Answer and Win
-
Peace all,
When one uses the scripture to have a MIND GAME. He is so busy in his MIND that he misses the MESSAGE WHICH IS VERY SIMPLE.!
GET STRAIGHT FROM INSIDE.
Having the whole QURAN in the brain will not bring guidance till one starts to get straight from WITHIN. Then honesty,.... will start manifesting.
Peace,
-
peace,
Answer to 7 we all know
From the book, "TWO ISLAMS" 1949 by Faazil Deeniyaat, Ghulam Jeelani Barq
"While the Sahaba Kiram had been burning collections of Ahadith, how did our Muhaddithin encounter millions of Ahadith? Bukhari found 600,000 plus. The chain of narration contains 5-6 persons. How could he investigate 3.5 million narrators 99.9% of whom were dead and buried? And Yahya bin Moin had 1.4 million Ahadith! One doesn?t need to be a rocket scientist to gauge the chaos, forgery and fraud.
Allama Muhammad Tahir Gujrati, in his famous book ?Qanoon Al-Akhbaril Maudhu?ah War Rijalud Dhu?fa? has collected the names of nearly 2,000 men who spent their lives in forging Ahadith. If one forged 1,000 the other manufactured 10.000.
Maulana Ubaidullah Sindhi said, ?I cannot tell in public why I cannot teach Bukhari to a European convert.?
Do not think that that only non-Muslims used to commit this crime. Numerous men like Ibn Abi Yahya in Madina, Alwaqidi in Baghdad and Maqatil bin Sulaiman in Khurasan, being on high posts such as provincial chief justices, were very much involved in this ?noble? assault on the Qur?an. Allama Ibn Jozi has compiled a long list of many ?revered Imams? of Islam participating in this deplorable assault. (Tazkarah Maudhu?aat by Allama Muhammad Tahir, pgs 9 on) "Imam Muhammad bin Ishaq (famous for writing the first biography of the exalted prophet) said Imam Maalik is a liar. (Jaame? Mukhtasir pg 19
Imam Maalik said Imam Muhammad bin Ishaq is DAJJAL. (Jaame? pg 19
Imam A?mash said to Imam Abu Hanifah I can?t stand you in your own home. (Pg 199)
Imam Abu Hanifah said Imam Jabir Al-Ja?fi is a great forger.
Imam Abu Hanifah said Imam A?mash neither observes Saum nor does he take the post-coital bath. (Pg 199)
Imam Saeed bin Musaib and Imam Hasan Basari called Hazrat ?Ikramah a liar and ?Ikramah said the same about those two. (Pgg 197-19
Imam Qatadah considered Imam Yahya bin Katheer a fabricator and the latter thought the same of the former. (Pg 199)
Imam Saleh Al-Marri said Imam Hammad is a big liar. (Fathul Mulhim pg 13
Imam Yazeed bin Haroon said Imam Ziyad bin Maimoon keeps changing the chains of narration. (Fathul pg 139)
Imam ?Ubaidullah bin Ma?az said Write nothing from Qazi Abi Shaibah (Fath pg 13
Imam Abu Ja?far Al-Hashmi said Imam ?Umro bin ?Ubaid is a liar. (Fath pg 137)The first ever man to collect the names and details of (5 million!) narrators was Imam Yahya bin Mo?een. Imam Shaafi?i said He is absolutely unreliable. (Kitab fi Dhu?fa, Jaame? Mukhtasir pg 201)
If Bukhari really was so carefull and that only small mistakes ended up in his books, how then can you explain this?
Hazrat Ayesha narrated that the prophet (S) used to kiss his wives and had intercourse with them while he was observing Saum (Abstinence). (Bukhari pg 226, vol 1)Muhaddith Abu Daud was not to be left behind. Hazrat Ayesha said, ?The prophet used to kiss me and suck on my tongue while he was fasting.?
Hazrat Ayesha was sitting at her home in Aisha bint Talhah?s company when her husband Abdullah came in and he was fasting. Hazrat Ayesha said to Abdullah, ?What is holding you back from embracing, kissing, riding and playing with your wife even though you are fasting?? (Muwatta Maalik pg 89)
Ayesha said, ?When Rasoolullah desired to have intercourse with me while I menstruated, he would order me to tie a piece of cloth around my waist.? (Bukhari, The Book of Menstruation124)"no offense. but "bunch of idiots". who? you answer if you truely know god and the quran.
ahora, comprendes tu sennor virtualeye porque yo no acceptir ahadith?
(translation do you understand now why i reject EVERY hadith, mr. virtualeye).why don't you look at surah fil/feel according to the quran. isn't the quran alone enough?
if you still say, the hadith explains the quran better than the quran explains itself, then aren't you saying those "bunch of idiots" explain the quran better than allah?
i know what you are going to say! you will say, nauzubillah. surely, reject all hadith except the best hadith, the quran. know what is important for you to live by acoording to the quran.surely, it contains no contradictoin or 'nonsense'.
what was the purpose for you to ask this question. do you question the authenticity of the quran? or do you simply ask whether this "bombing of the elephants" happened in history or not. to answer this question, one must look upon why is it in the "fully deailed quran"? god punishes the igorant SPIRITULLY... it serves its purpose why those band of elephant riders were punished... because they turned away/rejected GOD WHILE KNOWING...perhaps there is something to be learned from the quran and its message and why is it important. so review your question (the purpose).
peace, rifat