The Paris massacre - Silence as always
-
?Not equal are those of the believers who sit , except those who are disabled, and those who strive hard and fight in the Cause of Allah with their wealth and their lives.? (495)
?no person shall have a burden laid on him greater than he can bear? (2286).
Verse 495 has nothing to do with salat or the nameless cleaning rituals. Provide a verse telling disable people on how to perform "wudu" or a physical salat for people like Nick. Every human with a sound mind can perform salat. Verse 56 contradicts this. Nick needs limbs to perform "wudu" and a physical salat.
If verse 56 is true, then it directly contradicts 2286. Nick is told by 56 to wash is arms, elbows and feet. Nick also needs limbs to perform a physical ritual called salat and not just a sound and functioning mind. Quran provides NO EXPLANATION on how disabled people perform the nameless cleaning ritual and physical salat.
This can only mean two things. Either the interpretation of 56 is false or disabled people are deprived from performing "wudu" and a physical salat. There isn't even a detailed explanation on how to perform a physical salat for healthy individuals in the Quran.Allah is fair and just. Allah gives every human, disabled or not, the ability to do salat. Salat is not a physical ritual. Everyone can do it, anytime and anywhere.
-
Invalid777 you say this " And what on earth has rubbing soil got to do with this so called cleaning ritual? Why is no name given to it? Please rub some soil on your face and tell me if it makes your face shine clean."
Maybe here lies your answer http//www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2646748/Hogwash-Yes-Meet-man-showered-12-years-instead-sprays-bacteria-hes-collected-pigsty-cowshed-chicken-coop-clean.html
and to be more precise"For the last 12 years he has sprayed himself with AOB that he has collected from soil in the pigsty, cowshed and chicken coop of an organic farm."
Peace.
Here's a challenge mmmm. Since you strongly support the interpretation of 56. Go out, grab a handful of soil, wipe it on your face and tell me how clean your face will shine.
http//www1.pictures.zimbio.com/gi/Tough+Bloke+Challenge+QNbjgU7xQjHl.jpgThis man looks clean, doesn't he?
-
Here's a challenge mmmm. Since you strongly support the interpretation of 56. Go out, grab a handful of soil, wipe it on your face and tell me how clean your face will shine.
http//www1.pictures.zimbio.com/gi/Tough+Bloke+Challenge+QNbjgU7xQjHl.jpgThis man looks clean, doesn't he?
Tayammum is a DRY ablution brother. Your analogy of this guy with mud over his face isn't accurate. Even animals can clean themselves effectively using dry sand.
-
Tayammum is a DRY ablution brother. Your analogy of this guy with mud over his face isn't accurate. Even animals can clean themselves effectively using dry sand.
Where can I find dry sand here in London? New York? Alaska? Quran is a guide for every human. Not just someone living in the Middle East or in a beach.
-
There's plenty of dry earth abound in London and New York what you talking about bro.
http//i.imgur.com/9PQBA3A.jpg
Britain is over two thirds Inceptisols. This is what it looks like.
http//www.cals.uidaho.edu/soilorders/i/Alf_02b.jpgAnd this is what beach sand looks like in Britain.
https//www.travelnation.co.uk/sites/default/files/styles/780x520/public/brighton_beach_turns_to_sand2.jpg?itok=S3q7VcJmUnless you live near a beach, there's no way you can clean yourself with dry earth. The soil here does NOT clean you. It makes you dirtier, not cleaner. Unless of course, you want to look like a tramp.
-
Hello,
Supposedly you can find dry sand to use to wipe a surface of the body in order to remove dirt, but I wonder about its deeper cleansing properties?
Even if you are careful, does it not leave particles of dirt (the sand) on your skin?
Ah well, everything people do to defend some silly rituals.
Be safe
Amenuel -
-
But at least middle eastern people is also not excluded from the Qur'an are they?
And sand, after water is not such scarce commodity aftera all anywhere.
Salaam
The same scum who hijacked the Quran came from that part of the world. Every interpretation of the Quran seems to go their way. It's no wonder it tells you to wipe dry soil to clean yourself. Dry soil isn't available everywhere. Every human should move to a beach or the Middle East.
Also, the stone cube in Mecca. Imagine living in Hawaii in the 7th century and being told to go for hajj. You'd die before you even reached Mecca. Yet we're told that Allah doesn't wish hardship on us. Quran only seems to benefit Middle Easterners.
