salat = prayer? How do you explain this then...
-
ILisa,
Sorry, I thought I replied to this. I read it. I dont have much to say on it. The only comments I'd make is that a balance of giving thanks and requesting blessings needs to be struck. Now, I tend to stay away from specific blessings, just general ones, as I am more comfortable with that. I do agree with the gist of the following statement "It really is true that what we give or do to others, we give or do to ourselves. If we want peace, healing, light and love in our lives, we must focus our will, intent and actions on opening to these qualities and extending them to self and others."
PA,
Thanks for the feedback. The older article is present on the free-minds articles page
http//www.free-minds.org/articles/quranic/salat_wakas.htm -
Wakas,
I know this is a very old forum. Sorry for re-opening it. I dont know what is your current position on salat. Please send me the link on your recent article on this subject. I found this debate very thought provoking.
I am not sure if you are still maintaining "non-muslims can also perform salat" based on chapter 9.
My question
In 56, believers are asked to clean themselves before salat. Can we infer from this that only believers are expected to perform salat?
"O you who believe, if you rise to hold the Salat, then wash your faces and your hands up to the elbows, and wipe your heads and your feet to the ankles; and if you have had intercourse, then you shall bathe. And if you are ill, or traveling, or you have excreted feces, or you have had sexual contact with the women, and you cannot not find water, then you shall select from the clean soil; you shall wipe your faces and your hands with it. God does not want to place any hardship on you, but He wants to cleanse you and to complete His blessings upon you that you may be appreciative." (56)
-
peace explorer,
My position is that the regular/timed "salat" is only upon the mumineen/believers.
And yes, my position is still that according to chapter 9, non-believers can uphold/maintain the "salat". This can confuse some, however, if you read my articles all should become clear
http//mypercept.co.uk/slw.htm (an introductory article to the basic concept)
http//mypercept.co.uk/quran_on_salat.htm (reasonably comprehensive list of additional information)
http//mypercept.co.uk/articles/disproved_traditional_salat.htm (a discussion on chapter 9's pivotal usage) -
Peace Wakas,
This method of salat makes a lot of sense, just one question though (for now)...
In 9122
Progressive Muslims"
And it is not for the believers to march out in their entirety. For every battalion that marches out, let a group remain to study the system, and warn their people when they return to them, perhaps they will be aware.If part of our salat is to be studying/reflecting etc.. why would people need to stay behind to study the deen and remind the others?
What's your view on this sign?
-
Peace Wakas,
This method of salat makes a lot of sense, just one question though (for now)...
In 9122
Progressive Muslims"
And it is not for the believers to march out in their entirety. For every battalion that marches out, let a group remain to study the system, and warn their people when they return to them, perhaps they will be aware.If part of our salat is to be studying/reflecting etc.. why would people need to stay behind to study the deen and remind the others?
What's your view on this sign?
War strategy perhaps? Consider that in another quranic verse it instructs believers to strike at the enemy's command centres.
-
Peace OPF,
First, this thread is regarding this article(not sure/making sure you know that). Without reading that article, you may not know what I am taking about.
http//mypercept.co.uk/articles/disproved_traditional_salat.htm
Secondly, The ones staying behind are 'studying the deen' literally. I don't think that qualifies as war strategy.
-
Peace OPF,
First, this thread is regarding this article(not sure/making sure you know that). Without reading that article, you may not know what I am taking about.
http//mypercept.co.uk/articles/disproved_traditional_salat.htm
Secondly, The ones staying behind are 'studying the deen' literally. I don't think that qualifies as war strategy.
What is the 'deen'?
-
Usually translated as 'religion' but the better word for it is 'system'. FM uses 'system'.
Example, see how it's used in 2256 (no compulsion in al-deen)and 4213 (...the same 'deen'...).
= Dal-Ya-Nun = obedience/submissiveness, servility, religion, high/elevated/noble/glorious rank/condition/state, took/receive a loan or borrowed upon credit, become indebted, in debt, under the obligation of a debt, contract a debt, repay/reimburse a loan, rule/govern/manage it, possess/own it, become habituated/accustomed to something, confirmation, death (because it is a debt everyone must pay), a particular law/statute, system, custom/habit/business, a way/course/manner of conduct/acting, repayment/compensation.
dana vb. (I)
impf. act. 929
pcple. pass. 3753, 5686dayn n.m. 2282, 411, 412, 412, 412
din n.m. 14, 2132, 2193, 2217, 2217, 2256, 319, 324, 373, 383, 385, 446, 4125, 4146, 4171, 53, 53, 53, 554, 557, 577, 670, 6137, 6159, 6161, 729, 751, 839, 849, 872, 911, 912, 929, 933, 933, 936, 9122, 1022, 10104, 10105, 1240, 1276, 1535, 1652, 2278, 242, 2425, 2455, 2682, 2965, 3030, 3030, 3032, 3043, 3132, 335, 3720, 3878, 392, 393, 3911, 3914, 4014, 4026, 4065, 4213, 4213, 4221, 4828, 4828, 4916, 516, 5112, 5656, 608, 609, 619, 619, 7026, 7446, 829, 8215, 8217, 8218, 8311, 957, 985, 985, 1071, 1096, 1096, 1102,
tadayana vb. (VI) perf. act. 2282
Lane's Lexicon, Volume 3, pages 108, 109, 110, 111, 112
http//www.studyquran.co.uk/PRLonline.htm
-
Peace.
