Skip to content
  • Categories
  • Recent
  • Users
Skins
  • Light
  • Brite
  • Cerulean
  • Cosmo
  • Flatly
  • Journal
  • Litera
  • Lumen
  • Lux
  • Materia
  • Minty
  • Morph
  • Pulse
  • Sandstone
  • Simplex
  • Sketchy
  • Spacelab
  • United
  • Yeti
  • Zephyr
  • Dark
  • Cyborg
  • Darkly
  • Quartz
  • Slate
  • Solar
  • Superhero
  • Vapor

  • Default (No Skin)
  • No Skin
Collapse
Free Minds Forum Icon
  1. Home
  2. General Issues / Questions
  3. Questions/Comments on the Quran
  4. Jonah---Never swallowed by a whale

Jonah---Never swallowed by a whale

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Questions/Comments on the Quran
48 Posts 16 Posters 954 Views
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • Z Offline
    Z Offline
    zayd
    wrote on last edited by
    #21

    Since " Althulumaat" means darkness, which darkness was it?

    There are verses that talk about the darkness of bahr/bodies of water (663, 2440, 2763), and also verses that talk about darkness figuratively ("from out of the darkness and into the light&quot. The one in could very well be both.

    http//islamawakened.com/21/87/

    Does "Musabbiheen" mean glorifying/imploring or swimming? and so on....

    "To swim hard" is one of the meanings of S-B-H and fits the context in . What we usually understand as glorifying God, I now understand as something like "to strive/work hard towards/for God".

    1 Reply Last reply
    0
    • FusionF Offline
      FusionF Offline
      Fusion
      wrote on last edited by
      #22

      All of what you said have been discussed on this site and people have given answers with logic and wisdom and I have gone thru those posts and realized that the error in our judgment is purely based on our understanding of how these events could be possible to have happened and if our mind does not comprehend we will tend to give up and accept the literal meanings.

      Moses never part the sea literally, it was God who revealed info to Moses to take his people at certain time/point/direction when the water level was set too low/dry there, and this has been discussed on this site in detail (It wasn't even a sea for example). I am not going into details but please search.

      Similarly.
      (69) Thus while they were busy flaming
      the fire of revenge, We were planning a way
      to cool down its flames so that no harm
      would come to Abraham,

      How do I take Quran literally or take those verses as metaphors is the question and am at a loss some times but I DO hope and want to believe that God is capable of all things and every thing is possible for him. However I also believe that god has chosen messengers from us and those were also subjected to the same physical laws with the exception that God is on their side.

      There are of course many questions in my mind too but I think it is impossible to know exactly what God means , until we meet him and ask. -) Looking at all of the religions and books, I found Quran as the book which gives me comfort and although there may be many verses which I may not understand but the central theme is One God and none others which qualifies for all of the logics and wisdom in my dictionary.
      Cheers

      peace Fusion.

      Looking at some stories from the Qoran s point of view defies our limited logic.

      Did Moses part the sea?

      Did Jesus heal the leper?

      Was Jonah swallowed by a whale?

      Was Abraham saved from the fire?

      Were Noah s people drowned by the flood?

      Is GOD real? That story alone can defy our logic.

      Believing is both faith and reason. Logic and defying logic. It depends on how certain one is about Qoran.
      GOD bless you.
      Peace

      1 Reply Last reply
      0
      • G Offline
        G Offline
        good_logic
        wrote on last edited by
        #23

        Peacee Fusion/zayd.

        I am merely asking questions.

        I expect people to go with their understanding of course.

        I am not going to enforce anything on anyone.

        However , Qoran deals with beliefs that require both faith and reason/Science/logic.

        Sometimes ,yes stories have happened literaly and to serve as lessons...etc.

        For example when Moses was sent to Pharoah,what happened?was it literal?

        And We have sent Moses with Our Ayah?s (miracles or signs) to Pharaoh and his elders proclaiming ?I am a messenger from the Lord of the universe?. When he brought them our Ayah?s they laughed at him. Every Ayah We showed them was greater than the one that preceded it.? 4346-48

        Someone will explain the "plagues" similar to what they explain other "Aayats" i.e signs/miracles... Does this mean they did not happen?

        Just to ponder and search deep ,that s all.
        GOD bless you.
        Peace.

