Alif; Laam and Meem with ancillary glyph/prolongation sign
-
Peace Mazhar,
What Lisan Al-3arab indicated is precisely and exclusively monocoteledon. He has translated , singular sprout of and only NOT all plants.
This is a circular argument. You are trying to prove that means exclusively monocotyledons so this cannot be one of your premises.
And he did not say "leaves of vegetation". Both and are monocotyledon.
The Arabic word "waraq" means "leaves". Leaves are not exclusive to monocotyledons.
Arabic is a scientific language, each Root containing in it the physical realities.
Nope. It is a human invented language full of inconsistencies. If it wasn't for the great reading, it would have been a dead language by now. You sound like you worship it.
At any rate, at least you are no longer disputing the following fact
1437 talks about a valley that didn't have any human-planted plants at the time Abraham settled his family. This doesn't mean that the valley wasn't fertile and didn't have naturally occuring vegetation. It also doesn't mean that thousands of years later humans didn't plant anything in it.
This is what matters.
Peace,
Ayman
-
Peace Mazhar,
This is a circular argument. You are trying to prove that means exclusively monocotyledons so this cannot be one of your premises.
I am not trying to prove anything. Qur'aan is telling that like the ; what is peculiar he/that discharged his/its . "ka" Like; and the peculiar feature of is that it discharges one single which Lisan ul Arab translates as sprout of....and then tries to equate it with one leaf of and not "leaves of vegetation- vegetation means plants in general" while neither Qur'aan nor Lisan is talking about plants in general. Both are specific. Qur'aan is extremely precise and exactly according to the physical fact when its uses instead of waraq leaf. Monocotyledons means Angiosperm (flowering plant) having an embryo with a single cotyledon, or seed leaf (as opposed to dicotyledons, which have two). Monocotyledons usually have narrow leaves with parallel veins and smooth edges, and hollow or soft stems. Their flower parts are arranged in threes. Most are small plants such as grasses , and lilies, but some are trees such as palms.The Arabic word "waraq" means "leaves". Leaves are not exclusive to monocotyledons.
If you change the words of Qur'aan one can mean anything he likes to understand. The word is singular one leaf; it is about discharge not about leaves on the stem. There are only two types of plants, one who sprout/ discharge/germinate with only one needle like leaf and the others with two leaves.
Nope. It is a human invented language full of inconsistencies. If it wasn't for the great reading, it would have been a dead language by now. You sound like you worship it.
Qur'aan keeps rotating its Aa'ya'aat so that people can understand and see a thing from 360 angles. One perceives things from the angle he is looking at. I do not "worship" even Allah what to say of a language. I praise a thing which deserves praise. You ascribe the existence of Arabic to Qur'aan but Allah says "Qur'aan has been made easy in your language, O Muhammad sas". If you accept and repeatedly call that Qur'aan is a great reading, how can you deny that the Arabic language is great. Have you thought of your inherent contradictions?
At any rate, at least you are no longer disputing the following fact
1437 talks about a valley that didn't have any human-planted plants at the time Abraham settled his family. This doesn't mean that the valley wasn't fertile and didn't have naturally occuring vegetation. It also doesn't mean that thousands of years later humans didn't plant anything in it.
This is what matters.
Do you know or have you visited in these days the valley where Ibrahim alahissalm was statnding? Even today no body cultivates . Do not confuse Saudi Arabia with the valley.Peace,
Ayman
-
Peace Mazhar,
This is what matters.
Do you know or have you visited in these days the valley where Ibrahim alahissalm was statnding? Even today no body cultivates . Do not confuse Saudi Arabia with the valley.One could equally ask you
Do you know or have you visited in these days the valley where Ibrahim alahissalm was standing? How do you know that today no body cultivates ?
Qur'aan keeps rotating its Aa'ya'aat so that people can understand and see a thing from 360 angles. One perceives things from the angle he is looking at. I do not "worship" even Allah what to say of a language. I praise a thing which deserves praise. You ascribe the existence of Arabic to Qur'aan but Allah says "Qur'aan has been made easy in your language, O Muhammad sas". If you accept and repeatedly call that Qur'aan is a great reading, how can you deny that the Arabic language is great. Have you thought of your inherent contradictions?
