thank you
-
not sure if i get you, are you saying you think salat should be left to personal interpetation with some conditions?
There is nothing to interperate. Thats whole problem. It's not in the Quran. We know Mohammed didn't bring a new salat, all he did was tell people what they were doing wrong with the one they had. All we have are the conditions which are as clear day.
what do you mean when you say 'They forget that God tells to do salat as he as already taught us like speach, walking and other things we do' ?...that it is natural or coded into our design?
I would imagine it's alot more complex than that. You must agree that God has ways other than the Quran to guide us.
'In the desire to the learn something new lets not forget the old'.....do you mean we should make salat as traditional muslims do?
Yes if that was your way. If you were hindu before I'd expect you carry on with that way but applying the Quranic conditions.
You'd be surprised how similiar salat is among different cultures and religions. And if everyone devoted their salaat to God alone, there wouldn't be any issues at all.
God makes no difference between Salaat of Noah and Mohammad.
peace.
-
Greetings & Welcome!
welcome
The "Salat Prayer" issue would continue to be one of the most confusing puzzle if it is really a "prayer".
Very well said by House M.D.
That's because salat doesn't mean 'prayer'.
Please see
http//mypercept.co.uk/articles/slw.
http//mypercept.co.uk/articles/disproved_traditional_salat.htm
http//free-minds.org/articles/quranic/salat_wakas.htm
(I Don't want to go off topic here but I just want to share it the sincere & natural way.)
I know it's quite hard to reject the "ritual" at first when you see most translations refer to it as "salat". But just try to consider why this word "salat" pops up all over the quran in many many context which are completely unrelated to "prayer" - but it is fully related to uphold the "bond" of God's laws since "aqemous-salat" occurs many times immediately near the commandments God tells the messengers or believers with him or believers in general.
I used to ask myself
Why is it such a great puzzle to figure out the rituals if the quran is God's preserved revelation and complete, fully detailed?
Is it this ritual stuff or rather upholding God's laws (believe/worship/glorify God alone, be kind to parents, tell the truth, speak in good manners, stay away from adultery, etc... etc, etc.) that can make us far from evil as in 2945? Which one is more Natural? Do I have to be more "Arab" or traditional to be a good man?
I see all the messengers are telling the same Natural message to glorify the One God and do good.
Also ,the world bend, prostrate, stand, many times are allegorical but it would be confusing if we see it literal... Chapter 37 shows that there are both clear and allegorical verses but if people take the allegorical as literal then it would cause lots of confusion, etc. (Yes, not all translations are the same, this is from having read "QXP"... which I don't agree on all points but is truly a very very good rendition (not translation) that shows the harmony of the quran excellently!)
Therefore, believe/understand/praise the One God and do good is the way. God explains in his book how to do so complete, fully detailed.
Then I ask myself, what if I'm wrong? My friend said something like, we do our best to be most sincere to God Alone as he clarified - we want to stay away from the human-added falsehood. God gave us this much means and knowledge and we did our best most sincere way. Would God punish us for us not solving the great "salat prayer" puzzle when He didn't clarify it? Also, as we tested/verified for ourselves that the quran is indeed God's preserved revelation, and it is complete & fully detailed - then such a repeated/important issue like salat can't be a puzzle like this.
May God Guide & Bless!
Glory to God, the Creator of all things!
-
salam,
Respectfully.welcome and hope you find many friends here.
Read the Qur'an and always rely on The God.Remember God The Most Powewrful hears you all the time so whatever you ask, ask God and know that God is The Most powerful, He can do anything and everything.
Glory be to God, The Most Wise.
Glory be to God The Most Just.Peace.
-
Salaam brother, welcome
Salat... for me it's a personal thing. It's our personal offer to God. Our personal time to show our gratitude to the Creator. So instead of worrying about how many rakaat why not just do what your heart tells you. I'm sure you'll feel much better.
The result? When i don't salat i feel distant, when i salat i feel closer to Him. if i do too much, somehow the sincerity kinda gone. If i do too less i kinda forget Him. Just need to find the right balance that your heart agrees. I always salat when my heart tells me. That way i'm practising to listen to my inner voice/ guide instead of doubting or rejecting it.
There is one time when my wife had safely borne a child (about 2 months ago). When i got back home from hospital at that morning a voice tells me to salat and prostrate to God. It's repeating and it's getting louder the more i delay it. Sounded like "Prostrate to Me". I started my salat and directly prostrate. I prostrate with all my heart. I kinda know that it is from the Most High. I have been praying to seek refuge for my wife and my child. He granted it. I have to show my gratitude to Him. Then the sound is gone. Only God knows how i felt. All the Praise upon Him.
Just don't think too much on the details. It's the sincerity that counts. That's the lesson that i've learned. ;D ;D
handshake
-
Peace dc2 )
Although it maybe is kind of late to reply to this thread, I want to say welcome to the forum, and that i am glad too see another convert here. Its amazing how the quran guides people to the truth.
Many things in your story reminded me of things that i also had experienced before i had read and reflected upon the Quran. Its great that people question what they have been thought and are critical. All this questions we ask are like a fuel to a car. Without the fuel, the car can't go any longer. The same thing is applied to the questions. Without questions, we can't evolve spiritually. The questions = fuels. lol
Anyway, i have a text about hadith in my second post in the thread below, that i think might interest you. It is about the history of hadiths. Scroll down to almost the end of the thread and there is you will find my post about hadiths
http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=16809.0
Yours sincerely
David -
thanks for the welcome dave, it is i think detremental to islam that so many ignorant hadith are regarded as divine regulations.
the quran accuses the jewish nation as a people who hindered many from the path of god and compares them to a donkey carrying a vast tome of writings, percieving them not.
how are mainstream muslims any different now with all their diabolical laws based on these contrived hadith, fatwas etc? i dont see a difference.