Skip to content
  • Categories
  • Recent
  • Users
Skins
  • Light
  • Brite
  • Cerulean
  • Cosmo
  • Flatly
  • Journal
  • Litera
  • Lumen
  • Lux
  • Materia
  • Minty
  • Morph
  • Pulse
  • Sandstone
  • Simplex
  • Sketchy
  • Spacelab
  • United
  • Yeti
  • Zephyr
  • Dark
  • Cyborg
  • Darkly
  • Quartz
  • Slate
  • Solar
  • Superhero
  • Vapor

  • Default (No Skin)
  • No Skin
Collapse
Free Minds Forum Icon
  1. Home
  2. General Issues / Questions
  3. Questions/Comments on the Quran
  4. Prophet Muhammad (PbuH) is the "Seal/Final" (="Khatama") of (which) Prophets?

Prophet Muhammad (PbuH) is the "Seal/Final" (="Khatama") of (which) Prophets?

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Questions/Comments on the Quran
36 Posts 8 Posters 809 Views
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • I Offline
    I Offline
    Israfeel
    wrote on last edited by
    #21

    Peace Israfeel.

    How are you?

    Please explain the term . What does it mean?
    How does GOD "Yusalli" upon someone no longer alive ? What does GOD do to fulfil that?
    Thank you.
    Peace.

    Allah sends blessings upon the pious souls of the deceased, especially our beloved Prophet

    How do you explain Allah commanding the Believers to send Salawaat upon the Prophet (Sallallahu alahi wasallam)?
    If you don?t send Salawaat it means you don?t consider yourself in the category of ?Those who believe?. And that is true, people who hate the Prophet Sallallahu alaihi wasallam and refuse to send Salawaat upon him can hardly be considered Believers. And you yourself are excluding yourself from ?Those who believe? who are addressed in Surah 3356.
    Also, consider the fact that the word ?Yusalloona? is an imperfect verb, or . It means ?Verily Allah and the Mala?ikah are continuously sending blessings upon the Prophet?.

    1 Reply Last reply
    0
    • N Offline
      N Offline
      Novice
      wrote on last edited by
      #22

      Also, consider the fact that the word ?Yusalloona? is an imperfect verb, or . It means ?Verily Allah and the Mala?ikah are continuously sending blessings upon the Prophet?.

      This is Ayat 3351 Here "turji, Tashaa, tuvi, taqarra, yahzanna ..." are all imperfect verbs or . So as per your interpretation all these actions are continuously happening?

      My teacher told me never to interpret single ayat of AL-Quran without understanding the context.

      Peace.

      1 Reply Last reply
      0
      • I Offline
        I Offline
        Israfeel
        wrote on last edited by
        #23

        This is Ayat 3351 Here "turji, Tashaa, tuvi, taqarra, yahzanna ..." are all imperfect verbs or . So as per your interpretation all these actions are continuously happening?

        My teacher told me never to interpret single ayat of AL-Quran without understanding the context.

        Peace.

        Certainly your teacher is right. I too subscribe to that view. My original point is that Allah is commanding the Believers to send Salawaat upon the Prophet (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam). Someone objected that what is the point of sending Salawaat upon a deceased person. This question reveals that the questioner is someone who denies the life of the hereafter or Hayaat al-Ukhrawi. That is an atheistic or materialist view that after death a person ceases to exist. But of course Al-Quran teaches that after death a person?s existence does not cease, and the soul goes to Allah.
        Furthermore, no one could answer my argument that here Allah is commanding those who Believe to send Salawaat upon the Prophet (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam). Therefore, if someone says that he is not bound by this commandment, it means he is excluding himself from the category of ?those who believe?.

        1 Reply Last reply
        0
        • N Offline
          N Offline
          Novice
          wrote on last edited by
          #24

          Certainly your teacher is right. I too subscribe to that view. My original point is that Allah is commanding the Believers to send Salawaat upon the Prophet (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam). Someone objected that what is the point of sending Salawaat upon a deceased person. This question reveals that the questioner is someone who denies the life of the hereafter or Hayaat al-Ukhrawi. That is an atheistic or materialist view that after death a person ceases to exist. But of course Al-Quran teaches that after death a person?s existence does not cease, and the soul goes to Allah.
          Furthermore, no one could answer my argument that here Allah is commanding those who Believe to send Salawaat upon the Prophet (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam). Therefore, if someone says that he is not bound by this commandment, it means he is excluding himself from the category of ?those who believe?.