If it is so great, why don't you speak Quranic Arabic at home? People call a certain language a living language because it evolves. Quranic Arabic has not evolved and thus it is a dead language that is not used in everyday life. If the prophet spoke English then the god would have equally made the great reading easy in the prophet's language. The specific language doesn't matter. The god can take any imperfect and inconsistent human language and use it to compose a consistent and powerful message.
By the way, here is what Lisan Al-3arab says about Al-zar3
Here is what Lisan Al-3arab says about Al-zar3
I hope that you can see the inconsistency in Lisan Al-3arab.
Peace,
Ayman
-
One could equally ask you
Do you know or have you visited in these days the valley where Ibrahim alahissalm was standing? How do you know that today no body cultivates ?
I visited quite many times and witness that in that valley there is no cultivation of . And let me tell you it will remain so till the last day because I know the words of the man who gave information about this fact are nothing but the truth since he was cautious about his reputition to be known as truthful in history and Allah has confirmed he was absolutely a truthful person. The people who keep spraying conjectural thoughts and opinions are never considered truthful.
-
By the way, here is what Lisan Al-3arab says about Al-zar3
Here is what Lisan Al-3arab says about Al-zar3
I hope that you can see the inconsistency in Lisan Al-3arab.
May I know what you think the inconsistency is? And if you think there is insistency in the explanation by Lisan how can you attribute it to the language itself that it suffers from inconsistencies? Some one could have said that the language is inconsistent because it applies the same Root for menses and quraan; but today we would have said that he was himself ignorant of the reality and fact.
And have given a thought to the fact that you are basically not aware of the Plant Kingdom and its classification that might be causing inconsitency in your perception? Qur'aan and Arabic Mubeen are not based on generalizations; both are specific and act as making everything specific and distinct. When you say Arabic suffers from inconsistences you in fact refute the "Grand Reading" which tells its language is Mubeen.
-
Peace Mazhar,
I visited quite many times and witness that in that valley there is no cultivation of . And let me tell you it will remain so till the last day because I know the words of the man who gave information about this fact are nothing but the truth since he was cautious about his reputition to be known as truthful in history and Allah has confirmed he was absolutely a truthful person. The people who keep spraying conjectural thoughts and opinions are never considered truthful.
Then tell us where that valley is so that we can visit it too and verify if you are truthful or lying.
Peace,
Ayman
-
Peace Mazhar,
May I know what you think the inconsistency is? And if you think there is insistency in the explanation by Lisan how can you attribute it to the language itself that it suffers from inconsistencies?
Among other things, it is saying that "7arth" and "zar3" can have the same meaning while they are clearly used in the great reading to mean plants at different stages of the agriculture cycle.
Some one could have said that the language is inconsistent because it applies the same Root for menses and quraan; but today we would have said that he was himself ignorant of the reality and fact.
This is a wrong classification by Lisan Al-3arab. The term "QuR'AN" should be under QR'A not under QRW. There are many such classification errors in Lisan Al-3arab. Another example is its misclassification of Allat in 5319 under LTT as opposed to its correct classification under ALH, etc.
And have given a thought to the fact that you are basically not aware of the Plant Kingdom and its classification that might be causing inconsitency in your perception? Qur'aan and Arabic Mubeen are not based on generalizations; both are specific and act as making everything specific and distinct. When you say Arabic suffers from inconsistences you in fact refute the "Grand Reading" which tells its language is Mubeen.
You are spraying conjectural thoughts and opinions that contradict reality.
Peace,
Ayman
-
Some one could have said that the language is inconsistent because it applies the same Root for menses and quraan;
but today we would have said that he was himself ignorant of the reality and fact.This is a wrong classification by Lisan Al-3arab. The term "QuR'AN" should be under QR'A not under QRW.
Where did you find that Quran is under QRW? Both menses and quran is under qra, in Lane's lexicon. one meaning collection of blood and the other means collection of words; commonaility is that of collection, the basic perception of the Root.
