Skip to content
  • Categories
  • Recent
  • Users
Skins
  • Light
  • Brite
  • Cerulean
  • Cosmo
  • Flatly
  • Journal
  • Litera
  • Lumen
  • Lux
  • Materia
  • Minty
  • Morph
  • Pulse
  • Sandstone
  • Simplex
  • Sketchy
  • Spacelab
  • United
  • Yeti
  • Zephyr
  • Dark
  • Cyborg
  • Darkly
  • Quartz
  • Slate
  • Solar
  • Superhero
  • Vapor

  • Default (No Skin)
  • No Skin
Collapse
Free Minds Forum Icon
  1. Home
  2. General Issues / Questions
  3. General Issues / Questions
  4. Do we need books to believe in God?

Do we need books to believe in God?

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved General Issues / Questions
180 Posts 40 Posters 9.8k Views
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • B Offline
    B Offline
    Bahman
    wrote on last edited by
    #35

    From this what I learn from you is unless one who is lucky enough to know Arabic, Quran is out of bounds to them.

    Pleas read this tread

    I am not sure why Rashad used Mathematical for his discovery, general public mathematic means calculating using number for formula and equation, a primary school student cn understand it easily which is pure number interlocked to each other and there is no other way to fit unless changing understanding Interlock is very simple and simplest one is jig saw puzzle which there is only one way for fitting each peace and no probability, which is interlock, I call Miracle
    Numerical Textual Security Interlocking System

    And then, you have to be well-versed in Arabic to get anywhere near Quran. Am I right?

    For meaning you are and yet you may be another translation differing from others, I prefer to use translation for reading but for witnessing God's design of text and how is interlocked knowing alphabet is enough, it can bee witnessed even by one letter Q which have same shape as English or simplest one
    is this one

    I believe unless one ponders, reminisces, reflects and strive to rehearse every single ayat with sense of justification and purity at heart alone can even touch Quran. If you really need to know the ayats ask for it I will produce them.

    God made it easy to understand and we should stay away from making it difficult, God is only teacher of Quran , in older time our parents were illiterate and school ans cholar were teaching words of God in all religions, now we have proof for Quran and this screen , slowly those school get empty unless forcing people to attend, this screen is best source for study and no scholar can replace it. There would not be paid job as scholar for explaining God's words as God warned prophet is not his duty to explain.

    Now I want the ayat from you that says Quran is meant only for Arabic pundits and scholars; and meant only for mathematicians with sound knowledge in interlock patterns.

    Not such verse exist and in above I have explained it that we do not need Mathematic jus 4 arithmetic functions -+/* little patience and knowing how interlock works in text like Q in chapter 50

    I am independent learner of Quran without being tainted by mullahs and madrasahs. I am the one who disengaged from the parental pseudo religion called Islam.

    Masha Allah, that is great and you are right but you need water in your tank and you need proof for Quran other way it is another scripture like the previous one.
    God bless you for your clear path.

    I do not want to be blind. Show me a plain ayat that says about interlock patterns and sound Arabic knowledge is essential to prove this Quran is from Allah. Before that I will show you the verse how to testify that this is from Allah and not from man.

    I am not rejecting Text Miracle of Quran in its time and even now for those like you know good Arabic.
    Writting such rhymes and deepness in meaning which loose it in translation could not be work of prophet that only knew ABJAD for his business. But as time change and people can imitate it then God reveals new Miracle challenging the knowledge of human in that Era, in Moses time magics were populate and and may may claim their work is divine. so God supported Moses with best as Miracle and opening sea which was using sight,in Jesus time medication and recovering sick people was populate and God supported the only prophet with God's soul with miraclouse rev covering, In time of prophet Mohammed already Bible were produced and learning reading and writing poems were populate. Then God supported prophet with ever best rhyme in Arabic language which may they understand it.
    But god knows future and knew human will discover this screen and his knowledge reach to a point that imitate His work in Quran like this
    http//suralikeit.com
    2-106
    When we abrogate any miracle, or cause it to be forgotten, we produce a better miracle, or at least an equal one. Do you not recognize the fact that God is Omnipotent?
    The excellency an deepness of Arabic Quran can not be seen by 7 billions poeple as they do not know Arabic.

