Death by God's leave

farati

Salam,

The Quran (3145) states that only by God's will death may occur at appointed time. My questions are

Isn't committing a suicide or murder a violation of God's willexistence of death? Since it is stated that nothing can violate it?
If it doesn't violate and it is not his will, then why would he punish a murderer or a suicider for the cause of death? Since it isis his will that they died?

reel

This is how I see God's will

Will=Formula

People can choose which one they want. They also have the tool to control the randomness, but it is usually kept at bay by those who give preference to group think.

imrankhawaja

i see it in a different way

suicide bomb attack ( if there is a will of God in that blast ) it will take place

if the mission get unsuccessful then it was also the will of God

he do what he wish according to the laws design by him

but we cant understand his laws by this human mind perhaps the very same confusion occured between traveller and moses

sometimes he save people from suicide bomb,robbery,rape,losses etc

sometimes it happen even how hard you try to save it becoz its the will of God

the beautiful thing is every single second is a mysterious one in this time place

bagyane

Salam,

The Quran (3145) states that only by God's will death may occur at appointed time. My questions are

Isn't committing a suicide or murder a violation of God's willexistence of death? Since it is stated that nothing can violate it?
If it doesn't violate and it is not his will, then why would he punish a murderer or a suicider for the cause of death? Since it isis his will that they died?

The arabic term ?kitaban mu?ajjala? as stated in 3143 was further elucidated as two periods that is ajlan (a period) wa (and) ajlan musamma (a specified period) in verse 62

the link below might be a resource
https//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9608149.msg381795#msg381795

Jafar

Isn't committing a suicide or murder a violation of God's willexistence of death? Since it is stated that nothing can violate it?
If it doesn't violate and it is not his will, then why would he punish a murderer or a suicider for the cause of death? Since it isis his will that they died?

Nothing can "violate" God's will and plan..
From tiny cells and atoms up to something as powerful as Stars and Blackhole

Thus one need to rethink the concept of (2)