My question for Wakas Have you read Layth's new article on Salat?
If so, how does your view differ from his?
What parts if any do you think are missing from Layth's article?
My question for Layth Have you read Wakas' article on Salat?
If so, how does your view differ from his?
What parts if any do you think are missing from Wakas' article?
Thoughts......
I have read both articles and I am wondering.....what is the real difference between the two thoughts processes?
I understand from Wakas' article that salat is not prayer, but I also understand from Layth's article what salat is... and how to... on a practical basis...implement that in my life.
But is there someway that we can combine both articles to give a more clear picture? Is there someway we can come together as brothers and sisters in the deen? We need to unite...I am asking in the name of God, The Almighty, The Merciful...for uniting on the parts of Layth and Wakas in regards to the salat issue, and come up with a unified article on the issue.
Wakas tells you what Salat isn't and Layth tells you what Salat is...why couldn't we combine them and perhaps expand on it, and maybe come up with a unifed article that could be produced, God willing, down the road... as a small salat leaflet or booklet?
I have the technological ability and software needed to be involved in that if needed. I am also willing to contribute financially if need be as much as I can afford, God willing.
I have been here under many names for the past three years or more, and have gone through the learning process with both brothers, and now is the time I stand up and say we need to unite our understanding of salat. I feel we are so close, yet we need some sort of document that is the standard. I will not accept the comments that drag the process down. We WILL God willing, have a central unified understanding on salat, God willing. Then this when done needs to be the only article on the article section and if people want to debate it or come up with other ideas that is why we have the forum section where people could debate it. Make sense?
Please comment.
YTV
P.S. I love you ALL....for the sake of God and whatever it is you need feel free to ask anytime..and God willing whatever I can contribute I will, God willing.
YTV
-
peace HMD, YTV, all,
Re 9122
I have not studied the context and cross-referenced it but from 9122 the timeframe cant be judged. For example, they may be setting out to battle immeditaely or in the next few hours, i.e. there is no time for salat al fajr / salat al esha etc. As a side note, there is a sign that discusses the prophet setting out at dawn (to battle?) and there is a sign discussing a salat during a time of fear, limited time, so these events may be connected.
Re Layth's article
I responded to it here
http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=14843.15
As I stated in the above thread, the direction of the article is ok, but the core premise is built upon an unverifiable point.HMD, referenced one slw article, but the others which I referenced prior in this thread should be read in conjunction with it.
-
Peace.
My question for Wakas Have you read Layth's new article on Salat?
If so, how does your view differ from his?
What parts if any do you think are missing from Layth's article?
My question for Layth Have you read Wakas' article on Salat?
If so, how does your view differ from his?
What parts if any do you think are missing from Wakas' article?
Thoughts......
I have read both articles and I am wondering.....what is the real difference between the two thoughts processes?
I understand from Wakas' article that salat is not prayer, but I also understand from Layth's article what salat is... and how to... on a practical basis...implement that in my life.
But is there someway that we can combine both articles to give a more clear picture? Is there someway we can come together as brothers and sisters in the deen? We need to unite...I am asking in the name of God, The Almighty, The Merciful...for uniting on the parts of Layth and Wakas in regards to the salat issue, and come up with a unified article on the issue.
Wakas tells you what Salat isn't and Layth tells you what Salat is...why couldn't we combine them and perhaps expand on it, and maybe come up with a unifed article that could be produced, God willing, down the road... as a small salat leaflet or booklet?I have the technological ability and software needed to be involved in that if needed. I am also willing to contribute financially if need be as much as I can afford, God willing.
I have been here under many names for the past three years or more, and have gone through the learning process with both brothers, and now is the time I stand up and say we need to unite our understanding of salat. I feel we are so close, yet we need some sort of document that is the standard. I will not accept the comments that drag the process down. We WILL God willing, have a central unified understanding on salat, God willing. Then this when done needs to be the only article on the article section and if people want to debate it or come up with other ideas that is why we have the forum section where people could debate it. Make sense?
Please comment.
YTV
P.S. I love you ALL....for the sake of God and whatever it is you need feel free to ask anytime..and God willing whatever I can contribute I will, God willing.
YTVSalam,
Respectfully.I agree and i am also willing to help in any way that i can, God willing.
Many times have i been asking many questions regarding the prayer and i wold love to join the debate and the search, God willing.Allah Ellem.
Peace.
-
Peace.
I previously read the articles about salat from layth and wakas....now I have come across the submitter perspective....now I am even more confused.....
they say 7431 over it is nineteen.....etc etc and I have checked and rechecked the numbers for salat and it does add up right...
24434 is a multiple of 19 (1286x19)
so I wonder if anyone layth or wakas has come across that information....
and if so how did they disregard it as false and on what basis...
I am a bit perplexed.....
seems once a person gets a firm handle on what they belive a new twist comes along.....
YTV
-
peace YTV,
submission.org articles were actually the first ones I read on "salat" a long time ago, so I am familliar with what they say. Personally, I do not use code-19 to validate non-Quranic info.
As a side note, if anyone is confused about "salat" or any concept for that matter, simply study it from al quran itself. The tools are available online now and it has never been easier. This methodology is very effective, as there is nothing more powerful than seeing the truth for yourself.
-
Peace.
I appreciate your prompt reply to my post. I am wondering what is the root I should be looking up?
Any assistance would be highly appreciated.
YTV