        1 Reply Last reply
        0
        • FusionF Offline
          FusionF Offline
          Fusion
          wrote on last edited by
          #24

          Buddy, I did not say you wanna enforce anything upon others, certainly you cant enforce faith upon others unless you make them really believe from bottom of their hearts OR you show these people some Magic and you have a different agenda, which has happened ironically. Unfortunately I spent time with the people who believe in curse, nazar, magic, cast bad spells etc in order to justify their sufferings or to cause others ills, and those were all Muslims by faith.
          Is it not the most ironic thing that most of the non-arabs muslims do not know more than a few verses of quran for the sake of prayers?
          Because the do not know Arabic or perhaps because the priests in their culture make them not to read Quran with translation as this will make the people ask questions and those so called priest will lose their power upon them.

          I am but student and I started Quran understanding with a couple of years ago. The more I read, the more doubtful I become, until came a point where things started to make sense and I hope my journey will continue in the same manner.

          There are some good people here who helped me as well. The verse 48 to me means that God punishments successively appeared in different forms with each new one more severe, for the purpose to make the rebellious leave their evil path.

          I wanna share something here.

          https//www.youtube.com/watch?v=LChGfJMur5o

          The woman is talking about not believing in Angel Gabrael and the authenticity, saying that since there is no proof of such a person as Gabrael (even though there are proofs of all these men whom we called messengers from history for being reformers and helper of poor folks and with books) ever exited, hence the concept of wahi can not be true, and which implies no divine message was revealed.

          So yes I agree with your statement that Quran expects believers to believe in FAITH. Simply put it. you must believe in Angels. Now its not similar that you can equate angels with god, saying that since you don't see or prove god, so its the same. No, there are many many signs around us that compel us to believe in the creator and his creations. But no such signs for what is called an Angel. except the fact that this concept is repeated from old scriptures/prophets with continuity and down to prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him.

          So how can some one prove existence of Angels with logic and wisdom ??? I wish if folks can give me an answer as this would be a great help to my understanding.

          What are the roles of Angels in this universe? is all of this documented in Quran? For example if we see disasters happening around us like earthquakes , tsunamis .. are these carried out by angles upon God instructions? Similar to the verses where two strangers came to Ibrahim as guests but were actually angels sent to destroy people of Lot. By this definition, there are disasters more than that of people of Lot (different kinds of viruses killing humanity in recent time) hence are we being cursed and punished by God, the only difference is that there is no prophet among us today to actually explain this phenomenon to us.

          The point is that same chain of events are happening now, as they happened thousands years ago , cause and effect, peace and war, are we to believe the same context???

          Cheers

          Peacee Fusion/zayd.

          I am merely asking questions.

          I expect people to go with their understanding of course.

          I am not going to enforce anything on anyone.

          However , Qoran deals with beliefs that require both faith and reason/Science/logic.

          Sometimes ,yes stories have happened literaly and to serve as lessons...etc.

          For example when Moses was sent to Pharoah,what happened?was it literal?

          And We have sent Moses with Our Ayah?s (miracles or signs) to Pharaoh and his elders proclaiming ?I am a messenger from the Lord of the universe?. When he brought them our Ayah?s they laughed at him. Every Ayah We showed them was greater than the one that preceded it.? 4346-48

          Someone will explain the "plagues" similar to what they explain other "Aayats" i.e signs/miracles... Does this mean they did not happen?

          Just to ponder and search deep ,that s all.
          GOD bless you.
          Peace.

          1 Reply Last reply
          0
          • H Offline
            H Offline
            huruf
            wrote on last edited by
            #25

            All this questions about belief in God or angels depend on the first place on the idea one has of God and angels or whatever else. Many people who say they do not believe in God I could say that I don't believe either in the God they are thinking of, which continues, even considering him abstract or incorporeal, being a man, rather bypolar and not very logical. Weknow though, root of being itself is beyond us, beyondm our comprehension.

            With angels I have the same "problem" I can't get a clear idea of them. I wuould dare to imagine that they are the agency through which God may manifest things for us. I would not think they are the movers of nature, I would think that is in nature laws themselves, but may be they are our movers in circumstances or all the time.

