Core values.
-
What is your stand on these core values in Islam
- Promiscuity
- Homophilia
- Intoxicants
- Criminality
And also
5) 19
6) HadithAnd is there any particular scholar you associate with your choices?
Peace Be With You.
1 disgusting and degenerate behavior that should be punished with severe lashings. 2 likewise, though it only becomes a problem when people demand it be recognized as legitimate (and no punishment is ascribed for it). 3 prohibited. As for 1667, that verse is clearly speaking to the disbelievers. 4 pretty broad.
-
"Homosexuality can not be punished as its nobody's concern."
This is even worse than Farouk A Peru.
Ofcourse if we have people in our society, that obsesses with sex on public toilets, to the offense of normal people. you know they do not understand a decent society, and cannot go around your children.
That is my final word in that.
Peace Be With You.
Then why start a thread then? You bring no evidence from the Quran.
-
Ok.
Some comments from me. Sodom and Gomorrah was destroyed. Understanding satanic mindset a bit, they worship idols, and the bigger idol, is ofcourse the most powerful. That means they are run by their fears. The biggest fear would ofcourse be death-penality. God DESTROYED Sodom and Gomorrah. Isn?t that a "stipulation" of punishment enough? If gays hear God destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah, is not God the bigger beast and who runs them? And so to their own good ofcourse.
So that is how I feel about it, and why there should be death-penality for homophilia.
I think also the reply there on alcohol is a bit odd. Godconsciousness protects against satan. Alcohol removes one from godconsciousness. Alcohol is ofcourse forbidden.
Criminality in general, transgression/sin, is not a too wide subject, and can generally be answered.
So you say no "scholar" is promoted here, but yet present a uniform answer for "most people here". Who wrote these things? Should we say "the free-minds scholars"?
Peace Be With You.
Is this guy for real? A religious Trollolol perhaps?
-
Ok.
Some comments from me. Sodom and Gomorrah was destroyed. Understanding satanic mindset a bit, they worship idols, and the bigger idol, is ofcourse the most powerful. That means they are run by their fears. The biggest fear would ofcourse be death-penality. God DESTROYED Sodom and Gomorrah. Isn?t that a "stipulation" of punishment enough? If gays hear God destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah, is not God the bigger beast and who runs them? And so to their own good ofcourse.
So that is how I feel about it, and why there should be death-penality for homophilia.
Note that it was God who punished in the example you gave, not humans.
And in your last sentence you said "feel". That is very different from "as per Quran". Further, the law of equivalence is very clear in Quran. To do as you propose would violate it.
So you say no "scholar" is promoted here, but yet present a uniform answer for "most people here".
The two are not mutually exclusive. Feel free to read and explore the forum and make up your own mind.
-
What is your stand on these core values in Islam
- Promiscuity-bad for society
- Homophilia -no opinion
- Intoxicants- should be avoided
- Criminality-unacceptable
And also
5) 19-interesting, but not needed for salvation
6) Hadith-no goodAnd is there any particular scholar you associate with your choices? -God
Peace Be With You. -
I guess we shouldn't prohibit skipping your taxes, since the Koran says nothing about that.
This is a bit of a strawman. The Quran states repeatedly that people should honor their oaths and respect the law of the land. If you're a citizen of a country that demands taxes be paid, that's a binding oath and law. You could try to argue your point with the tax-man, (that the Quran doesn't specifically say you have to) but I don't think it would work. ;D
Even the Amish have to pay taxes and they've got a stronger religious leg to stand on, seeing as how their beliefs are explicitly against it. -
I guess we shouldn't prohibit skipping your taxes, since the Koran says nothing about that.
Taxes are based on the use of public goods like roads, bridges, emergency hospitals, public parks, sewages and police force and army. I studied economy so I know the logic behind taxes. Since everyone benefits from these public goods everyone should contribute or else people will try to use them without paying for them. That is why there are taxes.
