Right Hand Vs Left Hand
-
No it?s not quranic.. it?s traditional. I think its roots relate to Christianity.. they associate right with goodness such as the ?right hand of God? great men are of the right hand of god hence right hand is preferred? Right not wrong?
Maybe abit crazy calling it haram to write with left hand. I remember as a kid I wrote with both left and right hand, more so with left and my dad would make me write with my right hand. So I grew up right handed but it?s all about how you train yourself or what the child decides as their hand preference. Most people are right handed. But actually people have ambidexterity, they use both hands though mostly only write with one.what ? who said that is not Quranic ? ..that shows that your knowledge in Quran so so superficial and sorry to say that if that offended you . let's see what Qur'an said
(41) (42) (43) (44) (45) (46)
here in theses verses God told us that the left position in the day of Judgement is for the infidels and the non-believers.so from these verses we conclude that everything in the left position is not a good thing, in addition to this the hell is in the left position too.
one more thing, this is not a tradition is what the prophet ordered us to do (eat by the right hand, and give charity by the right hand). -
here in theses verses God told us that the left position in the day of Judgement is for the infidels and the non-believers.so from these verses we conclude that everything in the left position is not a good thing
That is your personal conclusion. But being right- or left-handed is not a choice, it is something you are born with, it was God's choice to create you that way. Are you suggesting we should try to change God's creation?
one more thing, this is not a tradition is what the prophet ordered us to do (eat by the right hand, and give charity by the right hand).
Yeah, but this thread was about whether there is a reason for that in the Qur'an. Most people here do not see traditions as binding, as I'm sure you have noticed. )
-
That is your personal conclusion. But being right- or left-handed is not a choice, it is something you are born with, it was God's choice to create you that way. Are you suggesting we should try to change God's creation?
that is not my personal conclusion, is what logic said " the right part of the mind control the left part of the body, and the left part of the mind control the right part of the body " so as you said that you have a God's creation is wrong, because you're not under the logic, plus doing things by the left hand is a habit you inherted it by using your left hand when you were a child.
by the way my brother eat by his left hand and write by it, but he changed it suddenly to the right hand because after all it's against the nature.
B.S the Satan eat and drink and do things by his left hand.
Yeah, but this thread was about whether there is a reason for that in the Qur'an. Most people here do not see traditions as binding, as I'm sure you have noticed.
well, the traditions things have been said by other memeber, I have just made it clear that is not tradition.
and about justifying from Qur'an that the left hand is not a good thing, I've already put verses. -
that is not my personal conclusion, is what logic said " the right part of the mind control the left part of the body, and the left part of the mind control the right part of the body "
In left-handed people, the right hemisphere of the brain is dominant. It is something you are born with and not something you can change or influence.
plus doing things by the left hand is a habit you inherted it by using your left hand when you were a child.
No, it is not a habit, it is dermined through your brain by birth. I suggest you do some research on "lateralization of brain function", then you might see what I am talking about. There is also a lot of research out there about left-handedness and the detrimental effect it has on a person if he or she is forced to use the right hand.
by the way my brother eat by his left hand and write by it, but he changed it suddenly to the right hand because after all it's against the nature.
How can something you are born with be against nature? Sorry, that doesn't make any sense at all.
B.S the Satan eat and drink and do things by his left hand.
Oh really? How do you know -- did you have dinner with him? http//www.clicksmilies.com/s1106/teufel/devil-smiley-019.gif
-
In left-handed people, the right hemisphere of the brain is dominant. It is something you are born with and not something you can change or influence.
Yes , it is something that you born with and why do you change it ? by contradicting with the process of this hemisphere.
No, it is not a habit, it is dermined through your brain by birth. I suggest you do some research on "lateralization of brain function", then you might see what I am talking about. There is also a lot of research out there about left-handedness and the detrimental effect it has on a person if he or she is forced to use the right hand.
Yes, it's a habit (because we can deviate it and make it vanish) if it was as you said that someone born with it, it'll impossible to change it, do we change our eyes ?
and about forcing the left-handedness to use the right hand will not make any change, in fact my brother have forced my brother to use his right hand and you know what he is genius I swear rotflHow can something you are born with be against nature? Sorry, that doesn't make any sense at all.
No, you're wrong. It's not something we born with, scientists can say everything to opposite our beliefs, you know that a recent discoveries said that gay is bron gay (I think you belive that a too and it doesn't make sense at all)
Oh really? How do you know -- did you have dinner with him? http//www.clicksmilies.com/s1106/teufel/devil-smiley-019.gif
[/quote
No, I didn't ...but the prophet peace be upon him told us about that and he knew this thing from God. I can make a jokes as well , so be careful -
Yes , it is something that you born with and why do you change it ? by contradicting with the process of this hemisphere.
You misunderstood my comment.
whether it is from sunnah or not , let's see what the doctors and scientists said
scientists can say everything to opposite our beliefs
Either you believe in science or you don't. But you can't use "doctors and scientists" in one post to support your allegations and say in another post that their opinion is worthless.
-
You misunderstood my comment.
No, I didn't , making my post short and choosing a part from it , shows that you have no points to make. hmm
-
HANDEDNESS, LANGUAGE, AND BRAIN LATERALIZATION
Perhaps the most striking anatomical characteristic of the human brain is that it is divided into two hemispheres, so that it has two of almost every structure one on the left side and one on the right. But these paired structures are not exactly symmetrical and often differ in their size, form, and function. This phenomenon is called brain lateralization.
The two most lateralized functions in the human brain are motor control and language. When a function is lateralized, this often means that one side of the brain exerts more control over this function than the other does. The side that exerts more control is often called the ?dominant hemisphere? for this function, but this expression can be somewhat misleading (see sidebar).
