What Constitutes a Muslim?
-
SaLaM progod
No brother i AM agreeing with you. When a christian is completely devoted to his/her God ( i.e Jesus or Mary or the trinity etc... ) then you CAN call that christian a muslim. Even Jews are muslim. Lollllllll hahahhhhh this is funny loooooooooooooooooollllllll
-
Salaam,
You cannot pray to a human and especially not a human who isn't here on earth.
God is the only ONE we can and shall pray to.
He is our creator and we are his creations.
Peace
Sis MajidahPs. prayings to Jesus,Mary,Muhammad etc are uselessD.s
-
Salaam Elena,
I'm aware of that sister!
And it makes me more thankful to Allah that I have opened my yes for the truth and not follow old hearsays.
The Bible have been so manipulated so I'm afraid that all is hearsays or the most of it is.
Peace
Sis Majidah -
-
You can see well in the Arabic that where the word 'Islam(submission/compliance)' is used the object of that compliance is stated in the context. Most times in the Koran it is to God. But in one context it is to Solomon, where Sheba complied/showed submissiveness to Solomon.
D
-
SaLaM Elena
I liked ur 2 green lemon pic more. Yea sunnis pray to Prophet Muhammad all the time. Not like praying to God. But like, they pray to him to intercede for them. Do u understand? So if i was a sunni, i would pray to Prophet Muhammad to ask God to forgive me. That kind of pray. http//www.geocities.com/bigjaxal/s1.gif
-
Salaam Elena,
It's true what Br Jaxal is saying, there are muslims who pray to Muhammad but they don't admit it.
I can take some examples, in their daily 5 times salat they always greet the prophet even if it is GOD they alone should greet.
And some muslims are celebrating the birthday of the prophet and there they use to sing hymns to the prophet and it goes like this I guess.
Sallalahu alaihi wa salaam sallalahu wa alaihi Muhammad
Peace
Sis Majidah -
Salaam Majiidah
The Bible have been so manipulated so I'm afraid that all is hearsays or the most of it is.
Well u have the "Al-Furqon" (The Criterion) now... which has been prophesied in Isaiah 2911-12 as the "book with seal". U can read the bible and easily detect which part/verses are the truth, and which are from the serpent's.
As Peter said
"They (verses on the scriptures) do not lead astray, but convict and bring to light the evil disposition against God which lurks like a serpent in each one. For the Scriptures lie before each one like many divers types. Each one, then, has his own disposition like wax."It's true what Br Jaxal is saying, there are muslims who pray to Muhammad but they don't admit it.
I'm starting to grasp why prophet Muhammad add an extra sentence to the 'proclamation of faith' (Jews had The Shema Deu 64)
The 'original' shahada might be somewhat like this
-
Laa Illaha Illa Allah - There's no God (Illah) but The God (Allah)
U can find similar verse in Deu 57 3212, 3239 -
Muhammad Rasullullah Wa Abduhu - Muhammad (was no more than) Allah's messenger and servant.
(I use this kind of shahadah in my shalat)
I think the second sentence was 'made' / commanded by prophet Muhammad to make it clear and certain that
"I (Muhammad) am 100% human being, not God, Semi-God nor Divine or intercessor for any of u in front of Allah, do not idolize nor worship me, and please pray and worship directly to Allah only"The concept of "intercession to God" not only contradict the Quran, it also contradict the Bible
Deu 57 Thou shalt have none other gods before My face.
Praying in Judaism is considered as "standing / speaking in front/before His face".And praising to other than 'The He' is also forbidden
Isa 428 I am the LORD(YHVH), that is My name; and My glory will I not give to another, neither My praise to graven images.
-
-
Salaam Br Jafar,
I didn't say that everything in the Bible were hearsays but when I compare the Bible with Al-Quran i get the feeling it is a tale because there are so many persons addressed and long stories of what people said and did, not at all like Al-Quran as I see as a more respected Scripture already from the first time I read in it.
My shahada if I really must call it a shahada it goes only LA ILA HA IL ALLAH.