Also its not just about what the Qiran sepecifically said or not but what contradicts it. If the Quran geve freedom to believe or disbelieve and and the Quran itself says that God inflicts trials and tribulations to "see what we will do" than how can it then contradict itself by commanding a punishment for an act some may see as a disbedience or a sin. There is no sin greater than shirk or kufr and yet the Quran gave that right to humans to pursue that option if they wish.
Giving freedom does not mean an endorsement. Those of us who come from Islamic backgrounds have to make that adjustment from a dictatorial religious state we were raised in to and indoctrinted about to a free Quranic religious state that the Quran stipulates. And this usually takes time for people to adjust to.
-
This is a bit of a strawman. The Quran states repeatedly that people should honor their oaths and respect the law of the land. If you're a citizen of a country that demands taxes be paid, that's a binding oath and law. You could try to argue your point with the tax-man, (that the Quran doesn't specifically say you have to) but I don't think it would work. ;D
Even the Amish have to pay taxes and they've got a stronger religious leg to stand on, seeing as how their beliefs are explicitly against it.Ok then. If you're a citizen of the country that demands you keep your ****s in your pants unless you're married to the opposite sex, that's a binding oath and law.
Problum?
-
Taxes are based on the use of public goods like roads, bridges, emergency hospitals, public parks, sewages and police force and army. I studied economy so I know the logic behind taxes. Since everyone benefits from these public goods everyone should contribute or else people will try to use them without paying for them. That is why there are taxes.
Does Allah say anything about public goods in the Koran?
Also its not just about what the Qiran sepecifically said or not but what contradicts it. If the Quran geve freedom to believe or disbelieve and and the Quran itself says that God inflicts trials and tribulations to "see what we will do" than how can it then contradict itself by commanding a punishment for an act some may see as a disbedience or a sin.
Hitler didn't agree with the Koran's prohibition of murder. Degenerates are free to believe whatever they want - that doesn't mean they are free to do whatever they want.
There is no sin greater than shirk or kufr and yet the Quran gave that right to humans to pursue that option if they wish.
Keyword that.
Giving freedom does not mean an endorsement. Those of us who come from Islamic backgrounds have to make that adjustment from a dictatorial religious state we were raised in to and indoctrinted about to a free Quranic religious state that the Quran stipulates. And this usually takes time for people to adjust to.
There is no compulsion in religion. We are not forcing them to hold that the law is good and just. If that was the case, we wouldn't need to punish them.
-
Does Allah say anything about public goods in the Koran?
Hitler didn't agree with the Koran's prohibition of murder. Degenerates are free to believe whatever they want - that doesn't mean they are free to do whatever they want.
Keyword that.
There is no compulsion in religion. We are not forcing them to hold that the law is good and just. If that was the case, we wouldn't need to punish them.
I am sorry but I don't get your answer and can't follow your logic. What do you mean does the Quran talk about pulic goods.? That has to do with justice since why should some spend on public goods while others don't even when they are enjoying those goods. Its about justice that the Quran does speak of.
I mean did the Quran tells us not to shit and pee on someone's face? Does that mean we can? Thats inflincting some damage and harm on somebody and that is when the Quran allows us to hold others accountable. Two guys deciding to have sex is not anybody's concern. I sense you are not able to tell the difference.
And what does Hitler killing has to do wth all this? The Quran did precribe a punishment for murder.
I have no clue to the last part of what you said also.
-
Ok then. If you're a citizen of the country that demands you keep your ****s in your pants unless you're married to the opposite sex, that's a binding oath and law.
Problum?
As an individual, no, I would not have a problem with a law like that since I do that, anyway. As a citizen who respects my fellow citizens' right to live their lives free of tyranny, I would have a problem. This is another strawman.
The law that demands everyone pay taxes is fair in that benefits everyone, equally. We all have to use the roads and we all get to use the parks that taxes pay for. A law that intrudes on some people's right to privacy benefits no one but the minority who are obsessed with what others do with their privates in private. One is clearly unfair and has no place in a free society.