            Salaam

            1 Reply Last reply
            0
            • G Offline
              G Offline
              good_logic
              wrote on last edited by
              #26

              Peace Fusion.

              That s it. Keep asking questions and learning and studying Qoran.

              Of course we can have different views/opinions... But it does not mean we cannot grasp the truth.

              The most important message from Qoran is to work on oneself and become a good soul. This requires time and effort and patience and help from GOD as we are being tried while going through this process.

              We can start from any position of belief. Then we begin by getting to know about GOD,Angels ,scripture ,messengers, the straight path...And so on.

              It does not really matter what Angels look like or what happened in the past, I mean it is pointless arguing about it.

              I believe Qoran has all the answers we need for our salvation. We cannot know everything.

              If we believe in Qoran, then we are asked to study/ponder and be patient until we attain certainty.

              I have not asked ,in my posts,anyone to follow me ,neither have I said I am right or wrong in my understanding. I always ask people to check and find out for themselves.

              However I point out that Qoran always advices us to be loyal to GOD Alone, trust only GOD, rely only on GOD. i.e Not to rely/trust /take as authority any of GOD s creations.

              We should read//study/look at other views/advice/opinion and take what is best and what agrees with Qoran.

              GOD bless you.
              Peace.

              1 Reply Last reply
              0
              • FusionF Offline
                FusionF Offline
                Fusion
                wrote on last edited by
                #27

                What you said is cool and all fits perfectly if one has absolute belief in the Quran being word of God, every part of it with no changes whatsoever. If that belief is attained then definitely the path of journey becomes rather easier to travel.

                So the question would be if one has already attained the above belief then he/she would read Quran and take it slow and try to understand bit by bit and if things look non logical or magical or miraculous on the surface, am sure with God's guidance, he/she will certainly hope to get an answer in his/her life before he/she passes away.

                My question is what makes one have absolute belief in the first point, is it because he was born as muslim or because he was converted or because he read and understood... hence my question to you.. what makes you believe in Quran with absolute 100% comfort level, that it is indeed the word of God. am not questioning in the wrong way but I welcome every one to share what events or study etc make em believe in its truthfulness??? and how they crossed the line to be on the other side---believers.(angels/books/prophets)

                Cheers

                Peace Fusion.

                That s it. Keep asking questions and learning and studying Qoran.

                Of course we can have different views/opinions... But it does not mean we cannot grasp the truth.

                The most important message from Qoran is to work on oneself and become a good soul. This requires time and effort and patience and help from GOD as we are being tried while going through this process.

                We can start from any position of belief. Then we begin by getting to know about GOD,Angels ,scripture ,messengers, the straight path...And so on.

                It does not really matter what Angels look like or what happened in the past, I mean it is pointless arguing about it.

                I believe Qoran has all the answers we need for our salvation. We cannot know everything.

                If we believe in Qoran, then we are asked to study/ponder and be patient until we attain certainty.

                I have not asked ,in my posts,anyone to follow me ,neither have I said I am right or wrong in my understanding. I always ask people to check and find out for themselves.

                However I point out that Qoran always advices us to be loyal to GOD Alone, trust only GOD, rely only on GOD. i.e Not to rely/trust /take as authority any of GOD s creations.

                We should read//study/look at other views/advice/opinion and take what is best and what agrees with Qoran.

                GOD bless you.
                Peace.

                1 Reply Last reply
                0
                • A Offline
                  A Offline
                  amin
                  wrote on last edited by
                  #28

                  Believing angels is like believing in the natural order, natural forces and their effects on humans and their deeds. This belief is there in all religions including Buddhism. Not all can be equal, some are benefited with wealth, some with knowledge and some with good health etc... the natural forces plays an important role in balancing on who gets what, even modern science cant define on who gets what and the belief of this is primary for the belief in God.

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  0
                  • G Offline
                    G Offline
                    good_logic
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #29

                    Peace Fusion.

                    This is a good question

                    .. hence my question to you.. what makes you believe in Quran with absolute 100% comfort level, that it is indeed the word of God. am not questioning in the wrong way but I welcome every one to share what events or study etc make em believe in its truthfulness???

                    My simple answer to you is this
                    http//www.total-loyalty-to-god-alone.co.uk/is-qoran-the-word-of-god/

                    GOD bless you.
                    Peace.

