Hot/"ramadan" Answer
-
Peace Ayman,
As I said and explained in the article and in the above posts, you have ZERO evidence for the completely arbitrary traditional timing from the great reading. So you are defending something which is indisputably completely arbitrary and entirely based on manmade decisions. Therefore, I would suggest that you study and come up with the correct timing based on the great reading before criticizing from the indefensible traditional position.
Why do assume I'm defending all the traditional timings?
I'm looking into this and yours doesn't make sense either. For example, below you state...
- The traditional timing creates a contradiction between 2185 and 971
On the one hand, traditionalists claim that according to 2185 the great reading was descended in a month while 971 clearly says that it was descended in one night. This false understanding creates a contradiction in the great reading.
How is that a contradiction?
Is it a contradiction for me to say that I stayed up all last night in the month of September?
Its clear Quran was sent in a night 971 ?
973 the night Al-Qadr better than a thousand shahr
What contradicts is to compare a ?night? (i.e. time sunset to dawn) better than a thousand full moon snapshots which occur half the time during "the day" as did the full moons after the summer solstice in Makkah, Saudi Arabia for a brief moment the five prior years in a row and will likewise do so in the next three years...
http//www.timeanddate.com/worldclock/astronomy.html?n=151&month=7&year=2009&obj=moon&afl=-11&day=1
Moonrise, Moonset and Moonphase for Saudi Arabia ? Makkah ?
Jul 2, 2004 Full at 209 PM
Jun 22, 2005 Full at 714 AM
Jul 11, 2006 Full at 602 AM
Jun 30, 2007 Full at 449 PM
Jul 18, 2008 Full at 1059 AM
Jul 7, 2009 Full at 1222 PM
Jun 26, 2010 Full at 231 PM
Jul 15, 2011 Full at 940 AM
-
Peace Nun de plume
Peace adjwi,
Use link below and check the full moon for your area after June 21st and notice sometimes they appear in the daytime and varying hours as well.
Moonrise, Moonset and Moonphase for Saudi Arabia ? Makkah ? July 2008
http//www.timeanddate.com/worldclock/astronomy.html?n=151&month=7&year=2008&obj=moon&afl=-11&day=1
Jul 16, 2008 97.8%
Jul 17, 2008
Jul 18, 2008 99.8% Full at 1059 AM
Jul 19, 2008 99.7%Take a look at the picture I posted earlier and imagine walking outside seeing each of those four moons individually (don't have luxury to compare next to each other) -- how would be able to tell which is the full moon with less than .3% Illuminated Phase difference?
The new moon waxing crescent (D in DOC) stands out as does waning crescent C...
http//farm4.static.flickr.com/3226/2472224091_c9637ac4f8.jpg?v=0
We're getting there anthony.
Peace
I appreciate your answer and the difficulty you present. Now, my understanding is that a ''Full Moon'' lasts an instant, then it is enters its phase of less illumination. Now if the question is how can you differ from a ''Full Moon'' and one that is becoming or one that was simply by looking, I agree it is indeed difficult. My answer was to look at it's rising and compare that time to that of the setting sun. Upon re-examining anew the schedule calculated for my location, I noticed that the occurance of the ''Full Moon'' (UT) seems to co-incide with a rising ''Full Moon'' simultaneously to that of the setting sun.
The day of the ''Full Moon'' is one of no darkness sort to speak. After the sun set, the moon rises before the darkness gains all of the sky. Afterwards, the next day and so on darkness seems to take hold up to the time when the moon rises. So to know when is the full moon, one is to watch the movie and not simply look at a picture.
The point that Ayman presents and the problem of calendar is interesting however what does this the new timing of fasting do for the people who live ''down under''? Would we now have two ramadans, one in the northern hemisphere and one in the southern? Both regions can't have scorching moons at the same period of the year. How then would the ''Great Reading'' apply to them? And what about the night of destiny? In who's ramadan does it occur in? Ayman, any thoughts?
adjwi
-
Peace everyone,
I think that at this stage, it is best to summarize all the different viewpoints on the timing of the abstinence so that people can see the essence of each and not get distracted by all the noise. There are basically four points of view
- The traditional timing
We all know the traditional timing so I am not going to waste time on explaining it. Also, everyone who has read the great reading knows that the traditional point of view has zero support in the great reading and this is what has prompted many people here to search for a better one based on the great reading. Basically, the traditional timing has the following problems
Peace all;
My answers to Aymans propaganda is here, http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9597103.0, if you are interested to know about his misleading allegations; (this thread is getting to be so confusing)
Ayman, I'm Looking forward for a True debate with you so we can show the truth.
Salam -
Peace Nun,
Why do assume I'm defending all the traditional timings?
