Skip to content

General Issues / Questions

This area deals with any general questions/issues regarding God / Islam / Quran not covered under other headings.

This category can be followed from the open social web via the handle [email protected]

7.1k Topics 133.0k Posts
  • Righteous Deeds vs. Rituals: The Quran’s Emphasis on Amal Ṣāliḥ

    3
    0 Votes
    3 Posts
    100 Views
    H
    PEACE, Righteousness is not that you turn your faces toward the east or the west, but righteousness is one who believes in Allah , the Last Day, the angels, the Book, and the prophets and gives wealth, in spite of love for it, to relatives, orphans, the needy, the traveler, those who ask , and for freeing slaves; establishes prayer and gives zakah; fulfill their promise when they promise; and are patient in poverty and hardship and during battle. Those are the ones who have been true, and it is those who are the righteous. The ayat begins by stating that righteousness is not that you turn your faces toward the east or the west. Turning your face to the east or the west represents rituals. An unrighteous person can do rituals. A righteous person prioritizes righteous behavior above all. God bless you peace
  • The Purpose of Our Lord Asking Questions

    2
    0 Votes
    2 Posts
    56 Views
    R
    Thank you Emre Karaköse for sharing such an insightful and inspiring analysis. The explanation that the questions in the Quran are not meant to probe the unknown, but to confront people with themselves and their choices, is truly meaningful. The examples you give – from the stories of Ibrahim (Abraham), Iblis (Satan) to the questions on the Day of Judgment – ��all show that such questions help clarify the truth, reinforce Allah’s justice, and highlight each person’s personal responsibility.
  • 0 Votes
    3 Posts
    56 Views
    Z
    Beautifully put, Emre. You've articulated a profound reflection on divine design—how perfection must be viewed relative to the purpose and context of creation. The idea that this world is a testing ground, with built-in limitations and dualities, highlights the wisdom behind temporary suffering and joy. And contrasting that with the afterlife, where perfection aligns with eternality and stability, gives deep meaning to our journey through both worlds. May your reflections continue to inspire.
  • Qur’anic ayahs that start with the word "Say"…

    3
    0 Votes
    3 Posts
    70 Views
    Emre_1974trE
    there is one ayah in Quran which is very interesting Say, "O My slaves! Those who have transgressed against themselves, (do) not despair of (the) Mercy (of) Allah. Indeed, Allah forgives the sins all. Indeed He, He (is) the Oft-Forgiving, the Most Merciful.(3953) when you compare to all other ayahs which start with Qul, this one is different. In an old article of mine, I had written the following Response to the Question Regarding Verses 10 and 53 of Surah Az-Zumar… I wanted to share here the answer I gave to those who asked why the phrase "My servants" is used after the expression "Say" in verses 10 and 53 of Surah Az-Zumar. (Az-Zumar 53) Say “O My servants who have transgressed against their own souls! Do not despair of Allah’s mercy! Allah forgives all sins. Indeed, He is the All-Forgiving, the Most Merciful.” We see a similar situation not only in these verses but also in other examples. In this narrative style of the Qur’an, the phrase “Say” is used in the sense of “convey” or “speak on My behalf.” For example Say “Whoever is an enemy to Gabriel—it is he who has brought it down into your heart by Allah’s permission, confirming what came before it, and as guidance and good news for the believers.” (Al-Baqarah 97) As can be seen, the phrase “Say” is followed by “who has brought it down into your heart.” So this is not talking about a conversation or direct speech that the Prophet would say verbatim to people. Here, “Say” does not mean “recite this word-for-word,” because when speaking, the Prophet would naturally say, “Gabriel brought it down into my heart,” or he might say, “Allah wanted me to say/convey this,” and then quote the verse as is. Let’s look at more examples of such verses Al-Anfal 38. Tell those who disbelieve “If they desist, their past will be forgiven. But if they persist, the precedent of those before them will apply.” Al-Jathiyah 14. Tell those who believe “Let them forgive those who do not look forward to the Days of Allah, so that He may recompense people for what they have earned.” Again, the sentence after “Say” here is not meant to be relayed verbatim. Once the verse is recited, the information is already delivered, so there’s no need to repeat it again separately. But as I mentioned, if the Prophet wanted to share this statement during a conversation, he would adapt the expression to fit the context. The intended meaning here is “Convey this to them / Deliver this on My behalf.” From this perspective, it is clear that there is no inconsistency in the use of “Say” in verses 10 and 53 of Surah Az-Zumar either Az-Zumar 53 Say “O My servants who have transgressed against their own souls! Do not despair of Allah’s mercy! Allah forgives all sins. Indeed, He is the All-Forgiving, the Most Merciful.” In these verses as well, it is not that the Prophet is addressing people directly as “My servants,” but rather, it is about conveying the sentence in the appropriate form. Moreover, as mentioned, there’s not even a real need for adjustment—the information is already communicated as is when the verse is recited. In this context, the most accurate translation of such verses should begin with “convey” or “speak on My behalf” rather than simply “say”—and indeed, there are translators who follow this approach Az-Zumar 10 Speak on My behalf “O My believing servants! Be conscious of your Lord. For those who do good in this worldly life, there is goodness. And the earth of Allah is spacious. Indeed, the patient will be given their reward without account.” Az-Zumar 53 Inform them “O My servants who have transgressed against themselves, do not despair of Allah’s mercy. Allah forgives all sins. He is the Forgiving, the Merciful.” Peace and love.
  • Translation of ayah 2:108

