MUSLIM WOMAN CHALLENGES ISLAM TOWARDS REFORM

progod

Her name is Irshaad Manji, her story is here

http//www.muslim-refusenik.com/index.html

Godbless,
Anwar

Andya_Primanda

Irshad Manji? She's frequently discussed here... and AFAIK the general consensus here is that she's trying too hard to please the west. She does raise some interesting points, but her position's not that agreeable here.

AspeRin

you take a picture with satan guliani then you really dont know was up...trying to please the west out of fear, is what i see here.
peace

Samia

Her name is Irshaad Manji, her story is here

http//www.muslim-refusenik.com/index.html

Godbless,
Anwar

I surfed through her web, and frankly I found a slightly different Irshad than the one who wrote "the trouble with islam". She is still far from being analytic rather than reactionistic, but now she at least acknowledges a difference between culture and islam.

I still feel she does not want to even come near the quraan to try to understand it away from culture and "history". She wants a reform "the christian way", putting the script on hold and move on with what the society acknowledges. Hardly an islamic reform. A submission...to society.

I just hope that some of the muslims who activly support her help her be more rational and

almarh0m

Peace all

The thing about Irshaad Manji is , that she appears like a an Intellectual giant among the Intellectual Pygmies -[

Salaam