quran-ic arabic experts: definition of sadqa in the quran?
-
Salam Ik, AhmadBahgat, all,
I always understood "sadaqa" as an action to purify/clean our self (nafs). It can be in different forms and Quran gives us some examples, see verses 9103 and 5812 for instance. It has a sense of remitting some of our bad actions and thus the ttahara (cleaning) and zakat (purification) associated to it in Quran. It is worth noting in Quran that sadaqa is defined by the one who initiates it and not the one who is impacted by it. And God the All-Mighty knows best.
Peace, Myr.
Peace sister
The outcome of the Sadaqa is what you said above, the Sadaqa itself is giving Alms, i.e. giving money to the poor, 9103 clearly says the action of the Sadaqa then the outcome of that action
Take alms of their wealth, wherewith thou mayst purify them and mayst make them grow, and pray for them. Lo! thy prayer is an assuagement for them. Allah is Hearer, Knower.
(103)
-> 9103 clearly says ?Take alms of their wealth, i.e. Sadaqa is from our perspective is to give Alms, the outcome of Sadaqa is ? thou mayst purify them and mayst make them grow?, please don?t mix the action and its outcome, in my previous comment I showed clearly that we should not commit evil deeds after we give Alms otherwise it will not be accepted, and that is how the outcome will be gained by controlling the self not to cause harm or do any bad deeds after giving Alms so Allah accept these Alms as genuine good deed ?Sadaqa?, then we will be entitled for forgiveness in the JD ?only if we believe?
For 5812, it actually related to some history in the life of the prophet where many (including the Jews and the Christians) used to ask him zillions of questions and the prophet felt shy to let them down and not answering them, this caused a lot of hardship on him and disturbance to his main mission of the establishment of the religion, many of the questions were silly and some were a setup to create discord, so Allah revealed this verse saying to those who lived with the prophet that if you want to ask him a question then it is better that you pay Sadaqa as well, then those Sadaqat will be given to the poor and needy as managed by whoever was in charge to distribute the Sadaqat, this verse in effect will expose the hypocrites because they now should pay Sadaqa before they ask the prophet a question, however if the verse still allowed them to consult the prophet if they can't donate a Sadaqa for the consultation
O ye who believe! When ye consult the Messenger in private, spend something in charity before your private consultation. That will be best for you, and most conducive to purity (of conduct). But if ye find not (the wherewithal), Allah is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful.
(12)
-> It is in effect a test to the believers at the time as well an advice because the verse said? That will be best for you and most conducive to purity (of conduct)?, but if they can?t afford it then no problem they still can consult him? But if ye find not (the wherewithal), Allah is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful.?, please donlt mix the conduct with the action of Sadaqa itself, the proper conduct should be the automatic conduct for those who give Alms otherwise they will be nothing but hypocrites as well the Alms will not be accepted by Allah if the follow the Alms with bad conduct as I explained earlier
Peace
-
what's the difference between sadqa and zakat then?
-
peace
thank you all for your replies.
God bless !
-
what's the difference between sadqa and zakat then?
Salam
Zakat is compulsory, Sadaqa is not compulsory
other than that, both should cost mony
Salam
-
what's the difference between sadqa and zakat then?
Salam
Zakat is compulsory, Sadaqa is not compulsory
other than that, both should cost mony
Please EXPLAIN why zakat is compulsory and sadaqa is not? How do you understand what zakat and sadaqa is with respect to Quranic contexts. No need to WINK? Have you read and understood what some of the people herer believe in what zakat and sadaqa means? How do you know that you are right and others wrong???
-
what's the difference between sadqa and zakat then?
Salam
Zakat is compulsory, Sadaqa is not compulsory
other than that, both should cost mony
Please EXPLAIN why zakat is compulsory and sadaqa is not? How do you understand what zakat and sadaqa is with respect to Quranic contexts. No need to WINK? Have you read and understood what some of the people herer believe in what zakat and sadaqa means? How do you know that you are right and others wrong???
