Math of Quran

Noon_waalqalami

So it is your Math that does not add up.

You are forgetting the " if"s. That means you cancel the last share every time the word " if" is mentioned!

You do not add up all the shares? " if" that last one did not exist!

Peace good logic,

Why not then use your favorite translation and add it up for him?

pls help to understand MATH of Quran

Man dies leaving behind
Wife is1/8 = 3/24 (412)
Daughters 2/3 = 16/24 (4176)
Father 1/6 = 4/24 (411)
Mother1/6 = 4/24(411)
Total = 27/24=1.125 NOT equal to 1

Woman dies leaving no descendants or ascendants
Husband, (1/2) = 1/2 (412)
Brother (everything) = 2/2(4176)
Total = 3/2 =1.5 NOT equal to 1

Woman dies leaving no ascendants or descendants and no brother
Husband, (1/2) = 3/6 (412, 4176)
Sister (1/2) = 3/6 (411)
Mother (1/3) = 2/6 (411)
Total = 8/6 =1.33 NOT equal to 1

Man dies leaving behind
Wife1/4 = 3/12 (412)
Mother 1/3 = 4/12 (411)
Sisters 2/3 = 8/12 ((4176)
Total = 15/12 =1.25 NOT equal to 1

Peace,

Most your posts spread anti-Islamic and missionary contradictions -- do you really want to understand?

Here are all combinations http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9604035.msg305563#msg305563

ccamurad

Salam,

Always I try to understand false calims about Quran. Thanx to help for the link.

good_logic

Peace Noon Waalqalami

You have already done it. No need for me to do it as well..

Thank you.

Peace.

Indelwyn

Someone needs to make a program, where you can just punch in the money and the ppl who are going to get the inheritance and then hit calculate... done.
This math kills me. I honestly think I am dividing it up evenly between my sons and daughter and calling it the day. This way I don't have to worry about my sons not taking care of their sister. She will have what she needs without favoring the males of the family.

farida

Someone needs to make a program, where you can just punch in the money and the ppl who are going to get the inheritance and then hit calculate... done.
This math kills me.

Salaam
That is a really good idea.

This way I don't have to worry about my sons not taking care of their sister. She will have what she needs without favoring the males of the family.

Who says that the boys have to look after their sisters in return for double share?
Peace

Noon_waalqalami

Someone needs to make a program, where you can just punch in the money and the ppl who are going to get the inheritance and then hit calculate... done.
This math kills me. I honestly think I am dividing it up evenly between my sons and daughter and calling it the day. This way I don't have to worry about my sons not taking care of their sister. She will have what she needs without favoring the males of the family.

Peace Indelwyn, there lots of calculators mostly all wrong.

It's best to make out a will since you know your situation.
It's the same if one is unsure when to fast, feed the poor.

GODsubmitter

That's for Qur'an being a clear guidance ???

Noon_waalqalami

That's for Qur'an being a clear guidance ???

It's clear for those who take their time to study it carefully and not rely on stupid sites, codes, or idiot messengers.

StopS

There is no way there will ever be agreement over this. Some people will say you need to learn more and it will be clear, others simply re-translate words until they fit what they want and others will create examples which fit their needs, as is the case in the link provided above. There are a couple of inheritance calculators on the net, but they don't really follow the guidelines as set out in the Koran and they provide different results.
The Koran is neither a science text-book nor a maths instruction manual, so I would leave it as spiritual guidance and not expect everything to add up precisely down to 10 decimal places.

GODsubmitter

There is no way there will ever be agreement over this. Some people will say you need to learn more and it will be clear, others simply re-translate words until they fit what they want and others will create examples which fit their needs, as is the case in the link provided above. There are a couple of inheritance calculators on the net, but they don't really follow the guidelines as set out in the Koran and they provide different results.
The Koran is neither a science text-book nor a maths instruction manual, so I would leave it as spiritual guidance and not expect everything to add up precisely down to 10 decimal places.

Very well said! Thank you
sun