Peace,
Is this because of the eve and rib theory? Was that prevalent in christianity before the revelation of the quran?
It's interesting but would you recommend a book or so which discusses this...or is this common arabic knowledge that the word nisaa is because the women came later?
I'm afraid I can't answer these questions . You might find this interesting too, another theory for why women are referred to as nisa'a in Arabic is because they are the ones responsible for giving birth which makes them the bearers of the later/coming generations. In 2431 (I'm using Abdullah Yusufali's translation or rather interpetation )
And say to the believing women that they should lower their gaze and guard their modesty; that they should not display their beauty and ornaments except what (must ordinarily) appear thereof; that they should draw their veils over their bosoms and not display their beauty except to their husbands, their fathers, their husband's fathers, their sons, their husbands' sons, their brothers or their brothers' sons, or their sisters' sons, or their women, or the slaves whom their right hands possess, or male servants free of physical needs, or small children who have no sense of the shame of sex; and that they should not strike their feet in order to draw attention to their hidden ornaments. And O ye Believers! turn ye all together towards God, that ye may attain Bliss.
Note I don't think it's correct but it serves the point I'm trying to make.
Dr. Shahrour says that nisa'a here (the underlined part )doesn't refer to women either , he says it refers to the later/coming generations decsending from the believing women. The verse says that these women are not supposed to display their beauty except for their
1-husbands
2-fathers
3-husbands' fathers
4-sons
5-husbands' sons
6-brothers
7-brothers' sons
8-sisters' sons
Notice that the verse till here is talking about men .
9-women ???
If nisa'a ( or nisa'ehen to be more accurate) indeed refers to women , which women are meant ? Other believeing women ?
Dr. Shahrour says that nisa'ehen here refers to the coming/later generations like grandchildren, which makes more sense IMO. Actually, if you refer to PM's translation nisa'ehen is translated as ( their children that come after them).
If you do speak Arabic then could you please skim a translation of that article for me? Just the main points. I tried sending you a private message regarding this, but I guess it did not work.
I would be glad to, but it's going to take time. I'll post it as soon as I finish it.
Also, here's my question How would one know in what sense what word is being used? The word used is clearly "nisa'a" which means women.
Well , like in English a word can a have a number of meanings but usually in Arabic they are closely related.We know its meaning through the context it was used in.
Now eventhough it means modern/new, do you think the case would be the same with all the places in the Koran where the word "nisa'a" is used? Could God use a word that is so close to having two totally different meanings?
No, not neccesarily( FYI, the word nis'e is mentioned in 9 37 )
As I said earlier , an Arabic word has a number of meanings but they all revolve around one main meaning . I'll give you an example .
The word tar in Arabic corresponds to flew in English (In Arabic the infinitive is the past tense, it's three-lettered usually ).
tayar = pilot (male)
tayara = pilot (female)
ta'era = airplane
ta'er = bird
Pilot , airplane & bird all revolve around the same meaning which is flying . That's why they go back to same root. This also applies to nisa'a. If my explanation isn't clear please tell me.
By the way, the person who wrote that article (whose link you posted) Dr. Muhammed Shahrour is he an Arab? Is Arabic his native language? Through my experience, I think it is best to ask such questions to those who speak that language and are fluent in it, instead of asking those who can only understand is so-much.
Yes , he's Syrian . Actually free-minds.org has translated some excerpts of his books , here's the link
http//free-minds.org/books/shahroor.htm