-
Also, the stone cube in Mecca. Imagine living in Hawaii in the 7th century and being told to go for hajj. You'd die before you even reached Mecca. Yet we're told that Allah doesn't wish hardship on us. Quran only seems to benefit Middle Easterners.
Back then, the middle easterners doesn't even aware that Hawaii or even pacific ocean exist )
They didn't even aware the entire size of the earth, they think the earth is flat.
If they do, they will address that properly and wrote more careful and properly well thought verses when they were compiling the Quran. -
If they do, they will address that properly and wrote more careful and properly well thought verses when they were compiling the Quran.
Or they do not even write anything but just say the verses say something else instead, like they did the first time.
Be safe
Amenuel -
Or they do not even write anything but just say the verses say something else instead, like they did the first time.
Be safe
AmenuelI would say there are OTHER VERSES who said something else.
The "pattern" is quite common to be found in the bible bundle, gospel and quran.
I don't believe all or any of them are 100% "Godly inspired".
Human with their vested interest always tried to add something.. or delete something (which not suitable to their own liking)Yet the are 'defense mechanism' from 'human manipulation'.. consist of two layers.
1st layer is inside the entire bundle itself, that's why there are conflicting verses.. one said A the other said B which makes A illogical.
2nd layer is outside of the bundle itself, that's by comparing the statement of the verse with known facts / reality.
There is no such thing as "Final Revelation" or "Revelation has ended".
Revelation is a continuing process up until now..
As time progress, human knows more, being revealed more by their Maintainer..
Thus falsehood (on any sources) shall be exposed... -
The "pattern" is quite common to be found in the bible bundle, gospel and quran.
I don't believe all or any of them are 100% "Godly inspired".
Human with their vested interest always tried to add something.. or delete something (which not suitable to their own liking)It is not utterly important, because the conveyed information, what you become taught in form of pedagogy and psychology is more important than Quran as a "law book" and a book of threats as the mainstream interpretation, but the people you mention did not have to bother writing anything because with Quran they just took a finished compilation and then interpreted at their own will.
You can learn everything there is to know about faith from the Biblical Gospels without even touching Quran, but the most important is that you improve your own spirituality in pace with it. And if you are truly looking, you could get your answers without any scripture, but you only have to open your mind. Some kind of background information can aid a person's cause though, excluding the biased interpretations. I call the Biblical Gospels better as guidance than Quran as usually interpreted.
People should ditch the religious doctrines and get the point that Mr. Jesus tried to make instead, i.e. that people should shun the World and "Satan". Satan is easy to logically deduce to be the instinct if they read Jesus' responses. Jesus was teaching about "separation of the Spirit from the Flesh" which is easy to understand with a little insight. The faith is closer to East Asian faiths than your typical Abrahamic faiths with excessive worship.
There is no such thing as "Final Revelation" or "Revelation has ended".
Revelation is a continuing process up until now..Quran does not say anything about final revelation or whatever. It does claim to be a manifestation. Isaiah speaks of it in Isaiah 816 and it is referred to as a record containing a sealed instruction when it has been "folded", among a lot of riddle-like passages that I have worked on interpreting.
Jesus was also reading from some source which they were astonished with his interpretation. Quran is a similar phenomenon. It was part of a prophecy. People who are already familiar could throw Quran behind their back because Quran confirms a Buddhist/Gnostic lifestyle a'la Jesus. Popular Judaism, Islam (which is however a form of Judaism) and Christianity missed the point in what the prophets taught. Judaism, aka Islam, did not even accept what Jesus taught and had "forgotten" what Moses REALLY taught ("I am who I am" should ring a bell). In fact Islam can be said to be "the empire strikes back" due to Gnostic ideals and early Christianity which drowned either by persecution of the Roman Empire or the Muslim barbarians with Persian clerics backing it all up. People were not allowed to associate themselves with God as is the greatest sin in Pharisee Judaism and this is what happened after John the Baptist and Jesus. Jesus taught people "to be in the Father and the Father in them" (i.e. no separation of God necessary). That caused the Pharisee (Pagan) Rabbis to boil.
Revelation can indeed continue also today 2015. I have heard "Quran has never been interpreted. Islam is not My religion" (without joking), among other things. God's presence is not restricted to 600-700 AD if that is what people think.
