Members Comments on Formal Debate on Abrogation in Quran
-
AQ asks question
Th1 says before he will answer this AQ must answer 5 questions from him including if AQ believes in the subject
AQ says he doesnt and asks TH1 to answer the question please
Th1 laughs and asks another question being why would I answer a question about something you dont know about
here I start thinking - DUH, so you have to know and believe in something BEFORE you can ask a question on it now? ???
TH1 declares debate over and brings a verse to 'prove' he shouldnt talk to AQTh1 then asks SC to bring 'the best on the site' and not someone who makes jokes.
I must have missed the other joke in there o
AQ answers that he doesnt believe in abrogation but confirms he knows about abrogation. and asks again fot Th1 to answer the original question
Score AQ - 1, Th1 - 0
-
The answer of abdulquran was "No, I don't know " and it is not an answer for my questions . No is with why .
So keep your comments in your side, I don't care about what might people said here . People read the debate and they saw the ignorance of Abdulquran .
Abdulquran didn't even know what the word means , I explained it to him before and he accepted it.
Do you know what his nickname here means ? the worshipper of Quran =Abdulquran .
-
Stickied it as a parallel. Here we can call idiocy idiocy as and when the idiocy occurs. Thanks Ayisha
-
Stickied it as a parallel. Here we can call idiocy idiocy as and when the idiocy occurs. Thanks Ayisha )
You can't even bring the best in this Forum . An Nabi is a moderator, Jack too, and you . A mission have done .
-
Go reply to the thread Th1, don't confirm further what we already know.
-
The answer of abdulquran was "No, I don't know " and it is not an answer for my questions . No is with why .
YOU were asked a question first and as always you DIDNT answer it and posed 5 questions for him to answer so as to avoid you answering the question he asked FIRST. To ask HOW MANY are abrogated does not require belief OR KNOWLEDGE in them.So keep your comments in your side, I don't care about what might people said here .
I will, thats why I opened the thread DUH.People read the debate and they saw the ignorance of Abdulquran .
well we have only seen yours up to now, but waiting patiently for you to answer the FIRST question. sunAbdulquran didn't even know what the word means , I explained it to him before and he accepted it.
Then explain it again and if i remember correctly you didnt answer this same question then. I think he accepted that you had no knowledge and gave up. I doubt very much he didnt know what the word meant, unless you have a totally off the planet theory on that too.Do you know what his nickname here means ? the worshipper of Quran =Abdulquran .
no it doesnt. Abd is slave, a slave doesnt necesarily worship his master, he does as his master tells him to.
-
Erm ... no. You asked whether he believes in abrogation, and his answer was "No, I don't."
As has been stated, you don't need to believe in something in order to discuss it. confused
exactly!! and you dont have to explain WHY you dont believe in something for a question to be answered, that is just AVOIDING answering and trying to go OFF TOPIC.
we are watching you Th1
still th1 = 0 AQ = 1
-
Of course he's running away, I have a bet worth 10 cookies on this. He will never answer, he'll keep saying everything under the sun but answer and shut us up <taunt>
-
Peace,
The debate is end here with a proof from Quran that the abrogation is existed and all Muslims believed in it .
{ } (106) .
Verse taken out of context; read verse prior to see what is being replaced/given similar...
2105
No abrogating within Qur'an otherwise that would be a contraction...
482 So do they not consider The Qur'an, and if (it) were from at other than God, they would have found in it much contradiction.
Did not read the title being a private debate -- if you like delete my post.
-
Th1 knows as well as I do WHY he cannot answer the question. He knows deep down the trickery and deceit behind abrogation. That's why he refuses to answer.
-
Noon, this thread is for comments, the other for the two members.
Not that there's any point as Th1's already lost <taunt>.
-
Th1 admits avoiding the question before and refuses to answer this time telling AQ to go find the answers himself.
looks like AQ is a WINNER bravo bravo
and still the question posed to the great KNOWLEDGE BUMP himself is UNANSWERED. rotfl
Aha, I understand now , everyone in this website doesn't know about the abrogate , wooww . You guys wanted the answer, hahahah, you will not take it , so keep dreaming . You don't even understand the verses, the abrogate will just make a headache for the rest of your life . rotfl yay
Well, don't need to shout and said that AQ is the winner , people are not ignorance like you .
-
Th1 logic 9or lack of)
"Yes, I've never gave you the number, you're right because you don't know about the subject and how the use of it, go learn and study about it, it will take you just some months , then come back and ask me this question, I'll give you every Nasekh with its Mansoukh .
UNtil that time , I must call you to convert "Islam". Do you know brother that Islam is the last religion from God to all humanity ? "
wow what a dance! So in order to ask a question to LEARN about a subject from one who CLAIMS to have knowledge, one must first LEARN the subject. ???