          Thank you but you did not reply to my question that does all imperfect verbs or in ayats before 3356 means continuous action till last day?

          Also how do you understand yusallimu tasleema in 465? Why sallimu has been translated different in 465 and 3356 by traditional translators?

          1 Reply Last reply
          0
          • B Offline
            B Offline
            Bender
            wrote on last edited by
            #25

            *my dear friend Bender, although your questions and words always seems
            to be very short and few in number,
            but they are very significant and deep and comprehensive in nature,
            and so they cannot be answered in the same short manner you ask them,
            so please, do me a Favor and do not ask anymore questions, for now,
            because I have to go back and do this (=73/1-9), for a specific period of time,
            and also I may have to post or reply, urgently, in some other Sections here as well,
            when I come back, we may continue as much/long as you may wish, inshaAL-LAH.

            I understand, no questions from me again!

            Allah sends blessings upon the pious souls of the deceased, especially our beloved Prophet

            How do you explain Allah commanding the Believers to send Salawaat upon the Prophet (Sallallahu alahi wasallam)?
            If you don?t send Salawaat it means you don?t consider yourself in the category of ?Those who believe?. And that is true, people who hate the Prophet Sallallahu alaihi wasallam and refuse to send Salawaat upon him can hardly be considered Believers. And you yourself are excluding yourself from ?Those who believe? who are addressed in Surah 3356.
            Also, consider the fact that the word ?Yusalloona? is an imperfect verb, or . It means ?Verily Allah and the Mala?ikah are continuously sending blessings upon the Prophet?.

            Do you have any idea why the red part is absent here if everyone has to do the sallawaat?
            472

            1 Reply Last reply
            0
            • G Offline
              G Offline
              good_logic
              wrote on last edited by
              #26

              Peace Israfeel.

              When GOD mentioned the "Nabi" in any Ayat ,it was when the Nabi was alive. When you say ,quote

              Allah sends blessings upon the pious souls of the deceased, especially our beloved Prophet

              How do you explain Allah commanding the Believers to send Salawaat upon the Prophet (Sallallahu alahi wasallam)?
              If you don?t send Salawaat it means you don?t consider yourself in the category of ?Those who believe?. And that is true, people who hate the Prophet Sallallahu alaihi wasallam and refuse to send Salawaat upon him can hardly be considered Believers. And you yourself are excluding yourself from ?Those who believe? who are addressed in Surah 3356.
              Also, consider the fact that the word ?Yusalloona? is an imperfect verb, or . It means ?Verily Allah and the Mala?ikah are continuously sending blessings upon the Prophet?.

              This tells me you do not understand what GOD is saying!!!

              GOD is asking the believers during the prophets time =i.e when he was alive!!!!- to support the prophet like GOD and His angels support the prophet and to totally submit- A total submission-.GOD is not asking us or them to parrot words that have no meanings whatsoever! Just how do you suppose GOD and His angels send "Sallawat" upon the prophet? Do you think GOD and the angels are repeating words like "Salla allahu alaihi wa sallam"?

              The same way when GOD asked the believers not to raise their voice above that of the prophet!!! Do you think GOD is asking us to do that now that the prophet is gone?

              The mind boggles at some logic and understanding of Qoran.

              However ,you can keep parroting them words if you choose to. A waste of time and effort I would say.
              GOD bless you.
              Peace

              1 Reply Last reply
              0
              • N Offline
                N Offline
                Novice
                wrote on last edited by
                #27

                Salaam Good logic

                Very well worded but it does not effect those who are "Muqallid" (blind followers of their scholars and imams) ignoring various commands in the Quraan like

                2170

                When it is said to them ?Follow what Allah has sent down,? they say ?Instead, we would follow that (religion) on which we have found our fathers.? Is it so, even though their fathers had no understanding at all, nor had they been on the right path

                5104

                When it is said to them, ?Come to what Allah has sent down, and to the Messenger;? they say, ?Sufficient for us is that on which we have found our forefathers.? Is it so, even though their forefathers knew nothing, and had no guidance either.
                (Translations are not mine)

                May Allah SWT guide us all to His straight path.

