Skip to content

General Issues / Questions

This area deals with any general questions/issues regarding God / Islam / Quran not covered under other headings.

This category can be followed from the open social web via the handle [email protected]

7.1k Topics 133.0k Posts
  • 2:185 'SHAHR RAMAZAN' Sign

    19
    0 Votes
    19 Posts
    594 Views
    N
    The first occurrence of the phrase 'al-rahman al-rahim' appearing together in The Quran within the 29 Initialled Chapters, is as the final two words at the end of Verse 2163 of The Quran. الرحمن l-rahmāni/the almighty الرحىم l-rahimi/the merciful 618 13020084050 13020081040 = 29 x 2131483451174142420717600 There are exactly 2888 words from the beginning of the initialled chapters 21 Alif, Lam, Mim in Chapter Two, up to the end of verse 2163… 2888 = 19 x 152 = 19 x 19 x 8 so what? show counts? which text you using? 1,000+ errors https//tanzil.net/download/ example ىاىها yāayyuhā/O you (single word not two as in tanzil يا أيها ) 221 ىاىها yāayyuhā/O you الناس l-nāsu 2104 2153 ىاىها yāayyuhā/O you الذىن alladhina The total count of all of the words of The Bismillah in The Quran is also 2888!! 11 1141 2730 بسم bismi 3 total 2155 الله l-lahi 240 والله wal-lahu 139 بالله bil-lahi 116 لله lillahi 27 ولله walillahi 8 تالله tal-lahi 6 فالله fal-lahu 6 فلله falillahi 1 وتالله watal-lahi 1 ابالله abil-lahi 2699 total (prime!) 45 الرحمن l-rahmāni 9 للرحمن lilrrahmāni 3 بالرحمن bil-rahmāni 57 total 34 الرحىم l-rahimi 60 رحىم rahimun 20 رحىما rahiman 6 الرحمىن l-rāhimina 120 total 3 + 2699 + 57 + 120 = 2879 (prime!) 3 2286 7155 23109 وارحمنا wa-irhamnā 1 723 وترحمنا watarhamnā 1 7149 ىرحمنا yarhamnā 1 1147 وترحمنى watarhamni 1 2375 رحمنهم rahimnāhum 1 6728 رحمنا rahimanā 8 total 2879 + 8 = 2887 (prime!) These are enormous proofs my companions. To deny the existence of nineteen as a structural marker of The Quran is becoming tantamount to denial of reality. I can only now pity the fate of those still caught in denial. infatuation (fitna) disease like worshipping idols! tempt peace
  • Deconstructing the arguments for hijab

    12
    0 Votes
    12 Posts
    160 Views
    G
    Peace. Is the argument about what Qoran- GOD s words- says or does not say about Hijab? Well what does it say? As for Hadiths, whatever they say, it is not important as they are men s words. If they agree with Qoran, then Qoran said it first. If they contradict it or say a different thing then it has nothing to do with GOD or Qoran. Hadiths have not been sent by GOD and are not GOD s words. Of course women have the choice in what they want to wear. Whatever Qoran says or Hadith says ,women should still have the choice There is no argument here or is there? God bless. Peace
  • Abortion and responsibility

    4
    0 Votes
    4 Posts
    88 Views
    G
    Peace. Carry on living the present being GOD conscious and disregard the past. GOD is well aware that you are worried about what you have done and you may be annoyed by it. We all struggle with daily shortcomings ,yours seem nothing , but if we believe in accountability ,we will remember GOD , repent and try to live to the standard He set for us. Do your best each day , serve you creator by seeking His help and support. GOD is forgiver most Merciful. GOD bless you. Peace.
  • True meaning of verses refer to life after death