                    1 Reply Last reply
                    0
                    • H Offline
                      H Offline
                      hawk99
                      wrote on last edited by
                      #30

                      Believing angels is like believing in the natural order, natural forces and their effects on humans and their deeds. This belief is there in all religions including Buddhism. Not all can be equal, some are benefited with wealth, some with knowledge and some with good health etc... the natural forces plays an important role in balancing on who gets what, even modern science cant define on who gets what and the belief of this is primary for the belief in God.

                      Excellent! @ amin

                      Thanks good logic for the link handshake

                      Peace Fusion, great insights on your part,

                      What you said is cool and all fits perfectly if one has absolute belief in the Quran being word of God, every part of it with no changes whatsoever. If that belief is attained then definitely the path of journey becomes rather easier to travel.

                      So the question would be if one has already attained the above belief then he/she would read Quran and take it slow and try to understand bit by bit and if things look non logical or magical or miraculous on the surface, am sure with God's guidance, he/she will certainly hope to get an answer in his/her life before he/she passes away.

                      My question is what makes one have absolute belief in the first point, is it because he was born as muslim or because he was converted or because he read and understood... hence my question to you.. what makes you believe in Quran with absolute 100% comfort level, that it is indeed the word of God. am not questioning in the wrong way but I welcome every one to share what events or study etc make em believe in its truthfulness??? and how they crossed the line to be on the other side---believers.(angels/books/prophets)

                      I believe totally in Quran Kareem because of several reasons. One of
                      which is my personal will and the will of God intersected at some point.
                      Another reason is that the Quran unlike other scriptures is bold and emphatic muscle
                      and leaves no doubt by saying "this Quran is from the lord of the worlds".
                      Pay close attention to that statement because no other scripture makes
                      such a claim. The Bible does not say this book is from God,
                      neither does any other scripture and the reason for this is worth noting.

                      ?This is the Scripture whereof there is no doubt, a guidance unto those
                      who ward off (evil).? (Q. 2 2)

                      ?A book which We have revealed unto thee (Muhammad) that thereby thou
                      mayst bring forth mankind from darkness unto light, by the permission of
                      their Lord, unto the path of the Exalted in power, Worthy of all praise.? (Q. 141)

                      It describes itself as discernment (Furqan) between truth and error

                      ?Truth has come and error has vanished; verily error is ephemeral.? (Q. 27 73)
                      ?And say the Truth is from your Lord. Let him the who cares to believe, believe ;
                      and let him who will not care to believe, believe not.?

                      ?Here is a Book whose verses are perfect in their form and content and are set
                      forth clearly by one who is All-wise and All-informed.? (Q.21)

                      Even though the Quran discusses a multitude of subjects and all facets of life
                      and sometimes in great detail, it makes a bold claim that no contradiction or
                      inconsistency can ever be found in it. It says

                      ?Had it (the Quran) been from any source other than God, you would have
                      found many contradictions in it.?

                      The Quran describes itself as a Light, a clear guidance and a blessed Book.

                      ?It is a blessed Book which We have revealed, so follow it,? This Quran
                      verily guideth to the path, which is perfectly straight and announces to
                      believers who do what is right, for them there is a great reward.? (Q. 17 9)
                      ?These are the verses of the Quran ? the lucid Book offering guidance
                      and good tidings to the Believers.?

                      ?The Quran is an Admonition and a reminder.? (Q. 271)

                      ?And say (O Muhammad); The Quran hath been revealed to me that I
                      should warn you by it and also those whom it may reach.? (Q. 61

                      ? It hath come down from the Lord of all domains of existence, will you
                      deny the gift that is with one?? (Q. 36. 80-82)

                      The Quran cautions that if you will believe you will attain success and
                      sublimity but if you will follow Satan, his associates and progeny. you
                      will end in Hell. The Quran is a blessing, a healing and a mercy We
                      sent down through the Quran a healing and a mercy to the believers
                      which causes distress to the wicked.? (Q 17 82)

                      The Quran says that no power on earth can produce a Book like itself

                      ?Say ?Should men join together and attempt to produce the like of
                      this Quran, they cannot produce a like of it, however much the one
                      group may help the other. ? (Q. 17 8

                      As for the question, "was Jonah swallowed by a whale" for me the
                      creature is irrelevant, but the wisdom extracted from the revelation is
                      what matters

                      God bless

                      peace

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      0
                      • U Offline
                        U Offline
                        unknownuser
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #31

                        Salaam,

                        We forget that the same God who caused the sea to part for Bani Israel and prophet Musa (pbuh), is also able to sustain a human being's life against all odds that would normally end it!