    My Arabic is not enough to find if that writing has same value as Quran has but I reject it because do not have same protection with letters and numbers.

    we produce a better miracle

    Now we are at Hi Tech era and all our destine are based on numbers.
    God clearly say
    We do not see direct verses in Quran referring to count numbers in Quran but

    ....He is fully aware of what they have. He has counted the numbers of all things.7228

    When God say all things from DNA to unverses how we can exclude Quran which is His DESIGN
    ,
    Then is authored

    I swear by the positions of the stars. This is an oath, if you only knew, that is awesome.*
    This is an honorable Quran. In a protected book. None can grasp it except the sincere.*A revelation from the Lord of the universe.5870-85
    I have posted verses that call those i INITIALS secret and proof for book.

    482
    Do they not then reflect on the verses of Quran? And if it were from any other than Allah, they would have found in it many a discrepancy.
    Prove with your ayat now.
    Do they not then meditate on the Quran? And if it were from any other than Allah, they would have found in it many a discrepancy.
    I think it is your turn now.

    dis?crep?an?cy
    /diskrepns/
    Noun
    A lack of compatibility or similarity between two or more facts.
    Synonyms
    variance - difference - disagreement - contradiction

    I have not claimed for any discrepancy but manipulation which is 9128-129
    peace

    1 Reply Last reply
    0
    • B Offline
      B Offline
      Bahman
      wrote on last edited by
      #36

      Where is the need for you to jump from 262 to 2282 irrelevantly? Clearly you are out of context here.

      peace
      Oldness, low visions mistake sorry mean 262 )

      I am not accusing! I just want you to justify reason why you removed Allah's Ayats in sura Tauba and destroyed Quran thereby totally.

      Rashad has removed and has explained why? and I accept as is rejected in hundred cases and finally in final discovery of whole book which do not function with those verses
      http//purified-scripture.com/

      There you are going very personal showing your intolerance as you grow weaker in your defence.

      It is not personal when you added to your name, the reason iam asking is if your PHD has any link with theology and Quarn study .

      You call the verses of Allah as satanic verses because satan did not like those 2 verses? How do you call your Quran as purified while you fell prostrated to the likes and dislikes of satan; and when you abide by his order and removed the said verses?

      You are repeating same question in many different ways and such discussion could be tiring and no ending one if you do not read material I post and pinpoint the flaw .

      Not the Satanic Quran of Rashad! I am not running away; it seems your wits are running out of your time. I am following my Quran which has not been adulterated by satan.

      Expecting more valuable and reasonable response than this for question, you should come with some answere which of those Quran are the right copy of burnt one. ?
      Peace

      1 Reply Last reply
      0
      • B Offline
        B Offline
        Bigmo
        wrote on last edited by
        #37

        Peace everybody.
        I have tried to retire from this forum few times but still I am here )
        I have been enough here and is time to stay away from any discussion after this topic.

        Do we need books to believe in God?

        Either way yes or no please explain why?

        Peace.

        I think people mostly believe in scriptures because they already believe in its message. Unless you already believe in God than you would believe in scriptures. Scriptures confirms what we believe. But to understand the deen you need scriptures. After all God has many signs like the creation f the universe and also the creation of human beings and animals. Fate and destiny and the life itself are God's signs. Many believers in the Muhbammedan message believed in the message before most verses of the Quran did not come down yet. Moses had his own signs and so did Jesus. The Quran is a sign after all but as a scriptures its also a guidance towards the deen. The Quran reminds Muhammad about the stories of the past prophets as a further guidance. So scriptures guide us towards the deen but faith is internal.

        1 Reply Last reply
        0
        • B Offline
          B Offline
          Bahman
          wrote on last edited by
          #38