    2
    0 Votes
    2 Posts
    54 Views
    J
    Which means there is LIFE even after this Life immediately after they part and we are not supposed to call them dead but we just cant perceive that their eternal life has already started vs those who are in deep sleep and will be resurrected on day of judgement. There are lives even before "this life" and there are lives after "this life". There are identities even before "this identity" and there are identities after "this identity". Because life, where life here refer to consciousness, is eternal, no beginning and no end. Yet identity, in which the consciousness identify/attached itself to, is temporary. God told him that you are forgiven even before the judgement day "Physical life review session" begins after the consciousness unit has able to let go of it's attachment to the physical body who just became dysfunctional. When physical bodies drop dead, the consciousness unit focus itself to another layer of body, this layer of body is called by many names, astral body, pranic body, energy body, ghost body etc.. It can choose to "go to the light" a.k.a enter the time/space dimension where "review session" will be started OR linger around (temporarily) in the "lower astral dimension", the dimension / realm which is closest (in frequency) to the physical realm. Where he/she can watch events happened in the physical realm but no longer physically interact with it. When it entered the time/space dimension, it will then experience the "replay" of all events during his/her physical experience. With a little twist; he/she can also experienced the events from "other identity's perspective". Let say he was a bully during high school, he can experience the bullying events from the bully perspective and also the kid that he bullied during high school. As thus he will then 'judged himself' so to speak. Thus the saying, 'using the standard that you judged other people, you will also be judged'. Judge and you shall be judged, forgive and you shall be forgiven. "Paradise already existed in reality in todays time" Time and space is virtual, an illusion. Yes there are other dimensions/realms, some are beautiful, happy, peaceful and some are the opposite.
  • ACCORDING TO THE QURAN , ALCOHOL IS NOT HARAM, IT IS "CONDITIONAL HALAL"

    16
    0 Votes
    16 Posts
    264 Views
    J
    God gas given common sense and every one can use it to take benefit. They ask you ˹O Prophet˺ about intoxicants and gambling. Say, “There is great evil in both, as well as some benefit for people—but the evil outweighs the benefit.” (Quran, Al-Baqarah, 2219). O believers! Intoxicants, gambling, idols, and drawing lots for decisions are all evil of Satan’s handiwork. So shun them so you may be successful. (Quran, Al-Maidah, 590) It is as simple as this Technically you may have a point but if any one who is passionate about LISTEN to what God says then HE is telling you to "shun/refrain" from the "great evil" . Now this may not be HARAM but it is also not HALAL to disobey the God. Peace... Common sense is what all has to apply... But unfortunately you have not used it in this topic... God has forbidden four categories of food and you forbid more in literal statements... Do you think God is short of verses to forbid what you forbid... Where is your common sense brother... Don't forget word wine and intoxicants are different.. Read verses of intoxicants and wine... Different way of writing.. In Yousuf story ladies used and other are wine.. But God says to avoid is intoxicants .... If the wine is made to intoxicate then it is intoxicants.. But Quran is clear it onlyvsaid avoid intoxicants not wine... Further .izm is not Sin brother... Different topic but connected to the verses... Izm is fault/faulty or injustice. .what the heck is sin in a nutshell... Anyways until one realized on his own every advice may look alien abd against him... So seek guidance...
  • Where does the Qur'an mention that the Bible was distorted

    5
    0 Votes
    5 Posts
    84 Views
    FusionF
    Quran 345 And when the angels said 'O Mary! Allah gives you the glad tidings of a command from Him his name shall be Messiah, Jesus, the son of Mary. He shall be highly honoured in this world and in the Next, and shall be one of those near stationed to Allah. Ironically, In almost all translations in English, the ٱلْمَسِيحُ عِيسَى is translated as Messiah - Jesus Therefore many refer Isa, Jesus and Joshua to the same person. So much so that the Quran denies what is quoted in the Bible regarding the life of the messenger "Jesus" that he (God forbid) lived a life of helplessness and humiliation. His followers with great pride present a picture of him to the world in which he is depicted as living the life of a beggar and in the last moments of his life, Jewish and Roman soldiers treated him with extreme humiliation. The Quran categorically refutes this and states (in above verse) that "His name will be Isa, the son of Mary, held in honour in this world and the Hereafter and of (the company of) those nearest to Allah. In the Bible it is stated that God created Adam only originally, but when Adam became sad due to being alone, then woman was created from his rib, so that she could provide him with pleasant company. Then Satan misguided woman (Eve) and she in turn became the cause of man’s slip – this is why in the world, woman is considered the source of all sins. The Quran has rejected both these concepts. It states that man and woman were created alike and declares that each has his or her own significance and both can commit errors. Therefore woman is not the source of sins. So the bible we have today is mixed with such fabrications and even if it has some relevance, based on the above examples, it is corrupted. Hence I agree with Jhkan,it is just a compiled book from different sources. Now, the question of Jesus, Isa,Joshua are same person... I leave this discussion open. or the person who raised this can open another thread.
  • Natural Disasters