As time progress, human knows more, being revealed more by their Maintainer..
Thus falsehood (on any sources) shall be exposed...Yes definitely. Exposing Quran is exactly what I am devoted to right now, by its own revelation.
How Quran has turned out to be has made the Biblical Gospels much more authentic because Quran confirms the Gospels which came earlier, i.e. the model of spirituality and the "To be Who Is is to be Such Who is" in "I am in the Father and the Father in me" manner.
Be safe
Amenuel -
But at least middle eastern people is also not excluded from the Qur'an are they?
And sand, after water is not such scarce commodity aftera all anywhere.
Salaam
I don't even know what the contention is here, I kind of tuned in and out intermittently.
I live the in the UK Invalid777 and you can get dry earth in London. Your chart is all well and fancy but the earth in the UK really isn't that different to the earth in Turkey, Iraq, Morocco, Greece, USA - think we have a classic case of nitpicking.
What is the argument here? That the Qur'an is being stupid asking for people to make tayammum?
-
You can learn everything there is to know about faith from the Biblical Gospels without even touching Quran, but the most important is that you improve your own spirituality in pace with it. And if you are truly looking, you could get your answers without any scripture, but you only have to open your mind. Some kind of background information can aid a person's cause though, excluding the biased interpretations. I call the Biblical Gospels better as guidance than Quran as usually interpreted.
Certainly, many people received guidance without any books.
The entire notion of "God(s) authored a book" was started by Ancient Egyptian.
Dogmatized as such in order to make revenue from selling the "God's authored book".
Inside it contains many things which is impossible to believe (or prove), thus the argument that "it was coming from God" will silence all the questioning.The first "God's authored book" titled "Book of the dead" was put for sale at around $200,000 if it's in today US dollar. Or about 4 years salary of highly ranked Ancient Egyptian's government official.
Not all people can buy it..
Yet the priest cannot make so many copies of such "God's authored book" either, due to non existence of Printing Press, everything need to be written and drawn manually.
However, the Ancient Egyptian priest did make a lot of money from it..The Ancient Egyptian priest has same motive as why Abraham's father invented a lot of myths and idols... to make a living.
People should ditch the religious doctrines and get the point that Mr. Jesus tried to make instead, i.e. that people should shun the World and "Satan". Satan is easy to logically deduce to be the instinct if they read Jesus' responses. Jesus was teaching about "separation of the Spirit from the Flesh" which is easy to understand with a little insight. The faith is closer to East Asian faiths than your typical Abrahamic faiths with excessive worship.
Definitely, now I'm starting to realize that the Eastern Asian tradition (Dharmic line of thought) makes more sense compared to their western counterpart.
And they don't have any "holy book" or claimed that the book was written by God.Quran does not say anything about final revelation or whatever.
Agree, revelation is still continuing up until now..
However this lead to another question
WHY DID SOMEONE CAME UP WITH THE IDEA OF FINAL REVELATION?
What are his or their motive of doing such? -
why do you need soil when there is water?
and invalid777, if youre problem is finding soil, then just buy some and save it so as to reuse it if you dont have water.
Can you tell me where there is lack of water? anywhere in the world. Oh right, there are som places ; Deserts.
oh
'Undoubtedly, my prayer, and my sacrifices, and my living and my dying are all for Allah Who is theLord of all the worlds.'
6162 -
why do you need soil when there is water?
and invalid777, if youre problem is finding soil, then just buy some and save it so as to reuse it if you dont have water.
Can you tell me where there is lack of water? anywhere in the world. Oh right, there are som places ; Deserts.
oh
'Undoubtedly, my prayer, and my sacrifices, and my living and my dying are all for Allah Who is theLord of all the worlds.'
6162http//replygif.net/i/90.gif
-
http//replygif.net/i/90.gif
Still didn't provide me with a verse on how people with no limbs are to perform the so called "wudu" ritual and the physical salat.
-
Hello brother Jafar,
Certainly, many people received guidance without any books.
Yes, but you must agree that sometimes books say something quite wise, even if it is taken from "holy books" such as the Biblical Gospels?
The Ancient Egyptian priest has same motive as why Abraham's father invented a lot of myths and idols... to make a living.
It has not ended there. The Pharisee clergy had high ranks within their society and while the people abstained, these hypocrites feasted in the shadows when no one was looking and they had many "exceptions" for themselves. I also wonder why only a priest class was allowed to enter specific parts of the temple hint hint. So much falsehood and greed.
