Who is Isra'iil إِسْرَائِيلَ
-
Oh they can be banu 'israiil all right, but they are not the onl banu israaill, they are the banu israail, of that episode. It is like who is the murderer en an episode or one of the murderers. But the thing is from the point of view that they are spokin of, they are not may be from hte point of vie of being musa's people or descendants of so and so, but as banu israail, those who are succeding some people who started a night journey and that now are lost in the night.
That is at least hat I get from the whole thing.
Salaam
-
Salaam, good logic,
I am going to take advantage of your patience once more.
Do you recall anywhere in the narration of Musa and his people that they did leave in the night. I have the impression that no particula hour or time is metionned, but I do not want to overlook anything.
Thank you again for your patience
Salaam
-
Peace huruf.
I was just indicating that Moses and Aaron were asking this (from Firoun)
2617
Beni Israeel existed before this
2622
But you are right this also happened after
2652GOD bless you.
Peace. -
Peace All.
So who are these Beni-Israeel?
1- 240
GOD made a covenant with them.
2-
Chosen people?
3-
They are Moses Quawm-People"
4 -
Here in the above verse GOD took the covenant with them.
5-
GOD is still addressing Beni Israeel here sending Moses and Jesus to them.
6-These must have been the people living with Moses and Aaron in Misr?
GOD bless.
Peace.Salaam bro
Really i don't see any problem
banu israel represents the people misguided by israel that is priesthood.
Allah sent many messengers to this people. that is a great gift from Allah and that's why it is logical Allah describe them as preferred to other people.
it is because he choose them for the great saga of prohets (from Abraham to muhammad)other people, let says chinese, had some prophets, but it is a discontinued serie of epides and not a saga.
i think the quranic word for "saga" is taour(َ . . . . . . . .
that is step by step, period after period and not a mountain like it used to be translated.
for example, my people(qawm) is "banu israel" since they believe in oulemas. But i am no more. Allah freed me from Israel and his bullshit.
my omma is not not my qawm. Oumma is spiritually linked
Perhaps, one day, Allah will say to me "Hey noshirk, go to president of republic and ask him to arsil bani israel wih you". Or perhaps he will call them banu muslim and bukhari.
it the president accepts, il will teach what Allah teached to me purified from priesthood bullshit. Since i will be rassool, it is logical to say "arsil bani israel with me".
but i don't think he will accepet. he will says "i am who decide who is teached or not in my country" which is equivalent to " i am your greatest rabb".Banu israel are neither good or bad people. i have many banu israel in my family. They beliveve in hadiths bukhari and muslim and sira of ibn hicham.
israel is a bad guy/people. Israel are ribbiyouns eating riba to do rabb in place of the true rabbarsil doesnt mean let me travel with them to another country. A serious study of quran shows that the land inherited by the followers of Musa is land of Firaoun.
it is an israel teachning who says that people moussa were allowed by Allah to attack other countries and take their land.There is something you have to always remember. There is only one deen. Judaism, and christianism don't exist for Allah. Judaism, christianism, and actual islam are sects of what Allah call islam. So there is no reason that "banu israel" concept is limited to judaism or people of Moses.
Peace
-
Peace noshirk.
there are plenty of theories, history for exampleThe Bene Israel, formerly known in India as the "Shanivar Teli" caste and later as the "Native Jew Caste", are a historic community of Jews in India. It has been suggested that it is made up of descendants of one of the disputed Lost Tribes and ancestors who had settled there centuries ago. In the 19th century, after the people were taught about normative Judaism, they tended to migrate from villages in the Konkan area to the nearby cities, primarily Mumbai, but also to Pune, Ahmedabad, and Kolkata, India; and Karachi, in today's Pakistan. Many gained positions with the British colonial authority of the period.
Or
https//www.benisrael.org/
Or
Some verses of Quran use the word (Jews), while other use (Children of Israeel). Apparently they seem to be pointing to the same group of people. But God does not do say anything without a purpose and indeed they should be some difference.
So what are the differences between these two group of people?
There are many verses that use both the terms. And they can be found in Qoran.
etc....
