:: How to... Salaat, Saum, Hajj, Zakaat! ::
-
Okay. You are free to have those opinions, hawk99. But you are intending to make me look in a bad weather.
Self-serving they are not because they are backed up by the Sustainer. And I told you I am searching for evidence every day to complement the evidence that is there already.
I do not care if you agree with me or not, but one does not intentionally work to make a person appear in bad weather. And if they were wise they consider every possible input.
It is not like it would be rocket science to understand that such an old language as Arabic with words derived from an even older language called Aramaic would have "innate letter meanings". And if they have that it means words have only one general meaning too.
-
Did either of you or anyone read my speech up there?
http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9607530.msg370374#msg370374
-
Did either of you or anyone read my speech up there?
http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9607530.msg370374#msg370374
Salaam,
Yes, I did. Nice work!
I like most of the part of it and agreed also but not all.May Allah increase our knowledge and guide us on His path pr
mmKhan -
Salaam,
Yes, I did. Nice work!
I like most of the part of it and agreed also but not all.May Allah increase our knowledge and guide us on His path pr
mmKhanWhich parts did you not agree with, so that I know and can maybe think about them?
-
Okay. You are free to have those opinions, hawk99. But you are intending to make me look in a bad weather.
Peace Man of Faith these are not my opinions but yours!
You basically agreed with
Peace Man of Faith, correct me where I'm wrong, thus far you
do not believe in a defensive war, ritual salat, ritual fast, hajj, the qiblah
being Mecca, the Quran's general interpretation as it is today. You do believe
one can be one/meld/blend with the Rabb, you prefer use of the word
Rabb instead Allah, and you mention/inspired by Jesus more than Muhammad.I said SIMILAR meanings, not synonyms.
My understanding
synonym
NOUN
a word or phrase that means exactly or nearly the same as another word
or phrase in the same language, for example shut is a synonym of close.synonyms alternate ? substitute ? alternative ? equivalent ? euphemism
kill
VERB
1.cause the death of (a person, animal, or other living thing)
"her father was killed in a car crash"
synonyms murder ? take/end the life of ? assassinate ? eliminate ? terminate ?
dispatch ? finish off ? put to death ? execute ? slaughter ? butcher ? massacre ?
wipe out ? annihilate ? exterminate ? mow down ? shoot down ? cut down ?
cut to pieces ? bump off ? polish off ? do away with ? do in ? knock off ? take out ?
croak ? stiff ? blow away ? liquidate ? dispose of ? ice ? snuff ? rub out ? waste ?
whack ? smoke ? slayDo not blame others for understanding your points of view. brickwall
Peace FreedomStands, as usual your posts are too long for me, yes
therefore I do not bother to read them, only a casual glance.
From the little I did read I disagree with your premise that the truth "shifts."May Allah guide Us to the truth
-
Peace FreedomStands, as usual your posts are too long for me, yes
therefore I do not bother to read them, only a casual glance.
From the little I did read I disagree with your premise that the truth "shifts."May Allah guide Us to the truth
Well, it is understandable that you might disagree, based on not reading what I wrote, where I prove extensively what my meaning is and the reasoning behind the statements.
My point was, had you read it, that God chooses what the "truth" is, and there is nothing stable on its own except God as the Ultimate Truth.
This is proven clearly in the Qur'an, where it was "true" that Musa was holding a staff, then it was "false" that Musa was holding a staff, and instead it was "true" that there was a snake instead, and then it was "false" that there was a snake, and "true" that there was a staff. This demonstrated that God can change anything, nothing is true except what God makes true, and all of those things can easily be shifted by God.
Am I wrong? Do you disagree with that?
All I was saying is God can shift the "truth", but the "Ultimate Truth" remains, which is God Alone.
Right?
So people take pride in all sorts of "truths" and "systems" and go mad over them, when God can shift anything, or is God incapable of that?
God controls all information. The laws of the Universe can suddenly be changed, and even history can be shifted entirely, this is the power of God.
Do you deny that, do you disagree then that God can shift and change the "truth"?
Maybe it is worth something to read whatever it is I wrote and see if I really am wrong.
-
Well, it is understandable that you might disagree, based on not reading what I wrote, where I prove extensively what my meaning is and the reasoning behind the statements.
My point was, had you read it, that God chooses what the "truth" is, and there is nothing stable on its own except God as the Ultimate Truth.
This is proven clearly in the Qur'an, where it was "true" that Musa was holding a staff, then it was "false" that Musa was holding a staff, and instead it was "true" that there was a snake instead, and then it was "false" that there was a snake, and "true" that there was a staff. This demonstrated that God can change anything, nothing is true except what God makes true, and all of those things can easily be shifted by God.