          ......................
          7521 and leave the afterlife

          7431
          Peace DR Eid Manipulator ,this id fits your work when like lock picker open other poeple lock and now you use your knowledge and all tools available for fiting my name or other name inot locked design by God.
          Nothing wrong with, it shows your ability and your knowledge of using tools available this this era
          in Satanic way to confuse the truth seekers, but your darkened minds has vieled you understanding that prophet Mohammed did not had your knowledge of computer and calculating when he scribes Quran
          You have posted many times this or other manipulated patterns.
          Stop such manipulation of God's Miracle and this is a warning, USE YOUR KNOWLEDGE AND DESIGN YOUR OWN PHRASE WITH 4 WORDS AND MEANINGFUL AND THE SHOW THE EMBEDDED COUNTS.
          BUT REMEMBER EVEN YOU DO THAT THEN IS ANOTHER PROOF THAT QURAN WAS REVEALED TO PROPHET WHICH DID NOT PROCESS PHD IN MATH AND ACCESS TO ALL TOOLS>
          PRODUCE ONE LIKE IT WITHOUT COMPUTER BY PEN AN PAPER
          STOP MANIPULATION AN SABOTAGING THIS TOPIC
          Peace

          1 Reply Last reply
          0
          • B Offline
            B Offline
            Bahman
            wrote on last edited by
            #39

            I am sorry I have not offended any one intentionally but my offence is against shaitan. Rashad just fell a prey to satan by a thread from him. Allah might forgive Rashad; Allah is the only judge; we do not judge here. We all seek forgiveness to ourselves and others. Had he lived today he might have undone the damage he had caused to Quran. The killers of Dr Rashad Khalifa will be in hell for sure for they took the judgment in their hands belying that Allah is the only Judge. Thus the killers are the disbelievers in Allah and the Last Day. I am sorry. I did not mean to demean anybody. I am here to discuss and exchange my view points.

            I pray for you; you pray for me.

            Salam, Bahman

            drfazl

            Peace
            You should clear your mind from your learning and have straight path on solid base, you should avoid talking with 2 sides of the mouth, in one way you write
            "I am sorry I have not offended any one intentionally"
            and then you claim again
            "Rashad just fell a prey to satan by a thread from him."
            and then again
            "I am sorry. I did not mean to demean anybody."
            Which one is right, make your mind please and do not be confused.
            Peace

            1 Reply Last reply
            0
            • B Offline
              B Offline
              Bahman
              wrote on last edited by
              #40

              I think people mostly believe in scriptures because they already believe in its message.

              I agree with you as the majority are in this category

              Unless you already believe in God than you would believe in scriptures.

              Not necessary to believe in book for believing in God, I personally from age of 50-60 believeing in Creation but no scripture as they do not match and contradict to each other and that causing big problem

              Scriptures confirms what we believe.

              Minus the messages belongs to time and location.

              But to understand the deen you need scriptures

              All God needs to follow straight path, 262.
              right?eous
              /rCHs/
              Adjective
              (of a person or conduct) Morally right or justifiable; virtuous.
              Perfectly wonderful; fine and genuine.
              Synonyms
              just - right - upright - rightful - fair - honest
              I have been as far as i could before believing in God , and any body can be , there are many atheist that have this qualification.
              Now since 50 i believed in God and rejecting that creation is due to chemical formation and big bang.
              but resurrection was not clear for me even accepting that nothing goes to null which after witnessing Miracle i believe in it as our craetor says.

              After all God has many signs like the creation f the universe and also the creation of human beings and animals. Fate and destiny and the life itself are God's signs. Many believers in the Muhbammedan message believed in the message before most verses of the Quran did not come down yet. Moses had his own signs and so did Jesus.
              The Quran is a sign after all but as a scriptures its also a guidance towards the deen.
              The Quran reminds Muhammad about the stories of the past prophets as a further guidance. So scriptures guide us towards the deen but faith is internal.

              Why not older scripture, Quran is completion of older scripture and verifying those, how a book can claim is completion and verification hence without Miracle is in same level as older when most part of it is repeating same messages. ?

              Peace

              1 Reply Last reply
              0
              • N Offline
                N Offline
                Noon_waalqalami
                wrote on last edited by
                #41

                Stop such manipulation of God's Miracle and this is a warning

                Simple combinations no need for special tools exposes what numerologist do everyday.
                Flip, flip, flip, etc., until multiples found then report to the ignorant and claim it's miracle.

                http//www.mathsisfun.com/combinatorics/combinations-permutations-calculator.html

                This nineteen nonsense code, interlock, blah blah blah is some of the dumbest invented.

