Thanks for your responses, I want to become a practising Muslim, but I don't know where to go. There are not many Muslims where I live, especially not Quranists. And how can you reject Hadiths and be a Muslim, when there are over 100 verses in the Qur'an telling you to obey the Messenger?
P
Plato2
@Plato2
Posts
-
How does ISIS violate the Qur'an? -
How does ISIS violate the Qur'an?I am referring to 4829
-
How does ISIS violate the Qur'an?Thanks, they are very good answers, but why in the Qur'an does it say merciful to believers and harsh to disbelievers? That sounds like it may inspire these extremists. I am sure I am wrong and you will be able to rectify.
-
What do you think of WikiIslam's "questions for Qur'anists?"- Why do you deny the hadith? Is it because you are ashamed of your prophet?
- Does it bother you that even without the hadith, the Qur'an sanctions pedophilia, domestic abuse, and many other crimes? Shouldn't you embrace your apostasy and get rid of the Qur'an?
- Why do some of you accept the hadiths that make Muhammad look good and reject the ones that make him look bad? Do you enjoy being intellectually dishonest?
- The historical evidence for Muhammad is found in the hadith and sirat. If you do not accept these sources, how do you know your prophet ever existed?
5.If you reject the hadith, you lose the whole context and order of the Qur'anic revelations. So is there no compulsion in religion or do you have to slay the idolaters wherever you find them?
6.Why do you believe the Qur'an is the uncorrupted word of God, when the narrators of corrupted hadith are the same people who passed down the Qur'an? - The Qur'an never explains how to offer salat. Who taught you how to pray?
- The Qur'an says there should be 3 daily prayers. Who told you to pray 5 times?
- The Qur'an mentions Abu Lahab. Without referencing "corrupted" hadith, please tell us who is he and why does Allah hate him?
- Is it upsetting knowing that most Muslims think you follow an obscure cult and that you're a non-Muslim?
One can be a Muslim their entire life without ever meeting a "Qur'anist". So why are there so many of you on the net? - Why accuse the Sunnis and Shi'ites, who've been following hadith for 1000+ years, of innovation, when it's you who's the innovator?
- What did Muhammad look like? How many wives did he have and what were their names? What were the names of his children? How old was he when he first received his prophethood? When and how did he die? Do you even know anything about your prophet?
- Why do you accept the revelations given to someone who you know nothing about?
- Did you know that Rashad Khalifa was a lying pedophile and rapist?
- If you don't accept the history behind the compilation of the Qur'an, what makes it different from any other poorly written Medieval text? How do you know that (like The True Furqan) it's not an old parody?
-
How does ISIS violate the Qur'an?When the Qur'an says the apostles of Muhammad are merciful to believers and harsh to disbelievers and command Muslims to wage jihad against disbelievers. I don't know much about Islam so may be someone could refute how ISIS go against Qur'an, because to me it seems like they are the ones following Islam properly whereas the "good" Muslims are not.