Skip to content

General Issues / Questions

This area deals with any general questions/issues regarding God / Islam / Quran not covered under other headings.

This category can be followed from the open social web via the handle [email protected]

7.1k Topics 133.0k Posts
  • Sense and Sensibility In Islam

    4
    0 Votes
    4 Posts
    65 Views
    S
    I haven't read it, but from the website it seems the author is familiar with my articles on "salat" My article, quote Familiarity? That looks like a full copy and paste job to me. Here's his e-mail address if you have anything you'd like to ask or discuss with him [email protected] I got this e-mail address from his other website Islam of Allah Somebody from the ourbeacon forum claimed that the author is Aidid Safar under yet another pseudo name, but he provided zero proof to back up that statement. I seriously doubt that it is Aidid. Aidid's name is already both famous and infamous (depending on which side of the fence a person is on concerninh him) so why would he craft another pseudo name when the name he is already using carries enough weight and popluarity? He already has a dedicated following and using another name would mean losing that following in search of a new (and probably different) target market. One last thing; as far as I know there is no free download of this book which let's me know that it isn't Aidid. This isn't his way of spreading his message. Even if the book is for sale, he will still have a free download option available on his website just like how he had it for Arab Conspiracies, Hijacking of Islam and now Mental Bondage.
  • 0 Votes
    26 Posts
    397 Views
    K
    A couple posters have mentioned eating organic and the like as they feel like it fits the spirit of what Allah wants. I read a blog article making a similar argument, I thought I would share it http//www.hijabman.com/journal/halal-zabihah-organic-eat-local/ As for what exactly 'halal' means and never being able to be 100% sure about the meat I've basically given up on the idea of eating meat at all. It kind of depresses me but I want to do my best so that's the direction I have moved. I still plan on eating all seafood, eggs, and diary. So far I have stopped eating cow for the most part. I also try to eat organic and cruelty free when I can.
  • Sufi Quranist Muslim? Anyone?

    21
    0 Votes
    21 Posts
    456 Views
    A
    i got something interesting on wikipedia about inayat khan and his sufi universalism Foundational principles Inayat Khan set forth ten principles that formed the foundational principles of his Universal Sufism There is one God; the Eternal, the Only Being; None exists save He. There is one master; the guiding spirit of all souls that constantly leads all followers toward the light. There is one holy book; the sacred manuscript of nature, the only Scripture that can enlighten the reader. There is one religion; unswerving progress in the right direction toward the Ideal, which fulfills every soul's life purpose. There is one law; the law of reciprocity, which can be observed by a selfless conscience, together with a sense of awakened justice. There is one brotherhood; the human brotherhood which unites the children of earth indiscriminately in the fatherhood of God. This was later adapted by followers to; "There is one Family, the Human Family, which unites the Children of Earth indiscriminately in the Parenthood of God." There is one moral; the love which springs forth from self-denial and blooms in deeds of beneficence. ... (later alternative; "which springs forth from a willing heart, surrendered in service to God and Humanity, and which blooms in deeds of beneficence&quot. There is one object of praise; the beauty which uplifts the heart of its worshipper through all aspects from the seen to the unseen. There is one truth; true knowledge of our being, within and without, which is the essence of Wisdom. There is one path; annihilation of the false ego in the real (later alternative; "the effacement of the limited self in the Unlimited&quot, which raises the mortal to immortality, in which resides all perfection.
  • 7ad El 7araba??

    16
    0 Votes
    16 Posts
    169 Views
    A
    Peace Confused, Thanks for responding, but I am not sure what the significance of the word Khizy is in these ayat. Could you please clarify? In all the occurences of the word "khizy" in the great reading, it is the god that does the action and not people. There is no imperitive verb used ordering people to do anything. So the passages must be interpreted figuratively. Peace, Ayman
  • Biography of Muhammad

    31
    0 Votes
    31 Posts
    535 Views
    H
    Peace Andantino, Yes, Jonah is yunus (Sura 10, Jonah (Younus) and Zal-Kifl by many is believed to be Ezekiel Also, Ismail, Idr?s, Zal-Kifl; all were steadfast, patient. Remember Ismail, Elisha, and Zal-Kifl; among the most righteous. Nevertheless the point being, many who mention the names of some messengers will not say P.B.U.H after mentioning such names, making distinction. Just my experience. God is all-knowing peace
  • Adam: The Quran, Creation and Evolution ? Science vs Scripture

    7
    0 Votes
    7 Posts
    112 Views
    J
    There's another 'hint' provided by Genesis and Quran which might able to serve as a 'clue' to indicate which 'species' (or remains) is under AMH / Adam progeny or not (or hasn't yet). That is if they WEAR CLOTHES to (at least) cover their genital. Homo Neanderthal does wear clothes (made from animal skin) as thus, according to Genesis and Quran, they're among "Adam" progeny. HOMO NEANDERTHAL http//img.timeinc.net/time/daily/2010/1005/360_neanderthal_genome_0505.jpg PAPUAN HOMO SAPIENS http//www.drokpa.com/PotD/Jiwika-2.jpg ZULU HOMO SAPIENS http//www.ezakwantu.com/Penis%20Cover%2002.jpg 15,000 KM of distance between Sub-Saharan Africa and Papua, yet you can see the similarities of 'clothing' and features among it's inhabitants which still can be seen up until today. There's no such thing as 'ancient human', all 'walking primates' who already wear clothes or cover of their genitals are Adam's progeny.
  • After death ?!

