Breaking News: The Nasa Tribe's traditional justice system mimics Islamic Laws!

unknownuser

Has anybody in their excitement asked if these laws are actually workable,just and logical? Some of the talibans laws were similar to the literal quran as well.....

Samia

Has anybody in their excitement asked if these laws are actually workable,just and logical? Some of the talibans laws were similar to the literal quran as well.....

You mean their punishment, not their laws. When the punishment is removed from the devine law and applied to a hadith/islamic law, it is no more qur'aanic.

unknownuser

But the taliban would say they are following the quran would they not? Those applying dictionaries/ opinions to intepret the quran are little different in method to those who apply hadith to the quran.....

Samia

But the taliban would say they are following the quran would they not?

Did they?

unknownuser

Of course they claimed to be following the quran,every religious sunni does.....

unknownuser

Of course they claimed to be following the quran,every religious sunni does.....

Actions > Words.

Samia

Of course they claimed to be following the quran,every religious sunni does.....

And that was enough to convince you that they do hmm...I see

agentxxx

And that was enough to convince you that they do hmm...I see

;D

peace

Bigmo

You mean their punishment, not their laws. When the punishment is removed from the devine law and applied to a hadith/islamic law, it is no more qur'aanic.

I do not understand what you mean ???

Samia

I do not understand what you mean ???

I meant capital punishment and lashing are used but not for cases mentioned in the qur'aan. Capital punishment is restricted to "corruption in the earth fasaad fil arDh", but is used for apostasy, fornication, ...etc; and lashing "restricted in the qur'aan for public fornication and spreading false rumors" is applied for not wearing the veil, wearing jeans ;D, not joining in for prayers and many other trivial things

Bigmo

I meant capital punishment and lashing are used but not for cases mentioned in the qur'aan. Capital punishment is restricted to "corruption in the earth fasaad fil arDh", but is used for apostasy, fornication, ...etc; and lashing "restricted in the qur'aan for public fornication and spreading false rumors" is applied for not wearing the veil, wearing jeans ;D, not joining in for prayers and many other trivial things

We are talking about paying Jizya, polygamy, inheritance, women's testimony, cutting hand of thief, etc.