Skip to content
  • Categories
  • Recent
  • Users
Skins
  • Light
  • Brite
  • Cerulean
  • Cosmo
  • Flatly
  • Journal
  • Litera
  • Lumen
  • Lux
  • Materia
  • Minty
  • Morph
  • Pulse
  • Sandstone
  • Simplex
  • Sketchy
  • Spacelab
  • United
  • Yeti
  • Zephyr
  • Dark
  • Cyborg
  • Darkly
  • Quartz
  • Slate
  • Solar
  • Superhero
  • Vapor

  • Default (No Skin)
  • No Skin
Collapse
Free Minds Forum Icon
  1. Home
  2. General Issues / Questions
  3. Questions/Comments on the Quran
  4. The Quran a failed book written by Men

The Quran a failed book written by Men

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Questions/Comments on the Quran
48 Posts 7 Posters 1.9k Views
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • C Offline
    C Offline
    centi50
    wrote on last edited by
    #21

    He naively ignores what forensic linguistics is while building up his basic argument and stance.

    Salam bro,

    What is it that they ignore? Can you point it out? Or refute their claims

    1 Reply Last reply
    0
    • C Offline
      C Offline
      centi50
      wrote on last edited by
      #22

      Here is the true narrative that both Traditional Muslims and Jay Smith are not able to refute in their so called debate
      True Islam is not the religion of the Traditional Muslims not is it an identity of any other religions like Christians , Judaism or any man made religion.

      Islam is an attitude of mind and a way of life towards GOD our creator. It is GOD s only "religion" subscribed through all His prophets and messengers throughout the humans existence.

      Mr Jay is right to criticise Traditional Islam that follows men s books -Hadiths- and contradicts /misinterprets Qoran. They have put themselves in a dire situation with their false interpretations and nonsense rules full of contradictions, hearsay and fables. They use Qoran for recitations and ceremonies and ignore or are ignorant of its true message.

      Mr jay himself isolate verses out of context and claims he has Scientific evidence of a made up history and origin of Qoran.

      Is he refuting Qoran and true Islam? He only thinks he is. he has no intention of studying Qoran sincerely, with honesty and solid knowledge. His agenda is to oppose and refute Traditional Islam.

      Why are you putting true Islam and traditional Islam in the same religion brother centi50?

      As far as I am concerned Jay Smith , his supporters along with traditional Islam and its supporters are both debating false religions. false history and false narratives. Nothing to do with GOD s true religion.
      GOD bless you all.
      Peace.

      Slama Gl

      No brother I am not pushing Traditional Islam. But I would like to see the argument they put forward is refuted.

      I don't believe in traditional Islam at all. There are very great minds in this forum who can refute these people in their channels. That's what I would love to happening

      God bless you

      God bless you

      1 Reply Last reply
      0
      • C Offline
        C Offline
        centi50
        wrote on last edited by
        #23

        "Information Only"

        Below are the copy paste of my messages to both of them

        1. The true Mecca/Becca is in Petra

        To Mr. Jay Smith/Al Fadi

        I have seen a lot of Dan Gibson and your videos on the issue of the Masjidil Haram/Qibla during and after Muhammad's time
        I believe you are very right that Makkah al-Mukarramah in Saudi Arabia is not the original place of Mecca/Becca where Muhammad was born
        It is Petra in Jordan and the one in Makkah al-Mukarramah is a fake and unauthorised by God

        I just watched your video "#28 FINALLY, A Rock Inscription Proves Mecca was "BUILT" late!" and this information is a great discovery!
        Thanks for the video!

        Note
        If you don't mind, please go to this link https//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9611307.0

        You will find that some Quranists (GOD alone, Quran alone) believed the authorised original Masjidil Haram/Qibla is situated in Petra, Jordan
        AND the shift to unauthorised sites is prophesied in the Quran via verses 9107-110
        Please see #Reply 15-18 on the link!

        9107 And some have taken a temple/masjid to do harm and cause rejection, and to divide between the believers, and as an outpost for those who fought God and His messenger before. They will swear that they only wanted to do good, and God bears witness that they are liars.
        9108 Do not stand in it ever. A temple/masjid that is founded on righteousness from the first day is more worthy that you stand in it; in it are men who love to purify themselves. And God loves the purified.
        9109 Is he who founds his building on obtaining righteousness from God and His acceptance better, or he who founds his building on the edge of a cliff which is about to crumble, so that it crumbled with him into the fires of Hell? And God does not guide the wicked people.
        9110 The buildings that they built continue to cause doubt in their hearts until their hearts are severed. And God is Knowledgeable and wise.

        The mathematical analysis of verses 9107-110 proves that your findings on this "shifting" issue of Masjidil Haram/Qibla are correct!
        Anyway, this message is just for information only!