Why must mention others beside Allah!?
Peace
Sis Majidah -
My shahada if I really must call it a shahada it goes only LA ILA HA IL ALLAH.
Why do you mean by shahada and why do you say it?
-
Salaam,
Well a shahada is some kind of witness that you have faith in God.
But as I said I don't think this is something you have to practise.
The only witness you need is God.
Peace
Sis Majidah -
Salaamun alaikum,
Majidah is rightWell a shahada is some kind of witness that you have faith in God.
But as I said I don't think this is something you have to practise.
The only witness you need is God.
Al-Quraan says Allah bears witness that there is no god except him, as do the malaika and THOSE WITH KNOWLEDGE....(3/18 )
So it seems that we don't need to SAY shahada at all, as long as we have the right knowledge (al-ilm) , we'll beat witness that Allah is one.
-
peace,
as far as I can understand "Muslim" is just an arabic word which means "submitter" in english. what matters most is to what we are becoming "muslim/submitter" to.
Its just like saying " I am a believer"
BUT
Believer to what ???
In the same way...we are muslim to what ??
I think just by saying..I am a muslim doesnt mean anything specific.
peace
-
What Constitutes a Muslim?
Here is a list for discussion on what you may think constitutes a Muslim
- Believing in and upholding the commands of 6151-153.
- Believing in and upholding all the social and legal laws of the Quran as per 37.
- Believing that the traditional interpretations and rituals must be followed.
- Believing in the Quran's text (word for word, verse for verse).
- Believing that messengers will come after Mohammed.
- Believing in the number 19 as a sign of the Quran.
- Believing that 2 verses (128&129) must be removed from the Quran.
Well, a muslim is a state of mind and is nothing that one can achieve by believing in things and thereby become in a mental state. Nowhere in the qur'aan is the word "muslim" mentioned other than presented as itself, explaining itself. There is no implacation that there would be a sense to it other than "in peace " or that the use of muslim is exclusivly revolving around the theology of the arabs and its record in the qur'aan.
Lots of love!
/St?phane -
In simple words, a Muslim is one who declares that ?there is no God but Allah, and Muhammad is the messenger of Allah?. This automatically gives a social passport and acceptance to the individual by the rest of the Islamic mobs. It seems that this strategy (foot in the door) perfectly worked among the Bedouin. In away it reflects human submission to the will of one without rationalising or justifying their authority.
If we look deeply, we can easily see that such submissive slogans worked and played crucial rolls in mob psychology. For instance, it?s natural that most human have a need for religiosity in most societies. (If there ever was a God, as it is introduced in the Semitic literature, which appeared from the clouds, I am sure even an extreme atheist will submit to his/her rules.) But this is just a catch 22 used by the Semitic dogma. It needs such slogans to reinforce the submissive behaviour upon the individual and it has two purposes. First, it arouses our religiosity needs in us by introducing God as the ultimate truth and power. This is quite ok as all humans have a need to submit to a higher being. But the real catch is the acceptance and adherences to of the middleman or in this case the Semitic prophets (in away a foot in the door stragety is used!).
In the case of Islam, it is quite obvious that all the other Semitic prophets are considered at the lower end of the ladder but Muhammad is the last and best and that?s why it?s absolutely necessary for any one to declare his or her kalima in the first instance to be considered a Muslim (so he or she is Islamically shaped and framed by way of social pressure).
The rest of the Semitic dogma is often followed by a mix bag of goodies, bigotry, ambiguity and common knowledge that all knew many years prior to Islam, i.e how clouds appears, or driven by the wind, or that rain drops from the sky, or that everything is found in pairs, etc..This was all known to man ever since man stood and pondered about it. Even some animals can sense when it rains and thus take shelter under trees or in caves.
So at the end of the day the zillion dollar question still remains. ?What constitutes a Muslim, Christian or Jew?? Well, in this case, your guess is just as good as mine! You don?t have to be a rocket scientist to figure it out! All we need is a free and rational mind to discover the truth and thus God.
Peace