Am I wrong? Do you disagree with that?
All I was saying is God can shift the "truth", but the "Ultimate Truth" remains, which is God Alone.
Right?
So far I agree
So people take pride in all sorts of "truths" and "systems" and go mad over them, when God can shift anything, or is God incapable of that?
What people take pride in does not make that system,
opinion etc. true. nopeGod controls all information. The laws of the Universe can suddenly be changed,
and even history can be shifted entirely, this is the power of God.God indeed controls all things.
Maybe it is worth something to read whatever it is I wrote and see if I really am wrong.
Peace FreedomStands, thank you for one page out of one of your books! )
Allah is Al Haqq (the truth) and Allah does not change.Allah controls all things, but we do not. Can you alter reality
like God when he wills? (change a snake into a staff) or duplicate
any of the incursions into reality that are in Quran Kareem? our truth
is static good brother, there is only one!God bless you
-
So far I agree
What people take pride in does not make that system,
opinion etc. true. nopeGod indeed controls all things.
Peace FreedomStands, thank you for one page out of one of your books! )
Allah is Al Haqq (the truth) and Allah does not change.Allah controls all things, but we do not. Can you alter reality
like God when he wills? (change a snake into a staff) or duplicate
any of the incursions into reality that are in Quran Kareem? our truth
is static good brother, there is only one!God bless you
Thank you, no I can't change or alter reality, only Allah can. I was just throwing in the suggestion that God can shock anyone by shifting things or suddenly making things that were not true to us appear to be true, or any number of things. So the end result is just to be wary of Allah, fear Allah, and know that only Allah is the Ultimate Truth, whereas all other things we think we see or know or believe can be shifted or transitory, and nothing can be held on to really. In some cases, Allah has convinced some people they are right when they might not be, or convinced others to view something as wrong (like how so many hate or dispute with Islam). So we just turn back to Allah in everything, the decider in all matters.
So in my speech, as you know there are people who believe the Earth is flat, who (if they are sincere) Allah has convinced of this, and can literally "prove" such a thing to all of us easily if Allah wills, making the whole topic arbitrary and vain (wasted).
For me, to consider such power of transformation, is a high meditation on Allah. I believe in science and whatever of course, and the situation that is at hand in my reality this moment as it appears to me, but I am just stating as an extra meditation on the power of Allah, that Allah can change anything too, so those who are obsessed with little "truths" (not you, I mean other people), are those who might not remember that Allah can change anything easily.
So I take it easy with Man of Faith. He is controlled by God, what he believes comes from God, and God can even make what he says seem true to any of us, but the better truth is always one God alone is the Greatest and Only Ultimate Truth, and God can shift anything freely with or without our awareness and convince anyone of anything.
-
Which parts did you not agree with, so that I know and can maybe think about them?
Peace brother,
I am sorry I cannot go through it again to pick up the point.
I agree with all the points that you made in relation to my opening post.
Yes, I was trying to say the same thing but in other words, but your words made is more easier to understand, mashaAllah.May Allah increase our knowledge and guide us on His path pr
mmKhan -
Peace brother,
I am sorry I cannot go through it again to pick up the point.
I agree with all the points that you made in relation to my opening post.
Yes, I was trying to say the same thing but in other words, but your words made is more easier to understand, mashaAllah.May Allah increase our knowledge and guide us on His path pr
mmKhanCool! Thank you!
-
Hawk99,
Peace Man of Faith these are not my opinions but yours!
What you wrote earlier speaks against this.
a word or phrase that means exactly or nearly the same as another word
or phrase in the same language, for example shut is a synonym of close.Yes and qatal is not a synonym because it does not imply that a person dies but only that the person is defeated, subdued. It is not even remotely synonymous because one word implies that the person dies while the other one does not. And qatal does not imply whether the defeat is peaceful or violent.
So how would you translate, or how do you understand 49/14?
One can submit, accept, resign to, acknowledge, conform to the tenets of Islam (Muslim)
which are indeed sound but why such grandiosity, nitpicking your own personal meaning?It is your opinion that I have grandiosity. And it is your opinion that I am "nitpicking" my personal meanings. Salam the root does not mean submit or whatever you are fed. It means that something is sound/pristine/healthy.
Just reflect upon why in tradition you greet someone with "salaam". Do you tell them "submit!" when you greet them or do you wish them health? You wish them health obviously. And Muslim means "a Sound one" which refers to that you are mentally and physically well, but its meaning does probably more imply that you have a sound judgment rather than kafar, i.e. deluded.