                1 Reply Last reply
                0
                • L Offline
                  L Offline
                  LastDay3
                  wrote on last edited by
                  #28

                  Brilliant!!!

                  I have also some verses for you with some of explanations

                  Jesus and The Mahdi are twins
                  1929 So she (Mary) pointed to him (Jesus). They (bad guys) said
                  "How can we talk to someone who was with The Mahdi in a cradle?"

                  Its better to spend every opportunity to witness and study the amazing moves of Michael Jordan
                  than sallaat, zakaat and good deeds
                  298 "Whoever is an enemy to God and His angels, and His messengers, and Gabriel, and Michael
                  (= His Airness, the greatest basketball player of all time), then so God is the enemy to the disbelievers."

                  there were no question here so no need to answer

                  Salaam/Peace Bender,

                  Okay, I will respect your request above and not going to answer,
                  because I know you are truly an intelligent Man and already know --(perhaps better than anyone of us here)--
                  the clear answers,
                  --(but for all of my other Friends who may still want to clearly see it, they may already be here, in my reply#14-15 above).

                  But I want to emphasize this Fact --(because many of my other Friends --especially, in my home Country--
                  still make the same mistake, again and again)

                  the root word (=ma-ha-da mahdi =19/29)
                  and
                  the root word (=ha-da-ya hadi =39/23),

                  is totally different, from the beginning. Should never be confused.

                  Remain in peace/salaam.


                  Whatever I have said that may be perfectly Correct and Right is from AL-LAH,
                  and whatever I have said that may be essentially or partially mistaken or wrong
                  may only be from my own self (shortcomings forgetfulness, hastiness, etc.) (=34/50)

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  0
                  • L Offline
                    L Offline
                    LastDay3
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #29

                    Prophet Muhammad ( &#1605 is the Last and Final Prophet to come with a Shari?ah.
                    There can come no prophet, new or old, after Prophet Muhammad ( &#1605.
                    However, there can come within the Ummah such saintly figures who are conversant with Allah ( &#1604,
                    known as Muhaddathun and Mukallamun. In Sufi terminology, such individuals who are honored
                    with communication by Allah ( &#1604 are ?prophets? in a figurative sense.
                    They project within themselves the characteristics of the Nubuwwah of Prophet Muhammad ( &#1605.
                    However, they do not possess any independent Nubuwwah, but are only reflecting or are a projection
                    of the Nubuwwah of Prophet Muhammad
                    That is the true significance of Khatam an-Nubuwwah

                    Salaam/Peace be upon you, too, Israfeel,

                    many of those "assumptions" you have made or referred to above
                    are essentially and totally baseless, in my understanding,
                    because I have clearly presented those most Essential and clear Verses here

                    =QURAN TESTAMENT 3/81 = 33/7-8
                    --(*please, carefully see it again, as it is clearly and openly presented in the very first posts above)--
                    which clearly and unmistakably proves that

                    there will come a "Messenger (=Rasool) / MESSAGE of the Covenant" after Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon Him),

                    and Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon Him) himself knows it very well, from within QURAN, and
                    especially by the Perfect Explanation of AL-LAH, unto him, from the beginning, therein
                    (=Sura, Qiyamah, Verses 17-19)
                    and thus makes most Miraculous and clear Predictions about this
                    most Critical and important "Messenger (=Rasool) / MESSAGE of the Covenant"
                    (*please, absolutely see those most Miraculous and clear Predictions as they are clearly and openly presented
                    in the previous posts above),

                    that no excuse shall never be accepted in the Sight of AL-LAH,
                    because this is absolutely the most Important "Covenant" in the history of Religion,
                    and those who would fail to fulfill this "Covenant" in this Final Age now,
                    will thus regret it, forever, therein

                    =QURAN TESTAMENT 3/81 = 33/7-8
                    --(*please, carefully see it again, as it is clearly and openly presented in the very first posts above)--

                    So here are some other most Essential and clear QURANIC Verses,
                    in this regard here

                    ==========
                    27- And that Day the unjust-one will bite on his/her two-hands and say
                    I wish I had taken the Path (of QURAN TESTAMENT above) with the "Messenger" (=i.e. that
                    long awaited and anticipated "Messenger (=Rasool) / MESSAGE of the Covenant" above).