        Thank you.

        Glory be to God!

        To be continued ...

        Salam bro shukri,

        You might want to see this channel,

        https//youtu.be/WmsjGAAw4Uw

        https//youtu.be/fTGxUHRfq9I

        Or

        https//youtube.com/@abu_ali_hail?si=I7pLV17N5AHxhhJ1

        Or read the book.

        Egypt knew neither Pharaoh nor Moses

        https//www.amazon.com/Egypt-knew-Pharaohs-nor-Israelites-ebook/dp/B00U8VK8JE

        1 Reply Last reply
        0
        • H Offline
          H Offline
          hawk99
          wrote on last edited by
          #24

          Peace centi50,

          Could we address their points of contention one at a time, rather than having to sit
          thru their entire discussion. pr

          God bless you

          peace

          1 Reply Last reply
          0
          • shukriS Offline
            shukriS Offline
            shukri
            wrote on last edited by
            #25

            Salam bro shukri,

            You might want to see this channel,
            https//youtu.be/WmsjGAAw4Uw

            https//youtu.be/fTGxUHRfq9I

            Or

            https//youtube.com/@abu_ali_hail?si=I7pLV17N5AHxhhJ1

            Or read the book.

            Egypt knew neither Pharaoh nor Moses

            https//www.amazon.com/Egypt-knew-Pharaohs-nor-Israelites-ebook/dp/B00U8VK8JE

            The information given in those channels/book is quite new for me!
            Thanks a lot brother!

            Salam.

            "Our Lord, do not impose blame upon us if we have forgotten or erred"

            1 Reply Last reply
            0
            • B Offline
              B Offline
              Bajram_Hoxhaj
              wrote on last edited by
              #26

              The question arises from this discovery
              Do we think the phenomenon of 19 denominators in Bismillah (the first verse of surah Al-Fatehah)

              Salaam shukri,

              I've already demonstrated that this method works for any text—whether it's ماري كان لديها حمل صغير ("Mary had a little lamb," for instance)—or any other verses, including 9128-129, which contain 19 words and 114 letters (19 x 6). This yields a 1/19 probability. The approach they used involved selecting 9 or more variables, shifting columns, reporting only multiples, and omitting 18 out of 19 failed trials. For example, they might manipulate values like 26040 بِسْمِ by combining the first and last digits (2 + 40 = 42) or calculating 102 + 3 = 105, and so on.

              https//www.mathsisfun.com/combinatorics/combinations-permutations-calculator.html
              Using permutations without repetition (where n=9, r=2; n=9, r=3), the sums are 9 + 72 + 504, resulting in 585. Doubling this total for combinations in the x1, x2, x3, and x4 formats yields 1,170 numbers. Dividing these numbers by 7 yields over 160 multiples; by 11, over 100 multiples; by 19, approximately 61 multiples; and by 29, around 40 multiples, and so on.

              "Another" example
              وَأَنَّ عَلَيْهِ النَّشْأَةَ الْأُخْرَىٰ
              19 letters
              1 19 3466 = 19 x 19 x 174
              123 + 4567 + 8910111213 + 141516171819 = 150426287722 = 19 x 7917173038
              6150 7030105 130503001400 130160020010 = 19 x 32372121107963422632315857978957900

              1 6150 57 3 3 57 60 56 123 123
              2 7030105 115 4 7 172 119 75 1234 4567
              3 130503001400 387 6 13 559 393 6 123456 8910111213
              4 130160020010 842 6 19 1401 848 11 123456 141516171819