    19
    0 Votes
    19 Posts
    204 Views
    J
    Sorry little off-topic... Just I saw in Jazeera.. Tow 20 year old brothers were saved just today after 190hours.. Alhamdullah... God only knows why they were saved... Tears all over..
  • What is the language in heaven?

    67
    0 Votes
    67 Posts
    2k Views
    J
    This is a misunderstanding of Quranic text. But it's not your fault. Some Quran translator put that the 'reward' for the people who passed the test is virgin lady rotfl But if you want to do a little research, you will find that the word used in the verse has nothing to do with that. Here is the example 3748 waʿindahum qāṣirātu l-ṭarfi ʿīnun Common Translation 3748 And with them are those with a modest gaze, with lovely eyes. My Translation 3748 And with them are adjacent house/palace with spring of water. Qasiratul = Qaf-Sad-Ra become short, have little or no power, become niggardly, fall short, i.e. not to reach something, left/relinquish/abstain/desist/cease, took from its length, clip/shove, restricted/confined/limited, kept within certain bounds or limits, restrain/withheld, hinder/prevent, contract or draw oneself together, obedient, last part of day. qasr (pl. qusur) - ample and spacious house, castle, palace. tarfi = = Tay-Ra-Fa attack the extremity of the enemy's lines, chose a thing, extremity, edge, lateral/adjacent/outward part, side, border, end, newly acquired, proximity, fringes. leaders/thinkers/scholars, best of the fruits. Look from outer angle of eye, twinkle in eye, putting eyelids in motion, looking, glance, blinking, raise/open eyes, hurt the eye and make it water. descend from an ancient family, noble man in respect of ancestry. inun = Ayn-Ya-Nun to hurt in the eye, smite anyone with the evil eye, flow tears, become a spy. Aayan - to view, face. 'Ainun - eye, look, hole, but of a tree, spy, middle letter of a trilateral word, spring of water, chief, personage of a place. A'yan lovely, wide-eyed, lovely black eyed. water, spring. As you can see, none of the Qaf-Sad-Ra literal translation means virgin ladies or something like that. I don't know how's the translator come into that conclusion. But as I mention in the previous reply, that the second creation is repetition of the first creation. It including the men and women creation. Here is the verse talk about humans creation 41 O people, be aware of your Lord who has created you from one person and He created from it its mate and sent forth from it many men and many women; and be aware of God whom you ask about, and the relatives. God is Watcher over you. So there is no new creature called angels or virgins to accompany the man who passed the test.. "The virgin ladies" is no other than the woman who passed the test during the first creation. So basically, we are all in the same level. Peace Peace everyone... Very very interesting.... So.. According to him, it seems no sex in Janna and no women partner... Well it makes sense in angle.. Why we need sex in Janna? Your well constructed opinions within Quran or logic pls..
  • Guys, how's your experience with du'a/ personal prayers

    7
    0 Votes
    7 Posts
    72 Views
    H
    Peace Sarah, All Here is a short video that may be helpful. https//youtu.be/zHgJEZEnwH0 God bless you all peace
  • HELL FIRE Punishment