                    28- Woe to me, I wish I did not take so and so as a friend!

                    29- Because he/she has led me away from the "Reminder" (="Dhikr"
                    a most specific reference to these "19" coded, "Symmetrical Miracles" which are specifically called
                    "Dhikr/Dhikra" here, in the first place 39/"23" = 74/26-30, "31")-- after it came to me.
                    Indeed, the Satan (ultimately) lets down his human victims.

                    30- And the "Messenger" (=i.e. that long awaited and anticipated "Messenger (=Rasool) / MESSAGE of
                    the Covenant" again above) said

                    My LORD, my people have deserted this QURAN --(which strongly and unmistakably emphasizes
                    the Essential Importance of these "19" coded, "Symmetrical Miracles" which are specifically called
                    "Dhikr/Dhikra" here, in the first place, for/in this Final Age now

                    74/26-30, "31"-32-33-34-35-36-37-38-39-40)!

                    31- It is such that We make for every "Informer" (=i.e. also for that long awaited and anticipated
                    "Messenger (=Rasool) / MESSAGE of the Covenant" above)-- rivals from among the criminals.

                    Your LORD will suffice --thus especially, due to on the left side of those "19" coded Tables
                    above now =29/47-- as a "Best-GUIDE", and --due to on the right side of those "19" coded Tables
                    above now =29/49-- as a "Best-HELPER!"

                    QURAN TESTAMENT 25/27-31

                    ==========
                    Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon Him) said

                    ...... Then the black banners will come from the East, and they will kill you (=i.e. humanity)
                    in an unprecedented manner (therein).
                    (*Who could be these People with black banners that would make terror their business,
                    blasphemously and wrongfully using the name of Religion and committing such Gross Sins therein now? =2/205-206)

                    ...... Then Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon Him) said
                    "When you see him --(in those times, strongly condemning all such Gross Sins above =2/205-206
                    and calling them urgently to repent and reform themselves immediately =25/68-71, 72-76)--

                    then pledge your allegiance to him even if you have to crawl over the snow,
                    for that is the Servant of AL-LAH, "Mahdee" (=i.e. that long awaited and anticipated
                    "Messenger (=Rasool) / MESSAGE of the Covenant" above).

                    Sunan Ibn Majah, Book 36, Hadith 159

                    As it has clearly and strongly been emphasized, many times, in the previous posts

                    In essence, the One and Only "Mahdee" is "QURAN TESTAMENT"

                    specifically with its "19" coded, "Symmetrical Miracles" with which our Lord AL-LAH

                    will thus perfectly "Guide" (="Yahdee") all of HIS truthful Servants to the Path of Ultimate Security/Peace/Serenity (=5/16),
                    in this Final Age now

                    ="QURAN TESTAMENT" 74/26-30, "31")!

                    Remain in peace/salaam.


                    Whatever I have said that may be perfectly Correct and Right is from AL-LAH,
                    and whatever I have said that may be essentially or partially mistaken or wrong
                    may only be from my own self (shortcomings forgetfulness, hastiness, etc.) (=34/50)

                    1 Reply Last reply
                    0
                    • M Offline
                      M Offline
                      Mazhar
                      wrote on last edited by
                      #30

                      Thank you but you did not reply to my question that does all imperfect verbs or in ayats before 3356 means continuous action till last day?

                      Also how do you understand yusallimu tasleema in 465? Why sallimu has been translated different in 465 and 3356 by traditional translators?

                      Therefore; your Sustainer Lord swears; they will not believe in the manner acceptable to Allah the Exalted until and unless they might consider and make you the Messenger judge-authority-ruler to decide in matters that have become hardened belief like entrenched tree amongst them.

                      Afterwards; they would not find hesitative embarrassment in their thoughts about what you the Messenger had ruled-decided in accordance with the Grand Qur'aan .