For me. like sister huruf I take what Qoran says.
But the main task from Qoran from what I can make out is to lead my life according to the instruction of Qoran. To do my best to follow the best advice from Qoran.
Things like who are beni Israeel? who has done what?...Are not my priority although I do not mind others searching and looking. I read with an open mind
I was quoting verses from Qoran, others can make of them what they want.
Thank you for your posts.
GOD bless you.
Peace. -
How can we say that other people have not been favoured with prophets? What do we know about 99,99% of traditions are cultures that are not the homologised judeo-christian cum islamic and a little of indian-budist lore?
We do not know a damned thing and we affirm they have this or the have it not. We do not even know our on ancestors before christianity or greco-roman lore did away with all religious traditions in Europe and other places before them.
I have studied a little of aztecs and they indeed had prophets and they indeed had a religion which was completely sure of peoples ties with God to a depth as I have not seen anywhere else.And we speak of a chosen people? All people are chosen. That tribe has so many prophets, very likely because they needed them and any other triby that should need God would give, because God is merciful beyond our imagination. And do we know that no tribe in the world had as many? we certainly do not know. "Judeo-Christian" culture as they call a certain mindset now poses as the all-knower and judge of everything, because hat they do not kno of,simply does not exist, it is the universal pin-roller of anything that it does not overlords. It misses a lot doing so.
Salaam
-
Sister huruf.
Of course in real terms the chosen people are those that choose right from wrong and apply it in their life.
But also GOD creates what He wills and chooses. We can all do with a little or big help from GOD.
Mind you do we really have a choice? Right from wrong ?
Well even our instinct is telling us there is only one winner!
GOD bless you.
Peace. -
How can we say that other people have not been favoured with prophets? What do we know about 99,99% of traditions are cultures that are not the homologised judeo-christian cum islamic and a little of indian-budist lore?
Salaam
1047 And for every nation is a messenger; so when their messenger comes, the matter is decreed between them with justice, and they are not wronged.that is not the question
the fact is that there is only one saga similar to the saga from Noah to Muhammad
the fact is that there is only one book called Quran it seems that it will be the "last book" that will dominate "other books"619 He is the One who sent His messenger with the guidance and the system of truth, so that it will expose all other systems, even if the polytheists hate it.
Seems that Allah send isolated messengers from time to time to other people.
But no as form of Saga over thousand years.
i checked the "99,99% of traditions are cultures that are not the homologised judeo-christian cum islamic and a little of indian-budist lore" and i found no such millenary saga there.i repeat.
on the footsteps of each messenger sent by Allah, grows a priesthood from the darkness sent secretly by chaytan and called Israel.
if no messenger then no israel and no banu israel.6112 And as such, We have permitted the enemies of every prophet ? mankind and Jinn devils ? to inspire each other with fancy words in order to deceive. Had your Lord willed, they would not have done it. You shall disregard them and their fabrications.
2252 And We did not send before you any messenger or prophet, without having the devil interfere with his wishes. God then duplicates what the devil has cast, and God secures His revelations. And God is Knower, Wise.
that is false "prophethood", that is "priesthood", that is Israel. Victims are banu Israel who eats their rubbish.
And like brother Pazuzu would have said, all history written by Israel is lies, lies, lies and lies...
From Jerusalem To Mecca, all is lies.
that is the job of Isra-el, sons of Ibliss.Peace
-
I agree with Pazuzu's work on the matters he dealt with, except for the flat earth, that for me is not in question.
But I do not see why it has to be that saga of prophets. Of course youd do not know the 99,99% nobody does, in particular because if has been hidden, for ancient people since a long time ago.
And it dpeends on hat you call prophets or warners or what you do not.
Nor are youg iving any explanation for the saga. You talk about priests and I dop not kno whether hat you intend is to say that the prophets are sent to undo the priesthood or what.
For me 'israa'iil doe snot need a lot of explanation, the words say it all. As to banu 'israa'iil those are the successors of the 'israa'iil spirituality, many a time corrupting or undoing it, which is why they get again warners against that. Whether the corruption consists in establishing a vested interest priesthood or not, is a detail. That may be a kid of corruption not necessarily the only one. The lust for power may be another.