              Likewise, all these are multiples

              1 3 2 4 3 6 4 6
              1 3 2 7 3 13 4 19
              1 56 3 2 75 4 3 401 6 4 11 6
              1 3 3 57 2 7 4 172 3 13 75 559 4 19 75 1401
              1 3 3 57 2 4 7 172 3 75 13 559 4 75 19 1401
              1 56 3 57 2 75 4 115 3 6 75 387 4 11 75 842
              1 57 3 3 2 172 7 4 3 559 13 75 4 1401 19 6
              1 57 56 3 2 172 75 4 3 559 6 75 4 1401 11 6
              1 3 56 57 2 7 75 172 3 13 6 559 4 19 11 1401
              1 57 56 60 2 172 75 119 3 559 6 393 4 1401 11 848
              1 60 123 3 2 119 1234 4 3 393 123456 75 4 848 123456 6
              1 60 3 123 2 119 7 1234 3 393 13 123456 4 848 19 123456
              1 3 57 123 2 7 172 1234 3 13 559 123456 4 19 1401 123456
              1 123 56 57 2 1234 75 172 3 123456 6 559 4 123456 11 1401
              1 3 123 60 2 4 4567 119 3 75 8910111213 393 4 75 141516171819 848
              1 3 56 6150 2 7 75 703060 3 13 6 130503001400 4 19 11 130160020010
              1 60 56 123 2 119 75 4567 3 393 6 8910111213 4 848 11 141516171819
              1 123 60 57 2 4567 119 115 3 8910111213 393 387 4 141516171819 848 842
              1 60 6150 3 2 119 703060 7 3 393 130503001400 13 4 848 130160020010 19
              1 57 3 6150 2 172 4 703060 3 559 75 130503001400 4 1401 75 130160020010
              1 6150 123 2 7030105 1234 3 130503001400 123456 4 130160020010 123456
              1 6150 57 56 2 703060 172 75 3 130503001400 559 6 4 130160020010 1401 41
              1 123 57 123 2 1234 172 4567 3 123456 559 8910111213 4 123456 1401 141516171819
              1 6150 123 2 703060 4567 3 130503001400 8910111213 4 130160020010 141516171819
              1 57 6150 123 2 172 703060 1234 3 559 130503001400 123456 4 1401 130160020010 123456
              1 6150 123 57 2 703060 1234 172 3 130503001400 123456 559 4 130160020010 123456 1401
              1 60 6150 123 2 119 703060 4567 3 393 130503001400 8910111213 4 848 130160020010 141516171819
              1 6150 123 123 2 703060 1234 4567 3 130503001400 123456 8910111213 4 130160020010 123456 141516171819

              3 57 1 4 115 2 75 387 3 75 842 4
              3 3 56 1 7 4 75 2 13 75 6 3 19 75 41 4
              57 60 1 115 119 2 387 393 3 842 848 4
              57 3 3 1 115 7 4 2 387 13 75 3 842 19 6 4
              57 3 3 1 115 4 7 2 387 75 13 3 842 75 19 4
              56 60 3 1 75 119 7 2 6 393 13 3 11 848 19 4
              60 56 3 1 119 75 7 2 393 6 13 3 848 11 19 4
              123 3 1 1234 4 2 123456 75 3 123456 75 4
              123 1 4567 2 8910111213 3 141516171819 4
              3 60 57 1 4 119 172 2 75 393 559 3 75 848 1401 4
              123 3 1 4567 4 2 8910111213 75 3 141516171819 75 4
              123 60 3 1 1234 119 7 2 123456 393 13 3 123456 848 19 4
              3 123 60 1 4 1234 119 2 75 123456 393 3 75 123456 848 4
              123 60 57 1 1234 119 115 2 123456 393 387 3 123456 848 842 4
              3 123 3 1 4 4567 7 2 75 8910111213 13 3 75 141516171819 19 4
              3 56 123 1 7 75 4567 2 13 6 8910111213 3 19 11 141516171819 4
              123 3 57 1 4567 7 172 2 8910111213 13 559 3 141516171819 19 1401 4
              123 56 57 1 4567 75 115 2 8910111213 6 387 3 141516171819 11 842 4
              57 3 6150 1 115 7 703060 2 387 13 130503001400 3 842 19 130160020010 4
              6150 57 3 1 703060 172 4 2 130503001400 559 75 3 130160020010 1401 6 4
              3 6150 57 1 7 703060 172 2 13 130503001400 559 3 19 130160020010 1401 4
              60 57 123 1 119 172 4567 2 393 559 8910111213 3 848 1401 141516171819 4
              6150 3 57 1 703060 4 172 2 130503001400 75 559 3 130160020010 75 1401 4
              6150 57 3 1 703060 172 7 2 130503001400 559 13 3 130160020010 1401 19 4
              123 3 123 1 1234 4 4567 2 123456 75 8910111213 3 123456 75 141516171819 4
              57 57 6150 1 115 172 703060 2 387 559 130503001400 3 842 1401 130160020010 4
              6150 123 3 1 703060 1234 4 2 130503001400 123456 75 3 130160020010 123456 6 4
              123 123 57 1 4567 1234 172 2 8910111213 123456 559 3 141516171819 123456 1401 4
              123 6150 57 1 4567 703060 172 2 8910111213 130503001400 559 3 141516171819 130160020010 1401 4

              It's easy to verify simply copy and paste each item or the entire set into a calculator and use the X/Y MOD button.

              https//www.calculator.net/big-number-calculator.html

              The proof
              1094 If you (Muhammad) have any doubt regarding what is revealed to you from your Lord, then ask those who read the previous scripture. Indeed, the truth has come to you from your Lord. Do not be with the doubters.
              7430 Over it is nineteen.

