RULES:
-
hi mquran,
Can you please define what you mean by 'suitable'. What makes something more 'suitable'?
by suitable, i mean appropriate to the present state of affairs and living conditions.
for eg, the punishment for stealing- i would think imprisionment is appropriate rather than chopping the hand.
propably people of that period needed such rules as they did not have much concepts of right and wrong. would the same severity be required now? -
Peace,
i think most of it stands good for all times
I'm not sure why the punishments and rules of society should not stand for all time.
chopping hand vs imprisonment for stealing?
Which standard are you talking about? Is this the standard of the society in which you live, imprisonment for stealing? As MQ said, the punishment is not the physical chopping off of one's hands rather cutting their power or means. The punishment should fit the crime.
again, poly gamy? wasnt it specific?
Yes alquran does have specific instances under which polygamy may come into play. You may not like it, I do not necessarily like the idea . Monagomy is what is basically promoted.
and should the punishment for adultery be
100 lashes. You must not let pity detain you from obedience to Allah.
mind u, am not saying adultery is right. all i am asking is, is this punishment not more suitable for that era than now?
Could you explain why this punishment may be less suitable?
Joe
-
Peace,
propably people of that period needed such rules as they did not have much concepts of right and wrong.
Are you saying the moral conceptions of men a few milennia ago were not on par with our own today? That our morals have evolved from a more primitive morality?
Joe
-
Salaamun alaikum Elena and PM,
PM can u explain what u think Allah meant by slaves in that verse?
Raqabah in 4/92 refers to a person in bondage. It could be a financial bondage for example.
its quite surprising to know that someone believes that our living conditions are no better than people of 570 AD. and that we are equal to the slaves of that period .
Im sorry but this doesnt answer my point. Im not talking about living conditions, im speaking of what matters, the evolution of our selves. I can live with all the amenities which these times provide but unless I follow Quranic law, my self will not develop accordingly. In other words, 'technology' is not an element in the equation of suitablility in the Quranic criteria.
o.k. do u believe the torah, gospel etc were guidance/messages from God?
No.
Elena it is unfair that you say I have attached preconception about the word when the meaning from the beginning was slave = a person who is owned by another person
You asked me if paying taxes makes one a slave. I replied that slavery is defined by governance. I.e. you follow X's laws, you're X's slave. So the essence of slavery is not Kunta Kinte style suffering. You could live in relative opulence and still be a slave to a person.
I said I intuit that you've attached a preconcieved notion. If Im wrong, my humble apologies.
good to know that the reading uses two different words for those two different meanings. Then, why did you start talking about abd-servant when the topic was slave person who is owned by another person?
Because that's not the only verse pertaining to slaves. Please look at 24/32, which uses the word 'your slaves' (ibadikum)
what slavery? person who is owned by another person or servant of God?
Both. You cannot escape from serving something, even if its your ego. That's why there's no 'athiesm' in quranic thought.
PMby suitable, i mean appropriate to the present state of affairs and living conditions.
for eg, the punishment for stealing- i would think imprisionment is appropriate rather than chopping the hand.
propably people of that period needed such rules as they did not have much concepts of right and wrong. would the same severity be required now?I salute your honesty in using the phrase 'i think' and 'probably'. Sadly, this is where it ends because on paper, we can't see which is more suitable, modern retributions or quranic retributions. I trust al-quraan to provide the most suitable punishments because of the accuracy with which it has deconstructed the world for me. The only test to suitability is the results.
-
I respect your opinion and decision but keep developing yourself by reading and studying the Quran. It's not as hard as it is as people will tell you but takes time and I'm still learning
I have witness your understanding of Qur'an on Leaving the Body and other threads. Its you who needs to learn how to do interpretation of verses logically instead of me.
Again thank you for advice.
-
Salaam KGB,
I have not problem with different interpretation of cutting hands. I said exactly what you are saying in different words ofcouse. I never had any problem discussing issues with Joe, Kyle or you.