                Peace

                1 Reply Last reply
                0
                • B Offline
                  B Offline
                  Bahman
                  wrote on last edited by
                  #42

                  Simple combinations no need for special tools exposes what numerologist do everyday.
                  Flip, flip, flip, etc., until multiples found then report to the ignorant and claim it's miracle.

                  http//www.mathsisfun.com/combinatorics/combinations-permutations-calculator.html

                  This nineteen nonsense code, interlock, blah blah blah is some of the dumbest invented.

                  Peace

                  7431 )
                  You mean Prophet Mohammed had Mathematics PHD like you and doing flip flop the words for 23 years using tools and programms you offerhad access to your offered site ? rotfl

                  Where you got your Phd and How )

                  If using 10 letters producing a phrase with beautiful meaning by 4 words then make simpler for you.

                  Use 3 letters and designe for words with such meaningful meaning multiple of 19

                  PRODUCE ONE LIKE IT WITHOUT COMPUTER BY PEN AN PAPER

                  Or use computer too then i consider your claims. )

                  Don't waste time of readers please.

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  0
                  • N Offline
                    N Offline
                    Noon_waalqalami
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #43

                    doing flip flop the words for 23 years using tools and programms you offerhad access to your offered site ?

                    You don't understand the simplest of things; I'm not doing anything special only showing what you are doing.

                    If using 10 letters producing a phrase with beautiful meaning by 4 words then make simpler for you.

                    It is really simple, "you write any 4 word 19 letter phrase in Arabic" post it here, we'll use your same method.

                    1 Reply Last reply
                    0
                    • B Offline
                      B Offline
                      Bahman
                      wrote on last edited by
                      #44

                      It is really simple, "you write any 4 word 19 letter phrase in Arabic" post it here, we'll use your same method.

                      My Arabic is not enough to do so, you claim then do all show.
                      What you mean by these abbreviation , write in detail

                      w l tl wgv lgv lgv-added

                      Try this then do your own show.

                      301
                      1305
                      1301
                      130305

                      30,113,051,301,130,305=
                      19x 1584897436901595

                      30,113,051,301,130,3051584897436901595=
                      7x.........
                      reading in Arabic from right to left
                      130305 1305 1305 301

                      53030113015301130,
                      Total GV
                      165,53030113015301130,12
                      7x.........
                      total gv in text > total words > total letters >letter I has 2 letters >letters Gv >total gv >word 2 ?.
                      165 4,12,1 2 301 31 2 3 1305 36 3 3 1301 32 4 4 130305 66
                      7x.........

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      0
                      • N Offline
                        N Offline
                        Noon_waalqalami
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #45

                        What you mean by these abbreviation , write in detail

                        w l tl wgv lgv lgv-added

                        Was this not obvious?

                        in name BaHMaN
                        26040 254050 13020084050 13020081040

                        w l tl wgv lgv lgv-added
                        1 3 3 102 26040 2 62 102
                        2 4 7 97 254050 104 109 149 199
                        3 6 13 329 13020084050 200 230 430 438 478 528
                        4 6 19 289 13020081040 529 559 759 767 777 817

                        Example...
                        1 3 3 102 26040 2 62 102

                        w=word# 1
                        l=letters 3
                        tl=total letters 3
                        wgv=102
                        lgv=26040
                        lgv-added=2 62 102

                        Try this then do your own show.

                        Show same consistent pattern for all 59 verses?

                        w lts chv text
                        4 19 11
                        4 19 14
                        4 19 1216
                        4 19 205
                        4 19 2023
                        4 19 234
                        4 19 2336
                        4 19 2654
                        4 19 2679
                        4 19 2696
                        4 19 2699
                        4 19 26114
                        4 19 26192
                        4 19 26212
                        4 19 3740
                        4 19 3752
                        4 19 3774
                        4 19 3780
                        4 19 3781
                        4 19 3796
                        4 19 37103
                        4 19 37111
                        4 19 37121
                        4 19 37123
                        4 19 37128
                        4 19 37131
                        4 19 37132
                        4 19 37141
                        4 19 37142
                        4 19 37160
                        4 19 3837
                        4 19 4054
                        4 19 412
                        4 19 4314
                        4 19 4427
                        4 19 483
                        4 19 5121
                        4 19 5134
                        4 19 5341
                        4 19 5347
                        4 19 5359
                        4 19 5617
                        4 19 5683
                        4 19 5687
                        4 19 6950
                        4 19 708
                        4 19 7312
                        4 19 7618
                        4 19 7744
                        4 19 8040
                        4 19 8042
                        4 19 8328
                        4 19 8330
                        4 19 8333
                        4 19 848
                        4 19 849
                        4 19 8712
                        4 19 8927
                        4 19 1071

                        Peace

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        0
                        • B Offline
                          B Offline
                          Bahman
                          wrote on last edited by
                          #46

                          Was this not obvious?

