JK- Lets say GOD forbid a person kills my mother and gets away with it without being legally punished in his life. Later on in his life he sincerely repents to GOD for what he has done. Now what good would that do to me? Did you think of that? How will that benefit me? Do you think GOD deosnt care for me anymore once that other murderer has repented? No the Quran does state that the offence from GOD's side maybe forgiven but that does not mean that i dont have the right to take revenge. GOD clearly says in the Quran that "equivalence has been prescribed for us"
And we decreed for them in it that the life for the life, the eye for the eye, the nose for the nose, the ear for the ear, the tooth for the tooth, and an equivalent injury for any injury. If one forfeits what is due to him as a charity, it will atone for his sins. Those who do not rule in accordance with GOD's revelations are the unjust.
So i cannot believe that GOD will be injust towards a victim just because the offender asked forgiveness from GOD and never bothered to ask forgiveness from the victim. The case is different if the intention of the offender was to ask the viictim for forgiveness but that either he himself or the victim died before he could. GOD Bless!
Peace,
Khizar 545 does not relate to forgiveness for the sins of someone who commits wrong. The God is the one who forgives regardless.
Your verse relates to the punishment for a crime and not the forgiveness or repentance for sins committed which 4125 deals with and which I quoted previously.
You were initially saying you would have a right against that person in the afterlife and this remains wrong. In 545 you see that your right for revenge is limited to this world. If the offender is caught then you can shoose to have the person punished or forgo the punishment in which case the God rewards you!
If the offender is not caught, and that is under the God's control also then you have nothing. The God will take account of that crime regardless and you don't have to worry about it.
Now returning to the topic of this post rather than twisting it to your own ends; in the case of a sin like adultery, the wife in this case may have a grievance but has no right over the man and no right for 'revenge' either. If the man repents sincerely then it is the God who forgives and he does not require forgiveness from the wife who may bear a grudge until the day she dies. That's to her detriment and says more about her inability to deal with it and move on than anything else. The woman does not have a right to send the person to hell because of a grudge, especially if the man has sincerely repented and reformed.
