Peace,
All examples can be worked out using the template posted earlier...
http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9599979.msg240753#msg240753
I have my own approach to this problem. Please critique it.
So let us consider
The Qur?an distinctly says that the male child will receive the share of two females and that if there are two or more females then the females receive 2/3 between them. In other words, if there are male children then the share of the children comes last since the ?double share? of the male must be preserved.
No, says presicely "double share" is when they are exactly two! This has been explained...
411 starts with to the male equal share the two females
Above if left alone would be as understood today includes all mixed daughter/s & son/s combinations;
Qur'an continues with...
ELSE IF they are women over two, so for them two thirds what left
This excludes all combinations when > 2 or 3+ females from the first statement.
Further continues...
AND IF she was one, so for her the half
This excludes the case of one female from the first statement above.
Thus the only possibility to apply "to the male equal share the two females" is when they are exactly two!
Whereas in 4176 the shares 1/2 or 2/3 for the sisters are when they are alone (i.e. no brothers) and Qur'an precisley states "Wa ?In Kn 'Ikhwatan Rijlan Wa Nis'an" which covers all possibilities for mixed siblings apply "to the male equal share the two females" and gives definition of Ikhwatun in 411 -- at least two persons, one is male.
Let us use the example which people use to ?disprove Islam?
Harold dies and leaves behind three daughters, two parents and his wife. The three daughters receive 2/3 between them, his wife receives 1/8 and the parents receive 1/3 of what is left. In this case there will be an excess which can be distributed to relatives or charity according to usage (48 ).
There is never any access. 48 says to be benevolent give out of one's inheritance...
http//corpus.quran.com/wordbyword.jsp?chapter=4&verse=8
1 - 1/3 parents - 1/8 wife = 13/24 CHILDREN (dependent on # of females)
Without males the daughters get the whole same as would sons without females; else if mixed use...
http//i45.tinypic.com/2zz4z0m.jpg