                      And they will not be considered as believers unless they might pay you obeisance and salutations; respectfully dignifying.

                      Ayah 459-70

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      0
                      • N Offline
                        N Offline
                        Novice
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #31

                        Therefore; your Sustainer Lord swears; they will not believe in the manner acceptable to Allah the Exalted until and unless they might consider and make you the Messenger judge-authority-ruler to decide in matters that have become hardened belief like entrenched tree amongst them.

                        Afterwards; they would not find hesitative embarrassment in their thoughts about what you the Messenger had ruled-decided in accordance with the Grand Qur'aan .

                        And they will not be considered as believers unless they might pay you obeisance and salutations; respectfully dignifying.

                        Ayah 459-70

                        Salaam Mazhar

                        I respect your interpretation because everyone has the right to have his understanding. The context in red gives me the sense of submission and not salutation. Here are some interpretations at quranix.org

                        465
                        465 fla wrbk la yamnwn Hty yHkmwk fyma jr bynhm m la yjdwa fy anfshm Hrja mma qDyt wyslmwa tslyma
                        Transcription (English)
                        465 Fala warabbika la yu/minoona hattayuhakkimooka feema shajara baynahum thumma layajidoo fee anfusihim harajan mimma qadaytawayusallimoo tasleeman
                        Edip-Layth (Quran A Reformist Translation)
                        465 No, by your Lord, they will not acknowledge until they make you judge in what they dispute with each other, then they will not find in their persons any animosity for what you have decided, and they will yield completely.25
                        The Monotheist Group (The Quran A Monotheist Translation)
                        465 No, by your Lord, they will not believe until they make you judge in what they dispute with each other, then they will not find in their souls any animosity for what you have decided, and they will comply completely.
                        Muhammad Asad (The Message Of Quran)
                        465 But nay, by thy Sustainer! They do not believe unless they make thee a judge of all on which they disagree among themselves, and then find in their hearts no bar to an acceptance of thy decision and give themselves up in utter self-surrender.84
                        Rashad Khalifa (The Final Testament)
                        465 Never indeed, by your Lord; they are not believers unless they come to you to judge in their disputes, then find no hesitation in their hearts whatsoever in accepting your judgment. They must submit a total submission.,
                        Shabbir Ahmed (Quran As It Explains Itself)
                        465 By your Lord, they do not really believe unless they make you (O Messenger) a judge in all their disagreements, then find no hesitation in their hearts in accepting your judgment, and submit with full submission.

                        And this is how greeting is used in the Al-Quran

                        (4863) bitaiyyatin with a greeting
                        (10105) wataiyyatuhum And their greeting
                        (142315) taiyyatuhum their greetings
                        (246164) taiyyatan a greeting
                        (2575 taiyyatan (with) greetings
                        (33441) taiyyatuhum Their greetings

                        No offence to your understanding. May Allah SWT guide us to good understanding of His Book.

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        0
                        • M Offline
                          M Offline
                          Mazhar
                          wrote on last edited by
                          #32

                          465 No, by your Lord, they will not acknowledge until they make you judge in what they dispute with each other, then they will not find in their persons any animosity for what you have decided, and they will yield completely.25

                          A critical read will reveal it is rather meaningless and quite vague a statement.

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          0
                          • M Offline
                            M Offline
                            Man_of_Faith
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #33

                            The only meaning of khatam is not end or seal (as in the end). Search etymologically. Do not just outright believe common dogma.

                            Khatam can also refer to the effect or imprint someone or something has. In your narrow scope we can speak of the passage saying "Allah" put a "seal" on their hearts, hearing or eyesight, but it could also be afflicted with, i.e. they were afflicted/affected in their heart, hearing and eyesight.

                            Be well
                            Amenuel

                            1 Reply Last reply
                            0
                            • L Offline
                              L Offline
                              LastDay3
                              wrote on last edited by
                              #34

                              The only meaning of khatam is not end or seal (as in the end). Search etymologically.
                              Do not just outright believe common dogma.