              1094 --> 10 + 94 = 104
              7430 --> 74 + 30 = 104

              AND
              1094 --> 1+0 + 9+4 = 14
              7430 --> 7+4 + 3+0 = 14

              (Indication The verse 1094 is related to verse 7430)

              No, not really since
              1094 = 104 1 0 9 4 = 14
              1193 = 104 1 1 9 3 = 14
              1292 = 104 1 2 9 2 = 14
              2084 = 104 2 0 8 4 = 14
              2183 = 104 2 1 8 3 = 14
              2381 = 104 2 3 8 1 = 14
              3371 = 104 3 3 7 1 = 14
              4064 = 104 4 0 6 4 = 14
              4361 = 104 4 3 6 1 = 14
              5153 = 104 5 1 5 3 = 14
              5351 = 104 5 3 5 1 = 14
              5450 = 104 5 4 5 0 = 14
              7034 = 104 7 0 3 4 = 14
              7430 = 104 7 4 3 0 = 14
              8024 = 104 8 0 2 4 = 14
              8123 = 104 8 1 2 3 = 14
              8321 = 104 8 3 2 1 = 14
              8420 = 104 8 4 2 0 = 14
              9014 = 104 9 0 1 4 = 14
              9113 = 104 9 1 1 3 = 14
              9212 = 104 9 2 1 2 = 14
              9311 = 104 9 3 1 1 = 14

              Perhaps something like this

              ق total = 7034 The Prime Factorization is 2 x 3517
              likewise, 703423517 is a prime number.

              ق start = 2288 The Prime Factorization is 2 x 2 x 2 x 2 x 11 x 13
              likewise, 228822221113 is a prime number.

              ق ending = 737 The Prime Factorization is 11 x 67
              likewise, 7371167 is a prime number.

              1 Reply Last reply
              0
              • shukriS Offline
                shukriS Offline
                shukri
                wrote on last edited by
                #27

                I've already demonstrated that this method works for any text—whether it's ماري كان لديها حمل صغير ("Mary had a little lamb," for instance)—or any other verses, including 9128-129, which contain 19 words and 114 letters (19 x 6). This yields a 1/19 probability. The approach they used involved selecting 9 or more variables, shifting columns, reporting only multiples, and omitting 18 out of 19 failed trials. For example, they might manipulate values like 26040 بِسْمِ by combining the first and last digits (2 + 40 = 42) or calculating 102 + 3 = 105, and so on.
                .
                .

                No need to bring up this matter again
                Enough is enough!

                Once again, please consult your maths professor and show him the "Masjid Tucson's findings"
                AND then you will know whether the "Masjid Tucson's codes" are coincidentally happened or divinely designed!

                Also, if you think you are very right
                Please send your rebuttals (in your Reply #26) to Mr. Jay Smith and Mr. Al Fadi
                Stated that my message to them titled "Al Quran is the word of God" is null and void
                And ask them to abandon my previous message
                That's the best thing you should do, I suppose!

                No, not really since
                1094 = 104 1 0 9 4 = 14
                1193 = 104 1 1 9 3 = 14
                1292 = 104 1 2 9 2 = 14
                2084 = 104 2 0 8 4 = 14
                .
                .

                To understand why only verse 7430 is fit for verse 1094, we should look the context of verse 1094

                1094 If you have any doubt regarding what is revealed to you from your Lord, then ask those who read the previous scripture. Indeed, the truth has come to you from your Lord. Do not be with the doubters.
                1095 Nor shall you join those who rejected God's signs, lest you be with the losers.
                1096 Surely, those condemned by a decree from your Lord cannot believe.
                1097 No matter what kind of sign you show them, (they cannot believe), until they see the painful retribution.

                Here we can see the phrase "what is revealed to you from your Lord" in verse 1094 is related to the revelation of "sign/miracle"
                AND the sign or the miracle-19 in verse 7430 is fulfill the context of verse 1094
                Whereas other verses on your list do not speak about "sign/miracle" and should be classified as "not applicable"!

                Note
                4610 Say, "What if it is from God and you disbelieved in it? A witness from the Children of Israel has borne witness to a similar phenomenon,* and he has believed, while you have turned arrogant. Surely, God does not guide the wicked people."
                *This witness is Rabbi Judah the Pious (11th Century A.D.), who discovered the same 19-based phenomenon
                https//whoisourcreator.blogspot.com/2008/09/rabbi-judah-pious-witnesses.html

                Thanks.

                "Our Lord, do not impose blame upon us if we have forgotten or erred"

                1 Reply Last reply
                0
                • B Offline
                  B Offline
                  Bajram_Hoxhaj
                  wrote on last edited by
                  #28

                  No need to bring up this matter again
                  Enough is enough!

                  Once again, please consult your maths professor and show him the "Masjid Tucson's findings"
                  AND then you will know whether the "Masjid Tucson's codes" are coincidentally happened or divinely designed!