                        Normally if you are swallowed, I agree with amin, the natural forces created by God, do what they are created to do, but God is capable of stopping or altering these at Will. And God is certainly capable of all things.

                        So no harm or otherwise can come about to anyone except with the permission of God. I think that's the case too here.

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        0
                        • FusionF Offline
                          FusionF Offline
                          Fusion
                          wrote on last edited by
                          #32

                          You are giving new definitions to Malaika which are mentioned many many times in Quran. I was under the impression that angles are creations of God from source light and with no free will and they act upon God's instructions. Creation in the sense that they have physical body etc.
                          What you said makes sense but then how your definition can be put to test with the word angles and its context used in the quran? Please clarify because I have certainly read angels in so many places in Quran as if they are creatures.

                          Cheers

                          Believing angels is like believing in the natural order, natural forces and their effects on humans and their deeds. This belief is there in all religions including Buddhism. Not all can be equal, some are benefited with wealth, some with knowledge and some with good health etc... the natural forces plays an important role in balancing on who gets what, even modern science cant define on who gets what and the belief of this is primary for the belief in God.

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          0
                          • FusionF Offline
                            FusionF Offline
                            Fusion
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #33

                            I am in no way saying that God is not capable, it is just a discussion to understand the meaning of verses with the common understanding that people have had for centuries (3 days or 40 days inside stomach and what Quran says).
                            What I mean is when God wants to break his laws it is clearly mentioned as in the case of people of caves (Ashab Al Kahaf) or when God made the person die for 100 years along with his donkey and made them alive to show his power to them for he can create anything.

                            I have no issue with believing any of the definitions, its just that am trying to understand where and at which point I should use my faith to understand Quran or where would I use the logic and wisdom.

                            For example the following verse
                            Take this, my shirt, and cast it over the face of my father; he will be able to see. And bring me your family, all together. (Surah 12, Yusuf verse 93). Should I take it part of faith because otherwise rubbing of cloths would not return once lost eyes.

                            OR should I use the following interpretation... which makes sense to my logic and appears wise.
                            "Go back to your home
                            and present my shirt to my father, (I know
                            that he possesses so much insight that) he
                            will recognise this shirt. And come back to
                            me with all your family members."

                            So you see my confusion? And I believe this same phenomenon has created ignorance and rise to myths and miracles etc to so many people in the Islamic world in past and now that we see many silly things and ideas floating and give rise to some sort of a magical islam and the same thoughts and beliefs actually makes the people void of (innovations, creations, free thinking etc) if it is blown out of proportion which ironically has been the case. Like when I shares some of these ideas and thoughts with my mom, she told me to repeat Kalima as if am going out of islam.. It is like embedded into the generations.

                            Cheers

                            Cheers

                            Salaam,

                            We forget that the same God who caused the sea to part for Bani Israel and prophet Musa (pbuh), is also able to sustain a human being's life against all odds that would normally end it!

                            Normally if you are swallowed, I agree with amin, the natural forces created by God, do what they are created to do, but God is capable of stopping or altering these at Will. And God is certainly capable of all things.

                            So no harm or otherwise can come about to anyone except with the permission of God. I think that's the case too here.

                            1 Reply Last reply
                            0
                            • FusionF Offline
                              FusionF Offline
                              Fusion
                              wrote on last edited by
                              #34

                              So basically you took the verses of Quran and try to make your point that after reading these verses, you are absolute sure that this indeed is the Book from your lord revealed to Muhammad via Gabrael. Is that correct?
                              If yes then I am glad for you.
                              May I ask other folks how did they come to the same conclusion about Quran, what made them reach to the height of utter belief In Quran?