                              Khatam can also refer to the effect or imprint someone or something has.
                              In your narrow scope we can speak of the passage saying "Allah" put a "seal" on their hearts, hearing or eyesight,
                              but it could also be afflicted with, i.e. they were afflicted/affected in their heart, hearing and eyesight.

                              Salaam/Peace MoF,

                              in my understanding, "kha-ta-ma" essentially means the "final/seal/end" of something,
                              as we can clearly see it in QURAN TESTAMENT, here

                              if there is "kha-ta-ma" set on the "hearts" or "ears," that is the "final/seal/end" of it,
                              from that point on, canNot "comprehend," canNot "hear" nothing anymore ...... (=2/7, .....)

                              if there is "kha-ta-ma" set on the "mouths," that is the "final/seal/end" of it,
                              from that point on, canNot "talk" nothing anymore ...... (=36/65, ....)

                              if there is "khi-ta-ma" set in a cup of "drink," that is the "final/seal/end" of it,
                              from that point on, canNot be "drunk" anymore, it is already finished therein ...... (=83/26, ....)

                              So, if there is "kha-ta-ma" set on a specific line of Prophets, that is the "final/seal/end" of it,
                              from that point on, no other Prophet canNot come anymore therein ...... (=33/40, ....)

                              In this respect, Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon Him) is clearly the "khatama" (="final/seal/end&quot of the Prophets
                              coming from this specific Ancestral Line of "Ishmael, Al-Yasa, Dha Al-Kifl", from the beginning,
                              therein

                              QURAN TESTAMENT 33/40 = 2/127-129 = 38/48
                              (*please, absolutely see these Verses, clearly and openly, in the very first posts above)

                              And Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon Him) clearly and unmistakably confirms it
                              in one of his authentic Message here

                              ==========
                              Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon Him) said

                              And indeed there shall be thirty imposters in/among my "Ummah" (=i.e. in/among "Children of Ishmael" living
                              in Makkah and Arabia therein =Sura Baqarah, Ayat 127-129)-- each of them claiming that he is a Prophet.

                              And I am the "khatama" (="final/seal/end&quot of the Prophets, there is no Prophet after me" --(from this
                              specific Ancestral Line of "Ishmael, Al-Yasa, Dha Al-Kifl", from the beginning, therein
                              =Sura Baqarah, Ayat 127-129 = Sad, Ayat 48)

                              Tirmidhi, Book 33, Hadith 62

                              But on the other hand, "Messenger-Prophet" (="Rasoolan-Nabiyyan" =19/51) can still come
                              from this other specific Ancestral Line of "Abraham, Isaac, Jacob", from the beginning,
                              therein

                              QURAN TESTAMENT 29/27 = 38/45-47
                              (*please, absolutely see these Verses, clearly and openly, in the very first posts above)

                              And Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon Him) also knows this Fact very well therein,
                              by the QURANIC Inspiration and Perfect-Explanation of AL-LAH unto him therein
                              (=Sura Ali Imran, Ayat 81 = Ahzab, Ayat 7-8), from the beginning, therein,
                              and so, clearly and unmistakably informs about it in his authentic Messages.
                              (*please, absolutely see it, clearly and openly, again in the very first posts above)

                              Remain in peace/salaam.

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              0
                              • M Offline
                                M Offline
                                Man_of_Faith
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #35

                                That means you outright buy the story of the clergymen who interpreted it. You do not realize that book has been in the hands of a clergy for centuries?

                                If you are the slightest source critical you can search in generic Classical Arabic lexicons to find alternative meanings to pretty much every Arabic word. If you were, you would discover that Quran is a jungle of misinterpreted words misused in translation and interpretation. It is to the level that entire segments of text say something vastly different to what is presented.

                                Besides, you surely have never reflected upon the Arabic word 'nabi' and its true meaning. Prophet is a quite weak translation and its best translation I know of is 'insightful'. It is not some magical title but the scripture uses it to present when a certain person is particularly insightful into the 'Deen' of God. Anyone sufficiently enlightened can be a 'Nabi' which you call a prophet. If you say there is no 'nabi' from 1400 years ago and until now then that means you say people are entirely in the shadows (which I can agree on though for most people). If a person grasps the truth behind faith and acts accordingly that means automatically that the person is nabi, no matter what any person says. But if a person claims to be insightful but he actually is not, he is a false 'nabi'. The word's secondary meaning implying that the person is fairly wise.

