will paste below references from your posts and prove to everyone that you do nothing but lecture and repeat yourself and whenever you do that I will go back to the thread and dig out your previous posts even if it means ignoring rest of my work.Peace Farida and everyone who is having a panic attack as a result of the indisputable fact that their traditional calendar is 100% arbitrary,
Me and "my cronies" used to be in the same exact place as you. A few years ago I used to believe in the arbitrary sectarian Ramadan that has ZERO basis in the great reading exactly like you do. No matter what the result is, trying to determine the timing purely based on the great reading is better than ignoring the great reading and mindlessly following the chain of tradition. People who try to follow the truth in the great reading will always have the higher moral and logical ground over those who blindly follow arbitrary and false manmade traditions. This might seem like arrogance to you but it is because you have no real faith in your so-called Ramadan and this explains all the anger and inferiority complexes that you demonstrated on this thread. All that you proved is that your house is made of cards and this is why you get so mad when anyone shakes it.
AymanYou have given similar lecture in this thread I give you page numbers for your convenience Page 16 Re Hot/"ramadan" Answer Reply #234 on September 08, 2008, 042443 AM ?
Exactly, this is what the verse says. We have been taught otherwise by the Mullahs. Since I was in elementary school we were told that ......... Its a long similar lecture. Check it and let me know if I am wrong &There are 84 pages on this thread of evidences and sources. Despite all the noise you are making, you have not provided even one valid or invalid argument.
Lets see your last yrs post first
[b For etymology note here your blabbling on Page 16 and
Of course the etymology of "shahr ramadan" points to the red moon after the summer solstice.... page 81 Re Hot/"ramadan" Answer Reply #234 on September 08, 2008, 042443 AM ?
Now See My Month Etymology below pg 81
Re Hot/"ramadan" Answer
? Reply #1213 on August 27, 2009, 042925 PM ?
Month Etymology Since Urdu is nearest to Arabic culturally so let me start with Urdu "Mahina", also called "Mah" and moon too is called "Mah" (Mahjabeen) in Swedish, the word for month is M?nad (from M?ne=moon) in Icelandic M?nu? (from M?ni=moon) and, as pointed out in my earlier post, in
Middle English < Old English mna? < Proto-Germanic *mn?- < Proto-Indo-European *me(n)ses- (moon, month), probably from PIE base *m?- (to measure), referring to the moon?s phases as the measure of time. Cognate with moon.
? Cognates include Ancient Greek (mn), Armenian (amis), German Monat, Old High German mnd, Middle High German mnt, Old Irish m?, and Old Slavic(msncĭ. http//en.wiktionary.org/wiki/monthAll you have done is be a cheerleader for Guest or Progressive1993 or anyone who comes along repeating the same old stale arguments for the sectarian arbitrary timing that we all know (remember we all have been there and done that). At least those people tried and made an effort even if they were unsuccessful and their own arguments turned against them.
Don't fool yourself into thinking that and try to fool others evey one can check here what we said
Up to page 28 you had several post form belH Anwar Nun but you ignore themn and Nun, Pseudo, EId, or Rex gave you scores of picture as evidence including that of the crescent But you kept saying in your response where the picture of the crescent I would like everyone to see for themselves here on page 19 this several post including this one Re Hot/"ramadan" Answer
? Reply #273 on September 10, 2008, 044131 PM ?
The new moon waxing crescent (D in DOC) stands out as does waning crescent C...but you keep coming back with accusation that he did not supply you with the picture ..dont hide the truth
I summed up my evidence from the Qur?an on page 19 in response to your theory the root question Hot/Ramadan or The Month of Ramadan. I would suggest we all do our own verification by looking into.91-5 and 81Re Hot/"ramadan" Answer
? Reply #277 on September 10, 2008, 094900 PM ?You started ignoring my post see page 19 Re Hot/"ramadan" Answer
? Reply #284 on September 11, 2008, 123243 AM ?When you saw that I bowed out you came back with same old rhetoric so I came back with further evidence on page 20 Re Hot/"ramadan" Answer ? Reply #298 on September 11, 2008, 090417 PM ?
You summed up yet again on here page 22 Re Hot/"ramadan" Answer
? Reply #327 on September 13, 2008, 043310 AM ?Samia came to support you and of course truthseeker11 with his duel ID, not to forget Umm Tariq yay
On page 25
Re Hot/"ramadan" Answer
? Reply #379 on September 15, 2008, 094133 PM ?