                  Also, if you think you are very right
                  Please send your rebuttals (in your Reply #26) to Mr. Jay Smith and Mr. Al Fadi
                  Stated that my message to them titled "Al Quran is the word of God" is null and void
                  And ask them to abandon my previous message
                  That's the best thing you should do, I suppose!

                  Why bother replying to those who, like many on this site, can't comprehend even simple concepts? No need for math professors; this is simple stuff that even kids can do, and I've already shown you the template. This method works for any written material—phrases, text, verses—and it doesn’t matter if words are misspelled, letters are added or deleted, or even written backward.

                  Again, what they're doing, without realizing it, is using nine parameters and choosing up to three to generate 1,170 numbers. This yields ~61 multiples, or 1/19, and then they print selective results to deceive while hiding the 18/19 that are not multiples.

                  Note
                  4610 Say, "What if it is from God and you disbelieved in it? A witness from the Children of Israel has borne witness to a similar phenomenon,* and he has believed, while you have turned arrogant. Surely, God does not guide the wicked people."
                  *This witness is Rabbi Judah the Pious (11th Century A.D.), who discovered the same 19-based phenomenon

                  Again, most of you can't read In Arabic, "مثله" means "similar to it"
                  The Arabic word "وشهد" (wa-shahida) is actually in the past tense.
                  see context 468-10 "Wa Shahida Shāhidun Min"
                  see context 1226 "Wa Shahida Shāhidun Min"

                  شَهِدَ (shahida) – He witnessed (past tense).

                  يَشْهَدُ (yashhadu) – He witnesses or testifies (present tense).

                  سَيَشْهَدُ (sayashhadu) – He will witness (future tense).
                  That someone shall witness something in the future.

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  0
                  • shukriS Offline
                    shukriS Offline
                    shukri
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #29

                    To bro Bajram,

                    Just for my curiosity!
                    Here i put forward the same question I asked bro JinnJinn on Reply #14
                    Hope you don't mind answering it!

                    There are five objectives of number 19 in verse 7431
                    May I know which one do you belong to?

                    7430 Over it is nineteen.
                    7431 We appointed angels to be guardians of Hell, and we assigned their number (nineteen)
                    (a) to disturb the disbelievers,
                    (b) to convince the Christians and Jews (that this is a divine scripture),
                    (c) to strengthen the faith of the faithful,
                    (d) to remove all traces of doubt from the hearts of Christians, Jews, as well as the believers, and
                    (e) to expose those who harbor doubt in their hearts, and the disbelievers; they will say, "What did God mean by this allegory?" God thus sends astray whomever He wills, and guides whomever He wills. None knows the soldiers of your Lord except He. This is a reminder for the people.

                    Thanks in advance.

                    "Our Lord, do not impose blame upon us if we have forgotten or erred"

                    1 Reply Last reply
                    0
                    • B Offline
                      B Offline
                      Bajram_Hoxhaj
                      wrote on last edited by
                      #30

                      There are five objectives of number 19 in verse 7431
                      May I know which one do you belong to?

                      7430 Over it is nineteen.
                      7431 We appointed angels to be guardians of Hell, and we assigned their number (nineteen)
                      (a) to disturb the disbelievers,

                      Salaam shukri,

                      1. The translation you are using is horrid and misleading.

                      2. Why did they use the incorrect translation "is"? It should be "are."
                        In 7430, "over it (feminine) are a group of nineteen (masculine)," which you confirmed is the correct meaning of "their number" in 7431.

                      3. Do you acknowledge that any written text—whether a verse, "Mary had a little lamb," etc.—using 9 parameters up to three levels deep, has 1,170 possible combinations and yields 1/19 or ~61 multiples, as previously explained?

                      4. Do you acknowledge that the Arabic word in 4610, "وشهد" (wa-shahida), is in the past tense?

                      5. Do you acknowledge that in 7430-31, fitnah (فتنة), meaning "test" or "trial" in this context, was applicable at the time of revelation? Who were the unbelievers then, and what were they doubting or questioning?

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      0
                      • shukriS Offline
                        shukriS Offline
                        shukri
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #31

                        Bro Bajram,

                        Please, give a straightforward answer to my question
                        Whether (a), (b), (c), (d) or (e) or any combination of them!

                        For example
                        If you ask me the same question
                        I will say that i'm belong to (c) and (d)
                        AND full stop!

                        Note
                        If you choose not to answer my question, it's okay brother!

                        Salam.

                        "Our Lord, do not impose blame upon us if we have forgotten or erred"

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        0
                        • B Offline
                          B Offline
                          Bajram_Hoxhaj
                          wrote on last edited by
                          #32

                          Bro Bajram,

                          Please, give a straightforward answer to my question
                          Whether (a), (b), (c), (d) or (e) or any combination of them!

                          For example
                          If you ask me the same question
                          I will say that i'm belong to (c) and (d)
                          AND full stop!

