Are Wahabbis the closest to those who follow Quran alone?
-
Peace
Such hadith depicts Muhammad on the status of God's partner I would say ...
And what those wahabis/salafis are believing is no different from that of shia
The quote was taken from this thread by brother Pazuzu
http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=13598.0Wow...those are ridiculous. However, what if the tablet does have that inscribed on it? I mean its in a museum, right? Have they carbon dated it to your knowledge?
Also, the idea of Muhammad being before the big bang...I think thats the Christian idea of Jesus, even Jehovahs Witness. According to the Quran, were we all before the big bang (if that happened). I remember Rashad Khalifa stated that we made a mistake in Heaven by aligning ourselves with Shaitan and then we were given a second chance to redeem, which is on earth. Doesnt the Quran allude to something like that? I dont remember the exact verses.
Wa Salaam
-
Also, the idea of Muhammad being before the big bang...I think thats the Christian idea of Jesus, even Jehovahs Witness.
Yeah, it is probably because the early Christian converts brought along this story with a little a change of the 'character' as they were also undergoing a change of religion.
-
How can people believe all that...
people can believe more than that i will post one shair ( poetry) for those who under stand Urdu,
sitare toot jayinge zameen per zalzala hoga
Muhammad takht per honge adalat per khuda hogaIt means Muhammad position will be higher then Allah ( God forbid) even he will be able to terminate him with out notice as pervez musharraf did in the case of chief justice chudhri. & & &
-
Hmm.
I don't know, wahhabis are definently Bukhari worshipers. The Quran to them is a decor but their definition of tawheed is very similar to amny people who identify with the Quranist thinking. I always wondered about that, but other than their definition of tawheed and shirk, there is absolutely nothing the wahhabis and quranist have in common, nothing. So other than their belief that Muslims are practicing shirk when visiting shrines and seeking intercession of pious saints, I see nothing in common.
I also think that the Quranist definition of shirk differ from the wahhabis. The Quranist do not necessarily see tawassul as "pure" polytheism as the wahhabis do and since the Quranist do not believe in death to an apostate they do not follow that with violence. I still think its a disturbing similarity however hypno, but thats just my 2 cents.
Anyways wahhabis kill the heart, just being around them can kill the heart. They are bad news.
-
How can people believe all that...
people can believe more than that i will post one shair ( poetry) for those who under stand Urdu,
sitare toot jayinge zameen per zalzala hoga
Muhammad takht per honge adalat per khuda hogaIt means Muhammad position will be higher then Allah ( God forbid) even he will be able to terminate him with out notice as pervez musharraf did in the case of chief justice chudhri. & & &
Oh well that's it i've seen it all. Useless sectarians.
-
What I meant is in regards to all sects. Are they the closest to being Quran Alone without following much tradition like others, such as Sunnis and Shias.
Actually, I posted a comment regarding this yesterday but I think there was an error -[ ...I will repeat now
As far as I know, compared to sunnis, I would say wahabis/salafis are hardcore HADITH ELEVATORS. I have posted their challenge to bring one shahih hadith which contradicts quran in this thread. Sunnis (some of them) can still reject few hadiths such as hadiths pertaining to the second coming of Jesus. Please CMIIW peace
As for wahabis/salafis and shias, a direct comparison is not possible since both have their own set of hadiths as authoritative divine revelations in their religion.
-
Well if you think about it most other Muslims follow a load of other crap on top of Hadith, so in a way the Wahabis/Salafis' strict adherence to 'Sahih' hadith alone does kinda make them closer, but obviously the relative 'closeness' is negligible
-
These people sicken me, what sickens me even more is that the American supported Salafists actually control alot of mosques and insitutions, so generally watch what you say around many of these ignorant morons
-
Peace
These people sicken me, what sickens me even more is that the American supported Salafists actually control alot of mosques and insitutions, so generally watch what you say around many of these ignorant morons
I have heard this too, particularly in those undercover videos (mainly UK stuff though).
Peace
-
These people sicken me, what sickens me even more is that the American supported Salafists actually control alot of mosques and insitutions, so generally watch what you say around many of these ignorant morons
This is true according to the recent Newsweek Magazine I read.
-
Oh really? How do you know that?
I know it because alot, well to be honest, I'd say all mosques in the UK are run by people who have the salafi mindset, it's a complex issue and also involves race but basically, the Saudi Arabian royal family took on Wahabbism as they came to power, they export all kinds of books and leaflets exporting their interpretation of Islam, one of the biggest beneficiaries is Pakistan, who in turn prints alot of it's own books.
Then what you have is a loada Muslims in the UK, many of whom have read nothing but the Arabic Qu'ran (i.e. they don't understand what it means) and sport this mentalitly. Look at all the mosques where some of the infamous hate-preachers and bombers have come from and you'll see they're all salafi-run. Other British people can tell you, but the majority of Mosques in the UK are presided over by such individuals.
-
These people sicken me, what sickens me even more is that the American supported Salafists actually control alot of mosques and insitutions, so generally watch what you say around many of these ignorant morons
Oh really? How do you know that?
Besides mosques, departments of islamic studies in most of, if not all, the universities in the UK are sponsored by Saudi Arabia, and they may even choose its Chair or some of the prof/lecturers.
-
Oh really? How do you know that?
Besides mosques, departments of islamic studies in most of, if not all, the universities in the UK are sponsored by Saudi Arabia, and they may even choose its Chair or some of the prof/lecturers.
I take it you've lived in the UK too Samia
Salamun alaikum
If the Wahhabis follow The Quran and so against Shirk , then why would they perpetuate The Stone-Worship in Mecca and continue placing prophet Muhammad besides Allah ?
Peace
That's the thing, they don't just follow the Qur'an