                              cheers

                              Excellent! @ amin

                              Thanks good logic for the link handshake

                              Peace Fusion, great insights on your part,

                              I believe totally in Quran Kareem because of several reasons. One of
                              which is my personal will and the will of God intersected at some point.
                              Another reason is that the Quran unlike other scriptures is bold and emphatic muscle
                              and leaves no doubt by saying "this Quran is from the lord of the worlds".
                              Pay close attention to that statement because no other scripture makes
                              such a claim. The Bible does not say this book is from God,
                              neither does any other scripture and the reason for this is worth noting.

                              ?This is the Scripture whereof there is no doubt, a guidance unto those
                              who ward off (evil).? (Q. 2 2)

                              ?A book which We have revealed unto thee (Muhammad) that thereby thou
                              mayst bring forth mankind from darkness unto light, by the permission of
                              their Lord, unto the path of the Exalted in power, Worthy of all praise.? (Q. 141)

                              It describes itself as discernment (Furqan) between truth and error

                              ?Truth has come and error has vanished; verily error is ephemeral.? (Q. 27 73)
                              ?And say the Truth is from your Lord. Let him the who cares to believe, believe ;
                              and let him who will not care to believe, believe not.?

                              ?Here is a Book whose verses are perfect in their form and content and are set
                              forth clearly by one who is All-wise and All-informed.? (Q.21)

                              Even though the Quran discusses a multitude of subjects and all facets of life
                              and sometimes in great detail, it makes a bold claim that no contradiction or
                              inconsistency can ever be found in it. It says

                              ?Had it (the Quran) been from any source other than God, you would have
                              found many contradictions in it.?

                              The Quran describes itself as a Light, a clear guidance and a blessed Book.

                              ?It is a blessed Book which We have revealed, so follow it,? This Quran
                              verily guideth to the path, which is perfectly straight and announces to
                              believers who do what is right, for them there is a great reward.? (Q. 17 9)
                              ?These are the verses of the Quran ? the lucid Book offering guidance
                              and good tidings to the Believers.?

                              ?The Quran is an Admonition and a reminder.? (Q. 271)

                              ?And say (O Muhammad); The Quran hath been revealed to me that I
                              should warn you by it and also those whom it may reach.? (Q. 61

                              ? It hath come down from the Lord of all domains of existence, will you
                              deny the gift that is with one?? (Q. 36. 80-82)

                              The Quran cautions that if you will believe you will attain success and
                              sublimity but if you will follow Satan, his associates and progeny. you
                              will end in Hell. The Quran is a blessing, a healing and a mercy We
                              sent down through the Quran a healing and a mercy to the believers
                              which causes distress to the wicked.? (Q 17 82)

                              The Quran says that no power on earth can produce a Book like itself

                              ?Say ?Should men join together and attempt to produce the like of
                              this Quran, they cannot produce a like of it, however much the one
                              group may help the other. ? (Q. 17 8

                              As for the question, "was Jonah swallowed by a whale" for me the
                              creature is irrelevant, but the wisdom extracted from the revelation is
                              what matters

                              God bless

                              peace

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              0
                              • U Offline
                                U Offline
                                unknownuser
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #35

                                Salaam,

                                I am not giving any definitions to the malaika. Even if they are frequently mentioned, they are not clearly defined. We do know that they serve various functions, possibly one of these are the observable natural laws.

                                The Quran, is simply a warning and a reminder. The focus as itself advises, should not be on verses that are ambiguous, but the direct ones that give laws or commandments ( i.e. believe in God and do this and dont do that etc). Focusing and trying to derive interpretations from ambiguous verses is identified as having a kind of disease.

                                As for coming to the conclusions that the Quran is from God, there are many reasons and no reason at the same time.

                                One of the reasons among many reasons, is that of the coming end which the Quran frequently refers to and the recreation of life, a central theme.

                                Think of the typical life cycles of solar systems. The star is born and consequently all the planets are born, some of them having the right conditions for life, breed and host life. We know only of earth for sure, there maybe others that we are unaware of. The star burns through its fuel, towards the end of its term it expands either to engulf and destroy all of its planets and become silent as a white glowing mass or explode as a supernova, also, destroying planets, in both cases leaving star dust. From this star dust, new stars and planets are born and thus life can come about, again!

                                I think the detail was not that necessary, but that is the biggest example of life and death that we have and also that of resurrection - something that the Quran emphasized heavily over a 1000 years ago when the prophet Muhammad (pbuh)'s audience astonishingly would question him in ridicule.."shall we be brought back after we are mere dust and bones?"