I'm looking into this and yours doesn't make sense either. For example, below you state...If you are not defending the traditional timing then how is your understanding different from the traditional one?
How is that a contradiction?
Is it a contradiction for me to say that I stayed up all last night in the month of September?It is a contradiction to say "I stayed up only all last night" and then say "I stayed up all night in the month of September". Remember we are talking about TWO SEPARATE statements not one statement like you made up in order to make it work. You are intelligent enough to make up one statement to easily make it work and eliminate the contradiction. Don't you think that the god is certainly far more intelligent than you?
Its clear Quran was sent in a night 971 ?
973 the night Al-Qadr better than a thousand shahr
What contradicts is to compare a ?night? (i.e. time sunset to dawn) better than a thousand full moon snapshots which occur half the time during "the day" as did the full moons after the summer solstice in Makkah, Saudi Arabia for a brief moment the five prior years in a row and will likewise do so in the next three years...Please see the etymology of the word "ShaHR" and see how the ancient Arabs used the term and its derivatives. In addition to full-moon, it also means something apparent, something bright, something big and round. Do you think that the ancient Arabs thought about the invisible full-moon that has not risen yet from below the horizon as the "ShaHR"?
Also, please look back on this thread and read sister Marie's excellent commentary on 973.
I would suggest that you try for yourself next year to witness the scorching full-moon. It is not just about percent illumination. It is about the full-moon taking the lowest path accross the horizon when it rises and thus appearing more red than the next day's full-moon. Therefore, this year in Mecca one had a choice between the full-moon on the 17th and the one on the 18th. However, if you observed the actual full-moon in Mecca you would see that the one on the 17th takes a lower path accross the horizon and rises more slowly to a maximum altitude of 43 degrees while the one on the 18th rises faster to an altitude of 46.6 degrees. So the one on the 17th in addition to being full would also appear more vivid red than the one on the 18th. Moreover, EVERYONE would have seen it and not had to rely on their Mullah or a computer to tell them when the timing is while they never actually witness it their entire lives. The idea is to start the fast the next day after one witnesses the "scorching full-moon". So observing the scorching full-moon in Mecca on the night of July 17th, you would start the fast on July 18th. This is true for all of the northern hemisphere. So whether in the US or in Europe you would have still fasted starting on the 18th. There is no doubt or confusion about that.
The calculations for Mecca below are from the following site
http//aa.usno.navy.mil/data/docs/AltAz.php
MECCA
E 40 00, N22 00
Altitude and Azimuth of the Moon
Jul 17, 2008
Zone 3h East of Greenwichh m Altitude Azimuth Fraction Illuminated
1850 1.7 118.1 1.00
1900 3.6 119.0 1.00
1910 5.5 120.0 1.00
1920 7.4 121.1 1.00
1930 9.3 122.1 1.00
1940 11.2 123.3 1.00
1950 13.0 124.4 1.00
2000 14.9 125.7 1.00
2010 16.7 127.0 1.00
2020 18.5 128.3 1.00
2030 20.2 129.7 1.00
2040 22.0 131.2 1.00
2050 23.6 132.7 1.00
2100 25.3 134.3 1.00
2110 26.9 136.0 1.00
2120 28.4 137.8 1.00
2130 29.9 139.7 1.00
2140 31.4 141.6 1.00
2150 32.8 143.7 1.00
2200 34.1 145.8 1.00
2210 35.3 148.0 1.00
2220 36.5 150.3 1.00
2230 37.6 152.8 1.00
2240 38.6 155.3 1.00
2250 39.5 157.9 1.00
2300 40.4 160.6 1.00
2310 41.1 163.4 1.00
2320 41.7 166.2 1.00
2330 42.2 169.1 1.00
2340 42.6 172.1 1.00
2350 42.9 175.1 1.00
0000 43.0 178.1 1.00
0010 43.0 181.2 1.00
0020 43.0 184.2 1.00MECCA
E 40 00, N22 00
Altitude and Azimuth of the Moon
Jul 18, 2008
Zone 3h East of Greenwichh m Altitude Azimuth Fraction Illuminated
1930 1.3 114.3 1.00
1940 3.2 115.2 1.00
1950 5.1 116.2 1.00
2000 7.1 117.2 1.00
2010 9.1 118.2 1.00
2020 11.1 119.3 1.00
2030 13.0 120.4 1.00
2040 14.9 121.6 1.00
2050 16.9 122.9 1.00
2100 18.7 124.2 1.00
2110 20.6 125.5 1.00
2120 22.4 127.0 1.00
2130 24.2 128.5 1.00
2140 26.0 130.0 1.00
2150 27.7 131.7 1.00
2200 29.4 133.4 1.00
2210 31.0 135.2 1.00
2220 32.6 137.2 1.00
2230 34.2 139.2 1.00
2240 35.6 141.3 1.00
2250 37.0 143.5 1.00
2300 38.4 145.9 1.00
2310 39.6 148.3 1.00
2320 40.8 150.9 1.00
2330 41.9 153.6 1.00
2340 42.8 156.3 1.00
2350 43.7 159.2 1.00
0000 44.5 162.2 1.00
0010 45.2 165.3 1.00
0020 45.7 168.5 1.00
0030 46.1 171.7 1.00
0040 46.4 175.0 1.00
0050 46.6 178.3 1.00I hope this helps.