                          Note
                          If you choose not to answer my question, it's okay brother!

                          Salam.

                          Salaam shukri,

                          There’s no "abc 123." I appreciate the believers from the time of revelation or the time of Mehmed Fetihler Sultani (a slightly embellished TV series I'm watching, set during the time when my great-grandfathers were imams). They and I believe there are nineteen controllers, entities, or forces over the abyss or hellfire. That’s it.

                          Now, I pose a question to you, which others have also avoided as you avoid answering my previous questions, if you had lived during the time of revelation or the Ottoman period 1,000 years later, would you have been a believer then—or even now? Or would you require a code of sorts that could align with everything ever written, as I’ve shown you?

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          0
                          • J Offline
                            J Offline
                            JinnJinn
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #33

                            Bro Bajram,

                            Please, give a straightforward answer to my question
                            Whether (a), (b), (c), (d) or (e) or any combination of them!

                            For example
                            If you ask me the same question
                            I will say that i'm belong to (c) and (d)
                            AND full stop!

                            Note
                            If you choose not to answer my question, it's okay brother!

                            Salam.

                            Hey Shukri,

                            This nipple sucker doesn't know to differentiate between singular and plural. 'Over it is 19' is absolutely right.

                            but he is right on the matter you guys discussing. for that, I salute him.

                            You belong to group C or D, and the rest of the believers belong to group A or B just because they don't believe your false messenger, who introduced fancy structures to elevate himself to a Messenger and follow him.

                            Ask yourself, is this the only verse that convinces you and increases your faith, and does the rest of the Quran not teach you anything to get convinced and increase your faith?
                            Come on man! where are you lost?

                            Let me modify my thread.

                            You said a week or so ago that you were agnostic and a disbeliever and this number magic turned you to believe in Al Quran and God. Lemme put that this way.

                            according to verse 74'31 disbelievers will go far away from this temptation of the verse but you turned toward faith as you claim. Allah's verse states disbelievers would sink into deep disbelief hearing this verse and how come you turned into a believer with 19? It points out that Allah is wrong. It should only increase the faith of believers of any ethnicity it states.

                            How was it possible for a disbeliever to get faith thru this verse while it states otherwise?

                            You didn't get the verse right, but you embraced the shit of your fancy messenger.

                            1 Reply Last reply
                            0
                            • B Offline
                              B Offline
                              Bajram_Hoxhaj
                              wrote on last edited by
                              #34

                              Hey Shukri,

                              This nipple sucker doesn't know to differentiate between singular and plural. 'Over it is 19' is absolutely right.

                              nineteen morons (masculine) تِسْعةَ عَشرَ بليداً
                              you don't say "is" nineteen morons you moron!
                              اللعنة عليك مصاصة الديك

                              اللعنة (al-la‘nah) — "Curse"
                              عليك (‘alayk) — "upon you"
                              مصاصة (miṣṣāṣah) — "sucker"
                              الديك (al-dīk) — "the rooster" or, in slang, it can mean "d***"

                              In other words, using 19 characters fk off you c***sucker!

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              0
                              • shukriS Offline
                                shukriS Offline
                                shukri
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #35

                                Salaam shukri,

                                There’s no "abc 123." I appreciate the believers from the time of revelation or the time of Mehmed Fetihler Sultani (a slightly embellished TV series I'm watching, set during the time when my great-grandfathers were imams). They and I believe there are nineteen controllers, entities, or forces over the abyss or hellfire. That’s it.

                                Now, I pose a question to you, which others have also avoided as you avoid answering my previous questions, if you had lived during the time of revelation or the Ottoman period 1,000 years later, would you have been a believer then—or even now? Or would you require a code of sorts that could align with everything ever written, as I’ve shown you?

                                My simple answer
                                2141 That was a community from the past. They are responsible for what they earned, and you are responsible for what you earned. You are not answerable for anything they did.

                                AND for you, the wisdom of verses 7430-37 is still hidden as a mystery, i suppose!
                                But for me, the wisdom of "the nineteen" is the greatest sign/proof that the God exists and the Quran is the word of God

                                Thank you God for your guidance and mercy on me
                                AND chosen me to be blessed with the wisdom of miracles-19
                                All praise be to God!

                                Salam!

                                Ends.

                                "Our Lord, do not impose blame upon us if we have forgotten or erred"

                                1 Reply Last reply
                                0
                                • shukriS Offline
                                  shukriS Offline
                                  shukri
                                  wrote on last edited by
                                  #36

                                  According to verse 74'31 disbelievers will go far away from this temptation of the verse but you turned toward faith as you claim. Allah's verse states disbelievers would sink into deep disbelief hearing this verse and how come you turned into a believer with 19? It points out that Allah is wrong. It should only increase the faith of believers of any ethnicity it states.