    48
    0 Votes
    48 Posts
    747 Views
    D
    I don't see any need to diminish Torah or the New Testament at all. There is harmony between them and the Qur'an so far as I can see. In fact, some of what you quote below gives further evidence that the Qur'an explicitly supports my manner of understanding things. The full context here is a chastening from Allah. It was according to His will that people should understand these things. He intended for them to but because of their own failings they failed to. This is why he graciously forgave and why in verse 5 He said "Surely We will make to light upon you a weighty Word." The fact that Allah forgave them for not knowing means that in due time He would go ahead and bring that understanding when it became immediately relevant to do so. I have plainly quoted the passage from 7320 and had not given my interpretation of it. I am in line with you but with a slight difference, which I have given in the red of your quote The full context here is towards seeking Guidance from Allah. It was according to His will that people should understand the Truth of these things, He has intended for them. But because they took to their own innumerable deadly ways, leaving the One Straight Path from Him they meet with their dead end at which point they turn to God. This is why He Mercifully forgave, and more, in verse 5 He said "Surely We will make to light upon you a Mighty Promise." The fact that Allah forgave the humankind for their turning away from the Path of Reward that in due time He brings that understanding when it became immediately relevant to do so i.e., as they repent and turn to Him when all their efforts failed them, and with all humility and servitude. I will give my understanding of the passages 325; 704 with reference to the relation between the man and his servants, the entire universe - as God has destined upon it. Peace, brother.
  • Learning from modern jewish history....to go forward.

    31
    0 Votes
    31 Posts
    644 Views
    J
    Hi Everyone, Jafar... I agree with most of what you say. Rabbinic Judaism doesn't accept Jesus nor Muhammed. However since the fall of the Temple in 60CE Rabbinic Judaism is pretty much all that is left. Yes there are a few groups here or there that are not Rabbinically based. But they are very few and very limited. I don't believe the Quran was written for Jews. I believe it was written for everyone. Just like I think the Torah was written for everyone. I think many Jews today can't get past the media hype against Islam. Otherwise I would imagine they would get along fine with muslims. They are essentially the same religion. Minor difference that people seem to amplify. They take a small crack and turn it into a canyon. Andantino... Go see Jewfaq.org. That is a good resource to understand a lot of the Jewish point of view. Remember not ALL Jews feel this way. But it is a starting point. Trinity in Torah... No way. The main prayer in Judaism is the "Shema" which is basically... "Hear O'Israel Adonai is your G-d, Adonai is One". The unity of G-d is imperative. Same as Islam. I have issues with the Torah and NT. Hadith bother me because they are unverifiable. However the Quran is the most clean of all of the scriptures. Just my crazy thoughts... JewishDude peace Salam, Shalom, Peace peace
  • The Qur?aan Cosmological Model - Delineation Of The Current universe.

    98
    0 Votes
    98 Posts
    3k Views
    K
    Dear kylixguru, Thank you for your participation in this thread. Your ideas relating to the Creation Account are interesting, however, can I request that you create a new thread for the topic? This is in order to keep the forum?s organisation optimal. Thank you for your kind acknowledgment.
  • An article on: Intercession and Transfer of deeds

    38
    0 Votes
    38 Posts
    563 Views
    F
    No problem! Wa salam.
  • A little bit of alcohol

    69
    0 Votes
    69 Posts
    2k Views
    A
    maybe its the reason behind you drink, why would you Drink? some people drink alcohol for healthy purpose, and some people drink for fun purpose. Quran itself as far as i know never said "its haram" as it did to pork and other haram foods, but Quran wants us to THINK
  • Will we remember our life here on earth?

    14
    0 Votes
    14 Posts
    131 Views
    J
    So that means when we're in Heaven, I can wow you all with the riveting tales of my video game exploits! "AND THEN, IT WAS LIKE ZAPBOOMPOW! WOW! I WAS LEVEL 99!" O0 And somebody else will dazzle you with his riveting tales of wrestling with a woolly mamooth..
  • Pazuzu/badr society's books

    7
    0 Votes
    7 Posts
    89 Views
    W
    I hope it will be completed. Truth must come out, irrespective of how many takers are there.
  • How do you Pray???