Peace,
Ayman
-
Peace Adjwi,
The point that Ayman presents and the problem of calendar is interesting however what does this the new timing of fasting do for the people who live ''down under''? Would we now have two ramadans, one in the northern hemisphere and one in the southern? Both regions can't have scorching moons at the same period of the year. How then would the ''Great Reading'' apply to them? And what about the night of destiny? In who's ramadan does it occur in? Ayman, any thoughts?
Those questions have been answered several times on this thread. The fact that the restricted full-moons only purpose is wild life hunting restriction and wild life follows the solar cycle tells us that the period of the restriction must be different between the Northern and Southern hemispheres. Everything has a purpose. The idea that everyone has to fast together to achieve "unity" is false as evident in the highly disunited and self-destructing so-called Islamic world today.
Peace,
Ayman
-
Peace aymen, and all
There is only one place to worship God at...
He sees you looking to the sky; now He will thus set for you a focal point that will be pleasing to you...
You shall set yourself towards the Sacred Temple...
All of you...
And were ever you be or werever you at, or werever you go out, you shall set yourselves towards it...
So now let us ask this, traditional or not
Are the believers fasting in mecca??? In accord to the command in 2183-186 .??? Or at least do they think they are fasting in accord to it if you are in opposition...?
peace
-
Peace Anthony,
There is only one place to worship God at...
No way. The god is not an idol stored inside a black stone box.
He sees you looking to the sky; now He will thus set for you a focal point that will be pleasing to you...
You shall set yourself towards the Sacred Temple...
All of you...
And were ever you be or werever you at, or werever you go out, you shall set yourselves towards it...Do you face a Sacred Temple "wherever you be or wherever you at, or wherever you go out"? I think not.
So now let us ask this, traditional or not
Are the believers fasting in mecca??? In accord to the command in 2183-186 .??? Or at least do they think they are fasting in accord to it if you are in opposition...?No one (believer or otherwise) anywhere (Mecca or anywhere) can fast according to 2183-186 if they take the key word "ramadan" in 2185 as meaningless.
Peace,
Ayman
-
Peace Anthony,
No way. The god is not an idol stored inside a black stone box.
Do you face a Sacred Temple brickwall "wherever you be or wherever you at, or wherever you go out"? I think not.
No one (believer or otherwise) anywhere (Mecca or anywhere) can fast according to 2183-186 if they take the key word "ramadan" in 2185 as meaningless.
Peace,
Ayman
He chooses to worshiped at the Sacred Temple. And He is owed by the people to make pilgramage to it, P and whoever rejects, then God is Rich, the Praiseworthy...
And you shall face that direction when you pray...and that should be were you plan to go... P
were are the sacrafices slatered at? were is the pilgramage to? What is the focal point? Towards the Temple... ;D
Do not sacrafise goat demons in just any field ect...There is only one place to do this at and to make pilgramage to...
And my Lords hands are wide open, spending as He pleases...I didnt say He was an idol stored in a black stone box...My Lord will destroy every idol...
And my focal point is that direction, towards the Sacred Temple P
Yes I do. P
-
Hi,
Plume wrote
What contradicts is to compare a ?night? (i.e. time sunset to dawn) better than a thousand full moon snapshots which occur half the time during "the day" as did the full moons after the summer solstice in Makkah, Saudi Arabia for a brief moment the five prior years in a row and will likewise do so in the next three years...Night is actually measured accurately by seamen as
Nautical Twilight Starts/Ends
Nautical twilight is the period when the center of the Sun is between 6 and 12 degrees below the horizon, when bright stars are still visible in clear weather and the horizon is becoming visible. It is too dark to do outdoor activities without additional lighting.thx.
-
Peace Ayman,
If you are not defending the traditional timing then how is your understanding different from the traditional one?
I'm still working on it.
It is a contradiction to say "I stayed up only all last night" and then say "I stayed up all night in the month of September". Remember we are talking about TWO SEPARATE statements not one statement like you made up in order to make it work. You are intelligent enough to make up one statement to easily make it work and eliminate the contradiction. Don't you think that the god is certainly far more intelligent than you?