                          Example...
                          1 3 3 102 26040 2 62 102

                          w=word# 1
                          l=letters 3
                          tl=total letters 3
                          wgv=102
                          lgv=26040
                          lgv-added=2 62 102 ?

                          peace )
                          lgv-added=2 62 102 ?
                          what is 62

                          Show same consistent pattern for all 59 verses?

                          w lts chv text
                          4 19 11
                          ....

                          I asked you write your own text in Arabic with 4 words and 19 letters then do your show.
                          Thank you for your search if you are right there are 112 unnumbered Bsm 4 w 19 l plus another 59 numbered verses having 4 w and 19 l = 171 =19x9 total of all verses having same property as first verse. ! may be something more into it.
                          Do you think this is coincidence ? )
                          Do you claim that all those 58 verses can be manipulated as you did with first one and have same patterns already you have.?
                          Peace
                          PS YOUR OWN TEXT NOT QURAN.

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          0
                          • B Offline
                            B Offline
                            Bahman
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #47

                            peace )
                            lgv-added=2 62 102 ?
                            what is 62
                            I asked you write your own text in Arabic with 4 words and 19 letters then do your show.
                            Thank you for your search if you are right there are 112 unnumbered Bsm 4 w 19 l plus another 59 numbered verses having 4 w and 19 l = 171 =19x9 total of all verses having same property as first verse. ! may be something more into it.
                            Do you think this is coincidence ? )
                            Do you claim that all those 58 verses can be manipulated as you did with first one and have same patterns already you have.?
                            Peace
                            PS YOUR OWN TEXT NOT QURAN.

                            There are ONLY 152 ( 19x verses ending NUN with 4 words and 19 letters in Quran
                            God blesses Eid AbdAllah showing him His creation of Quran may he understand.
                            This is not first time that in middle of his critics new fact appears .
                            One of his most complicated and amazing discovery has been following which the file link is broken .

                            Fact 7
                            My finding for adding 3 digits 666 concluded
                            Dr.Eid Abdallah discovery that table after adding 2 verses convert any random 3 , 21, 39 ...by adding 18 digits each time to infinite;
                            Any figure with having digits divisible by 18 with reminder 3 in either side of table converts to multiple of 19

                            Table 23
                            Peace )
                            Please use explorer

                            1 Reply Last reply
                            0
                            • B Offline
                              B Offline
                              Bahman
                              wrote on last edited by
                              #48

                              There are ONLY 152 (19x verses ending NUN with 4 words and 19 letters in Quran
                              God blesses Eid AbdAllah showing him His creation of Quran may he understand.
                              This is not first time that in middle of his critics new fact appears .
                              One of his most complicated and amazing discovery has been following which the file link is broken .

                              Fact 7
                              My finding for adding 3 digits 666 concluded
                              Dr.Eid Abdallah discovery that table after adding 2 verses convert any random 3 , 21, 39 ...by adding 18 digits each time to infinite;
                              Any figure with having digits divisible by 18 with reminder 3 in either side of table converts to multiple of 19

                              Table 23
                              Peace
                              Please use explorer

                              Peace everybody,
                              I started this topic for simple answer and reason why we should believe in books or not, but as usual the discussion took off the topic when Dr.Fazi claimed for his understand of initials A LM and then as usual Dr.Eid Abdallh as usual poured all kinds of numbers, but finally if Satan schemes God knows best and you witness how the claim are in benefit of God's Miracle.