Salaam
-
Peace noshirk.
there are plenty of theories, history for exampleThe Bene Israel, formerly known in India as the "Shanivar Teli" caste and later as the "Native Jew Caste", are a historic community of Jews in India. It has been suggested that it is made up of descendants of one of the disputed Lost Tribes and ancestors who had settled there centuries ago. In the 19th century, after the people were taught about normative Judaism, they tended to migrate from villages in the Konkan area to the nearby cities, primarily Mumbai, but also to Pune, Ahmedabad, and Kolkata, India; and Karachi, in today's Pakistan. Many gained positions with the British colonial authority of the period.
Or
https//www.benisrael.org/
Or
Some verses of Quran use the word (Jews), while other use (Children of Israeel). Apparently they seem to be pointing to the same group of people. But God does not do say anything without a purpose and indeed they should be some difference.
So what are the differences between these two group of people?
There are many verses that use both the terms. And they can be found in Qoran.
etc....
For me. like sister huruf I take what Qoran says.
But the main task from Qoran from what I can make out is to lead my life according to the instruction of Qoran. To do my best to follow the best advice from Qoran.
Things like who are beni Israeel? who has done what?...Are not my priority although I do not mind others searching and looking. I read with an open mind
I was quoting verses from Qoran, others can make of them what they want.
Thank you for your posts.
GOD bless you.
Peace.Salaam
There is many people around the indian ocean who claims to descent of "israel" or yehud.
there is of course the "yemenites jews", the indian jews, the ethiopian jews and other in black africa (south africa, zimbabwe, tanazania). Seems that DNA links them to Yemenite people.And it is difficult to find traces of Jews before Cyrus the great. Greeks for example never spoke about them.
this is a clear indication that "the tribe" is originated somewhere in Yemen and not somewhere in palestine.
The funny thing is that like "Israel" who became a tribe, Yahood also became a tribe based on genealogy and not on faith.
Same people who rewrote torah to make their "Israel" their ancestor rewrote it to make Yehuda theit ancestor.
Yehuda is said to be a son son of Israel/Jacob. In bible it was the was who wanted to sell Yusuf for some coins. And if course, the funny parabolists evanglists choosed that name for the guy who sold Jesus to romans for some coins. Funny evangelist reminded allegorically that father of Jesus if "Joseph" while rabbis until now are saying that their Messiah should be a descent of Juda.Brother ayman brought a theory that Jinn is our "spiritual/imagination" side. JINN is a kind of zawj of INS. This couple is very knows in all religions (execept in "islam" as the couple spirit/flesh. Israel, his son Yehuada and their filiation represents a "flesh" conception of the religion. It is totally opposed to the spiritual conception of "Jesus" . It worth read the bible to see the opposition between old and new testament. Old testament is racist and flesh based religion in wich Yahveh is just the tribal god of Israel tribe. The new testament is something where god is god of all humans.
Actually, people originated from east europe claims (an believe) to be descent of Israel. They are occupying a land they have named Israel. And every town in Palestine have been renamed with a name from Torah. "Israel" is a specialist in rewriting history as they want, claiming that the aim is "faith", to obtain advantages in this live for their flesh. That is priesthood whose work is to guide from light to darkness.
There is understandings of Quran that help to understand what happen now. I think is not by chance and that Allah wanted so.
Why Israel name is so high now ? Why there is so lies around the name of Israel ?Israel is great and very difficult subject where we have to mix many sources of knowledge.
it is not "all in the name" like huruf said. It is not so simple.Peace
-
Peace noshirk.
Of course history is not simple to unravel.
I keep saying this over and over again.
Let me give you a clear example of todayThe western media is making a new history by deceiving folks and feeding them information/news in an edited way following a leaders/system agenda.(I live in the west so I am commenting on the west. I am also assuming other media do the same).
The west media ,in the past few days or before that has not even mentioned the bombing of Syria by Israel. Why?