                                But if you would like to live in your little delusion feel free to. And in ways you idolize the one you call Muhammad too, or rather the clergymen who can be seen as the author of the tales of Muhammad.

                                Human worship is the most dumbening factor for themselves, making humans reject all logic and rationality for a cheap tale.

                                Be well
                                Amenuel

                                1 Reply Last reply
                                0
                                • L Offline
                                  L Offline
                                  LastDay3
                                  wrote on last edited by
                                  #36

                                  That means you outright buy the story of the clergymen who interpreted it.
                                  You do not realize that book has been in the hands of a clergy for centuries?

                                  If you are the slightest source critical you can search in generic Classical Arabic lexicons to find alternative meanings
                                  to pretty much every Arabic word. If you were, you would discover that Quran is a jungle of misinterpreted words
                                  misused in translation and interpretation.
                                  It is to the level that entire segments of text say something vastly different to what is presented.

                                  Salaam/Peace MoF,

                                  first of all, our Lord AL-LAH has sent down QURAN TESTAMENT in such a perfectly

                                  "clear" (in Arabic "mubeen") language that we may easily and unmistakably comprehend it (=12/1-2),
                                  that only such betrayers would try to distort or reject the essential perfect meaning of those
                                  crystal clear Verses here (=41/40 & 2/99),

                                  and

                                  "straightforward" (in Arabic "qayyiman") with no "ambiguity/flaw/discrepancy" (="iwajan") in it, at all,

                                  this also means each and every "Word" mentioned in QURAN TESTAMENT
                                  always has one essential perfect spelling and meaning (*which is almost always the first meaning recited in all credible
                                  classical Arabic Lexicons)

                                  --(no one can never change any of those "Words" of/in QURAN TESTAMENT
                                  with regard to their essential perfect spelling and meaning, never =6/115)--

                                  that everyone who knows basic Arabic could clearly, unmistakably and easily witness and understand it therein,
                                  in the time it was first revealed, and also thereafter in all Ages, generation after generation, to the Day of Resurrection,
                                  here (=43/2-3 = 62/2-4).

                                  And because of this perfect Property of QURAN TESTAMENT above, it is always perfectly Protected by our Lord AL-LAH
                                  thus both in their essential perfect spelling and meaning therein =6/115, from the very beginning to the very end.
                                  (*Otherwise, all deluded or crooked persons would come up and easily deceive everyone
                                  with speculative meanings (=i.e. generally secondary, tertiary meanings) from within many man-made crazy Lexicons all around.
                                  Many impostors already came up in the previous centuries and attempted to do it ........)

                                  And in this respect, when we carefully looked into that specific root word "kha-ta-ma" throughout the
                                  whole QURAN TESTAMENT above,
                                  we have clearly witnessed this one essential perfect meaning therein (=i.e. "seal/final/end&quot
                                  --without any exception-- perfectly in all of those occurrences therein. (*Please, clearly see it again in the previous post)

                                  And thereby thus we have clearly and unmistakably understood that Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon Him)
                                  was/is indeed "kha-ta-ma" (=i.e. "seal/final/end&quot of the Prophets --(specifically, in the Ancestral line of
                                  "Ishmael & Al-Yasa & Dha Al-Kifl" therein; *please, clearly see it again in the previous post)--

                                  And then Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon Him) himself clearly and unmistakably confirmed it
                                  that no other Prophet would never come, after him therein, in one of his authentic Message above. (*Please, absolutely
                                  see the authenticity and importance of such perfect-explanations (=litubayyina) of QURAN
                                  by Prophet Muhammad (PbuH) specifically for/unto his own Nation =i.e. "Children of Ishmael" living in Makkah and Arabia
                                  therein Sura Baqarah 127-129 = Nahl 43-44 = Shoora 7 = ..................
                                  again in the previous posts above.)