Lateralization of motor control is what determines whether someone is right-handed or left-handed. When someone is ambidextrous?when they can use either hand as easily as the other?it means that their brain is only partly lateralized or not at all lateralized for motor control.
In right-handed people, the ?dominant? hemisphere for motor control is the left, while in left-handed people, it is the right. The reason for this inversion is that the motor pathways of the nervous system cross over to the other side of the body as they go down the spinal cord. Thus the movements of one side of the body are controlled by the hemisphere on the opposite side.
About 9 out of 10 adults are right-handed. This proportion seems to have remained stable over many thousands of years and in all cultures in which it has been studied
http//thebrain.mcgill.ca/flash/d/d_10/d_10_cr/d_10_cr_lan/d_10_cr_lan.html.
-
HANDEDNESS, LANGUAGE, AND BRAIN LATERALIZATION
Perhaps the most striking anatomical characteristic of the human brain is that it is divided into two hemispheres, so that it has two of almost every structure one on the left side and one on the right. But these paired structures are not exactly symmetrical and often differ in their size, form, and function. This phenomenon is called brain lateralization.
The two most lateralized functions in the human brain are motor control and language. When a function is lateralized, this often means that one side of the brain exerts more control over this function than the other does. The side that exerts more control is often called the ?dominant hemisphere? for this function, but this expression can be somewhat misleading (see sidebar).
Lateralization of motor control is what determines whether someone is right-handed or left-handed. When someone is ambidextrous?when they can use either hand as easily as the other?it means that their brain is only partly lateralized or not at all lateralized for motor control.
In right-handed people, the ?dominant? hemisphere for motor control is the left, while in left-handed people, it is the right. The reason for this inversion is that the motor pathways of the nervous system cross over to the other side of the body as they go down the spinal cord. Thus the movements of one side of the body are controlled by the hemisphere on the opposite side.
About 9 out of 10 adults are right-handed. This proportion seems to have remained stable over many thousands of years and in all cultures in which it has been studied
http//thebrain.mcgill.ca/flash/d/d_10/d_10_cr/d_10_cr_lan/d_10_cr_lan.html.They said the same thing about gays .
-
Trying hard to change the subject, huh? http//foolstown.com/sm/umn.gif
No at all, I've just related what you said about born with from a scientists views . scientists according to your post said that 9 out 10 adults (not childs) are right handed, and I said that scientists said the same thing about gays adults as well (not childs) ....I'll let you think !
-
scientists according to your post said that 9 out 10 adults (not childs) are right handed, and I said that scientists said the same thing about gays adults as well (not childs) ....I'll let you think !
Scientists say that 9 out of 10 gays are right handed? rotfl
Btw., it's "children", not "childs".
-
Salaam,
I think it will be very nice if the debate can proceed without one ridiculing one's language skills, be it English or Arabic. It's unnecessary and will only make things worse.
Sorry for being off topic.
grabs a popcorn and continues watching the debate
Salaam.
-
Hi & salam
My apologies, you are right that we should not ridicule each others' language skills.
I usually don't comment on anyone's mistakes. As long as I can figure out what a person is trying to say, I see no problem with someone making grammar or spelling mistakes or whatever.
But here the poster has on repeated occasions mocked or put others down for their supposed lack of understanding Arabic. He has also said that he believes English is lacking in expressions and has used this an argument for not explaining his own arguments properly.
I find that a bit weird -- not to say arrogant -- because it is obvious that his knowledge of English is rather superficial and it is obvious that he is sometimes lacking the vocabulary to express himself properly. And this sort of attitude just rubs me the wrong way.
http//www.clicksmilies.com/s1106/teufel/devil-smiley-029.gif
-
Scientists say that 9 out of 10 gays are right handed? rotfl
Btw., it's "children", not "childs".You see your aim is not understanding neither in your hand to understand anything, I've said scientist said that 9 out 10 born are adults gays . sorry if you'll consider me rude, but I have to say the truth that you're stupid because you didn't understand that a gay is an abnormal situation of nature because of a deviation of the environment of a child, the same thing for left handed one . it's a comparison between what you said and what I said and both of the comparison show that being gay is a habit and being a left handed is a habit, so don't believe what scientists said.
one more thing about writing "childs" it's because I didn't pay attention, if you'll blame me about that, I can blame you about writing "BTW" .... o? that obviously shows that you are not deserving even knock your door.
-
I've said scientist said that 9 out 10 born are adults gays .
Erm ... no. The way you worded your post, you made it sound as if nine out of ten gays are right-handed. But m3alesh, I will refrain from making sarcastic remarks about your language skills, so let's just skip this.
I have to say the truth that you're stupid because you didn't understand that a gay is an abnormal situation of nature because of a deviation of the environment of a child
I have not said anything about gays here or in any other thread.
being gay is a habit and being a left handed is a habit, so don't believe what scientists said.
Being left-handed is not a habit. If it was only a habit, it would be possible to change it. But fact is that forcing someone to use their right hand when they are actually left-handed (or vice versa) can have very negative consequences for the individual.
I can blame you about writing "BTW" .... o?
"BTW" means "by the way". What does that have to do with you using a wrong plural form?
-
Erm ... no. The way you worded your post, you made it sound as if nine out of ten gays are right-handed. But m3alesh, I will refrain from making sarcastic remarks about your language skills, so let's just skip this.
I have not said anything about gays here or in any other thread.
Being left-handed is not a habit. If it was only a habit, it would be possible to change it. But fact is that forcing someone to use their right hand when they are actually left-handed (or vice versa) can have very negative consequences for the individual.
"BTW" means "by the way". What does that have to do with you using a wrong plural form?My discussion with you is over . try to look for a kid to play with him.
-
Alhamdullilah! yay
we wrote " " Alhamdulilah is wrong ...