                                  You're wrong!
                                  During my agnostic/atheist I was in concordance with objective (a) of verse 7431
                                  viz. to disturb/test the disbelievers (agnostic/atheist)

                                  NOT objective (e)
                                  viz. to expose those who harbor doubt in their hearts, and the disbelievers; they will say, "What did God mean by this allegory?"

                                  Thanks.

                                  "Our Lord, do not impose blame upon us if we have forgotten or erred"

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  0
                                  • B Offline
                                    B Offline
                                    Bajram_Hoxhaj
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #37

                                    My simple answer
                                    2141 That was a community from the past. They are responsible for what they earned, and you are responsible for what you earned. You are not answerable for anything they did.

                                    AND for you, the wisdom of verses 7430-37 is still hidden as a mystery, i suppose!
                                    But for me, the wisdom of "the nineteen" is the greatest sign/proof that the God exists and the Quran is the word of God

                                    Thank you God for your guidance and mercy on me
                                    AND chosen me to be blessed with the wisdom of miracles-19
                                    All praise be to God!

                                    Salam!

                                    Ends.

                                    Salaam shukri, to clarify on numbers and groups.

                                    تِسْعَ (Tis‘a) refers specifically to the number nine.
                                    Example تِسْعَ كُتُبٍ (tis‘a kutubin) means "nine books."

                                    In verses 17101 and 2712, تِسْعَ (Tis‘a) refers to nine signs.
                                    In verse 2748, تِسْعَةَ (Tis‘atu) refers to a group of nine (m/p).

                                    In verse 7430, عَلَيْهَا تِسْعَةَ عَشَرَ (ʿalayhā tisʿatu ʿashara) refers to a masculine plural group.
                                    Translates to "Over it are nineteen," indicating nineteen controllers guarding the hellfire.

                                    Btw, since it was mentioned ماري كان لديها حمل صغير ("Mary had a little lamb&quot
                                    19 letters
                                    5 19 1750 = 19 x 2732500

                                    1 40120010 251 4 4 251 255 50 1234 1234
                                    2 20150 71 3 7 322 74 70 123 567
                                    3 3041051 50 5 12 372 55 31 12345 89101112
                                    4 84030 78 3 15 450 81 38 123 131415
                                    5 90100010200 1300 4 19 1750 1304 290 1234 16171819

                                    = 19 x 73747373816548690818 42754801801060563880 64603690714070021606 05532827659532813626 84796044226727976056 91480164811346847368 95790158115355270022 5795969272201

                                    = 29 x 48317244914290521570 69391077042074162542 49223107709218290017 76038749156245636514 14176718631304536037 28900797635020348276 21379758765232763118 2418048833511

                                    … and numerous others flipping above columns

                                    Take care and all the best!

                                    1 Reply Last reply
                                    0
                                    • J Offline
                                      J Offline
                                      JinnJinn
                                      wrote on last edited by
                                      #38

                                      nineteen morons (masculine) تِسْعةَ عَشرَ بليداً
                                      you don't say "is" nineteen morons you moron!
                                      اللعنة عليك مصاصة الديك

                                      اللعنة (al-la‘nah) — "Curse"
                                      عليك (‘alayk) — "upon you"
                                      مصاصة (miṣṣāṣah) — "sucker"
                                      الديك (al-dīk) — "the rooster" or, in slang, it can mean "d***"

                                      In other words, using 19 characters fk off you c***sucker!

                                      Ooh baby! this is fun after work.

                                      I want to take a leak. Open your nasty mouth. How was it? Pure Arabic distillery. Made in Dubai.
                                      Not satisfied? OK. Sck my blls then you will discover a 9" miracle. You can become a messenger for 9. Pure Arabic miracle. rotfl
                                      Fools cannot be fixed. OVER IT IS 19.

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      0
                                      • G Offline
                                        G Offline
                                        good_logic
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #39

                                        BH and JJ, why are you both even discussing Qoran, especially thinking you are correcting beliefs and mistakes of others ?

                                        First, mind your language and heed a basic etiquette from Qoran . i.e avoid using bad and disrespectful words and converse amicably and with respect.
                                        Of course it is your choice.
                                        But what is your aim here? There is no benefit or need for this kind of posts that repel honest truth seekers!
                                        May the Lord guide you both.
                                        Peace.

                                        1 Reply Last reply
                                        0
                                        • C Offline
                                          C Offline
                                          centi50
                                          wrote on last edited by
                                          #40

                                          Salam bro Shukri,

                                          Did you try to contact those two disbelievers Al Fadi and Jay Smith? Instead of people fighting here, they should be fighting Al Fadi and Jay Smith to show how wrong they are in the Quran.