                                  Besides, you surely have never reflected upon the Arabic word 'nabi' and its true meaning.
                                  Prophet is a quite weak translation and its best translation I know of is 'insightful'.
                                  It is not some magical title but the scripture uses it to present when a certain person is particularly
                                  insightful into the 'Deen' of God. Anyone sufficiently enlightened can be a 'Nabi' which you call a prophet.
                                  If you say there is no 'nabi' from 1400 years ago and until now then that means you say people are entirely
                                  in the shadows (which I can agree on though for most people). If a person grasps the truth behind faith
                                  and acts accordingly that means automatically that the person is nabi, no matter what any person says.
                                  But if a person claims to be insightful but he actually is not, he is a false 'nabi'. The word's secondary meaning
                                  implying that the person is fairly wise.

                                  But if you would like to live in your little delusion feel free to. .........

                                  It is already perfectly Explained by our Lord AL-LAH in such a straightforward and clear manner
                                  in QURAN TESTAMENT here again (75/17-19 = 2/99 = 54/17 = ......)
                                  what the "Naba" and "Nabi" means, from the very beginning.

                                  But I still generally prefer to say "Prophet," because everyone easily and clearly understands what I mean,
                                  because if I say (="Information-Giver" or "Informer") it would require extra explanation, and it would be a distraction
                                  from the most important Issue above.

                                  But now, we should absolutely and clearly see it in QURAN TESTAMENT here

                                  ==========
                                  21- Did the "Information" (=in arabic "Naba") come to you of/about the disputing party when they
                                  came over into the Sanctuary? (=38/21)

                                  51- And "give-Information-to-them" (=in arabic "Nabbihum") of/about the guests of Abraham. (=15/51)

                                  So thus whoever comes with a specific "Information" (=in arabic "Naba") from AL-LAH
                                  is rightfully called an "Information-Giver" (=in arabic "Nabi"), in the first place.

                                  And in this general/broad sense above, each and every Believer who delivers a perfect "Information" (=in arabic "Naba")
                                  from within The Scripture unto other people is such a regular "Information-Giver" (=in arabic "Nabi") to them,
                                  for/in that particular situation.
                                  In this general/broad sense again, all Believers who have been murdered by such barbaric rejecters
                                  were such truthful Believers and regular "Information-Givers" (=in arabic "Nabiyyeen") to them,
                                  e.g. as indicated in this Verse (=3/21).

                                  So, again in this general/broad sense above, each and every Believer, in our Age now, is
                                  such a regular "Information-Giver" (=in arabic "Nabi"),
                                  as long as they truthfully deliver a perfect "Information" (=in arabic "Naba") from within The Scripture unto
                                  all people therein.

                                  But in particular/specific sense, only a Person who comes with a new "Scripture = whole Information"
                                  (=in arabic "Naba") from AL-LAH can rightfully be called such a specific "Information-Giver" (=in arabic "Nabi"), (=19/30)

                                  and in this particular/specific sense, Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon Him) was/is indeed
                                  "kha-ta-ma" (=i.e. "seal/final/end&quot of such specific "Information-Givers" (=in arabic "Nabiyyeen")
                                  --(exclusively, in the Ancestral line of "Ishmael & Al-Yasa & Dha Al-Kifl" therein above)--

                                  because there will be no one who can come, after him, with another new "Scripture = whole Information"
                                  (=in arabic "Naba") from AL-LAH, therein.

                                  But if you would like to live in your little delusion feel free to. .........

                                  I always like to totally get rid of all kinds of delusions, they should never manipulate or rule over me,
                                  for that reason I always wholeheartedly and strongly recommend unto my self, and to you, MoF, and to all of
                                  my other Friends here, and everywhere,

                                  always to hold fast to the Scripture (=QURAN TESTAMENT), from the very beginning, Steadfastly and Rightfully,
                                  always and forever, here (7/196 = 35/29-30 = 6/114-115).

                                  Remain in peace/salaam.

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  0
                                  Reply
                                  • Reply as topic
                                  Log in to reply
                                  • Oldest to Newest
                                  • Newest to Oldest
                                  • Most Votes


                                  • Login

                                  • Don't have an account? Register

                                  • Login or register to search.
                                  • First post
                                    Last post
                                  0
                                  • Categories
                                  • Recent
                                  • Users