    11
    0 Votes
    11 Posts
    80 Views
    J
    But do we take the test seriously? Do some care about being tested by GOD? Or even know they are being tested? Or care if GOD exist? How come one is in a test he is not aware of until he/she believes in a message from GOD? So the initial step is "true belief" in GOD and starting to be GOD conscious. Then this test will have to go both ways, you also testing if what GOD says is true.. This leads to the road of "certainty" or not.that can go on as long as one lives. Therefore it is the journey of trials of the test of success and failures that will take place that is going to shape your character and relationship with GOD. Again this may end in success or failure. Only if the devotion to GOD Alone and the sincerity is consistent and sought with perseverance and effort ,then success may follow. With pain there is gain. The road to hell is easier. GOD bless you. Peace. Some very good points you are raising... But everyone who spent at least 50 years of life having no physical defects by birth knows that this life is full of struggle and they all know that the life is a test.. It is the natural consciousness God has inserted in everyone.. But your concern how one knows that he is being tested by God... As I said three reasons God created human and Jinns... First point Worship God alone ie Obey God / believe God / Accept God second point is to TEST and Third point is who is better in DEEDS through the Test or rather struggle of life time. ... Well when a child grows he is impulsively confined into a Testing field which is full of struggle regardless of how rich or how poor or how illiterate or how erudite his condition may be. Test is of various types/nature to every individual.. So God is doing His part when a child is growing... During the test a person chooses a path... For example a disbeliver of any type (atheist / idol worshipper etc) .. No one is literally born but get adapted to with willingness .. Meanwhile life is beautiful not in everyone's life in absolute sense but peoples perception that life is beautiful and they realize to live that beautiful life they need to fight with certain elements/factors regardless of rich or poor or intelligent or laymen.. . So it differs what they fight with... So they give priority to life to maintain that beauty in life.. In a nutshell happy life.. And they totally discard the natural instinct and follow own desire to overcome the beauty of life.. Literally they surrender to life though life is a mere test only.. Nobody who lived a matured life denies the fact that life is struggle /Test. They know.. They definitely realize. But from whom the struggle is they don't want to know/realize but life itself they love.. And they take struggle/test as a challenge and proceed coz they want the beauty of life to be maintained ... But failing to realize struggle should be turning point for human to perceive who is behind this and why. But they didn't give priority to it. Coz they loved this life more than anything... so they continued and ended life in their desired manner... But believers are totally opposite to this.. They also going through same struggle / test. But gave time in life to realise why they struggle and they paved in roads to the natural instinct which God kept in every human being. So they chose the right path and enhanced it throughout the life and they gave priority to the life hereafter and not to the life of this world.. So succeeded in Test and bettered their Deeds and thus Obeyed God. So failure begins in loving the life more than anything consequently leading to choose wrong path out of their own desire... They all know to say "this is such a short life" but They dig their own Hell pit knowing the life is short and meaningless. ..
  • I have a weird question

    23
    0 Votes
    23 Posts
    303 Views
    J
    Salvation from what? And why fear death? Since everything is already dying from the time it was born? And the death of something will be a birth of something else? If there's such thing as 'salvation' it is 'salvation from your own attachment'. And none others than your own self can 'save' you from an 'attachment' that you bind yourself to. Religion will be forgotten, language and script will be forgotten thus books will be unreadable, human will become extinct, nation / kingdom will crumble, planet will be devoured by star as the star reached the end of it's lifetime. Don't just pick part of my statemnt and highlight... That's weak argument... Salvation from what?... That's why I am reiterating you that verses of Quran cannot be incorporated eith Taoism and budhism like you keep trying all the way in this forum... Believers don't fear death... You Taoist or budhist do dear death... Coz they believe another birth on this earth either as animal or human... So they believ they suffer endless.. So they want to end this suffering but they don't even figure out how to live to end it.. Salvation is judgement for what every soul did on this earth.. With that everything is solved.. Wait for that if you have any faith on it.. Or else wait for a rebirth as at least human.. So continue you cycle.. Nothing will be forgotten... Everything is recorded.. See the difference... That's why don't incorporate two different teachings into one.. One is from God and the other is from human.. If you really want incorporate hadith eith Taoism and talk.. I don't care... Why waste your time by incorporating Taoism and budhism with verses of Quran... Believers are very minute and they will succeed and they are in the guidance of their Creator.. So bro.. There gap like sky to earth between Taoism budhism and QURAN.. No more comments.. Good luck in your journey... Let's meet on day of judgement... Do you believe that there is day of judgement.. Oops sorry.. It is not mentioned in Taoism.. So when you see in your own. Eyes believe.. Until then enjoy life and be detached... Since you don't want attachment...
  • Why do most Muslims remain Sunnis