    4
    0 Votes
    4 Posts
    61 Views
    G
    Peace tatanka. Fusion is right. The replacement is of the disbelief instead of the belief/faith.; Also the verb is "Yatabadal" not "Yabadal" which clarifies that the disbelief is replacing the belief/faith 2108 "Do you wish to demand of your messenger what was demanded of Moses in the past? Anyone who replaces/chooses disbelief, instead of belief/faith, has truly strayed off the right path. أَم تُريدونَ أَن تَسـَٔلوا رَسولَكُم كَما سُئِلَ موسىٰ مِن قَبلُ وَمَن يَتَبَدَّلِ الكُفرَ بِالإيمٰنِ فَقَد ضَلَّ سَواءَ السَّبيلِ The following context also clarifies this 2109 Many followers of the scripture would rather see you revert to disbelief, now that you have believed. This is due to jealousy on their part, after the truth has become evident to them. You shall pardon them, and leave them alone, until God issues His judgment. God is Omnipotent. وَدَّ كَثيرٌ مِن أَهلِ الكِتٰبِ لَو يَرُدّونَكُم مِن بَعدِ إيمٰنِكُم كُفّارًا حَسَدًا مِن عِندِ أَنفُسِهِم مِن بَعدِ ما تَبَيَّنَ لَهُمُ الحَقُّ فَاعفوا وَاصفَحوا حَتّىٰ يَأتِىَ اللَّهُ بِأَمرِهِ إِنَّ اللَّهَ عَلىٰ كُلِّ شَىءٍ قَديرٌ Like saying for example the Americans have replaced Trump instead of Biden as president, this choice will more likely leave them worse off. GOD bless you. Peace.
  • The false narrative : Changing GOD s religion "true Islam"

    13
    0 Votes
    13 Posts
    288 Views
    FusionF
    On the first part, I could not have explained it better than GL did. The Quran was revealed in Arabic, but that does not mean Umm al Kitab is limited to Arabic. It is a universal repository of truth, and previous scriptures, though revealed in different languages, also originated from it. So in short, divine truth was revealed across time, but the Quran remains the most reliable and complete source today. Arabic was simply the language chosen for the final revelation, ensuring clarity for its first audience, but the message itself transcends language.
  • Modern wars and their narratives : The Ukraine and Russia war.