                              Thsi forum has very good search engine and it can be used to post older discussions by a line of url .
                              For example using my name in first verse is not knew and just entering part of claim we find more pages about it.
                              http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=16958.msg293326#msg293326
                              http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9603635.msg295531#msg295531
                              http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9603452.msg292706#msg292706
                              http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=10044.msg232651#msg232651

                              Quote from NunHolidayPseudoEidRex on December 20, 2009, 190526

                              The last one gives warning Malvare ahead

                              IF any moderator reading this try it and may a virus nesting in forum!!!!!
                              Hope this helps to keep this topic clean.
                              Peace

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              0
                              • N Offline
                                N Offline
                                Noon_waalqalami
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #49

                                lgv-added=2 62 102 ?
                                what is 62

                                26040
                                (2) (2+60=62) (2+60+40=102)
                                thus 2 62 102

                                I asked you write your own text in Arabic with 4 words and 19 letters then do your show.

                                You claim there is code thus burden is on the claimant.

                                Try to reproduce this 4 word 19 letter text/pattern...
                                indeed we gave you to drink it the wine traces
                                150 16010010501204065 13060040200 1500 = 19 x ...
                                2+10+5+2 = 19 x 1
                                2 10 5 2 = 19 x 1108
                                2 1 10 2 5 3 2 4 = 19 x 11106596
                                2 1 12 2 17 3 19 4 = 19 x 1111693326
                                3 1 15 2 23 3 29 4 = 19 x 1639591226
                                51 1 293 2 871 3 501 4 = 19 x 26910173007106
                                51 1 344 2 1215 3 1716 4 = 19 x 2691285327121956

                                Do you think this is coincidence ?

                                Not coincidence each time you come across non-multiple you skip or add/delete to make multiple.

                                Do you claim that all those 58 verses can be manipulated as you did with first one and have same patterns already you have.?

                                No, that is what you have to show is a consistent pattern and apply to every verse.
                                That is code; input variables in consistent exact sequence each time output multiple.

                                Peace

                                1 Reply Last reply
                                0
                                • B Offline
                                  B Offline
                                  Bahman
                                  wrote on last edited by
                                  #50

                                  26040
                                  (2) (2+60=62) (2+60+40=102)
                                  thus 2 62 102

                                  You claim there is code thus burden is on the claimant.

                                  Try to reproduce this 4 word 19 letter text/pattern...
                                  indeed we gave you to drink it the wine traces
                                  150 16010010501204065 13060040200 1500 = 19 x ...
                                  2+10+5+2 = 19 x 1
                                  2 10 5 2 = 19 x 1108
                                  2 1 10 2 5 3 2 4 = 19 x 11106596
                                  2 1 12 2 17 3 19 4 = 19 x 1111693326
                                  3 1 15 2 23 3 29 4 = 19 x 1639591226
                                  51 1 293 2 871 3 501 4 = 19 x 26910173007106
                                  51 1 344 2 1215 3 1716 4 = 19 x 2691285327121956

                                  Not coincidence each time you come across non-multiple you skip or add/delete to make multiple.

                                  No, that is what you have to show is a consistent pattern and apply to every verse.
                                  That is code; input variables in consistent exact sequence each time output multiple.

                                  Peace

                                  you have posted 5 times and now 6th .
                                  You are proud of your work when using computer and programs to find words that fit into your cumulation and such forcing has caused such micky mouse design with none sense meaning.
                                  color=red] indeed we gave you to drink it the wine traces

                                  indeed we gave you to drink it the wine traces !!!c

                                  I let those that know good Arabic check it and those that are good in English translate it.

                                  How ever even you make a good text you have used computer to adjust it to your need. and certainly your work is a DESIGN to function with code 19 .
                                  If yours is design then why those discoveries are not considered same as your work without using computer.?

                                  For consistency i have shown how chapters with same patterns could be categorized into groups, i did not had time to do whole book as ima not very good like you for these kinds of calc. you may complete it ;D

                                  Nothing is coincidence even our presence on this screen and discussing such issues.

                                  Regardless proof for book have it or do not have it the question is the topic.

                                  We may stop this calc and take to the place which has been pondered many times and let others share their comments, you very welcome for your input but just topic please.
                                  Thank you for your effort and causing some new thing to be discovered by you as i have explained in previous posts
                                  Peace

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  0
                                  • E Offline
                                    E Offline
                                    easternqibla
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #51

                                    Returning to the original question

                                    Do we need books to believe in God?

                                    Either way yes or no please explain why?