    5
    0 Votes
    5 Posts
    50 Views
    FusionF
    why would you cut ties to your community and stop mingling with them socially? Do they force you to commit shirk or say things against God? if yes then stay away and thank God you are given Hidaya. Otherwise you should be with them, perhaps some one could get inspiration from you and be guided, after all you were one of em before until God opened up your eyes and you start to see things clearly. I never stopped mingling with my folks and they all know my position but then I dont force myself upon them, I try to say my point in a very soft way. There is no need to bash hadiths outright, just take hadith out of context and when confronted with a topic, read quran and give references. However you must also understand and read arabic because that will put a lot of weight on what you are saying... its not a criteria but it matters. Like we learn other things, we as Quran only believers should also try to learn Arabic. With me personally, I find it so comforting when I was able to read most of quran without translation and it really goes deep into your heart. 122 Indeed, We, We have sent it down, (as) a Quran in Arabic so that you may understand.
  • Doubts concerning the topic of embryology and a Atheist

    10
    0 Votes
    10 Posts
    113 Views
    WakasW
    You might find this thread interesting https//www.councilofexmuslims.com/index.php?topic=17132.0 https//www.councilofexmuslims.com/index.php?topic=16594.msg461391#msg461391
  • Love relationship

    5
    0 Votes
    5 Posts
    98 Views
    J
    Salam to all, Let me know if I understand correctly. So this secret lovers are those husband/wives who keeps their extra marital afairs secretly? Please can u quote me the the verse where Prophet Muhammad was attracted to a woman. God bless Yes ... Extra marital in the sense outside marriage ie married but having illegal sexual relation another married one or not married but illegal sexual relations with a married one or no intention ever to marry but having illega sexual relations... They are hidden /secret sexual relations ... Every sexual relations away from marriage is zina... So in that society the law and punishment was constituted fir them in Quran and applicable coz believers were rulers .. 3352 Not lawful to you, , are women after , nor for you to exchange them for wives, even if their beauty were to please you, except what your right hand possesses. And ever is Allah , over all things, an Observer.
  • 7:113 26:41 inconsistent?

    42
    0 Votes
    42 Posts
    1k Views
    J
    Peace hawk. It must have been "An error occurred"? Or me pressing some wrong button on my computer and banning myself? Or some conspiracy,who knows? It is history now. It is what one calls I had an offer I could not refuse! The way I see it is I had few days off. I enjoyed the celebrations with friends and family. Hope the problem is solved for your friends as well. brother jkhan. Anyway, here are some verses that gives us the "history" of others before us إِنّا أَنزَلنٰهُ قُرءٰنًا عَرَبِيًّا لَعَلَّكُم تَعقِلونَ We narrate to you the most accurate story- history- through the revelation of this Quran. Before this, you were totally unaware. نَحنُ نَقُصُّ عَلَيكَ أَحسَنَ القَصَصِ بِما أَوحَينا إِلَيكَ هٰذَا القُرءانَ وَإِن كُنتَ مِن قَبلِهِ لَمِنَ الغٰفِلينَ ثُمَّ بَعَثنٰهُم لِنَعلَمَ أَىُّ الحِزبَينِ أَحصىٰ لِما لَبِثوا أَمَدًا We narrate to you their past news-history-, truthfully. They were youths who believed in their Lord, and we increased their guidance. نَحنُ نَقُصُّ عَلَيكَ نَبَأَهُم بِالحَقِّ إِنَّهُم فِتيَةٌ ءامَنوا بِرَبِّهِم وَزِدنٰهُم هُدًى تِلكَ ءايٰتُ الكِتٰبِ المُبينِ We recite to you herein some past news-history- of Moses and Pharaoh, truthfully, for the benefit of people who believe. نَتلوا عَلَيكَ مِن نَبَإِ موسىٰ وَفِرعَونَ بِالحَقِّ لِقَومٍ يُؤمِنونَ حَتّىٰ إِذَا استَيـَٔسَ الرُّسُلُ وَظَنّوا أَنَّهُم قَد كُذِبوا جاءَهُم نَصرُنا فَنُجِّىَ مَن نَشاءُ وَلا يُرَدُّ بَأسُنا عَنِ القَومِ المُجرِمينَ In their stories here-history in Qoran-, there is a lesson for those who possess intelligence. This is not fabricated Hadith; this (Quran) confirms all previous scriptures, provides the details of everything, and is a beacon and mercy for those who believe. لَقَد كانَ فى قَصَصِهِم عِبرَةٌ لِأُولِى الأَلبٰبِ ما كانَ حَديثًا يُفتَرىٰ وَلٰكِن تَصديقَ الَّذى بَينَ يَدَيهِ وَتَفصيلَ كُلِّ شَىءٍ وَهُدًى وَرَحمَةً لِقَومٍ يُؤمِنونَ So" kASSAS" OR "NABAA"... i.e Telling us stories of the past or giving us past news ,is history in context and meaning and can be translated as such in my opinion. As for Is the exact Arabic word" history" mentioned ? I do not think so either. The context and story is the history. Or may be you have a different perspective and explanation as well. GOD bless you brother. Happy new year to you and your family. Peace. Peace again... Yes brother.. I accessed today after being unable to log in for three days.. I didn't know initially.. Then one of my forum friends told he is being blocked... I thought someone hacked.. But no conspiracy bro.. This forum one of the best... Therw must have been some technical issues.. People in Saudi cannot anyway access this forum since it is blocked in that country as many I believe access through VPN... So friend in Saudi has thought VPN blocked.. Anyway I believe problem is solved to all.. Thank you and yes.. happy New Year to all..
  • Did God create us from His soul? Quran 4:1