    15
    0 Votes
    15 Posts
    127 Views
    B
    Here is a site which tells you how to pray with help of verses from the Quran http//www.quran-islam.org/main_topics/islam/pillars/al-salat_%28P1192%29.html Salaam brother
  • Narcotic Painkillers

    11
    0 Votes
    11 Posts
    116 Views
    A
    As intoxicants which would cover drugs and alcohol is generally considered forbidden, what is the stance on narcotic painkillers? I use a narcotic pain killer which was prescribed by doctor for chronic tension headaches. What is your view and (if you are aware of such a judgement) what is the "traditional" view? Salaam Ayyub, Sahih International They ask you about Intoxicants (wine) and the easy money (gambling). Say, "In them is great sin and benefit for people. But their sin is greater than their benefit." And they ask you what they should spend. Say, "The excess ." Thus Allah makes clear to you the verses that you might give thought. 2219 According to the 2;219 there is benefit in intoxicants in a moderation. All the intoxicants effects human body and brain, for example the morphine/methodene normally prescribed for cancer patience to ease their pain. But if a normal person start taking these drugs it will dis balance its brain and harm the body. Peace
  • The Night Journey in Prophecy

    4
    0 Votes
    4 Posts
    43 Views
    N
    Salaam Muhammad traveled to the MASJID AQSA. AQSA mean farest. the one who have the farest Masjid will win. I found a Masjid in the heaven where Malaika are making Soujoud. Who can bring a farest Masjid than mine ? Peace
  • Muslim for Progressive Values???

    4
    0 Votes
    4 Posts
    51 Views
    B
    Yes Jewish dude. Please do share your experience if you go. Checked out the site. Better than locking the women up in the basement like they do at my local Sunni mosque (I'm exaggerating. They don't really lock them up... For too long). But a little TOO progressive for my liking. I don't think I'd feel comfortable and could easily be distracted if there's a woman next to me while I'm doing Salat. The smell of her perfume, shoulders touching, etc. We humans are genetically programmed to be aroused by smell, touch and visuals from an attractive member of the opposite sex. God made us that way. And women in front of men? Not saying this in a sexist way but think about it... There's an attractive girl in front of you, prostrating, bending over with her hands on her knees. How comfortable a situation is this for the men or the women? Salat should be between the individual and God. Eliminate as many possible distractions as you can. That's my opinion. The Submitter mosque I've been going to for the past 5 months has a healthy balance. Men and women pray in the same room but the men are in the front rows, women in the back. There is no Hijab or head cover required for women. After the prayer and during Quran studies, there is no segregation. Men and women eat and sit together and act like normal human beings. I think this is a normal set up without going to extremes on either side. Good point. I think that prayers as you said is not a place for distraction. But I think this will come by experience. We still have not really practiced any of the stuff we said. In time we will be able to figure things out.
  • about 1:7

    2
    0 Votes
    2 Posts
    37 Views
    F
    Hi, It is me again. I should admit that I know nothing about arabic. But I'd like to share my opinion on 17. The word "An'Amta" should be translated as joy, not blessing. I dont know what you mean by blessing but I think it is better if you translated as joy. Why? Because God way is joy. If you read Tanakh and a few of the quran, it is written that God's way is joy. That translation also give us understanding and motive for our life to search for joy that pleased by God. God told us to marry, is not it a joy. It is different if our motive to have intercourse just for lust, it would hurt somebody. Most of the prophet is a rich man, we can see Dawud, Sulayman, and also our father Ibrahim. Most of them even had more than 1 wives. I dont say we had to have more than 1 wives, but as a man, dont you also think having a lot of girls is a joy? What about war is you ask, did not God told us to war when we are offended. Did not it is not a joy. Yes of course. But sitting duck when we are offended is much worse than not fight back. By fight back and win, we can earn joy. Not waiting for our slaugther. Well, I know my opinion is flawed, and maybe look ridicoulous. But on my mind, Gods way is joy. And people should know that from the first chapter from the quran. Thanks. Onan Farabi. The best word according to our human dictionary is the "good luck" and Ghairil maghduubi? alaihim (not of those with the bad luck)
  • What is your understanding of 26:79?

    26
    0 Votes
    26 Posts
    412 Views
    F
    No, not one bit. We are talking about a god feeding people and providing for them and this is s story of a man losing his son and the reaction to that. I asked 3 questions which interest me. Well, 3 and a half actually. So what does a story about the death of a son have to do with it? Regarding your 3 questions about why god and not nature. Nature is an unconscious matter that can't manage or make any decision whatsoever. also humans and all other creations don't have any power to manage its own evolution through time. Now if we speak logic then we got 2 wrongs and which is the nature that don't got the ability to think and the creation that got no power to fix it's own evolution through time. 2 wrongs never gives right as an outcome in logic. Now which make sense to you when compared to a super entity that gots power over everything which created the unconscious nature and the living creations and manage and control everything in our universe. Of course it is up to you whether you want to believe what i had believed,but for me i found case 2 to be the wise choice and case 1 to be nonsense if not even stupid one.
  • Being heart broken

    23
    0 Votes
    23 Posts
    439 Views
    S
    Salam, I meant new in posting. I've been learning Islam for the last 15 years though, as well as other religions.