    3
    0 Votes
    3 Posts
    82 Views
    G
    Peace Fusion. Thank you for your interesting view. I agree with most of what you say.Yes indeed GOD is in overall control and this is part of the trial of the humans. In general, I was looking for views to see as many different takes and see what is the reality in this conflict. I listen to many different news channels and different takes on the issue, for example this Romanian guy does a lot of analysis and here is one of his view about the news of conflict and the latest talks of the ceasefire https//www.youtube.com/watch?v=cqM9s7y6EyM We sometimes do not know many things and we have to stay neutral until we get evidence. The world is strange and unpredictable . Reality is hard to accept by most. GOD bless you. Peace.
  • Relationship with Mother

    4
    0 Votes
    4 Posts
    81 Views
    FusionF
    Peace brother Since you brought this personal matter to a public forum I feel it is okay to respond Otherwise, I would not be comfortable discussing something so personal like your mother’s travel preferences or your family decisions. But since you asked for perspectives I will share my thoughts. You mentioned many things about your mother how she behaves and how she has affected different relationships. But in your own words you are playing two roles. First you say she played a role in your divorce then you say it was your own fault. Then you say she destroys relationships but at the same time you acknowledge that she cares for you and your sister. This is your view but do you truly know the full picture from her side. Have you really tried to see what she feels or are you judging her based on your frustrations. The Quran is clear in its guidance. It does not ask us to judge our parents. It asks us to be kind to them. Whether we agree with them or not is separate. Whether they are right or wrong in their words is separate. But our duty is to do good to them. Surah Luqman says accompany them in this world with kindness. Surah Al Isra says do not even say uff to them. You are in a Quranic forum so I do not need to tell you what you already know. So my advice is simple. There is no harm in making her happy. If she wants a vacation take her. If she wants business class and it is within your means why not. You can take her to Turkey or somewhere nice where she feels special. Life is short. Time will not come back. When they are gone you will regret every moment you did not do something for them. You can either hold on to everything you feel against her or you can just do good and have peace. That is your choice. But as the Quran says you are not asked to argue you are only asked to do good and not argue or raise a voice ever. May Allah guide us all. Peace.
  • 0 Votes
    12 Posts
    260 Views
    WakasW
    Someone asked me this recently. I haven't looked into it in detail but here is what I said. The verses are provided in the link https//misconceptions-about-islam.com/misconception.php?id=47 But could be added https//quran.com/en/al-ahzab/40 If al quran is a guardian/superintendent upon what was already there of al kitab it is unlikely that another scripture will come, and if this is coupled with the additional verse above then the seal of prophets implies final. Of course one could argue it is an interpretation/implication of what is said. Any counter view would have to have evidence.
  • The Story of Iblis – A Test of Obedience, Arrogance, and Envy

    3
    0 Votes
    3 Posts
    98 Views
    Emre_1974trE
    1- "Satan" is a descriptive name given to the wicked among jinn and humans. 2- Jinn are biological beings like humans, but they have some different physical characteristics and abilities. 3- I have explained the topic of destiny and free will in detail in this article https//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9612698.msg444702#msg444702 4- Iblis is a jinn. 5- Iblis is a narcissist, and I have explained this narcissism topic in this articlehttps//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9612021.0
  • 0 Votes
    2 Posts
    85 Views
    Emre_1974trE
    Hi; 1- According to the verses, everyone has innate divine knowledge—signs/verses(ayats)—within them from creation. With these fundamental inner truths and the intellect granted to us, we are responsible for seeking what is right and good. 2- The punishment of societies after the arrival of a messenger refers to their collective destruction. Otherwise, individual punishments and the punishments of the afterlife are continuously occurring. 3- In fact, throughout history, every nation has received warners. However, there have been long periods during which some nations did not receive a new messenger. 4- The verses state that the innate signs/verses/(ayat) within us, along with our intellect, make us accountable. Additionally, societies that have received a sacred book have, in a way, also received a messenger. For example, today, thanks to the internet, the Quran has reached all nations of the world. This increases responsibility, as warnings and guidance are being conveyed. 5- All prophets are a mercy to the worlds. However, the final prophet, Muhammad, brought the last sacred book, the Quran, which has been preserved and passed down to us. Until the Day of Judgment, the Quran will be a mercy to everyone it reaches. 1057 O people, advice has come to you from your Lord and a healing for what is in the chests, and a guidance and a mercy for the believers. 7203 And because you do not bring them a sign, they say "If only you had brought one." Say "I only follow what is inspired to me from my Lord. This is an evidence from your Lord, and a guide and mercy to a people who believe."
  • Why is only monogamy allowed