    9
    0 Votes
    9 Posts
    166 Views
    J
    only two things exist, consciousness and the product of consciousness, therefore to experience a shared reality of conscious thought, only a single fractally structured consciousness can exist, if you'd like to consider this further This means there is no god, only a single consciousness. It depends on how one define what the word "god" means.. Due to confusion caused by "poly-theist" and/or religion, which define "god" as an entity/being/soul, thus has a border that separate itself with "others" (ie the notion that there is something that "god made" which is different than "human made&quot, I tend to look for some crucial definition that cannot be mistaken with something else. And it's the definition of INFINITE or BORDER-LESS or BOUNDARY-LESS (No border and no boundary) If the word "god" and/or "consciousness" or any other words such as "XYZ" is defined as "something that is infinite" then it cannot be mistaken that we're talking about the same thing. Because there cannot be more than one thing that is infinite. For this occasion, let's use the word "consciousness" where in "consciousness" is the thing that is infinite. Consciousness is infinite. As such there is no such as thing as my consciousness, your consciousness, their consciousness, as consciousness has no border that separate one consciousness with other consciousnesses. There is only consciousness. And how it relate to a "soul" let's explain this metaphorically, let's use "air" as a metaphor. Consciousness is like air, it has no border yet it permeate all things. There is no "my air", "your air", "their air", there is just "air". And the "soul" is like "soap bubble". https//images.unsplash.com/photo-1612855190135-bdbacda2a2b5?ixlib=rb-4.0.3&ixid=MnwxMjA3fDB8MHxzZWFyY2h8M3x8c29hcCUyMGJ1YmJsZXxlbnwwfHwwfHw%3D&w=1000&q=80 Thanks to the soap bubbles, the air confined within a soap bubble can have a border that separate between itself (me) and other air confined in other soap bubbles (others). The soap bubble can split to become multiple soap bubbles (soul splitting) and multiple bubbles can also merged together to become a bigger bubbles (soul merging). Yet regardless of it's unique shape and size, each bubbles are essentially the same, it's a confined air, confined by the wall of the bubbles. After many events of splitting and merging, the wall of the bubbles shall become thinner and thinner. Until finally it will pop! Releasing the confined air within the bubble to rejoin the all, infinite, borderless air once again. As thus, the bubbles are an illusion / virtual / temporary / not really exist. It is the air that truly exist. Separation of finite amount of air through bubbles are illusion, the air within the bubble will eventually unite with the all, infinite, borderless air. Thus "soul" are temporary / illusion / virtual, only consciousness that truly exist. And everything, in essence, is consciousness. "Brahman Satyam, Jagat Mithya", a yogi once said, which means "The universe is an illusion, only Brahman that is truly exist". Where in Brahman is defined as something that is infinite and has no border. https//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brahman
  • Will Jesus return?