Same goes with me. We may not agree, but alhamdulillah, the right attitude is there.
If it was cutting of the hands, i should have no problem with it either if it was really the case. In any ruling given by Allah or His messenger, the correct response is we hear and we obey.
I had a problem with this with the democracy issue some years back. I could not believe that al-quraan doesn't prescribe democracy. However, after observing 'modern evolved' society, I understood why. Al-quraan simply knows us better that we'd ever know ourselves.
-
Raqabah in 4/92 refers to a person in bondage. It could be a financial bondage for example.
I call it Corporation slavery. Slaves of the sytem set up by rich and powerful. Financial institution and Credit Cards system Slavery. I believe I fully agree on you on the modern day slavery concept.
-
I call it Corporation slavery. Slaves of the sytem set up by rich and powerful. Financial institution and Credit Cards system Slavery. I believe I fully agree on you on the modern day slavery concept.
Yes exactly. These corporations are the best examples of the modern-day slave masters. Using their economic leverage , they enforce a whole culture of greed and oppression.
-
PeacefulMuslim
100 lashes punishment for adultery is the most appropriate even in today. Read the verses carefully which are clear that this punishment is prescribed by Allah Taala to cause shame and humiliation for adulterers instead of harming them physically. This is my understanding you have the right to disagree.
-
Salaam all,
wow hot discussions again!!!
Jaxal don't make us to be your enemies, please!?
Mq I agree with you, that's all I can say right now when i have read what you have written.
Peace Sis Maria
-
!
-
Salaam Br Jaxal,
Never mind Jaxal.
But aren't u and Br Joe argue too much???
Peace Sis Maria
-
Hi Nabi,
I'm not sure why the punishments and rules of society should not stand for all time.
hmm, ok.
do u feel if Quran was sent today, it would have the same kind of punishments and rules?Which standard are you talking about? Is this the standard of the society in which you live, imprisonment for stealing? As MQ said, the punishment is not the physical chopping off of one's hands rather cutting their power or means. The punishment should fit the crime.
Didnt quite get u. isnt the punishment for stealing, imprisonment in today's world?
if its not the physical chopping, then what is it?cutting their power or means- how?100 lashes. You must not let pity detain you from obedience to Allah.
Could you explain why this punishment may be less suitable?yeah, Adultery is not considered much of a crime these days and actual punishment for it doesnt really exsist. have no clue what a suitable punishment would be. but 100 lashes does sound harsh.
-
Hi Nabi,
Are you saying the moral conceptions of men a few milennia ago were not on par with our own today? That our morals have evolved from a more primitive morality?
Yes! do u believe that people have not evolved into more civilzed beings now?
i mean, if we dig into history, there wasnt much order, civilzation back then. -
o.k. do u believe the torah, gospel etc were guidance/messages from God?
No.
o.k.so, do u believe quran is a message/guidance from God?
33 It is He Who sent down to thee (step by step), in truth, the Book, confirming what went before it; and He sent down the Law (of Moses) and the gospel (of Jesus) before this, as a guide to mankind, and He sent down the criterion (of judgment between right and wrong).
I salute your honesty in using the phrase 'i think' and 'probably'. Sadly, this is where it ends because on paper, we can't see which is more suitable, modern retributions or quranic retributions. I trust al-quraan to provide the most suitable punishments because of the accuracy with which it has deconstructed the world for me. The only test to suitability is the results.
Are u saying the punishments used in today's world such as imprisonment, rigorous imprisonment etc are of no good and bring no results?
-
Hi KGB,
100 lashes punishment for adultery is the most appropriate even in today. Read the verses carefully which are clear that this punishment is prescribed by Allah Taala to cause shame and humiliation for adulterers instead of harming them physically. This is my understanding you have the right to disagree.
Hmm, yeah, but is there no other less physical way of doing it?
i mean, the point is, who ever commits adultery should be made to feel sorry for it coz its a sin. cant we do it in any other way, other than 100 lashes?just a thought!and u can disagree too. peace!