And yours is not a simple explanation, not even logically sound I paste here what I wrote earlier
as Nun says in his last post "Time is continuous " so the event continued from then onward and has been revolving around the globe so everyone can witness that night as it falls in their region. This is the simple logic and this is the truth for those who reflectHere you go again Quote
I think that everyone who doesn't have an inflated ego knows that the traditional timing has ZERO support in the great reading and This is fine but until a better understanding is found, we should follow the best available understanding at this stage and which keeps getting better and more confirmed (see 3918).And I provided you with all the evidence in my post to AW.. see below
Quote from farida on September 09, 2008, 092227 PMFinger prints, DNA sample from your skin can bear witness and are used in this life Now!
This is how i summed up
Quote from farida on September 09, 2008, 092227 PM
Salaam Anthony and everyone,Indeed!! As I understand from the verse above, there is no undue expectations on the physically impaired and, performing within their capacity will earn them a reward on par with that of the able.
However the argument was ?how can one witness a month?? so it must, here, imply the scorching moon, "shahr ramadan".
As we learn from verses 4120, 21, 22, it is confirmed that the skin is capable of witnessing and will testify.
One can witness a month simply by being present in that month, as the skin is in touch with the atoms/molecules , water vapor mixture of gases, temperature etc., present at such a time. In this world one?s finger prints and DNA can also testify against a person, but just imagine a blind one saying to God, on the Day of Judgement, ?I did not witness the month of Ramadan?. His skin will then speak out against him.b.? those amongst you who witnessed?? exclude only those who are mentally incapacitated.
These verses also made me realise that the deaf, the dumb and the blind are not excluded from testifying.
How does a deaf or dumb person bear witness?
By the use of eyes and skin, which would include using sign language, as well as employing writing tools. In both cases the skin is used to bear witness. Similarly a deaf person, capable of speaking, may use his sight and his lips/skin .
A blind person can use the skin (to feel with), along with the ears to witness and, regarding the month of Ramadan, a blind person has witnessed it simply by being present in his body, in that month .This, in my opinion, is conclusive evidence, but I would welcome any input from others.
I hope we can now look into a timing device, using the sun and the moon, as a next step forward
Whether you like it or not, the fact that your Ramadan is 100% arbitrary and is not based on the great reading is true and you can?t prove otherwise. As for lies, there are plenty of examples. For example, those desperately trying to save the traditional timing on this thread have argued using 2189, which talks about the ?crescents? being used as a timing device for the ?hajj?, but they are lying because their arbitrary timing for ?hajj? completely disregards the crescent and instead your pagan ?hajj? starts on the 8th of Dhu Al-Hija and not with any crescent and ends on the 13th of Dhu Al-Hija and not with any crescent. On the other hand, the timing that I found based on the great reading ends the ?hajj? with the crescent. Remember what I said about your house being a house of cards. I would suggest that you try to solidify your house and make a solid foundation for it before worrying about what others think. Start with something simple like 2189 that everyone agrees on and try to time your ?hajj? accordingly
.You can see duplicate of your this lecture hereRe Hot/"ramadan" Answer page 14 For today?s identical reply
? Reply #201 on September 06, 2008, 025412 AMThere is no difference between what you are saying and what Hadithists say. You might as well dip some fresh flies in your food and drink some warm Camel urine to cure all your ills. Instead of following the message, you fanaticize that you are following the messenger when you are in fact following your misguided forefathers. Your chain is tied around your neck.
This is what I consider below my standard and your too I hope you can see. nope
Indeed. This is why you are so upset.
Look in your above quote and see who is upset yes
This is also why many people like me who used to follow the traditional timing have disregarded falsehood and are now following the timing according to the great reading. On the other hand, you have not convinced anyone to go back to following the 100% baseless and arbitrary traditional timing.
You can see all this ranting along with TS11 joined you pg 27 to further repeat and support you with his duel ID and my responses
Re Hot/"ramadan" Answer
? Reply #402 on September 16, 2008, 082623 PM ?
Peace faridaRe Hot/"ramadan" Answer
? Reply #373 on September 15, 2008, 062405 PM ?
Peace Farida,
Quote from faridaTo make it easy for you go to page 28 there lot of evidence given by me check it now and 29 pg 30 31 and 32 this replay
Re Hot/"ramadan" Answer
? Reply #405 on September 16, 2008, 092856 PM ?I repeat again O0
I think you are completely exhausted and "stuck in paralysis" after working on your Summer Solstice Scorching Full Moon Theory and could not contribute further but No worries just look at all the brilliant minds on free-minds and outside free-mind I'm sure the best calculations will be reached in due time.
peace
Ps Long search so if any mistakes, please do point out.This thread is a black hole. Just link me to your killer post.
At your service see above ;D
peace