                                What about the "no reason" for my conclusion?

                                "I agree, and believe it, all of it is from God."

                                I recognize and turn to the One who initiated the universe, seen and unseen in monothiestic belief, God, the Almighty, the Eternal, the Absolute.

                                The Quran confirms and identifies God as such and this stance.

                                1 Reply Last reply
                                0
                                • M Offline
                                  M Offline
                                  Man_of_Faith
                                  wrote on last edited by
                                  #36

                                  Hello,

                                  Angels are what we are struggling to become. They do have free will since they are an independent consciousness in the Grand Consciousness, although they are simultaneously in symbiosis with God and that power source through the link. They lack a physical Body because they have been released from that attachment although they can gain possession over a Body if necessary. We are actually also as them, potential ones, but we are also being tested to see if we choose to succumb to the World or choose our divine nature. The World was made to be corrupting and deceptive and an obvious "testing ground". When a person has "separated the Spirit from the Flesh" then they can begin to see such things.

                                  For those blessed having seen the man-made science-fiction Star Trek can find a parable with 'the Borg' in there being connected to a huge computer network where there is a mainframe and infrastructure which can be considered to be 'Rabb' and Holy Spirit. Its allegorical use is very good actually. Just see the metaphor in it. That is basically how things work when joining the Realm/Kingdom of God.

                                  For those opposing the above can disregard the message at whole.

                                  Be safe
                                  Emanuel/Aminujil

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  0
                                  • FusionF Offline
                                    FusionF Offline
                                    Fusion
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #37

                                    Cool explanation buddy. Is this your own theses or you inspired from some sources? I would love to know because the mainframe example is really great.

                                    Since you did not cite references, hence point to your own understanding of them. I have a hypothetical question. Is it possible that these angels can be seduced to go and act against God?

                                    Hello,

                                    Angels are what we are struggling to become. They do have free will since they are an independent consciousness in the Grand Consciousness, although they are simultaneously in symbiosis with God and that power source through the link. They lack a physical Body because they have been released from that attachment although they can gain possession over a Body if necessary. We are actually also as them, potential ones, but we are also being tested to see if we choose to succumb to the World or choose our divine nature. The World was made to be corrupting and deceptive and an obvious "testing ground". When a person has "separated the Spirit from the Flesh" then they can begin to see such things.

                                    For those blessed having seen the man-made science-fiction Star Trek can find a parable with 'the Borg' in there being connected to a huge computer network where there is a mainframe and infrastructure which can be considered to be 'Rabb' and Holy Spirit. Its allegorical use is very good actually. Just see the metaphor in it. That is basically how things work when joining the Realm/Kingdom of God.

                                    For those opposing the above can disregard the message at whole.

                                    Be safe
                                    Emanuel/Aminujil

                                    1 Reply Last reply
                                    0
                                    • M Offline
                                      M Offline
                                      Man_of_Faith
                                      wrote on last edited by
                                      #38

                                      Hello Fusion,

                                      Cool explanation buddy. Is this your own theses or you inspired from some sources? I would love to know because the mainframe example is really great.

                                      The "mainframe allegory" was my parable in relationship to something some of us can relate to contemporaneously.

                                      It is based on my reinterpretation of Quran using unbiased and original ways of reading the ancient Arabic with a rendition into English I am working on right now. The real message of Quran conveys a very different perspective of faith much in line of what Jesus teaches in the Biblical Gospels. It simply confirms him really well. However, he is not some kind of unique "son of God" (which is used metaphorically there), nor does that son relationship have anything to do with any biological tie. The comparison is made when a person acts just as God would in any case scenario or at least very well close to it. Although no one can be above their Master they can yet be on equal level.

                                      Since you did not cite references, hence point to your own understanding of them. I have a hypothetical question. Is it possible that these angels can be seduced to go and act against God?

                                      When they abide separated from the Body and can be stern at this then it is not very likely, but it would be possible if someone was really that foolish and gave in to temptations. The biggest trap for an angel or someone close to being one is being arrogant due to your superiority and let it express itself in your decisions and judgements. That is not as according to the Rabb. When you are attached to a Body then the biggest concern is not allowing the Body to control you with its primitive instinctive drive and that you enjoy being it because gradually you succumb to its desires and it clouds your link to God.