Definitely, now I'm starting to realize that the Eastern Asian tradition (Dharmic line of thought) makes more sense compared to their western counterpart.
And they don't have any "holy book" or claimed that the book was written by God.I agree with you. What is cool however is that Jesus' life as portrayed by the Biblical Gospels is very much like their model of spirituality yet Christians, who mainly claim to adhere to the message, are more concerned with materialism and superficial worship (which the God has never prescribed anyway). Have you ever reflected upon that Jesus actively tries to diminish the obsession with God, rarely even using the term in his alleged sayings and boosts the confidence of being "I AM", even associating yourself with the phenomenon of God which he prefers to call 'Father' with all right. You can see similar ideas like in Hinduism and being complete in Brahman. Similarly, non-obsessed with an entity, is Jesus and Jesus works on actually being the entity in union. He is like a wise Buddha (which means "enlightened" in the tongue very identical to nabi in Arabic) and surely would not have liked to have been worshiped after he gave up the Spirit in the Body. Worship is a damned curse. Probably fueled by the instinct.
However, I like books and I like to interpret them myself rather than listening to someone else who has. It paid off for me. Quran looks like a Gnostic writing. It is yielding me wisdom. However like you say, to define something as holy is probably to take it too far, it causes the risk of tunnel-vision to have a unique holy scripture. Besides, there is clear evidence that Quran is not at 100% integrity even taking it once was an intact revelation, just see the Sana'a manuscripts. The word holy comes from whole, and if something is not 100% integrity it is not whole, i.e. holy.
Agree, revelation is still continuing up until now..
However this lead to another question
WHY DID SOMEONE CAME UP WITH THE IDEA OF FINAL REVELATION?
What are his or their motive of doing such?Perhaps interpretation acrobatics of linguistics. In English, last can either refer to the previous one in a succession or the final one, even if literally it would say nothing whether it is a permanent stop. Perchance similar ignorance can have caused a confusion between final versus the last. Quran is claimed to say that "Muhammad is a messenger and the seal of prophets", which virtually everyone interprets as "termination" or "end", but personally I take the seal as the brand or something like "circle of prophets".
Kh-Ta-Miim = To seal/stamp/imprint/impress, to secure/protect oneself against a thing, produce an impression or effect upon a thing, reach the end of a thing, cover over a thing, turn away/avoid/shun someone or something, to not understand, prevent the heart from believing, feign heedlessness.
Why would that man Muhammad be the last prophet anyway? Cannot anyone else become insightful (the word nabi means literally insightful)? I think it is quite easy to be a nabi actually but harder to perfect yourself. It is easier to talk and learn than do it in practice with yourself.
It is harder to be a 'Rasuul' in Arabic in that case which is an object of imitation, like a beacon, but even there for the ardent person there are possibilities. It is the will to join the power of 'Who Is' that puts the limitations. One is not born to be one either but it is a role you grow into. People who looked for real lexical definitions for rasuul did not look enough. If you help someone accomplish something you can be a rasuul, such as teach to play a guitar or sing. But it takes that you live as you teach if you are a spiritual rasuul, one who teaches to be 'Who Is'.
The idea of final revelation is because Muhammad is deemed the last prophet and only a prophet writes revelations.
I would be bold and claim no one knows Muhammad anyway. There has never been any man called Muhammad with the traditional characteristics in God's service. No man would be so unrighteous in that kind of service. Jesus would have shaken his head.
I think Muhammad was invented by the Persian clerics who took the opportunity to abuse Quran for their own purpose. In all that they wrote hadith so they had a little fairy tale connected to it, a background of a great warlord named Muhammad, entirely contrary (for some reason) to what Jesus taught as according to Gospels. I think I do not even know a prophet that is so portrayed as being so merciless. "Kill them wherever you find them". KILL KILL KILL, the word KILL is repeatedly used (as interpreted) so many times you wonder what kind of madman made it. "But if they are not associators (the word mushrik literally means this) then you can spare them when they Pagan worship our deity with exactly our ritual which "Allah" commanded us to do even if we never had any explicit manual and in our holy scripture its details are scattered all over it vaguely describing its practice". (I hope you enjoy the irony with an edge of sarcasm)
Be safe
Amenuel