The concept of "Sin"
-
Actually what rraza is saying is very logical but her argument is been bullied by opposition's arguments.
Some one said that "we need a test to go in to next grade"
Did in the very first place we asked to be created, was my question? then why enroll us and promote us or test us to promote to next grade, that does not make any sense.2362 And We do not burden a soul except with what it can bear. And We have a record that speaks with the truth, they will not be wronged.
This verse is supposedly for an after life. It is talking about soul. But we see that often body bears which it can't bear and end result is ........?
Caveman Doctor
The short answer is everyone is not in the same boat.
Different situations/circumstances/etc. affect to what degree one's soul is burdened or lightened through positive and negative actions.
See, e.g., 3330 and 425 which describe different punishments for the same action, depending on who the doer of the action is.But Doc, why punishment in the first place? no matter in whichever boat you are, you are in this world on some one Else's terms and conditions some one else has defined the rules and roles then why punishment? why pain ? by that some one else.
Wootah
Aren't you following the thread?
Is this answer to my question?
-
Actually what rraza is saying is very logical but her argument is been bullied by opposition's arguments.
Caveman Doctor
But Doc, why punishment in the first place? no matter in whichever boat you are, you are in this world on some one Else's terms and conditions some one else has defined the rules and roles then why punishment? why pain ? by that some one else.Pretty sure rraza isn't being bullied. At any rate, check out some of the earlier posts in this thread about 'punishment.' Might help to have a paradigm shift in how these issues could be thought about. With regard to being here on someone else's terms and conditions, you should check out 3372 and related verses.