                                          I have some books it was written by Pazuzu. It discusses

                                          "Arabia The Untold Story" A Summary

                                          This book aims to challenge widely accepted historical narratives, particularly those concerning the geographical locations of events described in the Quran and the Bible. The central argument is that a significant historical distortion has occurred, largely due to the influence of the Septuagint, a Greek translation of the Hebrew Bible, which the authors argue contains deliberate mistranslations and fabrications to advance political agendas.

                                          Key Claims

                                          • Egypt Was Never Called "Miṣr" by Arabs The sources assert that during the time of Prophet Muhammad (P) and the early period of Islamic expansion, the Arabs knew Egypt as "al-Qibt," derived from the Greek and Roman names for the region. "Miṣr," according to the sources, was initially the name of the Arab military encampment near the Roman fort of Babylon in the Nile Delta. This camp evolved into the city of al-Fusṭāṭ and, as its prominence grew, the name "Miṣr" came to be associated with it. However, a later misinterpretation mistakenly applied this name to the entire country, creating confusion and obscuring the original name "al-Qibt."

                                          • "Pharaoh" Is Not an Ancient Egyptian Title The authors challenge the widely held belief that "Pharaoh" was a title used to designate the rulers of Ancient Egypt. They point to the lack of any archaeological evidence to support this claim. Inscriptions, papyrus documents, and royal cartouches all reveal numerous titles used for Egyptian kings, but none resemble "Pharaoh." The authors argue that the term "pr-aa" ("Great House&quot, sometimes suggested as the origin of "Pharaoh," actually referred to the seat of government, not the ruler. They cite expert opinions from prominent Egyptologists, including Ashraf ‘Izzat and Professor Zāhi Ḥawwās, who confirm the absence of "Pharaoh" in Ancient Egyptian records.

                                          • The Septuagint Deliberately Misrepresented History The sources accuse the Septuagint translators of deliberately replacing the Hebrew term "Mtzrim" with the Greek "Aigypto" (Egypt) when translating the Exodus narrative. This substitution, they argue, was a politically motivated act designed to elevate the status of the Ptolemaic dynasty and the Jewish community in Alexandria by connecting them to pivotal biblical events. This fabrication, the sources claim, has had a lasting impact on perceptions of history, creating a false association between the Israelites and Egypt that persists to this day.

                                          • The Quranic "Miṣr" Is Not Egypt The sources argue that the "Miṣr" mentioned in the Quranic accounts of prophets Joseph (Yūsuf) and Moses (Mūsa) is not Ancient Egypt. They point to several factors to support this claim, including

                                          • Description of Miṣr as a trade citadel The Quranic narrative suggests a walled and fortified trade station or a central hub for travellers, which aligns with the original meaning of the term "Miṣr" as understood in Arabic.

                                          • Emphasis on rain-fed agriculture The story of Joseph features a drought that impacts the region's agriculture, a scenario unlikely in Ancient Egypt, which relied on the Nile's annual floods for irrigation.

                                          • The Israelites inheriting the land after Far‘awn's demise The Quran indicates that the Israelites became successors in the land where Far‘awn ruled, a claim not supported by any historical evidence related to Ancient Egypt.

                                          • Arabic names for Far‘awn and his wife in Islamic traditions The sources point to the use of distinctly Arabic names for Far‘awn and his wife in some Islamic traditions as further evidence that these figures were not associated with Ancient Egypt.

                                          • The Significance of "Ṭūr" and "Yamm" The authors differentiate between "Ṭūr," specifically "Ṭūr Seenā’" mentioned in the Quran, and the commonly known Mount Sinai in the Sinai Peninsula. They highlight verses that suggest "Ṭūr" is located in a fertile region with abundant water sources, unlike the arid Sinai. They also emphasize the distinct meanings of the Quranic terms "baḥr" and "yamm," arguing that "yamm" refers to a flowing stream of water, not a sea. They use this interpretation to challenge the traditional narrative of the Red Sea crossing, proposing instead that Far‘awn drowned in an inland stream located in the mountainous region of ancient Yemen.

                                          The book ultimately encourages a reassessment of widely accepted historical narratives, advocating for a critical reading of both the Quran and the Bible, free from preconceived notions and traditional interpretations. It urges readers to question established authorities and to engage in independent research, using reason and evidence to uncover the truth about history.

                                          You can give me your email and I will send the books to you. It's an eye-opener

                                          God bless all

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          0
                                          Reply
                                          • Reply as topic
                                          Log in to reply
                                          • Oldest to Newest
                                          • Newest to Oldest
                                          • Most Votes


                                          • Login

                                          • Don't have an account? Register

                                          • Login or register to search.
                                          • First post
                                            Last post
                                          0
                                          • Categories
                                          • Recent
                                          • Users