vinegar

ammarb87

Is Spirit Vinegar or Wine vinegar alright to consume ?

unknownuser

Peace. Its great with chips,but im not too sure about drinking it bro...

ammarb87

Na I just wanted to know whether Wine Vinegar/Spirit Vinegar is halal .. I checked various sites and most people say its halal cus alcohol isnt intentionally put in the vinegar. Its produced through the chemical reactions etc ..

Alen

Salam.

Vinegar is sin, doesn't matter where it came from, wheater was it made with or without the intention. Wine vinegar is a sin.
Of course, Allah Most Powerful knows best.

Salam.

ammarb87

??? How is it a sin ? Are you just saying that as a joke or mean it ?

Alen

??? How is it a sin ? Are you just saying that as a joke or mean it ?

Salam.

Alcohol, ANY AMOUNT, is a sin.
Few months ago i saw the ingredients on a toast and two struck me pork and alcohol.
But it doesn't matter where they put alcohol, how much of it is there, it is a sin. If we were not allowed to drink more than, say, two inches, Allah Most High wouls say so. But Alcohol is prohibited, no ifs, no buts and i'll post evidence as soon as i find them.

Salam.

savage_carrot

Few months ago i saw the ingredients on a toast and two struck me pork and alcohol.

What do you mean ingredients 'on a toast'? Can you clarify? Were they 'in' the toast? Or being served on top of it somehow? As for 'alcohol' being haram, please do a search on the topic. One can find loads of threads to read. Peace.

ammarb87

I dont believe Vinegar is haram ... most schools of thought have permitted it !!

Alen

Few months ago i saw the ingredients on a toast and two struck me pork and alcohol.

What do you mean ingredients 'on a toast'? Can you clarify? Were they 'in' the toast? Or being served on top of it somehow? As for 'alcohol' being haram, please do a search on the topic. One can find loads of threads to read. Peace.

Salam.

I took the toast that was on my table, just out of curiousity, because i knew what a bread is made of. So, i started reading. When i saw that one of the ingredients are pork and wine or alcohol, i forgot now, i was amazed!

Than my neighbor explained to me that they use these two things to make the toast fresh for a long period of time.

What they won't do, ha?

Salam.

ammarb87

That doesnt really make sense because then what are the vegetarians supposed to eat ? Do u get some special kind of bread or something?

Alen

That doesnt really make sense because then what are the vegetarians supposed to eat ? Do u get some special kind of bread or something?

Salam.

No, i buy same bread as you, i was just pointing out that TOAST has these ingredients, at least in Slovenia.
Vegetarians are commiting a sin when they deprive themselves of meat. They prohobit what is allowed.

Salam.

Elke

Peace alen

if a vegetarian choses not to eat meat - why do you consider this a sin ? Is the obligation of eating meat part of your religion ?

lk

ammarb87

Whats TOAST ? isnt it the same thing as normal bread ?

Alen

Peace alen
if a vegetarian choses not to eat meat - why do you consider this a sin ? Is the obligation of eating meat part of your religion ?
lk

Salam.

Dear sister, you misunderstood.
It's not a sin that a vegeterian chooses NOT to eat meat, it's a sin that he PROHIBITS what is already ALLOWED.

Allah Most Merciful says that it is okay to eat meat, not pork but cow, rabbit, chicken, duck but than this vegan person says"Hey, i'm not gonna eat meat because that is wrong."
Than i step in"Look, Allah Most Merciful gave me permission to eat meat."

So, the way i see it, vegan person is saying that soemthing that is allowed, is prohibited and that is a sin. The fact that he doesn't wangt to eat meat is just his choice. Wrong but .... what can i do?

No offence, Elke.
Salam.

Samia

Maybe he means lard and beer fermenter (dried yeast)

savage_carrot

Maybe he means lard and beer fermenter (dried yeast)

Hmm could be but it's been discussed before (the halal/haram thing). Thanks for the input. Peace.

Edited to clarify.

Tay

Peace ammarb87,

As far as haram and halal go, then it's the intoxication that is debatable. A drop of vinegar from one's food is not haram, nor is a little wine or any other alcohol for that matter. No one gets drunk on Penne Pasta w/Vodka sauce.

Peace,
Tay

Elena

Peace

vegetarians say meat is prohibited? ???

I know lots f vegetarians, I never heard them saying that.

The fact that he doesn't wangt to eat meat is just his choice. Wrong but ....

wrong for you.

I'd say you are confusing 'allowed' with 'compulsory' and 'choice' with 'prohibition' ??

I've added "Vegetarians are comminting a sin when they deprive themselves of meat" to the list of things some people say about vegetarians, the list is varied and imaginative but that one is priceless. No offence.

Peace alen
if a vegetarian choses not to eat meat - why do you consider this a sin ? Is the obligation of eating meat part of your religion ?
lk

Salam.

Dear sister, you misunderstood.
It's not a sin that a vegeterian chooses NOT to eat meat, it's a sin that he PROHIBITS what is already ALLOWED.

Allah Most Merciful says that it is okay to eat meat, not pork but cow, rabbit, chicken, duck but than this vegan person says"Hey, i'm not gonna eat meat because that is wrong."
Than i step in"Look, Allah Most Merciful gave me permission to eat meat."

So, the way i see it, vegan person is saying that soemthing that is allowed, is prohibited and that is a sin. The fact that he doesn't wangt to eat meat is just his choice. Wrong but .... what can i do?
.

Elke

Salaam Alen,

i absolutely did not misunderstand, but tried some irony on you. No offence

lk

ammarb87

Peace ammarb87,

As far as haram and halal go, then it's the intoxication that is debatable. A drop of vinegar from one's food is not haram, nor is a little wine or any other alcohol for that matter. No one gets drunk on Penne Pasta w/Vodka sauce.

Peace,
Tay

Thats true actually .. good explanation ) ..