Is this fair to quote it ??
-
If you see someone
-Mocking the sayings of the prophet PBUH
-Showing brainlessness and lack of knowledge
-Tampering the meanings of the Holy Quran
-Knowing arabic only this much that translates "wash your feet " as "rub your feet"
-not knowing the difference of "giving the book /teaching the book
-showing double standard (whereever he wants takes the shelter of the Hadith/whereever wants rejects it )
-That who says that whole quran is metaphoricThink that he is Quranist and Munkareen-e-Hadith
Thanks for the clarification. When you now use "Quranists" I will now know you are referring to those who fulfill the above criteria.
That is quite specific. I am unaware of such a group so cant really comment on your question(s). Good luck in your search.
-
If you see someone
-Knowing arabic only this much that translates "wash your feet " as "rub your feet"I am glad you ended with only this now about me.
First of all How much arabic do you know to judge mine or anyone else's?Secondly why don't you have the honesty to quote me where I said that? Did I really translate , interpret or did say "I rub my feet when it's cold and the water is cold, or when the sink is too high for me?" Do you believe too that the prophet was tampering with the qur'aan when it is said that he rubbed-not his feet-but his shoes?
Thirdly How did you benefit from believing in hadith, in qur'aan and in following in the steps of the prophet if you keep insulting people and telling lies about them without any evidence?
Fourthly If you so much believe in hadith, how about this one
"Say something good or shut up"?
-
Weather report
On this forum "Leoxyz" will be banned soon!
-
I am glad you ended with only this now about me.
First of all How much arabic do you know to judge mine or anyone else's?Secondly why don't you have the honesty to quote me where I said that? Did I really translate , interpret or did say "I rub my feet when it's cold and the water is cold, or when the sink is too high for me?" Do you believe too that the prophet was tampering with the qur'aan when it is said that he rubbed-not his feet-but his shoes?
Thirdly How did you benefit from believing in hadith, in qur'aan and in following in the steps of the prophet if you keep insulting people and telling lies about them without any evidence?
Fourthly If you so much believe in hadith, how about this one
"Say something good or shut up"?
Dear elder sister
This quote was not about you but I think it appeared to be a straw in the beard (as a proverb).
You saidFirst of all How much arabic do you know to judge mine or anyone else's?
Being absolutely honest ,I have no knowledge of arabic .I am a non arabic and just a learner.
You said ;Secondly why don't you have the honesty to quote me where I said that? Did I really translate , interpret or did say "I rub my feet when it's cold and the water is cold, or when the sink is too high for me?" Do you believe too that the prophet was tampering with the qur'aan when it is said that he rubbed-not his feet-but his shoes?
Two of your posts as evidence are here for benefit of "Quranists"
PEARL NO 1 TWO VERSIONS OF THE SAME AYAA OF THE QURAN
Salaam Leoxyz
It's not about a verse being correct or incorrect. No one is saying it's incorrect. It's about vocalization of the word "arjulakum or arjulikum". If one adopts the fisrt one, and on mere grammatical grounds, it will follow wash your faces wujuuhakum", so it will mean wash your feet.
On the other hand, if one adopts wa arjulikum", it will follow rub your heads ru'uusikum" and it will mean rub your feet.
or
And for your information, no one here messes with qur'aan, quite the opposite. If some people divide their efforts between the quraan and some twenty-hundreds other books, we concentrate ALL our efforts on the quraan. Keep an open mind and try to read more than talk.
PEARL NO2 ,SAME AYAA .TRANSLATION WEATHER RELATED
Sorry, I am not in a position to say which is correct, and I do not see why both cannot be correct. When it is cold, and I have no access to warm water, I would rub my feet; or if I am somewhere where the sink is too high for me, I can't just splash water on the floor, so I rub. Otherwise I wash them (washing is the default in my case). Perhaps God left it like that as a way of making things easy for u
You said
Fourthly If you so much believe in hadith, how about this one
"Say something good or shut up"?
Subhanallah !! What a scented language !!
Is this language of all Quranists or you are unique in this ? -
Thanks Leo for bringing the quotes and exposing your ignorance, not of Arabic alone, but mostly of English
"Say something good or shut up"?
Subhanallah !! What a scented language !!
Is this language of all Quranists or you are unique in this ?....and hadith!! For your information, this is a hadith...ranting in defense of hadiths and unable to recognize a famous one...
-
Yes, those whacky Quranists at it again! And they would have gotten away with it too, if it weren't for you meddling kids.
-
?
....and hadith!! For your information, this is a hadith...ranting in defense of hadiths and unable to recognize a famous one...
Good sign that you have converted.May Allah bless you
Hazrat Noha PBUH preached for so many yrs and could convert just a few "Kuffar" ---------->Muslims".
This credit goes to a follower of Muhammad PBUH by the Grace of Almighty Allah ,I was able to convert at least "one" within a few days could make that fellow ,real follower of Prophet Muhammad PBUH
Allah o Akbar. -
Every one should know that Quranists believe two versions of Quran and they do translation according to weather of the day.
Shall I add this additional criteria to your list below?
If you see someone
-Mocking the sayings of the prophet PBUH
-Showing brainlessness and lack of knowledge
-Tampering the meanings of the Holy Quran
-Knowing arabic only this much that translates "wash your feet " as "rub your feet"
-not knowing the difference of "giving the book /teaching the book
-showing double standard (whereever he wants takes the shelter of the Hadith/whereever wants rejects it )
-That who says that whole quran is metaphoricThink that he is Quranist and Munkareen-e-Hadith
I have to say these "Quranists" you speak of are quite specific. Do they have a website or book to read more of their views?
Thanks.
-
Truth is always bitter.My dear brother yuck yuck yuck
Yes, I hate Quranists too. My car broke down once, I think it was Quranists that did it.
-
Good sign that you have converted.May Allah bless you
Hazrat Noha PBUH preached for so many yrs and could convert just a few "Kuffar" ---------->Muslims".
This credit goes to a follower of Muhammad PBUH by the Grace of Almighty Allah ,I was able to convert at least "one" within a few days could make that fellow ,real follower of Prophet Muhammad PBUH
Allah o Akbar.What makes you believe that this is really a hadith? You see, in the bottom of your heart you know I do not talk nonesense as you claim, but you are in denial. This just adds more to your ignorance.
I accept any wise quote no matter who the author is. You look for who said what no matter what the content is. And because of this fallacious approach of yours, you miss on a lot of wisdom and knowledge. Look where you are now!! Much ado about nothing.
And this sums up my position against yours regarding hadith.
-
Yes they have a website.
Go to google and put Quranist in the search ,You will get it .Inshallah.Is this the Quranist's website?
http//www.sunniforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=1086
-
Is this the Quranist's website?
http//www.sunniforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=1086
I have given you criteria.Apply to them ,if they fit then they must be.So simple to evaluate.
One Question
Do the people on that website have some brain ?? If the answer is yes ,then they cannot be quranist. -