I leave you and the readers to find the answers ! I believe public support will diminish and the general public will start asking questions of !why are you supporting tyranny and injustice?"
The west media is pre-empting /preparing to get public support for attacking Syria again ,so it is feeding a cock and bull story about the Syrian army is about to use chemical weapons on their own people?
So what happens when they win wars by deceit? They write their own history!!! Are the coming generations going to argue this out ? They will have to dig for the truth?
Same about Beni Israeel ,or other tribes of the past. We cannot trust "men/folks" history unless we check it.That is why I try to push for the self correction/self cleansing of each individual to search for the truth and live the truth. Only then we can make sure "future history " is clean and honest.
GOD bless you.
Peace. -
Peace noshirk.
Of course history is not simple to unravel.
I keep saying this over and over again.
Let me give you a clear example of todayThe western media is making a new history by deceiving folks and feeding them information/news in an edited way following a leaders/system agenda.(I live in the west so I am commenting on the west. I am also assuming other media do the same).
The west media ,in the past few days or before that has not even mentioned the bombing of Syria by Israel. Why?
I leave you and the readers to find the answers ! I believe public support will diminish and the general public will start asking questions of !why are you supporting tyranny and injustice?"
The west media is pre-empting /preparing to get public support for attacking Syria again ,so it is feeding a cock and bull story about the Syrian army is about to use chemical weapons on their own people?
So what happens when they win wars by deceit? They write their own history!!! Are the coming generations going to argue this out ? They will have to dig for the truth?
Same about Beni Israel ,or other tribes of the past. We cannot trust "men/folks" history unless we check it.That is why I try to push for the self correction/self cleansing of each individual to search for the truth and live the truth. Only then we can make sure "future history " is clean and honest.
GOD bless you.
Peace.Peace good logic.
Seems like if we were in something like a messianic period.
the importance taken by "Israel" and all the powerful governments who make allegiance to Israel nowadays is very surprising.
Never in history, Israel was so important.
In fact, in history (not in old testament), we cannot find trace of an Israeli or even a Jewish civilization. there is no proof of existence of kingdom Israel even with saloman or david (i think even they were not from people of torah). Jews were always marginal people of little importance.in fact, seems like "Israel" is gathering his "childs". With my understating, Islamists are also banu israel. It is not surprising for me to see Daech working for Israel state.
And it is clear that opportunists/hypocrites of all countries are making allegiance to Israel.Of course, there is no massih dajjal in quran and no return of Jesus or something like this.
I consider all this as an Israeli prophecy which looks like it is realizing. However i think there will be an end of story not expected by Israeli "prophets". I would say as usual since Israel expect his Messiah from long time ago.Theological enemy of Israel personage is of course, for me,......the Messiah personage.
i dont know how it will end but i feel that big theological events are occurring.Peace
-
https//topicsfromquran.com/2018/09/29/israeel-and-bani-israeel/
Biblical beliefs which have crept into Muslim faith, make people believe that Israeel means Yaqoob A.S, however, this is not stated in Quran. Link to above post reviews Ayas of Quran, what does the terms 'Israeel' and ?Bani Israeel? mean as per character traits and description given in Quran.
-
Israel means God-conscious, the system of mode of conduct, among dwellers of this forum as well. It stems from Ancient root , meaning straight path, and also ads (El), which traditionally means God. Combined it means "Straight path to God".
In the Quran this phrase is available as a combination of and , which is joint + familiarity, unity, because that's what AL steps from. Together it means "Enjoined Unity", which is also related to A LOT OF Quranic phrases, including the name for the Quran itself, which means "Unification". Unification of what would you ask?
There was never such tribe as Children of Israel nor Exodus events, at some point in history they simply titled themselves as adepts of a particular religious movement as spiritual successors to these tribes described in the myth. Similarly as people in Arabia started calling themselves "muslims" and converting to "Islam" (also completely mistranslated words) because of the Quran. The twelve tribes is an allegory for what hangs on every wall in every house in your hallway.
Those who believe it to be a nation should also support the creation myth and explain the problem of different races from it as well, since there is banu Adama (Children of Adam) too. Israel is not a tribe.