                                      Be safe
                                      Emanuel/Aminujil

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      0
                                      • FusionF Offline
                                        FusionF Offline
                                        Fusion
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #39

                                        Interesting indeed, would you please share your work with me at this stage or you wanna keep it until it is fully translated?

                                        Cheers

                                        Hello Fusion,

                                        The "mainframe allegory" was my parable in relationship to something some of us can relate to contemporaneously.

                                        It is based on my reinterpretation of Quran using unbiased and original ways of reading the ancient Arabic with a rendition into English I am working on right now. The real message of Quran conveys a very different perspective of faith much in line of what Jesus teaches in the Biblical Gospels. It simply confirms him really well. However, he is not some kind of unique "son of God" (which is used metaphorically there), nor does that son relationship have anything to do with any biological tie. The comparison is made when a person acts just as God would in any case scenario or at least very well close to it. Although no one can be above their Master they can yet be on equal level.

                                        When they abide separated from the Body and can be stern at this then it is not very likely, but it would be possible if someone was really that foolish and gave in to temptations. The biggest trap for an angel or someone close to being one is being arrogant due to your superiority and let it express itself in your decisions and judgements. That is not as according to the Rabb. When you are attached to a Body then the biggest concern is not allowing the Body to control you with its primitive instinctive drive and that you enjoy being it because gradually you succumb to its desires and it clouds your link to God.

                                        Be safe
                                        Emanuel/Aminujil

                                        1 Reply Last reply
                                        0
                                        • M Offline
                                          M Offline
                                          Man_of_Faith
                                          wrote on last edited by
                                          #40

                                          Hi Fusion,

                                          I could, but it is nothing public right now because I cannot safely guarantee there are not interpretation errors which could be avoided merely by rereading the same passage several times and reflecting. I have had little to no revision of what has been rendered so far.

                                          The English rendition is also following Arabic sentence structure (albeit correct English word order but the clauses follow Arabic style) to retain faithfulness to the original script so can be a bit dull to read to not say the least. By the official release I plan on also publishing a paraphrased version that sounds okay in English. One issue is Arabic omits many pronouns, for example, in a relative clause and it is not always possible to remain totally faithful to the Arabic by not inserting any words however limited to mainly pronouns.

                                          Regardless, at whole it gives a different image of the faith system which not surprisingly (to me) looks somehow Gnostic to the style.

                                          The "deen" is easy; the Body is a test for you and its instinctive drive is Satan, so the only way is to fight it, fight yourself and find your Spirit which has the potential to be like God for you were created to be in His image. The World is a distraction and made to be corrupting by mode of deception to indulge in it. You probably see that the Body calls for you to enjoy its chemical processes. Once in the second chapter God (appropriately) calls it "ape", primate (misquoted/misinterpreted by sectarians to mean that people were to become despicable apes).

                                          No rituals, no weird stuff and in fact image-making of God is detrimental and against the advised decree of God due to the Body has a tendency to make physical beacons for itself (see Kabah in Mecca) or attribute force to lifeless items. God is within you; it is a symbiotic phenomenon and God spoke to Moses "I am who am I" and Jesus said "I am in the Father and the Father in me". That is the only way to Oneness and absorption/merging into the Oneness since there is only one existence, coexistence in God, and the Realm is at hand.

                                          And the communication (connection) with God should be constant, nothing timed to occur according to some fixed schedule and calling unto God can occur spontaneously whenever required to receive guidance that you cannot channel directly intuitively without imploring. Otherwise just have faith YOU CAN and it will be so. Revere God by your perfect resemblance, worship is empty words for something that has no needs or can be charmed or bribed. Prostration should be done with the heart.

                                          Sorry for flooding those who do not wish to hear with words. Please disregard my message.

                                          Be safe
                                          Emanuel

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          0
                                          Reply
                                          • Reply as topic
                                          Log in to reply
                                          • Oldest to Newest
                                          • Newest to Oldest
                                          • Most Votes


                                          • Login

                                          • Don't have an account? Register

                                          • Login or register to search.
                                          • First post
                                            Last post
                                          0
                                          • Categories
                                          • Recent
                                          • Users