-
Peace Mazhar,
Where did you find that Quran is under QRW? Both menses and quran is under qra, in Lane's lexicon. one meaning collection of blood and the other means collection of words; commonaility is that of collection, the basic perception of the Root.
Lisan Al-arab is wrong. Menses should be under QRA/QRW not under QR'A. The meaning of "collection of words" would make 7517 illogical since "its collection and its collection" is nonsense. On the other hand, / is a synonym of .
I also noticed that you evaded addressing my other points. It seems that your idea about the valley where Abraham settled some of his descendants was nothing but conjecture.
Peace,
Ayman
-
I also noticed that you evaded addressing my other points. It seems that your idea about the valley where Abraham settled some of his descendants was nothing but conjecture.
The valley he referred is the one where he said "your honourable bait is located" and that is what I know Mecca. I hope you agree and restrit yourself to the word "valley" and do not expand it whole of Arabia. Kaaba is located in the valley. That valley is not cultivated for crops even today. It is not conjecture but ground reality. This valley was not created for cultivation and agriculture; its purpose is defined and it only takes the visitors from outside it.
-
Peace Mazhar,
The valley he referred is the one where he said "your honourable bait is located" and that is what I know Mecca.
The great reading never says "your honourable bait is located in the valley of Mecca". You are spreading basless lies.
Peace,
Ayman
-
The valley he referred is the one where he said "your honourable bait is located" and that is what I know Mecca.
The great reading never says "your honourable bait is located in the valley of Mecca". You are spreading basless lies.
Do you refer to Grand Qur'aan by the words "great reading"? If so it is in it
-
Peace Mazhar,
Do you refer to Grand Qur'aan by the words "great reading"? If so it is in it
Here is what you said earlier
The valley he referred is the one where he said "your honourable bait is located" and that is what I know Mecca.
You are a liar because Mecca is not mentioned at all. If you are not a liar then please undeline for everyone the word Mecca here
Peace,
Ayman
-
Peace Mazhar,
Here is what you said earlier
You are a liar because dear Mazhar Mecca is not mentioned at all. If you are not a liar then would you please undeline for everyone the word Mecca here
Peace,
Ayman
peace
-
Peace Mazhar,
Here is what you said earlier
You are a liar because Mecca is not mentioned at all. If you are not a liar then please undeline for everyone the word Mecca here
Peace,
Ayman
qualfies/indicates the valley where he made to reside one of his progeny. is a definite physically existing point/location. And I exclusively submit allegiance to the Sustainer Lord of this particular house, adhering to the command of my Sustainer Lord.
Therefore/for reason you people be subservient/allegiant to the Sustainer Lord of this House.
Any one who does not know this house and its location, he may be worshipping some lord but then that is not the Sustainer Lord of this House.
-
Peace Mazhar,
qualfies/indicates the valley where he made to reside one of his progeny. is a definite physically existing point/location. And I exclusively submit allegiance to the Sustainer Lord of this particular house, adhering to the command of my Sustainer Lord.
Therefore/for reason you people be subservient/allegiant to the Sustainer Lord of this House.
Please underline Mecca in the above. If you can't then have the decency to admit the indisputable fact that your argument that the house is in Mecca has no basis in the great reading.
Any one who does not know this house and its location, he may be worshipping some lord but then that is not the Sustainer Lord of this House.
Any one who does not know this inviolable house and its real clear physical location given in 2226, he may be worshipping some false stone cube in Mecca but then that is not the sustainer lord of the real inviolable house.
Peace,
Ayman
-
Any one who does not know this inviolable house and its real clear physical location given in 2226, he may be worshipping some false stone cube in Mecca but then that is not the sustainer lord of the real inviolable house.
Where is this particular location/plot of the house? Can you show me "clear physical location" on the map?
-
Peace Mazhar,
Where is this particular location/plot of the house? Can you show me "clear physical location" on the map?
The clear physcial loaction is given in 2226 in no uncertain terms and it is certainly not Mecca. Just read the rest of 2226 and don't snip it.
Peace,
Ayman