    2
    0 Votes
    2 Posts
    45 Views
    E
    Monogamy isn't necessarily "everybody's natural inclination," but it has been culturally and socially reinforced as a dominant relationship model in many societies, particularly in the West. Human nature, in terms of relationships and sexual behavior, is complex and can vary significantly from person to person. best sex dolls
  • -=[ Correction/Modification to FM Translation of AlQuraan ]=-

    230
    0 Votes
    230 Posts
    18k Views
    A
    Surah Yaseen holds a profound place in the Qur'an, often regarded as the "heart" of the Qur'an due to its thematic depth and spiritual significance. Many scholars and translators have worked towards providing accurate translations of Surah Yaseen, but there are often nuances that are difficult to capture fully in any language. When discussing or modifying translations, it's essential to remember the importance of accuracy and context, as the Qur'an's words carry layers of meaning that require careful consideration. For a deeper understanding and authentic translation of Surah Yaseen, I recommend visiting this helpful https//suraheyaseen.com/.
  • THE ISLAAMIC RULING ON THE GAY HOMOSEXUAL LGBT AGENDA

    6
    0 Votes
    6 Posts
    152 Views
    B
    The new website address is https//www.islaamicrulingonlgbt.com
  • Sunni Islam is true, but this is a good place to study the Quran

    11
    0 Votes
    11 Posts
    215 Views
    B
    Selam Aleikum, Without Hadith you don’t have a clue when to pray or how. There are some wonderful Hadith, of course not all of them are true but no one is saying that they are all true, apart from maybe wahabis or isis or someone deluded like that. I urge you all to look into it, there is so much information and explanation in the Hadith for so many things. And in the Quran Allah SWTA says to obey Allah and His messenger, so stop lying to yourself that that only means to follow the Quran. No matter how many Quran alone arguments you provide, they can be easily refuted. Some people do it because it’s easier, less rules. I’m not saying il start straight away praying 5 times a day, I might start with juma first because I’ve been on psych drugs for many years and I’m totally worn out, I hope Allah SWTA gives me my strength back. Anyway, think about the judgment day and that hell is in most cases eternal. Thanks Sunni Islaam is false. I challenge you to produce one verse in the Qur'aan where Allah tells us to believe in or follow hadith or the hadith is the sunna of Rasuwl Allah. If you cannot produce a verse you have no claim.
  • What a lottery ticket can make think

    5
    0 Votes
    5 Posts
    50 Views
    Emre_1974trE
    GPT reviewed my writing and expressed its thoughts on the topic as follows "A ticket that wins a quadrillion times in a row has such an improbably low chance that it cannot be explained by probability theory. Therefore, it seems more logical to consider such an event as fate rather than luck. However, this depends entirely on an individual's worldview and their perspective on the concepts of luck and fate. From my point of view, such an event contains an improbability so large that it cannot be left to chance, and it is more meaningful to explain it with "fate." GPT O1
  • Hearts and minds.. Where do the thoughts start?