Well, it is up to me how I understand it really, did I force my opinion on the querstioner?
but what puzzles me is this, why a Quran rejector like you who is labelled Kafir by the Quran rant that much about it?, didn't you conclude to yourself what the Quran is?, now you should bugger off and leave the ones who believe in the Quran discuss it in peace
Salam dunk
-
what's the difference between sadqa and zakat then?
Salam
Zakat is compulsory, Sadaqa is not compulsory
other than that, both should cost mony
Please EXPLAIN why zakat is compulsory and sadaqa is not? How do you understand what zakat and sadaqa is with respect to Quranic contexts. No need to WINK? Have you read and understood what some of the people herer believe in what zakat and sadaqa means? How do you know that you are right and others wrong???
Well, it is up to me how I understand it really, did I force my opinion on the querstioner?
but what puzzles me is this, why a Quran rejector like you who is labelled Kafir by the Quran rant that much about it?, didn't you conclude to yourself what the Quran is?, now you should bugger off and leave the ones who believe in the Quran discuss it in peace
Salam dunk
Its clear enough to reject the Quran being Allah's Words with disgraceful remarks coming from you all over the forum without substantiating any effort to credibly support it. You are its true enemy hiding behind its pages, judging by its cover.
If you have the balls, then come and defeat me here http//www.free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=5264.30
-
what's the difference between sadqa and zakat then?
Salam
Zakat is compulsory, Sadaqa is not compulsory
other than that, both should cost mony
Please EXPLAIN why zakat is compulsory and sadaqa is not? How do you understand what zakat and sadaqa is with respect to Quranic contexts. No need to WINK? Have you read and understood what some of the people herer believe in what zakat and sadaqa means? How do you know that you are right and others wrong???
Well, it is up to me how I understand it really, did I force my opinion on the querstioner?
but what puzzles me is this, why a Quran rejector like you who is labelled Kafir by the Quran rant that much about it?, didn't you conclude to yourself what the Quran is?, now you should bugger off and leave the ones who believe in the Quran discuss it in peace
Salam dunk
Its clear enough to reject the Quran being Allah's Words with disgraceful remarks coming from you all over the forum without substantiating any effort to credibly support it. You are its true enemy hiding behind its pages, judging by its cover.
If you have the balls, then come and defeat me here http//www.free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=5264.30
Salam Danish
You are an idiot bro, because I'm not interested in defeating you, i hardly know you but what I'm interested in is to show all here that you are truely full of shit
Salam
-
peace
calm down ahmed, its best just to ignore and move on.
The worshipers of the Most Gracious are those who tread the earth gently, and when the ignorant speak to them, they only utter peace.
i thought zakat wasn't compulsory either. I thought it was compulsory on those who could afford it.
-
peace ahmed
also your opinion on this article on the free mind's front page about zakat
http//www.free-minds.org/articles/quranic/zakat.htm
-
peace
calm down ahmed, its best just to ignore and move on.
The worshipers of the Most Gracious are those who tread the earth gently, and when the ignorant speak to them, they only utter peace.
i thought zakat wasn't compulsory either. I thought it was compulsory on those who could afford it.
Peace bro
It makes sense that anything compulsory is for those who can do/afford it
also your opinion on this article on the free mind's front page about zakat
Bro, i will read the article later when I have a bit of time, however I can't take serioulsy anything said by anyone who suggest that Mohammad was a symbol, and that is what brother Kyle is suggesting all along
Peace
-
peace ahmed
muhammad as a symbol? thats a good one. How do you mean exactly? Do you mean to say he believes that there' was no muhammad in the quran and he's symbolic? from my point of view that's border-line insane
-
peace ahmed
muhammad as a symbol? thats a good one. How do you mean exactly? Do you mean to say he believes that there' was no muhammad in the quran and he's symbolic? from my point of view that's border-line insane
Sure bro
you may have a word with brother Kyle if you would like to understand that concept further, i tried with brother Kyle and he got me lost so i gave it a miss and i will take it as Mohammad was for real
Peace