God gave us intelligence and we know days/nights = months = years.
4615 And We have enjoined on man to be dutiful and kind to his parents. His mother bears him with hardship and she brings him forth with hardship, and the bearing of him, and the weaning of him is thirty (30) months, till when he attains full strength and reaches forty years...
Night is actually measured accurately by seamen as
Nautical Twilight Starts/Ends
Nautical twilight is the period when the center of the Sun is between 6 and 12 degrees below the horizon, when bright stars are still visible in clear weather and the horizon is becoming visible. It is too dark to do outdoor activities without additional lighting.thx.
Hi Sibute --
I go by Quran definition of night not seaman (I was one at age 16 btw) how dark is the night.
20130 So bear patiently what they say, and glorify the praises of your Lord before the rising of the sun, and before its setting, and during some of the hours of the night, and at the sides of the day, that you may become pleased with the reward which Allah shall give you.
See thread...
http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9596792.msg177611#msg177611
Thanks
-
Hi Plume,
20130 So bear patiently what they say, and glorify the praises of your Lord before the rising of the sun, and before its setting, and during some of the hours of the night, and at the sides of the day, that you may become pleased with the reward which Allah shall give .
Thank you for this wonderful quote plume but my point is night is not equal to sunrise - sunset but from the quote above it it clearly distincts between rising, setting and the hours of the night.
All scientific discoveries will relate back to the quran whether it be a seamen,scientist or anyone who seeks knowledge of this universe.
i can see that you are well verse with quotes from the quran and thats good but one should also refelect on how people with knowledge should also be sought after when it conforms with what quran is telling us.Thank you.
-
Hi Sibute,
You are welcome -- I read it as night being exactly from sunset to dawn.
911-3
And by the sun and its brightness;
And by the moon as it follows it (the sun);
And by the night as it conceals it (the sun);http//i34.tinypic.com/2qun98y.jpg
Peace
-
Peace Anthony,
No way. The god is not an idol stored inside a black stone box.
Do you face a Sacred Temple "wherever you be or wherever you at, or wherever you go out"? I think not.
No one (believer or otherwise) anywhere (Mecca or anywhere) can fast according to 2183-186 if they take the key word "ramadan" in 2185 as meaningless.
Peace,
Ayman
Let me ask you in other words
Has it been announed that it is time to fast? wow
Did you witness the month/moon ( of " Ramadan) ? yes, I believe you surely did.
And are they fasting in Meccah? ( celebrating Ramadan fast ) ?
-
Hi Sibute,
You are welcome -- I read it as night being exactly from sunset to dawn.
911-3
And by the sun and its brightness;
And by the moon as it follows it (the sun);
And by the night as it conceals it (the sun);Well I guess when the sun is concealed just below the horizon ( zero degrees) with its light beaming to the observer like you during sunset it must mean you break your fast??
thank you.
-
WHY THE MOON CHANGES COLOR
http//wiki.answers.com/Q/Why_the_moon_change_color
http//home.hiwaay.net/~krcool/Astro/moon/moonorange/
http//science.nasa.gov/headlines/y2007/03aug_dreamyeclipse.htm
Godbless,
Anwar
I'll see if i can find some more articles, from more scientific sources. -
Well I guess when the sun is concealed just below the horizon ( zero degrees) with its light beaming to the observer like you during sunset it must mean you break your fast??
thank you.
If the sun is concealed below the horizon then its direct light cannot beam the observer and I break my fast.
Likewise when it is unconcealed at dawn and its white thread is beaming at the observer I start my fast.
Thank you.
-
WHY THE MOON CHANGES COLOR
http//wiki.answers.com/Q/Why_the_moon_change_color
http//home.hiwaay.net/~krcool/Astro/moon/moonorange/Quote from above
When the moon is near the horizon, the moonlight must pass through much more atmosphere than when the moon is directly overhead. By the time the moonlight reaches your eyes, the blue, green, and purple pieces of visible light have been scattered away by air molecules. That's why you only see yellow, orange, or red.
It is a scientific fact that the full-moon around the summer solstice takes the lowest path accross the horizon. This is why it appears more vivid red than any other full-moon. This fact was explained in my article and people can easily confirm it.
Peace,
Ayman
-
And you shall face that direction when you pray...and that should be were you plan to go...
Where in the reading does it say we must face "Mecca" when we pray? And where does the reading say we must go to "Mecca" to make pilgrimage?
Peace,
Ahmad
-
Where in the reading does it say we must face "Mecca" when we pray? And where does the reading say we must go to "Mecca" to make pilgrimage?
Peace,
Ahmad
Were is the House of God at? The place of Abraham??? I thought it wa s mecca...