Physically killing of Prophet
-
Peace NK.
The most obvious one is Jesus. He came as a prophet to Beni Israeel.
There are others that have been killed between Moses and Jesus according to the bible,but Qoran does not confirm the stories.
GOD bless you.
Peace. -
Nk, I forgot to mention John the Baptist before Jesus in my last post.
-
Salam Submitter,
You are right, I have mixed two things in the verse and I have corrected my mistake immediately when Good logic explained it in his answer.
Regarding children of Israel, you are also correct that it refers to the descendant of Jacobs. Even if you look for all those prophets after Jacob till Prophet Muhammad some of them they only rejected and some of them they tried to kill.
Rejected Yaqub, Shauib, Ayyub, Musa, Haron etc
Tried to kill Yusuf, Jesus, Muhammad etc.
Peace
NK -
Didn't read whole, but read the part you claim Israel is God.
Do you have any proof from Quran?
We both know that God is not fed but He feeds, meaning He doesn't eat! So if He doesn't eat, how can there be a verse saying that "Israel" forbade for himself certain foods?
393 All the food was made permissible to the Children of Israel except
what Israel forbade for himself before the Torah was sent down.
Say ?Bring the Torah and recite it if you are truthful.?Your view of the truth is twisted
Since when was Israel a prophet? You come with a translation saying "himself". There is some kind of gross misinterpretation that Yacoob was renamed Israel, but this is simply not true. So what does "Children of Israel" refer to then? A nation called Israel? No, it is a kind of code name for God, only apparent for the really perceptive.
The twisted truth is likely more with your "borrowed" interpretation from medieval clergymen.
Be well
Amenuel -
Peace NK.
The most obvious one is Jesus. He came as a prophet to Beni Israeel.
There are others that have been killed between Moses and Jesus according to the bible,but Qoran does not confirm the stories.
GOD bless you.
Peace.The Bible does not confirm any particular killings of prophets either.
The truth is that the prophets were opposed and suppressed and that is what the Qatel is connoted to.
Be well
Amenuel -
Sorry I wrote to you, NK.
-
Peace Man Of Faith.
According to you ,Qoran does not say what it says. Bible does not say what it says.We already discussed "Kill" in another thread,so I am not going to waste your time and the readers time repeating my side of the argument.
However according to me,it is you who does not know what you say.
Nevertheless you are entitled to keep saying.
GOD bless you.
Peace. -
Since when was Israel a prophet? You come with a translation saying "himself". There is some kind of gross misinterpretation that Yacoob was renamed Israel, but this is simply not true. So what does "Children of Israel" refer to then? A nation called Israel? No, it is a kind of code name for God, only apparent for the really perceptive.
The twisted truth is likely more with your "borrowed" interpretation from medieval clergymen.
Be well
AmenuelThe translator is alive and not from medieval but today. Brother Layth, a devoted believer.
I find many of your interpretations quite twisted. To prove even further that your translation is twisted, let's have another look.
Christians and Jews claim they are the children of God. Be He glorified and exalted far above what they claim.
You say Israel is God. So in other words; "Children of Israel"="Children of God".
But God has condemned such claims...throughout the Quran, and especially with the Christians who say "three"...
Also
1120 In the name of God, the Almighty, the Merciful.
1121 Say ?He is God, the One,?
1122 ?God, the Indivisible,?
1123 ?He does not beget, nor was He begotten,?
1124 ?And there is none who is His equal.?HE DOES NOT BEGET!
-
The Bible does not confirm any particular killings of prophets either.
The truth is that the prophets were opposed and suppressed and that is what the Qatel is connoted to.
Be well
AmenuelSalam Man of Faith,
Could you please explain a bit more. What do you think about Zechariah and John the Baptish killing in the bible?. For death of John the baptist please refer Mathew 14.
Peace,
NK -
Yes, I know John the Baptist was beheaded. I am quite knowledgeable about most anything in the Bible, knowing some by heart.
John (Yahya), Jesus and Zachariah are the only famous prophets I know of being killed. And they lived about the same time which seems to have been a restless era. These prophets liked to convey a purified message that the clergy did not appreciate. Took three good men to get that message through.
Yes, I know I wrote "no particular killings", but okay we can say a few killings over time. Abel was slain by his brother too, if we consider Abel a prophet.
Be well
Amenuel