Circumstances requiring a bath ?
-
thanks for the reply Siki. Hmmm, I'm just wondering trying to separate what the Quran is literally saying from what the scholars interpret it as. Meaning I know that this verse typically refers to taking a bath after sexual intercourse etc. but I'm wondering if the Quran actually says that, or if thats how hadith and scholars have interpreted it as? That's really my question here.
I can understand your dilemma, sometimes back i went after these two verses to precisely comprehend what wudu is, and hence tried to dig this particular situation as well, I agree with you that one is not fully satisfied with this explanation, but despite my best efforts this was the max i could grab. I guess , at that particular time, the people were using this particular word (junub)to identify a particular situation, so God chose that particular word to convey what he desired.
siki
-
thanks for the links simple - however in the first two links I saw the meanings of "ghusl" and in the third, I'm not sure what you were trying to indicate which is relevant to the discussion here. Please elaborate, thanks.
-
thanks for the links simple - however in the first two links I saw the meanings of "ghusl" and in the third, I'm not sure what you were trying to indicate which is relevant to the discussion here. Please elaborate, thanks.
Salaams dbrowser,
Some of the possible meanings;
A man ,who compresses his wife
much.(so she is washed of being excited- maybe)
The evil eye is a truth; so when ye are
asked to wash, wash yeMay God cleanse
thee from thy sin.(cleansing of sin)
cleanse Thou me from sins.
His face is beautiful,
with no fat, or fatness, upon it(clean from fat in the face)
third link;
His peech, or language, is
devoid of nice, or subtile, expressions or allusions(may be the language hasn't been washed or something)
No washing mentioned in the quran but one does it because its to everybodies benefit...........i think.
peace
God Bless.
-
Ghusul is a very common word, and we use it in Urdu as well , It means dipping, or taking some thing through some media, like water , acid, any chemical etc, for a deliberate purpose. when no media is mentioned , it is always taken for granted that the media is water, and when even no particular part is mentioned and the subject is human (body) It is for sure understood as a whole body bath with water.
siki
-
Yes you are right in urdu we do use the it to mean washing , but is that what the word meant in the quran originally? from the context , the usage of the word in the quran.
like we all know a masjid is a building , salaat is the 5 daily prayers so and so and so..........God Bless All.
-
We are under obligation from others that we should take bath when we hear them say about us "He is so smelly; why doesn't he take a bath and come!" So, when we ourselves feel we are very nasty, we feel obliged to take bath; and also when we feel dead tired after our hectic activity but still we have some good works to attend to, we need to refresh ourselves so that we shall not be offensive looking in the company of others.
-
DrAfzal, SIki,
While I know that everyone can interpret, according to their own logic and rationale what "an obligation to take a bath" means, and I also know what tradition dictates to us about this situation, I was just wondering if the Quran itself mentions when exactly you are under obligation. How do Quran aloners follow this ayat? Surely it can't be left upto everyone's individual interpretation, which can be different.
-
DrAfzal, SIki,
While I know that everyone can interpret, according to their own logic and rationale what "an obligation to take a bath" means, and I also know what tradition dictates to us about this situation, I was just wondering if the Quran itself mentions when exactly you are under obligation. How do Quran aloners follow this ayat? Surely it can't be left upto everyone's individual interpretation, which can be different.
I think your querry is very valid, and my answer is , NO, it does not, or may be NOT that i know of.
siki
-
As of right now I follow the mainstream rules of what "obligation to take a bath" means, aka after sexual intercourse etc.
But what do Quran-aloners follow? What does Allah mean by "an obligation to take a bath" according to the Quran. I'd like to see some answers based on the Quran if possible, thanks guys. I looked and looked and looked, and couldn't find it anywhere. -
I was hoping that someone would answer my question here. To a Quran aloner, what are the "circumstances" requiring a bath in this verse? I have not found the answer in the Quran yet, so I follow tradition, but would like to know where the answer to this particular question is in the Quran. Under what circumstances do Quran aloners consider it necessary to take a bath before praying?
-
I have already posted, that janaba is the state which people then understood as , A state after intercourse which necessitates taking a bath, when the Quran was revealed people understood that meaning so that is why the language of the quran used that word, and that is why even the dictionaries mention that to be as one of the meaning. i think that should be enough. On the other hand if you are looking that quran should define every word of Arabic that it uses, I guess you would be disappointed.
siki
-
Salaams All,
Here is its usage also;
Waallatheena ijtanaboo alttaghootaan yaAAbudooha waanaboo ila Allahilahumu albushra fabashshir AAibadi
Tahir ul Qadri
Yousuf Ali Those who eschew Evil,- and fall not into its worship,- and turn to Allah (in repentance),- for them is Good News so announce the Good News to My Servants,Various meanings of Janaba, the actual word in the ayah 56 is JUNUBAN- I think
http//www.studyquran.org/LaneLexicon/Volume2/00000103.pdf
http//www.studyquran.org/LaneLexicon/Volume2/00000104.pdf
I wouldn?t say it is a wash after sex and that is it , its actually recognising and doing away with anything harmful to you or others. ? but that is my understanding.
Look around at the people who don't take a bath after sex in cold climates, how is it bad for them- i would have thought a bath after a hard hot day is very beneficial or when ever you are foul.
Salaams All.