    16
    0 Votes
    16 Posts
    227 Views
    FusionF
    Peace... Yes.. Failing to apply some sense with many a glaring verses of Quran leads to certain people to still believe that Isa son of Maryam would return.. Nonsense.. Take a look at below verses... 5116-117 And when Allah will say, "O Jesus, Son of Mary, did you say to the people, 'Take me and my mother as deities besides Allah ?'" He will say, "Exalted are You! It was not for me to say that to which I have no right. If I had said it, You would have known it. You know what is within myself, and I do not know what is within Yourself. Indeed, it is You who is Knower of the unseen. I said not to them except what You commanded me - to worship Allah , my Lord and your Lord. And I was a witness over them as long as I was among them; but when You took me up, You were the Observer over them, and You are, over all things, Witness." Do you get what verses say... Let me explain my understanding why Isa is dead and not a person to return here.. Carefully note verse.. What Isa reply to God... What God would ask... So.. Imagine at certain point of future Isa arrives on this earth and live certain number of years... So Isa has the access to Quran as well.. And he won't miss reading the above two verses... Well. He would get surprised.. Coz that's what he is gonna say on the day of judgement. . But point is it he really returns to the earth why would Isa reply to God he is not aware of what happened after he took him (died)? Coz he can tell God yes when I returned to them I reminded them and I convinced them and more people believed in me and more people disblieved and still they accepted me as god.. But Isa simply answered to God I am not aware everaince you tool me up... It cannot be an answer from a person who returned back to life again and lived with later generation... If you not get me pls read the above two verses and apply some sense of Isa lived once again on earth and think of practical point of view... All up to you.. But for me it is clear... And the verse 228 .. Well.. It is definitely for disbelievers... Even you can compare the verse 4011 ..definitely disbelivers had two lives and two death... It is confirmed from their own conviction on the day of judgment or rather in hell and by God's direct saying in 228.. But true believers only one life.. And Isa son of Maryam was a true believer and so did have one single life span... That's done... That's a very very good point you made bro. What you deduce is so logical.
  • Natural and Artificial/manmade

    24
    0 Votes
    24 Posts
    217 Views
    J
    In addition in 337 note carefully the usage of words... He found with her... Wajada indaHa Risks.. It cannot be wisdom.. And next point.. Anna Laki haza? Impossible usage of words to take as wisdom.. It's obviously a visible object zakaria referring to..
  • Few Intriguing questions

    8
    0 Votes
    8 Posts
    160 Views
    J
    For example in QURAN we find many verses which talks about God being "happy", "angry", "love", "hate", "waiting", "testing" and likes. My friend point is that all these qualities at least in a man is subject to "some external actions". For example, we become very happy when we see some one praises us , or when we achieve success. Likewise we weep or become sad when some external factor (like death , loss) affect us. So the characteristics exhibited here are a result of actions and we react. Tell your friend that it is possible to be happy regardless of external actions or events. And God is not separated with it's creation. I usually uses the metaphor of Novel Author and Character in his novel. I often uses Tolkien and his famous novel Lord Of The Rings. Everything and everyone inside Lord Of The Rings are created by Tolkien. Frodo is created by Tolkien, Sauron, Gollum, Gandalf are created by Tolkien. Furthermore Frodo, Sauron, Gollum and Gandalf are actually Tolkien! Tolkien playing the role of Frodo, Sauron, Gollum and Gandalf. Hence no one know why this universe is created in real sense, every one (so called prophets) created all from their own mind for the benefit of the society which is actually part of the big game which no one know why, what and how it will end, if at all or it will continue like a loop. The answer is then the same as why Tolkien wrote Lord Of The Rings.
  • 19:23 (why do all translations use the word "wish")

    3
    0 Votes
    3 Posts
    62 Views
    N
    Peace nimnimak_11. "yālaytanī" is made up of three word Ya,, lyta and ni.. I suppose one one can translate the three words like this Oh, if only, and I(ME) So instead of I wish, you could translate as Oh if only I was. i.e You want a different scenario for yourself than the one you have(you are in). GOD bless you. Peace. Thanks good logic. God bless you too!