                                    I posted here before, but remembered this quotation

                                    Narrated Jabir bin 'Abd Allah "We were with the Prophet when a Companion brought in a fledgling which he had caught, and one of the parent birds came and threw itself into the hands of him who had taken its young.

                                    I saw men's faces full of wonderment, and the Prophet said
                                    'Do ye wonder at this bird? Ye have taken its young, and it hath thrown itself down in merciful tenderness unto its young. Yet I swear by God, your Lord is more merciful unto you than is this bird unto its fledgling.'

                                    And he told the man to put back the young bird where he had found it."

                                    (Martin Lings, Muhammad His Life Based on the Earliest Sources, p. 20
                                    http//www.quranclub.net/2009/11/fledgling.html

                                    'Yet I swear by God, your Lord is more merciful unto you than is this bird unto its fledgling' Did the parent bird tweet instructions to its fledgling? Did it write anything in a book to its fledgling? So too with Allah.

                                    It's interesting, as an Orthodox Christian, I have read stuff Muslims have written against God becoming incarnate, and agree with what they say fully, in no way twisting things. It's just that our Christian terminology is somewhat loose (although various long councils have explained our beliefs more fully) that is why I can read the Quran and agree with it.

                                    Jesus is the Word bestowed on Mary, the Word which took flesh from her. Therefore we do not need words or books to listen to or to learn from if we can find the Word-in-humanity inside us.

                                    Simply really,

                                    Richard

                                    1 Reply Last reply
                                    0
                                    • B Offline
                                      B Offline
                                      Bahman
                                      wrote on last edited by
                                      #52

                                      Therefore we do not need words or books to listen to or to learn from if we can find the Word-in-humanity inside us.
                                      Simply really,
                                      Richard

                                      Peace
                                      Agree but when we promote existence of God on this screen then we need proof for such claim.
                                      My source for such proof is Quran.
                                      Peace

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      0
                                      • E Offline
                                        E Offline
                                        easternqibla
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #53

                                        Peace
                                        Agree but when we promote existence of God on this screen then we need proof for such claim.
                                        My source for such proof is Quran.
                                        Peace

                                        Depends on your interpretation of Jesus being the Word bestowed on Mary. Do we read the Quran alone (or with hadith) to try to understand it, or assume the same understanding as the Christian Ethiopian King to whom these verses were quoted?
                                        peace
                                        Richard

                                        1 Reply Last reply
                                        0
                                        • B Offline
                                          B Offline
                                          Bahman
                                          wrote on last edited by
                                          #54

                                          Depends on your interpretation of Jesus being the Word bestowed on Mary. Do we read the Quran alone (or with hadith) to try to understand it, or assume the same understanding as the Christian Ethiopian King to whom these verses were quoted?
                                          peace
                                          Richard

                                          Peace
                                          Over hundreds religions with their book and by many interpolations which has caused such divisions and sub divisions and causing such situation because each of us raise with our parents belief and we follow it blindly regardless our knowledge and education, but if we leave away the stories and hadith all of those claim the messages are for guiding human to straight path.
                                          In time of revealing those books up to few century when education started to be polpulare not only for rich and high level people more and more poeple could do their own study and search and now by such granted screen we can find truth in thousand of seconds when such search may was taking days, weeks even year time.

                                          Due to corruption in all religions the new generation re running away from religions and many of them are interested to believe in God without any book and such thing is recorded in Quran too.
                                          262

                                          Scholars and clergies sr till can do their paid job to promote their idols abusing name of God and his messages for those that they eyes are veiled and using books for n bloodshed , power and greed.

                                          Times go fast and in near future nobody goe to school to learn messages of God as God Alone is only TEACHER of his messages, Mufti bliion incorporated religions centers and school would be abandoned by people, as you said God is in humanity and all creation and anybody any time without any media man and building can meditate with his own God and no BOOK.

                                          Peace

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          0
                                          Reply
                                          • Reply as topic
                                          Log in to reply
                                          • Oldest to Newest
                                          • Newest to Oldest
                                          • Most Votes


                                          • Login

                                          • Don't have an account? Register

                                          • Login or register to search.
                                          • First post
                                            Last post
                                          0
                                          • Categories
                                          • Recent
                                          • Users