    5
    0 Votes
    5 Posts
    106 Views
    G
    Peace Marwan-Aed. So A kaffir is only the one who says GOD does not exist? The lesson of Qoran- Al Dhikr- is for those who have a heart- A mind- and is able to hear and witness. Iblis believes in GOD ,what do you call those who pretend to believe and try to hide their "Kufr"? These Then there are those who say, "We believe in God and the Last Day," while they are not believers. وَمِنَ النّاسِ مَن يَقولُ ءامَنّا بِاللَّهِ وَبِاليَومِ الـٔاخِرِ وَما هُم بِمُؤمِنينَ In trying to deceive God and those who believe, they only deceive themselves without perceiving. يُخٰدِعونَ اللَّهَ وَالَّذينَ ءامَنوا وَما يَخدَعونَ إِلّا أَنفُسَهُم وَما يَشعُرونَ In their hearts/ minds there is a disease. Consequently, God augments their disease. They have incurred a painful retribution for their lying. فى قُلوبِهِم مَرَضٌ فَزادَهُمُ اللَّهُ مَرَضًا وَلَهُم عَذابٌ أَليمٌ بِما كانوا يَكذِبونَ When they are told, "Do not commit evil," they say, "But we are righteous!" وَإِذا قيلَ لَهُم لا تُفسِدوا فِى الأَرضِ قالوا إِنَّما نَحنُ مُصلِحونَ In fact, they are evildoers, but they do not perceive. أَلا إِنَّهُم هُمُ المُفسِدونَ وَلٰكِن لا يَشعُرونَ Belief should be complimented by following the straight path. In fact you will find multitudes buy straying-Thinking it is guidance - instead of real guidance- which they call straying-. Well such trade will never prosper nor will they receive any guidance. Let us not confound the truth with falsehood ,nor conceal the truth knowingly when studying the scripture.Let us leave the judgement of people - Kaffirs and believers- to GOD Alone. So it is only others who can be kaffirs while we forget to double check ourselves? Yet we study GOD s scripture!Or should we try to understand what GOD is saying to us? Let us remember that we are accountable to the Lord and should believe also that we are going to meet Him and to Him we will all ultimately return. GOD bless you. Peace.
  • Is it ok to be a Quran alone Sufi?

    6
    0 Votes
    6 Posts
    104 Views
    J
    I’ve posted this around 12 years ago, and wanted to revisit it now. Once again it sounds good to me, but I would need a sheikh or should I take Quran as the sheikh in Quran only Islam. This brings me to question of should we have a leader, like someone who would have the last word on the teachings, like others have an Imam? Thanks Suk your own dck, and that's better than su*cking your Imam's. It may not taste better but worthy it is. Let me put it in good words; perhaps you would concentrate. Your Imam is Ibraheem, and his practices transpire in the Quran. Follow as much as you understand and wait for guidance on which you have limitations. Your guide is Allah and depend on him Alone. Is that a problem for you? if so, go find an imam and keep sucking as much as you are satisfied. On the day of judgment fck him for guiding you to hell. You are like the people of Musa, and they loved an idol like others devoted to it.
  • Is Playing Chess Haram in Islam? If yes, then why?

    11
    0 Votes
    11 Posts
    128 Views
    Emre_1974trE
    Peace Emre_1974tr, If you don't mind, could you give us the source of your conclusion that it's okay to "buy a lottery ticket on New Year's, etc." God bless you peace The necessary explanation regarding alcohol and gambling has already been made in the article I provided the link for, Peace
  • 5 articles first two were Israel being in Southern Arabia and the real Isa

    12
    0 Votes
    12 Posts
    219 Views
    C
    Peace centi50, I agree with you I opposed Brother Pazuzu initially, but I came to realize he was right that the Israelites were not slaves in Egypt. Understanding the truth of the "story" caused me to focus on the wisdom of the story rather than the literal interpretation. It was a valuable lesson that has help me grow spiritually and not just repeat verbatim ancient stories without gaining knowledge, wisdom and introspection from the verses of scripture. God bless peace Salam bro, I was like you too, too much evidence was there that its hard to ignore God bless you bro