4914 is quite easy to explain because allah is not a word for some god but the only word as a title used to refer to your Sustainer is 'Rabb' in the Arabic language here. Yet many translators add the word allah where 'aslamana' is mentioned in the sentence so it looks the way you believe. Try to find some better argument and please stop the derogatory remarks that I am filled with grandiosity just because I am propagating a truth that has been shoveled dirt on for over thousand years.
It is not a matter of grandeur. When someone struggles to proclaim a truth it is not arrogance, and I have the right to propel my words just like anyone else as long as I follow the forum rules. And I told you that I am basing these arguments on DEFINITIONS AVAILABLE IN ANCIENT LEXICONS and they are NOT MY MEANINGS. What is difficult to understand?
Do not blame others for understanding your points of view.
I blame people for "nitpicking" my words in order to find some way against me while they did not even care to study them first. You entirely took my words, rendered me in bad weather, and said I contradicted myself while I did not. A synonym must have almost the same meaning as the word referred to or else it can only be a somewhat similar word with some connotation. Perhaps I should not say similar because I have to be perfectly clear. They have some remote connection with each other, instead.
We were talking about Arabic words and I said there are no synonyms in the Arabic language, but there are words with a similar meaning. But that does not mean they are synonymous. You just based an opinion without reflecting upon what I wrote first and saying I contradict myself while I did not in the first place.
My understanding
synonym
NOUN
a word or phrase that means exactly or nearly the same as another word
or phrase in the same language, for example shut is a synonym of close.synonyms alternate ? substitute ? alternative ? equivalent ? euphemism
And where can you disqualify my argument with this? It is clear what a synonym is.
Be well
-
-
In my opinion, every truth (all truth) is static/steady/unchanged/stable,
because I think God is not "wishy washy".
I don't think God is wishy washy, but has shown examples of changing things, like the snake and staff. God is free to change anything, and if God changes anything, it is part of what God wants to do. There isn't really time for God, time is just something in our experiences as a concept.
So, for example, there once was no Earth. That state did not remain, and then there was Earth, etc. Constantly changing things, changing the seasons, and changing the humans, and they grow old and die and new ones appear, etc.
If God was "static", then the Earth would never have appeared nor would there be any creation or change from that original state, but God creates freely and new things and adds to things and transforms people and creations, and says even of the angels that God adds to their creation as he pleases. There is no time really, God is presently operating and doing whatever, and it is by "change" that we perceive anything at all.
Change is evident, or else God wouldn't have created in the first place and there would have been no change, nor would there have been progress which is all transformation. If everything was static, there would be no end to the Universe or Earth either.
-
I'm not saying everything was static, I think it could be that you misunderstood my point.
In short, I tend to believe that my Creator is consistent regarding His decisions for matters.
That's my personal understanding.
I think that is totally true. In my view, there are only Allah's decisions, and there is nothing in the heavens, or the earth or anywhere that can change the decision of Allah, Allah decides a matter and says "Be" and it is, but Allah's decisions are such that Allah can also change any of it, not because something convinced Allah to change it, or that Allah is wishy washy, but that Allah is now doing something else or wills there to be some change or transformation, and Allah is totally free to do that, is not bound by anything, etc, so freely can create and freely can destroy, and freely can make any sort of decision however weird it may seem.
-
Yeah... that's right. Thank you for the advice, brother hawk.
May Allah forgive me.
InshaAllah, I will be more careful if I speak about something like that next time.
Peace, when referring to my lord I try to stick to his attributes,
thereby not risking offense to our sustainer.Yes and qatal is not a synonym because it does not imply that a person dies but only that the person is defeated,
Makes sense if you invent your own definitions
God bless
-
Hawk99,
I have not done it. These are definitions in ancient lexicons. Defeat, subdue and master. It is NOT my inventions.
The word means to defeat someone, and whether the person dies or not does not come forth.
-
Peace Man Of Faith.
You say
The word means to defeat someone, and whether the person dies or not does not come forth.Here we go again, lexicans,dictionaries....are no use. Qoran comes back at you from where you do not perceive and tries you
Defeat does not even come close here
1874
So they went. When they met a young boy, he killed him. He said, "Why did you kill such an innocent person, who did not kill another person? You have committed something horrendous."Are you going to argue the first means defeat even if he dies? What about the second "Katalahu"?
Defeat will not make sense here!
GOD bless you.
Peace.